13 ms·
Horrible edge cases when dealing with music
- rcthompson 5y agoAC/DC is another edge case I've seen, mainly because in some contexts slashes are used as separators between multiple artists, so "AC/DC" could be misinterpreted as a list of 2 artists named "AC" and "DC".
- amelius 5y agoDoesn't work well in filenames either.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y ago"/Τĥιs ñåmè įß ą váĺîδ POSIX paτĥ" is my display name on some services at my job. It helps to remind people to consider things like spaces, homoglyph attacks, and non-ASCII characters.
- f7ebc20c97 5y agoI'm gonna name my band an 18 TB string of random characters, interspersed with an "idea" that you can't even put into text! Take THAT, Unicode!
- javajosh 5y agoOoh, that gives me the idea to name my album the base64 encoding of it's tracks. The album itself, of course, would be empty.
- akira2501 5y agoI believe you would no longer be able to copyright the track, then. So, you should encrypt the encoded titles, but record an audio track that is a voice recording of you reading out the encryption key for that track. You know, for DRM.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- labster 5y agoIt doesn’t matter if he can copyright it, he can still sell NFTs of each album track.
- seba_dos1 5y ago> I believe you would no longer be able to copyright the track Why? I'm not sure about US law, but here in Poland it would definitely still be copyrighted (even if you'd be effectively granting an automatic implicit license to use that name for the purpose of referencing the work).
- akira2501 5y agoMy logic is that you cannot copyright a fact. It is a fact you released an album, and it is a fact you titled it such. I'm free to reproduce that information, say in a catalog, without violating copyright.
- seba_dos1 5y agoBeing able to reproduce something in particular context without violating copyright does not mean it's not being copyrighted.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoHi are you Fiona Apple and if so can we be friends?
- scns 5y agoIs that the limit on Postgres' TEXT column?
- petsounds 5y agoThere is a band from Pasadena, California called Ozma. Way back in the day (1999), they released an album called “Songs of Audible Trucks and Cars” [0] via MP3.com. I later found out that they really wanted the title to be “Songs of Inaudible Trucks and Cars” [1], but MP3.com had a character limit on album titles, so they had to shorten it [0] https://www.discogs.com/release/8369169-Ozma-Songs-Of-Audible-Trucks-Cars https://www.discogs.com/release/8369169-Ozma-Songs-Of-Audibl... [1] https://www.discogs.com/release/15809071-Ozma-Songs-Of-Inaudible-Trucks-And-Cars https://www.discogs.com/release/15809071-Ozma-Songs-Of-Inaud...
- revolvingocelot 5y agoIf, like me, you immediately thought "why not just drop the 'and' and replace it with an ampersand?", Ozma had to do that, too, and parent's quoted the album title incorrectly, alas.
- tashi 5y ago"Songs of Inaudible Automobiles" would have fit and been fun to say aloud.
- throwaway684936 5y agoPresenting my new album: SQL Injection'); DROP TABLE Artists;--
- Tokkemon 5y agoAmazing!
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoProvocative, you could say.
- porcoda 5y agoIn addition to all of these edge cases, it doesn’t help that the metadata services have a lot of inconsistency as well. Say I have a song X that was performed live on DATE at some VENUE. It may show up as titled “X”, “X [live]”, “X (Live DATE)”, “X (DATE VENUE)”, and so on. Stuff that should be in metadata ends up in strings embedded in song and album titles, which makes for a big mess. I curate a huge collection and trying to keep my metadata consistent is a massive headache. I think I’ve tried just about every tool out there and still haven’t found one that I’m happy with.
- logbiscuitswave 5y agoOr the many ways to have “featuring” — “feat.”, “w/“, “ft.”, “(feat.)”, “[feat.]”, etc. MusicBrainz does a laudable job trying to standardize all this crap and as someone who is really particular about how their music metadata looks it’s highly appreciated.
- quickthrower2 5y agoNo mention of Prince?
- nocman 5y agoYou mean "The artist formerly known as the artist formerly known as Prince"? :-D
- joshspankit 5y agoAnother great one for the history books. His symbol broke so many music company systems and the story earned the respect of many.
- seaish 5y agoRelated, songs that are meant to be played by accident: https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/j4he7lv/183-the-venova-king https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/j4he7lv/183-the-veno... Example album: https://drumkoon.bandcamp.com/album/they-tried-to-ban-this https://drumkoon.bandcamp.com/album/they-tried-to-ban-this He has hits like "Hey Gugle Play Music" and "Hey Siri Play Space Music".
