5 ms·
Learn about Concept Maps
- ivansavz 5y agoCmap Tools is the best! I've tried all kinds of other mind-map and concept-map tools, but always keep coming back to Cmap tools and the "default" styles with simple lines and arrows. Here is an example with some concept maps from one of my books: https://minireference.com/static/conceptmaps/math_and_physics_concepts.pdf https://minireference.com/static/conceptmaps/math_and_physic... Lots of information density, and allows to show some of the key connections between concepts.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoWas just thinking of you today: https://twitter.com/rahimnathwani/status/1510810237522964487?s=21&t=4jvvWllhcwCXGKs9sIW78Q https://twitter.com/rahimnathwani/status/1510810237522964487...
- ivansavz 5y agoThx for the plug. I posted some direct links in that thread.
- tejtm 5y agoLast I looked their file format was serialized java objects wrapped in gzip. you might want to be cautious loading them.
- ivansavz 5y agoOoh I didn't know. I usually create my own files and exchange only with editor, but definitely worth watching out for this in general. CmapTools supposrts CXL format (https://cmap.ihmc.us/xml/CXL.html https://cmap.ihmc.us/xml/CXL.html) as export, which is an XML variant. That might be better for exchange...
- productceo 5y agoI grew up hearing a lot of buzz for concept maps (or mind maps as I heard). I never found them to be as powerful as advertised. A concept map is slightly easier than writing in bulletpoints because it can ignore structure. But this makes it incredibly difficult for anyone, including myself, to read after it is written. At best, I use a concept map as an intermediary stage for figuring out how to write in bulletpoints, write in paragraphs, or draw in diagrams. This intermediary stage never lasts overnight for me, and I discard the concept map immediately.
- RBerenguel 5y agoConcept maps are not mind maps, concept maps work in a different way. I'll just offer a self-reference about concept maps [1] since there I have an explanation of how they work I like. [1]: https://mostlymaths.net/2021/10/concept-maps.html/ https://mostlymaths.net/2021/10/concept-maps.html/
- jonsen 5y ago("Mind maps are similar in structure to concept maps, developed by learning experts in the 1970s, but differ in that mind maps are simplified by focusing around a single central key concept."): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_map https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_map
- productceo 5y agoPerfect one sentence summary. I wasted a minute or two searching online for the difference between the two, but I should have read your comment first! Thanks for communicating precisely and concisely.
- westurner 5y agoWhile scoping is necessary and useful, I hadn't ever learned that there were categorical restrictions upon mind map graphs, definitionally Centrality, Components, Cliques might be helpful for general network analysis: https://networkx.org/documentation/stable/reference/algorithms/centrality.html https://networkx.org/documentation/stable/reference/algorith... The difference between a URI and a URL; a URL is supposed to be dereferenceable and retrievable. Named Graphs are composed of triples: {named_graph_uri, subject_uri, predicate_uri, value_uri, [datatype_uri, language_uri]} {g, s, p, o, [d, l]} E.g. Rdflib supports various stores for and representations of RDF: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RDFLib https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RDFLib Though, general systems are more complex than the average [concept] network: there are nonlinearities in so many of the observed relations between components that trees and DAGs are laughably insufficient; systems descriptions require more than naievely-acyclical graphs without nonlinearity in independent relations even. Graph (disambiguation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graph Glossary of systems theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary_of_systems_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary_of_systems_theory How best to describe nonlinear relations without a MultiDiGraph that bundles edges together by [QFT] field, because they're objectively not statistically independent?
- Kit-Ko 5y agoThe idea of Concept Maps is better implemented via Neo4j or similar graph databases. Are there other reasons to use Cmap Tools instead of the established graph database ecosystem?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iammjm 5y agoI dislike mind maps because they always impose a central point/root and enforce hierarchy. I prefer to just have free floating nodes that I can attach however I want and build clusters. That way my thoughts are not constrained and and I can build all sorts of relationships. Too bad there are so few software products that enable that. The best one I found is called Scapple. It's easy, quick and cheap (30 day free trial, lifelong license for 20$). The only thing that sucks is the export, other than pdf or jpeg. And it's only fit desktops. Still a great tool for quick initial sketches
- eimrine 5y ago> I dislike mind maps because they always impose a central point/root and enforce hierarchy. That was my pain, like when I began to gather information about triangles and took "triangle" as a root point but then I need to change the root point to "flat figures" and I realize that there is no easy way to change the root point in mind-map software I have tried. This problem of mine has been solved with Zettelcasten, currently I am using Obsidian but going to switch for something FOSS.
- s_dev 5y agoI was hoping this was going to be some cool fictional maps about sci fi universes and mythology from times past. Sort of like how you understand the term "concept car" to be a harbinger of the future.
- fasteddie31003 5y agoConcept maps are exactly how I want to learn. They are behind the ideas on my startup I'm working on https://gainknowhow.com https://gainknowhow.com . Each edge in my software is a requirement. It's interesting that cmap has different edge types that specify how a connection is required. I think all edges should just be hard requirements.