6 ms·
I don't want to return my TV, I want to sue them for the theft of my functional TV and replacement with a superficially similar but vastly inferior alternative.
by thfuran 5y ago
I don't want to return my TV, I want to sue them for the theft of my functional TV and replacement with a superficially similar but vastly inferior alternative.
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoI never said you couldn't sue them. Those of us who would rather not waste the kind of time and money needed to sue an electronics manufacturer would prefer a return option instead.
- thfuran 5y agoWhy should it be the retailers' problem?
- tux1968 5y agoBecause they sold it to you. They're who set the price and took your money. They sold you defective goods. Why shouldn't it be their problem?
- thfuran 5y agoBut they didn't sell defective goods. They sold goods that were fit for purpose, and then the manufacturer deliberately destroyed them.
- tux1968 5y agoThat's between them and their suppliers. They should have picked better suppliers who didn't put them into the position they now find themselves.
- heavyset_go 5y agoSounds like a reason the retailer should either work it out with, or sue, the manufacturer.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> But they didn't sell defective goods. They sold goods that were fit for purpose, and then the manufacturer deliberately destroyed them. You don't see the manufacturer's ability to reach out and destroy the item you've already purchased as a defect in the item?
- mdoms 5y agoIf I buy a Google Home from JB Hifi I am not Google's customer, I am JB Hifi's customer. If they don't want to deal with a huge load of refund claims for Google products they are free not to sell them.
- Bud 5y agoIf the retailer is the only available target, they're a fair target. Make it clear that these products will cost them money if they try to sell them, and they'll stop selling them.
- yeetsfromhellL2 5y agoIf you're lucky you'll be included in a class action and get a $5 check in a few years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rland 5y agoA class action which may cost the manufacturer 10s of millions of dollars. Yeah, you only get a small check. Yeah, the lawyers get a lot. But what other remedy does the average consumer have against this type of subtle but abusive behavior.
- b112 5y agoSmall claims court.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I don't want to return my TV, I want to sue them for the theft of my functional TV and replacement with a superficially similar but vastly inferior alternative. So you want to file a lawsuit for damages that would be limited to the value of your TV (possibly reduced by the value of the substitute), instead of getting a refund of the purchase price of your TV? Other than enriching a lawyer, what benefit would that provide you?
- thrtythreeforty 5y agoNo immediate benefit, but it might provide a sufficiently deleterious effect for the manufacturer to effect the desired behavior.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoMaybe. I think it brings about more schadenfreude to just see their sales tank when they realize that maybe people don't want their tv owner to show pop ups on what should simply be a means of presenting content from other services.
- nerdponx 5y agoTheir sales won't tank, because this will start to get rolled out across the industry. They might take a hit for being the first mover, but once this is normalized they will ride the same gravy train as everyone else. This is classic industrial organization economics. These companies know that they are all in tacit collusion agreements with each other. It's not hard to set up "repeated prisoner's dilemma"-type games where collusion is the dominant strategy. Basically, as long as companies know that it's in their long-term best interest to all do the same thing, then they will all do the same thing, even if it might yield some extra profit in the short term to deviate. The only way to stop this garbage is to make it so bad for companies to engage in this behavior that the costs outweigh the benefits. Given the above situation, where the supply of alternative goods is likely to dry up, the only other forms of recourse are punitive court damages or prohibitive policy/law from a suitably powerful government.
- gruez 5y ago>I want to sue them for the theft of my functional TV and replacement with a superficially similar but vastly inferior alternative. You're free to sue them, but I suspect the lawsuit is going to get tossed almost immediately. Do you really think a multi-billion dollar company is going to expose themselves to a theft lawsuit?
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThis arguably falls under the implied warranty for fitness / merchantability and I don't think it's remotely a given that a lawsuit would be tossed.