- mherdeg 5y agoI enjoyed his track "Sorry Katie I Spammed Your Smart Speaker".
- bobbyi 5y agoAmongst major artists, Tupac is good at causing confusion. Is he Tupac, 2Pac or Tupac Shakur? Does it depend on the album? Is his alter ego Makaveli a different artist?
- emptybits 5y agoYup. ARTIST_ID does not have a 1:1 relationship with ARTIST_NAME over time. Another example... from 1976 to present day: Johnny Cougar → John Cougar → John Cougar Mellencamp → John Mellencamp. Close enough for library software to store/recall them all as "John Mellencamp"? Maybe. But perhaps not to fans or historian or artist liking.
- geenew 5y agoRichard D James == "Aphex Twin" || "AFX" || "Caustic Window" || "Bradley Strider" || "GAK" || "user48736353001" || "Polygon Window" || "Universal Indicator" || "The Tuss" || "Powerpill" || "Mike & Rich" (for me, 'artist' is the alias, 'album artist' is 'Richard D James'...)
- webmaven 5y agoDon't forget Garth Brooks|Chris Gaines and Eminem|Slim Shady
- Klaster_1 5y agoImagine documenting something like this https://www.discogs.com/artist/661099-Filipe-Santos https://www.discogs.com/artist/661099-Filipe-Santos (check out the edit history) where the artist actively sabotages the documentation effort and makes their music unavailable on a whim.
- tzs 5y agoIt's not much an edge case in the sense of those, which mostly concern software authors making incorrect assumptions about the data in fields, but rather a "not even realizing we need a field" case, but music library managers are often quite annoying when dealing with classical music. They really want to fit everything into the artist/album/song scheme, and that doesn't really work well for much classical music. In classical music most of us would want something like composer/piece/orchestra/conductor/performers (the "performers" field would be for performers in addition to the normal orchestra, such as soloists or choruses), and it should be possible to change the sort key order among those fields.
- jay-anderson 5y agoDefinitely. Pieces end up being listed something like "Symphony No.3, Mvt. II", but they only show the performer which is the orchestra playing rather than the composer so I have no idea which symphony it is. I haven't seen any service get classical music right. I think your list is pretty good (composer/piece/orchestra/conductor/performers). It'd be nice to also have a field for the movement. Also I totally agree with custom sort order being a must. E.g. for choir pieces swap out 'orchestra' for 'choir', for piano pieces only include 'performer' field, concertos should have the 'soloist' before the orchestra, etc.
- CharlesW 5y ago> …music library managers are often quite annoying when dealing with classical music. Apple will apparently be solving this problem this year with a dedicated "Apple Classical" app, the origin of which is their Primephonic (https://www.primephonic.com/ https://www.primephonic.com/) acquihire. "Why are you shutting down Primephonic?" "To focus on creating an even better experience for customers around the world. Apple Music plans to launch a dedicated classical music app next year combining Primephonic’s classical user interface that fans have grown to love with more added features."
- nerdponx 5y agoA lot of music library managers (including good old iTunes) let you add a lot of various and esoteric song tag data as columns in the track list. The problem was always that the column arrangement that makes sense for one style of music doesn't make sense for another. One missing feature that I've never seen in a music library application is the ability to have "presets" for these column headers that you can easily switch between. So you can turn on the "classical" preset which shows Composer, Performer, etc., and you can turn on the "contemporary" preset which shows Artist and Album.
- nailer 5y agoThe odd one for me is Pendulum - there’s two different Australian acts, both electronic, with the name Pendulum. For some reason the newer Pendulum really liked the name and weren’t bothered / ethically concerned that the Pendulum that made ‘Coma’ had already existed. As of today Spotify has songs from both artists under the same artist name.
- lukeh 5y agoPlenty of duplicate artist names, Spotify artist support will split them into separate artists if you contact them, and now aggregators like DistroKid let you specify the actual artist ID when uploading (at least for some DSPs). It’s just another instance of there are only two hard problems :)
- tomcam 5y agoYeah my favorite is definitely Pendulum.
- lukaslalinsky 5y agoThere are much worse things than Pendulum. John Williams seems a very popular name for artists. :) Back when I was designing the "new" MusicBrainz database, that's what we have been using as the test case for this.
- nescioquid 5y agoI wonder what the "You suck, Flying Circus" sounds like.
