5 ms·
Society needs to pay a competitive price relative to their other options.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
Society needs to pay a competitive price relative to their other options.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoExtremely unlikely there will ever be a will to do this considering the long term value to be compensated (hundreds of thousands of dollars per child, if not $1MM). Society is too short sighted and short term financially focused. The world already has almost 8 billion people though (with population momentum landing is at 10B-11B by the end of the century), so I’m hard pressed to argue for more children (and the necessary policy and financial support) when we, in aggregate, already don’t take care of the ones here (no subsidized child care, limited parental leave, half a million kids in foster care at any one time [US], ~120 million unintended pregnancies globally annually, etc). Also consider that in parts of Europe where pro natalist policies are very robust (subsidized childcare, very generous leave policies, and “baby bonuses”), the fertility rate continues to decline regardless. Kids might be valuable to society, but the data supports the idea they are not as important to individuals (opportunity costs, life choices, etc).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xyzzy123 5y agoYou could give the parents some kind of benefit(s) proportional to the taxes generated by their children /ducks (Yes, terrible idea for a number of reasons, but the incentives would be aligned...)
- WithinReason 5y agoOr just reduce their taxes, e.g. like Hungary
- cjbgkagh 5y agoLife is one big selection criteria bias. You don’t need all societies to work, just one. Unfortunately for us it may not be our society that makes it so there may be temporary setbacks. So long as designer baby technology is developed practically any amount of dysgenics can be reversed.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Extremely unlikely there will ever be a will to do this considering the long term value to be compensated (hundreds of thousands of dollars per child, if not $1MM). Parent here. You don’t need $1mm to raise a kid. You don’t need anywhere close to that, actually. Kids aren’t free, obviously, but this internet meme that they’ll bankrupt you is getting out of control. Honestly, how do you think people making the median US household income are affording kids? Multiple kids, even? I hope it’s obvious that households with two kids earning <$100K per year (a common situation) aren’t spending $1mm on each of them.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI did not say their cost ($270k in 2022 inflation adjusted dollars per child in the US). I said their long term value (over their lifetime to society). If you’re at a median income, you’re barely getting by with kids.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat people prefer is what matters, now that people can enjoy sex without worrying about having kids. I would not have had kids with a household income less than $100k (or even $200k), but that is just my preference for the type of life I would have wanted for the kids. I grew up poor as the child of struggling immigrants, and I want my kids to be very far from that quality of life for the portion of their life I am responsible for.
- ip26 5y agoI’m not sure how you can spend a 200k income on a kid and avoid them becoming spoiled rotten. Having been poor, you should have a good sense of just how little money it actually takes to leave the insecurity & want far behind (in my own experience & opinion)
- michaelt 5y agoI think a lot of people on this site are from Silicon Valley, and what they actually mean is "I wouldn't start a family until I could afford a 3-bedroom house in a reasonable school district, and you can't afford such a house in Silicon Valley without a 6-figure income"
- dmm 5y ago> The world already has almost 8 billion people though The grocery stores are already full of food, why do we still need farms? If you ever plan to stop working you need young people to buy your 401k stocks from you and pay for your Social Security. The problem with low fertility rates is not (primarily) population decline, it's demographic collapse. As long as fertility is below replacement the proportion of elderly increases _forever_. What about immigration? The US is in a much better position wrt to this than many other nations because of our high rates of immigration but low fertility is a global phenomenon outside of a handful of places like Nigeria and Afghanistan. > the fertility rate continues to decline regardless. You're right. Nobody has figured out how to raise fertility rates once they start dropping.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI’m always baffled when I read these comments from non-parents who describe parenting as the end of your life. Daycare isn’t prohibitively expensive for any of us in tech careers. Anyone quitting a $150K+ job to avoid paying $20-30K for a good daycare for the few years before kids entire school isn’t doing it because it’s the optimal financial decision. You don’t stop having a career or earning money or having career advancement when you have kids.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI am a parent, but society wide data indicates people’s preferences/risk assessments/perceived cost-benefit ratios better than individuals’ opinion.
- bradleyjg 5y agoI agree that for high income people ($150k+ for the sake of argument) it’s not strictly speaking a good idea financially to drop out of the workforce to avoid child care expenses. However, given the way taxes on two earner families work it is a much cheaper decision then it looks like at first blush. Maybe this is a good thing. But it is a bit counterintuitive if you think of salary in pretax dollars.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI am not sure what you are referring to, but the tax penalty for dual similar income earning married filing joint tax filers was removed in the 2017 tax cuts and jobs act. https://taxfoundation.org/tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-marriage-penalty/ https://taxfoundation.org/tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-marriage-pen...
- bradleyjg 5y agoWhat’s the disposable income difference, in say California, between: 1) Spouse 1 grossing $250,000 a year, spouse 2 grossing $150,000 a year, $40,000 in childcare costs. and 2) Spouse 1 grossing $250,000 a year, spouse 2 grossing $0 a year, $0 in childcare costs?