12 ms·
> Well, the body has a whole mechanism for manufacturing cholesterol, so it must be good for something. It seems obvious that there's some level at which low ch
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> Well, the body has a whole mechanism for manufacturing cholesterol, so it must be good for something. It seems obvious that there's some level at which low cholesterol must cause death.
Agreed.
> A U-shaped cholesterol-mortality curve is pretty much guaranteed to exist.
Yes, this is a necessary consequence of the first observation. Mortality will go to 100% if cholesterol is too low or too high.
> The only question is where the minimum is.
But I don't think this is right. You can calculate a mortality-by-cholesterol-level curve for the population, and it will have a minimum somewhere. But it doesn't follow that it would be good for you, even in a sense restricted to all-cause mortality, if you moved your personal cholesterol level closer to the minimum value on that curve. Most people in the population aren't like you.
- amelius 5y ago> Yes, this is a necessary consequence of the first observation. Not necessarily. The cholesterol could be redundant.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoNo, that's not the case. If your natural weight is 150 pounds, but you've gotten to the point where you contain 700 pounds of cholesterol, you'll die.
- amelius 5y agoI was referring to the lower bound.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoYou think we have a working system producing a substance that is only ever harmful? If it's ever helpful, that's already guaranteed to produce a U-shaped curve. Just like I say in the quote you pull. (It's theoretically possible that mortality won't go to 100% at zero cholesterol. But that's not the quote you pulled.)
- amelius 5y agoIf substance X produces Z and substance Y produces Z, then removing X still gives you Z. Or, removing a substance that is produced by the body does not necessarily leads to mortality. I'm not saying that Y exists, just that the argument is either incomplete or the logic unsound.
- radford-neal 5y agoWell, the body can utilize energy by either an aerobic or anaerobic pathway, but that doesn't mean we'd be fine if either of these pathways were disabled. We'd die without the aerobic pathway and have much reduced capabilities (probably fatal too, I'd guess - certainly if a tiger is chasing you) without the anaerobic pathway. If a mechanism has been produced/preserved by natural selection, it's hard to believe that disabling it wouldn't lead to death (or infertility), or to serious debilitation (also likely to lead to death, in a non-benign environment).