- Bud 5y agoPretty disappointing to see an entire article like this go by without a single mention of classical music. Also known as basically all music prior to 1940 plus a lot of the most enduring music since.
- Karuma 5y agoThey do mention Tchaikovsky there... Or what do you mean, exactly?
- tomcam 5y agoNot sure I understand? There are accepted names/sequencing for all major Baroque, Classical, Romantic etc. artists: Mozart K numbers, Bach BWV numbers, etc. And usually there’s a close to unique name like Adagio in D Minor, Piano Sonata in Bb Major, etc.
- repsilat 5y agoI guess they mean that there are no original recordings for most of it, lots of cover bands etc.
- zokier 5y ago> Also known as basically all music prior to 1940 Sure, if you ignore blues&jazz, traditional folk, and all non-western music.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoI was all geared up for a “misconceptions software developers have about _” post but this seems mostly like … Unicode exists and data modeling should at least comprehend the domain?
- jandrese 5y agoOr really: Natural Language Processing still sucks. Trying to fit anything human produced into a reasonable data model is doomed to failure.
- recursive 5y agoI was hoping this was going to be about the musical part of music rather than the book keeping.
- cratermoon 5y agoI was hoping it was going to be about music engraving. See e.g. https://twitter.com/ThreatNotation https://twitter.com/ThreatNotation
- cosmotic 5y agoVery "creative"
- tomcam 5y agoThey missed a few common ones; Led Zeppelin’s fourth album with Stairway to Heaven on it was named only with Prince-like symbols, and of course the group named The The (which Google indexes well).
- sriku 5y agoI understand "horrible" in this case in a somewhat lighthearted sense. But it points to a tendency to simplify cultural complexity in the interest of "legibility" from the system perspective. The same diversity of cases need to be accommodated in much design done for, say, a diverse country like India where though urban populace me be English savvy, rural populace aren't necessarily so ... And even in urban areas local language and culture dominates. A place this diversity crops up most commonly is the so called "standard" firstname middlename lastname fields. This just doesn't work in India where people may have even 7 components to their names ... and who are you, dear system developer, to dictate what their name should be like. The name structure diversity I understand is a problem for Europe too with hyphenated names. This brilliant sketch by Fry and Laurie says it all - https://youtu.be/1LopIroSjsU https://youtu.be/1LopIroSjsU
- wincy 5y agoI mean, we get to dictate it because we’re writing the code and don’t know? I guess enterprising Indian developers should help it get fixed. As the whole world gets online this stuff gets sorted out, eventually. It’s not as if it’s malice or something. There are Americans with longer names though, I had a friend whose full name was five words, and all of his sisters and brothers also had “three middle names”.
- sriku 5y agoNot malice ... rather incompetence. If we can't handle this much accessibility, what hope do we have of making "ethical AI"?
- defensem3ch 5y agoThere's also Goto80's Files in Space https://www.goto80.com/goto80-files-in-space-mcmp3-data-airlines https://www.goto80.com/goto80-files-in-space-mcmp3-data-airl...
- nescioquid 5y agoHere "edge-case" indicates that music is not mere noise, while somehow remaining an instance of "marketing" or "acculturation". This is a good example of what happens when the insensate take power and pander to those who just want to read the "rule book". No art. No expression. No bother. Let's just agree on some fucking fiction that gets record label to bother with classical music meta-data in a way that meets the real world. Can we start there, at least? edit: click the inverted triangle if you are a jack-ass
- nescioquid 5y ago
- nescioquid 5y ago
- cgh 5y agoThis is pretty classic r/iamverysmart material right here.
- thewakalix 5y agoYou didn’t say “only if”, so it’s still possible to click the inverted triangle without being a jack-ass.
- lacrosse_tannin 5y agoThere's also different releases of the same album... 2020 remaster, vinyl rip, web flac, japan edition... Sometimes the music app just smooshes all together so the "album" looks like it has 4 of each track
- thristian 5y agoPeter Gabriel's first four solo albums were untitled. Well, the fourth was titled in America, but untitled everywhere else. Fans tend to distinguish them by the cover art: there's "Car", "Scratch", "Melt", and "Security".
- sharph 5y agoIt's worse than that, they were self-titled. So if there were some mechanism for numbering untitled albums, it can break down.
- dehrmann 5y agoWeezer's self-titled albums are distinguished by background color of the cover art.
