6 ms·
virtue: volunteering at a soup kitchen virtue signalling: inviting the press to photograph you volunteering at a soup kitchen virtue: donating anonymously to
by WalterBright 5y ago
virtue: volunteering at a soup kitchen
virtue signalling: inviting the press to photograph you volunteering at a soup kitchen
virtue: donating anonymously to your favorite cause
virtue signalling: demanding the government fund your favorite cause
- orwin 5y ago> virtue: donating anonymously to your favorite cause > virtue signalling: demanding the government fund your favorite cause I thought that as we built and testes political systems, we decided that collegial decisions on fund attribution and nation goal were the best way of doing thing. I actually think lobbying and militant advocacy are the correct way of acting and spending money. If you aren't able to convince people, maybe your idea is not as good as you thought.
- LesZedCB 5y agoexcept that money isn't distributed democratically....... maybe if the government gave everybody a 'democracy fund' of $1000 to be distributed to whatever registered recipients/distributions. no more, no less spending on lobbying.
- WalterBright 5y agoI fail to see the virtue in forcibly spending someone else's money on your favorite cause, even if it is a good cause. A litmus test as to whether you really believe it is a good cause is if you're willing to spend your own money on it. And not a token amount, either. Real money.
- lamontcg 5y agoI could send my whole life savings / net worth off to some organization that is addressing climate change and it won't make a drop in the bucket and nothing will change.
- WalterBright 5y agoIf all the people that voted for it did, then it would make quite a big difference. After all, where does the government money come from?
- lamontcg 5y agoThat is why taxation is coercive to force people to cooperate, and to provide guarantees that other people are cooperating in addition to you and to spread the load out. If you don't do that, the prisoners dilemma is so out of adjustment that everyone would start to defect and it would unwind. That isn't really a moral observation, but its the nature of the game being so out of whack where it is you vs. 330,000,000 other people. Cooperating or not cooperating can have a large effect on your own finances while each single individuals contribution is miniscule (3e-9). But this is already happening and why we need higher taxes on the 1% and .1%.
- brimble 5y agoThis POV would be fine in a world where coordination problems didn't loom large. Effective collective action requires some "forcibly". Even when everyone agrees on what's good.
- WalterBright 5y agoThat's why forced collective action does very poorly compared with voluntary cooperation. People don't like being forced. Microsoft, SpaceX, the free market in general, etc., do not rely on forcible cooperation. Yet it's very successful.
- brimble 5y ago> That's why forced collective action does very poorly compared with voluntary cooperation. People don't like being forced. This is about the same as proclaiming a fringe explanation for relativity effects to be definitely true, in a physics thread.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe USSR was forced cooperation. The US is voluntary. Which economy fared better? It makes me sad to read so many comments from people who are convinced that the only way to get cooperation is through force.
- brimble 5y ago> The USSR was forced cooperation. The US is voluntary. Which economy fared better? This is a false choice, because both force cooperation, and neither "is voluntary". How they do so, when, and how much, is what's different. That's the trouble here, it's not a "force or don't" choice. If you don't force anything, you'll have a bad time. Evidently, if you force too much, you're also likely to have a bad time. There's a lot of room—and not just on that one-dimensional measure—between the two extremes. > It makes me sad to read so many comments from people who are convinced that the only way to get cooperation is through force. You don't need to be sad, then, because you're reading that into it.
- lamontcg 5y ago> virtue signalling: demanding the government fund your favorite cause yeah, not really. if the cause is something massive like global warning, it isn't happening due to the actions of individuals one by one, and its bigger than any charity. and making it an individual moral problem isn't helpful because it always devolves eventually into the "so you criticize society, yet you participate in it, curious" problem. the government is supposed to be there for the big problems, to get the government to move you have to do PR of one form or another.
- WalterBright 5y agoPerhaps true, but that has no bearing on whether you're being virtuous or not. For example, if you bike to work, you're being virtuous. If you drive your musclecar to work, you're not. How you vote has nothing to do with virtuosity.
- wolverine876 5y agoI am missing something about this distinction: It seems your actions, such as organizing community action via government or voting, are definitely implicated in your virtue. Why are these actions, which have serious consequences, treated differently from other actions? If I organize neighbors to pickup trash, or work through city council to clean the street, what is the difference other than the mechanisms?
- WalterBright 5y agoThe difference is are you sacrificing, or are you forcing others to sacrifice? How is it virtuous to make somebody else bear the cost of your dreams? Note that organizing neighbors to pick up trash is a purely voluntary task by you and your neighbors. I know that politicians routinely offer you virtue by voting for them to make someone else pay. But I hope you can see it's a false virtue.
- wolverine876 5y agoThanks for explaining and I understand your point. Regarding others or myself sacrificing: It is necessary in anything, if we are to accomplish much, for many people to contribute; not much happens alone. So generally no one person can do most of the sacrifice (and I'm not sure it's such a sacrifice), but I definitely believe in doing more than my share. The other part I think is rooted in common-on-HN perspective on government that I don't happen share. To me, doing it through local government or through organizing neighbors aren't much different. Democracy is another mechanism for how we get together and do things: We take a vote, we agree that we'll go along with the results - sometimes what I like to a greater degree, sometimes to a lesser one, but we also agree that we need to act as a community sometimes and can't be paralyzed, and that others' preferences are just as deserving as mine; and we have the enlightenment and good will and, failing that, the enlightened self-interest, to see that by working together in good faith we can achieve so much more for ourselves. To me, the idea of compulsion as the basis of democratic government is an interesting philosophical and theoretical question - and answered largely by free elections, representation, free speech, and limited government. Anarchy is similar to me - a philosophical / theoretical question but not reality. They seem to me like some things on HN, in a intellectual atmosphere - a theory taken to the extreme of thinking it's real, or of testing its boundaries by insisting it's real and challenging people to disprove it, rather than something used a tool for exploring reality. Because as a practical matter, I don't see the compulsion: People follow the rules and laws because they want to; we are social beings, even evolved to live socially and emotionally fall apart if alone. I pay my taxes, follow most laws because I would anyway (e.g., I don't want to murder or steal), and others because I want to do my part for my neighbors; I respect my neighbors votes. Compulsion isn't the basis, it's just a band-aid solution we sometimes use; there aren't nearly enough resources to make everyone obey if they don't want to. You seem to think differently, which is fine, but I think it's factually wrong to assume that everyone - who almost all live in democracies - agrees. Also, I think the compulsion theory is yet another attempt by certain groups (not you) to attack our democracy, to politicize the very idea of it, by transforming it from an achievement of humanity and a way we can live with hope and progress, to something dark and pernicious.