- kingcharles 5y agoLOL. I used to work for PG. I created a schema for storing music metadata for him, so it's somewhat ironic.
- eashman 5y agoOh please tell this old Genesis fan some more. Gabriel was a very forward thinking musician from a technology perspective. See this clip for his demonstration of an early sampler [0] [0] https://youtu.be/7Xfj5n1kYXY https://youtu.be/7Xfj5n1kYXY
- kingcharles 5y agoHa, not many stories. He's a nice guy. I worked for him like 1999-2004? Through the 'Up' album, which I think is really underrated. Mostly Real World stuff though, as that has been his primary focus. Some cool parties at his studio, which is beautiful. I remember one when Martha from Martha and the Muffins had just finished producing an album and was moving on.. there was a party and bands.. and then PG got up on stage and took over the keyboard and started playing the beginning of "Echo Beach" and Martha was laughing in the crowd and saying "Nooo!", but you can't say No to PG, so she had to get up on stage and her and PG gave us an impromptu performance of "Echo Beach" which was awesome. p.s. that video was awesome. Were those 8" floppies it used?
- egypturnash 5y agoI am amused that despite mentioning both Keygen Church and Master Boot Record, this list refrains from mentioning that the former is a side project of the latter. And, yeah, if I was still collecting my music as CDs? Keygen Church would be filed next to the MBR because of that, not over in the Ks.
- Lammy 5y ago> Most albums have several versions/releases And some times they're altered without any obviously-visible indication like differing number of tracks or "edition" naming, e.g.: - MM..FOOD? (2004) [RSE0051-2] where "Kookies" samples Sesame Street: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RYCLfGE-_Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RYCLfGE-_Q - MM..FOOD? (2007) [RSE0084-2] where "Kookies" is totally re-recorded with a different and non-infringing beat: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iYSwvdEfeY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iYSwvdEfeY If you use a streaming service you're hearing the latter and might not ever realize the former existed. The re-record is a fine song, but the original fits much better with the rest of the album.
- dotancohen 5y agoThis is my problem with Rust in Peace. It was a terrific album, but Dave didn't want to continue paying royalties to people he no longer likes. So in 2004 or so almost the whole album was rerecorded with studio musicians. It is horrible, mechanical, flat. Even some of the vocals were redone, poorly. I'll sign up for the streaming service that provides the original 1990 Rust in Peace.
- scns 5y agoIs that the album where they blew the advance on drugs and had none left for good mixing and mastering?
- dotancohen 5y agoThat was Killing is my Business I think. Dave remastered that one too, which is actually not bad, but some things were changed and due to copyright he had to leave off the Nancy Sinatra song. I'd love a version of Killing is my Business with the remastered content were it is identical to the original, but with none of the content or artistic changes. Something like the despecialized Star Wars videos.
- slothtrop 5y agoYeah that was particularly obnoxious. According to discogs.com I think there are more recent reissues/remasters of the original version.
- thrdbndndn 5y ago> Weird album names: > † from Justice > from David Bowie > ' from Frank Zappa > () from Sigur Rós How are these albums names "edge cases"? I feel like ANY software would deal with them just fine. Hell, the last two don't even use non-ascii characters (though you definitely should have unicode support regardless). Edit: I just realize HN won't the star symbol (U+2605). Which is weird since it does support characters like Chinese/Japanese glyphs あいうえお你好
- Beltalowda 5y agoThere are actually some challenges with stuff like that; how do you sort "'" for example? Most people call the album "Apostrophe"; should it be sorted under "A"? What about the "†"? "D" for dagger? Somewhere else? How do you find things like that in the search box? Should searching for "star" return that Bowie album? > Edit: I just realize HN can't display [star] It doesn't do emojis and various graphic characters. This is supposedly a "feature" shrug-emoji-here
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Freak_NL 5y agoSorting is usually solved by allowing for optional separate sorting-key tags. So ' : album=' albumsort=Apostrophe These can act as search input as well, so searching for 'apostrophe' could yield it depending on the software used. † can either just sort wherever Unicode puts it, or if the album has a known pronunciation like 'star' above, have a sorting key too.
- rzzzt 5y agoWikipedia lists it as "Cross": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_(Justice_album) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_(Justice_album)
- Beltalowda 5y ago> † can either just sort wherever Unicode puts it, or if the album has a known pronunciation like 'star' above, have a sorting key too. Sure, but it doesn't happen automatically, so it's not "just do [..]". You need to think about some of these edge cases. I wrote a simple music library/player a bunch of years ago and ran in to some of these issues. I never did figure out how to deal with the band named "" in a sane way.
- maxbendick 5y agoMy time to shine! I work in music distribution. The Apple Music style guide is a great and accessible place to look if you're interested in music metadata: https://help.apple.com/itc/musicstyleguide/en.lproj/static.html https://help.apple.com/itc/musicstyleguide/en.lproj/static.h... DDEX is the set of metadata standards used across the music industry: https://ddex.net/ https://ddex.net/ Also worth knowing that not all content on streaming services is music! Some of it is spoken word, ASMR, non-music field recordings, etc. The difference between sound and music is subjective of course though. On an artistic note, music can of course be presented in an infinite amount of ways. Not all these can be represented (i.e., re-presented) on streaming platforms. Installations and generative music for example. That's ok! To be able to represent all this music (and non-music) requires restrictions, otherwise we wouldn't be able to create programs for it in the first place. Sometimes restrictions on sound content are to make the streaming services friendlier to use, like the formatting of featured artists in titles. Royalty laws put restrictions on the handling of different roles, like songwriters and composers. BUT nothing is stopping you from building your own way of representing music digitally, so long as you follow relevant laws.
- infofarmer 5y agoPleasant to see Apple has made some progress on their metadata guidelines (it used to be abhorrent for a company saved by the iPod). Looks like a useful one-pager to get a quick overview of the challenges without getting into any of them. For a proper attempt to preserve metadata, I'd refer to the MusicBrainz Style Guideline — https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style
- Thorrez 5y ago>Sometimes restrictions on sound content Is there some sort of rule against sirens? The song "Car Alarm" prominently features a car alarm on Youtube, but not on Spotify. This could just be a choice by the artists though, rather than a platform restriction. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xV7nHX2RLjQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xV7nHX2RLjQ https://open.spotify.com/album/2u4HDb57v96iiJZUC7PqOx?highlight=spotify:track:0OvzUMsUDTUp9v8c8CxR1q https://open.spotify.com/album/2u4HDb57v96iiJZUC7PqOx?highli...
- infofarmer 5y agoThere's a reason why MusicBrainz SQL schema looks like what it looks like, after years of careful simplification to achieve an optimum approximation of reality. https://musicbrainz.org/doc/MusicBrainz_Database/Schema https://musicbrainz.org/doc/MusicBrainz_Database/Schema 10+ years ago at Zvooq, during the golden age of music metadata and recsys startups, we tried to really solve entity resolution in the domain. I've never seen another streaming service make an honest attempt at this, even at Spotify with their 2014 acquihire of the Echo Nest. You still get Utada and Hikaru Utada as ~completely separate entities
- andybak 5y agoHa! I contributed the initial classical style guide many, many moons ago. I'm still technically an automod although I haven't participated for a long time.
- willhinsa 5y agowhat.cd had a really solid model as a user, but I've certainly been pleasantly pleased with musicbrainz.org
- throwaway48375 5y agoI really miss what.cd
- isoprophlex 5y agoHow do you feel about redacted? It seems to operate in the same spirit (if not backend code)
- throwaway48375 5y agoGot nothing against them, but it's still not what just like what wasn't oink. Every time there is something lost you just can't get back.
- dewey 5y ago
- mehrzad 5y agoA funny edge case I've found in one of the most popular music services (Last.fm). There is an instrumental post-rock ish band called Collections of Colonies of Bees and they have an album where almost all the tracks have the same name; they are all titled "Fun" except for the last track titled "Funeral". https://open.spotify.com/album/0LP8DTy4amlLIVXGOjvCo2?si=HJ3ntxqARDWvpVmyNK_ZlQ https://open.spotify.com/album/0LP8DTy4amlLIVXGOjvCo2?si=HJ3... This has caused last.fm to think "Fun" is one of my most played songs of the year even though they were all separate tracks.
- aasasd 5y agoI bet the most popular track name in techno is “Untitled”.
- mehrzad 5y agoI would guess that the problem only appears if it's the same artist and same album ID. Not sure if techno artists use "Untitled" multiple times on the same album, haha.
- aasasd 5y agoOh, easily—whole careers are probably made of ‘untitled’ tracks. Afaik, in edm a more common identifier for such unnamed records and tracks is the catalog number and track number or the side (for a single). Here's one of the best albums by Hype Williams the duo: https://www.discogs.com/master/337242-Hype-Williams-Untitled https://www.discogs.com/master/337242-Hype-Williams-Untitled (not edm but still).
- zimmund 5y agoLast.fm doesn't allow "untitled", "various artists", "track 01" and other titles that may suggest the song is incorrectly tagged. This leads, of course, to edge cases where an artist has a track named "untitled" and it can't be scrobbled. Moreover, last.fm also has an issue with unicode characters and some artists/albums may have two or more different profiles. It's a mess!
- Tokkemon 5y agoMost of this is great, but I'm calling BS on the Tchaikovsky example. Yes, there's been multiple historical spellings of his name, and to be absolutely accurate you would use the Cyrillic. However, the vast, vast majority of use cases should use the modern accepted spelling in English when referring to Tchaikovsky, which is what Wikipedia uses. There's a line you have to draw somewhere between accuracy and comprehension by the user and "Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky" is a pretty damn good one. The only other one I see commonly these days is the slightly more Anglicized "Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky" but that's it. Most other variants are historical or just have different editorial decisions, but they all refer back to the same guy, not a living artist who is changing his stage name all the time.
- blahedo 5y ago> ...in English... Even in English-language contexts I've seen variants of the German-style transliteration on occasion. But more importantly, the author is not restricting himself to English, and indeed the musicbrainz link gets to such a high count precisely by including other languages' transliterations. Only three are listed as English, and they're the two you mention (with/without Anglo first name) plus one that omits the middle name. Were you saying that all other languages should use "the modern accepted spelling in English", or were you just ignoring the fact that speakers of other languages (or owners of foreign-published albums) might use music databases?
- kzrdude 5y agoThe database might implicitly force a monolingual perspective on the dataset if they can't handle multiple translations of several fields. It's not an easy problem to manage, I imagine.
- xenadu02 5y agoAnother famous one is Prince's "Love Symbol no 2". Fun fact: he adopted it as his stage name to spite Warner Brothers Music, due to the unfavorable contract terms and the creative meddling they kept doing (among other things). By terms of the contract they had to go along with whatever stage name he picked. They had to spend a bunch of money having a custom font created, then mailed on floppy disk to every music reviewer, newspaper, magazine, radio station, etc as part of album promotion. No one was on the internet in those days so it ended up causing them a lot of trouble. I guess he found his own loophole in the contract.
- buro9 5y agoI've recently wondered whether it's worth periodically reprocessing the metadata on music files with musicbrainz Picard. It was all done when added to the catalog, but presumably the metadata could be updated and a periodic refresh would be a benefit.
- can16358p 5y agoWhat is the deal with Japanese exclusive bonus tracks/promo thing? Interested about why a significant number of albums have Japanese promo versions with extra tracks. Is that a cultural thing about Japan or is there another specific reason? (I know it's not only Japan but mostly Japanese editions that I see throughout the web) As if, almost even brouillard has a Japanese bonus track named brouillard in their album brouillard.
- Hamuko 5y agoI heard somewhere that it was an incentive for the Japanese market, which still today is a large physical CD market, to buy the locally distributed releases of albums instead of just buying the original foreign release, which may have been available earlier and for cheaper, or if they already bought the original release, buy it again.
- dotancohen 5y agoIs this why the super-high quality vinyls were also available only in Japan? I cannot remember the name of the company, but there is (was) some company selling increased dynamic range recordings of popular albums, on very durable (as in, regularly replace the needle) vinyl. I had heard an imported (from Japan) Dark Side of the Moon recording on that once, and it just blew me away.
- Hamuko 5y agoI imagine the super-high quality vinyls are because of a very special breed of Japanese audiophiles who don't mind spending on their hobby. https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-gift-for-music-lovers-who-have-it-all-a-personal-utility-pole-1471189463 https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-gift-for-music-lovers-who-hav...
- dotancohen 5y agoI was likely wrong, it wasn't a Japanese company. This is most likely the company that produced the high-quality recording that I heard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_Fidelity_Sound_Lab https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_Fidelity_Sound_Lab
- whyoh 5y agoTagging challenges are one reason why I sort and browse music by folders/filesystem.
- klez 5y agoAren't you just moving the complexity from tags to the filesystem that way? How does that solve the problem in a way that tags don't?
- whyoh 5y agoYeah I should have made it clear that I mean specific problems, like musicians who release an album under a different name... With a folder based approach it's easier to put all of those in one place. The filesystem also has some drawbacks, like a more limited character set. But all in all, I like it.
- throwaway384813 5y agoBookmarking this for future reference! I recently started a fun/side project which aims to improve my personal tedious process of (a) managing a queue of things I want to listen to, (b) keeping track of which of them I listened/liked and (c) easily sharing my "discovery activity" with my friends who share the same passion. The idea is that you can add items to a "Queue" list, using Discogs Master URLs (e.g. https://www.discogs.com/master/1994809-Alt%C4%B1n-G%C3%BCn-Yol https://www.discogs.com/master/1994809-Alt%C4%B1n-G%C3%BCn-Y...) or Spotify album links, because this is what I use in my day to day. So I've started by parsing Discogs' data dumps[1] to backfill my database (aka. "release groups" in MusicBrainz), so that I avoid hitting Discogs API with every user query) with all "master" releases. But then realized that (a) they don't include cover images and (b) not every release has a corresponding "master" release and (c) they're not updated frequently enough (maybe monthly). Then I thought of using MusicBrainz data dumps[2] to augment the entries by Discogs in my database, which do provide cover art images, but then how do I correlate them with the already-inserted Discogs releases? Fortunately there's a Discogs URL for many release groups from MusicBrainz; unfortunately only 50% of them do have it. Then I could perhaps use solely MusicBrainz data and not Discogs at all, but then what if people are mostly using Discogs links? This will result in two identical records on my database, pointing to the same underlying release but in different sites (Discogs & MusicBrainz). Perhaps this can only be solved by human moderation and providing the ability to "merge two items". Then I thought of actually contributing to MusicBrainz and add the Discogs URL for every release group. Another interesting assumption I made, which turned out incorrect, was the every [artist, release title] pair was unique. But that's not the case - an artist may have multiple "master" releases (i.e. completely different tracks inside) with the same title. [1] http://data.discogs.com/ http://data.discogs.com/ [2] https://musicbrainz.org/doc/MusicBrainz_Database https://musicbrainz.org/doc/MusicBrainz_Database
- creshal 5y ago- Artist names can become rather long too, especially for collaborations. Some anime OSTs easily break 256 characters. - And for song titles that need careful escaping, QuelI->EX[cez]->{kranz}; and EXEC_SOL=FAGE/. have tripped up more than one CLI music player in my experience.
- morelisp 5y agoA simpler explanation is that your computer has an unstable grathnode installed.
- photon-torpedo 5y agoTo add to the list: Song titles that cannot be fully represented in Unicode. Example (also to plug my favorite band): Magma, a French progressive rock [*] band that's been (on and off) active for more than 50 years, mostly uses their own invented language "Kobaïan" where some of the characters use diacritics that are (to the best of my knowledge) not present in Unicode. E.g. there's an S with a kind of crown on top. [*] Actually their style of music is unique enough that it's given rise to its own genre, "Zeuhl".
- gorgoiler 5y agoCatalogue numbers! You wouldn’t index a collection of records by the shape of its sonic wave forms, would you? No more would you index by the artistic representations on the cover which, as we have seen, includes everything including the words purporting to be the artist name and the title of the release. No, of course not! You use the barcode on the back! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalog_number_(music) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalog_number_(music) For white labels, I guess you have to hide them in a pile until they get a release.
- shiomiru 5y agoUnicode support is one thing. I frequently have to re-tag Japanese music because its tags are encoded in shift-jis which in general doesn't work on Linux.
- eschneider 5y agoAnd for new bands: Maybe try not to name yourself after a Siri/Alexa/Whatever revered word. Jus try asking Siri to play a song by "Them." Ugh.
- FabHK 5y agoMeta Comment: I much prefer this informative post (with a clear title and plenty of examples and explanations) to the uncommented "Falsehoods programmers believe about ..." listicles.
- MereInterest 5y agoAbsolutely. Stating that an assumption is false with no further information doesn't help me update my mental model of the world. Giving an example of how an assumption is incorrect shows the type of errors that can occur, when they can occur, and lets the reader figure out a better way to work around the false assumption.
- DonaldFisk 5y agoI've noticed some of these for years. When designing a music database, you do need to be aware of them. You need to use unique identifiers instead of names. last.fm doesn't do this. There were four bands called Kaleidoscope, all active around the same time: one from England, one from Mexico, one from the USA, and one from Canada. To disambiguate them, generally the country is specified, e.g. Kaleidoscope (UK). There were two bands called Bulldog Breed, both of which recorded albums called Made in England. They're decades apart, but as albums can be re-released, they're normally disambiguated by record label, e.g. Bulldog Breed: Made in England (Deram). There are two Nirvanas, the original UK-based band, and the US one. The UK Nirvana recorded a cover of Lithium. You'll be aware that the Beatles recorded an album called Revolver. A Russian band, called Revolver, recorded an album called Beatles. Do you include the definite article in the band's name? If so, what about The The? Tintern Abbey released a single single, the A-side of which was called Beeside.
- mauvehaus 5y agoI've always thought it'd be a bit cheeky to start a band and name the first three albums "Self-Titled", "Eponymous"[0], and give the third album the name of the band. Fortunately, I lack any amount of musical talent, so this will never happen. [0] I know, REM beat me to it.
- cpeterso 5y ago> Do you include the definite article in the band's name? If so, what about The The? My SiriusXM radio omits leading articles like “The”, so “The Beatles” is displayed as “Beatles”. I alway long wondered how it would display “The The”. Would it be “The”, empty string “”, “The The”, or something else entirely. I eventually learned the answer: “The The”. Which is good, but then made me frustrated that it wouldn’t allow the “The Beatles” to be “The Beatles”.
- vermooten 5y agoDon’t forget how much streaming services struggle with classical music meta data.
- philjohn 5y agoSimilar problems when dealing with books. J.K. Rowling has written works under other names, e.g. Newt Scamander. And then you have the case of the (actually recorded this way by the Library of Congress) author "Mark Twain (ghost, through mediumship)"
- moogly 5y agoAdding to the list: There are two well-known Avishai Cohens, both jazz musicians (so you can't disambiguate on the broader genre), both from Israel (so you can't disambiguate on country of origin), but luckily they do play different instruments (bass and trumpet). --- The Australian post-rock/shoegazeish band The Dead Sea https://www.discogs.com/artist/1450625-The-Dead-Sea https://www.discogs.com/artist/1450625-The-Dead-Sea released a self-titled EP with 3 tracks in 2006. 2009 they released a full self-titled album (only 1 song from the EP featured on it). I can't even find the "second" release on discogs. Both were self-released, so no way to disambiguate on ISMN or record label/publisher. So you'd have to disambiguate only on the year of release, or define what demarcates an EP from a full album and mark them as such (there are some competing definitions out there, since it became less clear after the introduction of the CD, and now digital, but even back then you had complections like maxi singles and mini-LPs, IIRC). --- Many of John Zorn's releases tend to be headaches: "Tap" Composed and produced by: John Zorn Performed by: Pat Metheny Subtitle "Book of Angels, vol. 20" Overarching series "Masada Book 2" Released on Tzadik (Zorn's personal label) as a John Zorn/Pat Metheny output. Licensed to Nonesuch (Metheny's label) as a Pat Metheny release with different cover.
- slothtrop 5y agoYou also can't find Zorn's music streaming anywhere. I've heard of one store that offered digital purchases, but not for the whole discography. You can fill a large closet collecting just his stuff so I'm not sure why digital is off the table.
- adrianmonk 5y ago> There are two well-known Avishai Cohens, both jazz musicians (so you can't disambiguate on the broader genre), both from Israel (so you can't disambiguate on country of origin), but luckily they do play different instruments (bass and trumpet). Along very similar lines, there are also famously two musicians named Bill Evans. Both play jazz (genre) and both are from the US (country). As a bonus, both have been members of bands led by Miles Davis. And again you can differentiate them by instrument (piano and saxophone). Which is sort of what Wikipedia article titles do to differentiate them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Evans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Evans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Evans_%28saxophonist%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Evans_%28saxophonist%29 I guess Wikipedia also differentiates by level of fame, since the pianist article title doesn't have a qualifier.
- parenthesis 5y agoI was searching for the artist Urban Soul on Tidal to discover there's another artist called Urban Soul (I wanted the Roland Clark project) with albums by both mixed up together in the search result. 'Twas all in vain, since I wanted a particular remix of `Alright' — which I have on a vinyl promo less that a metre from where I am sitting (I can remember clear as day buying it more than 25 years ago) — which Tidal don't have. So I ended up listening to it on YouTube.
- inetsee 5y agoHow about the horrible edge case when trying to read this pale blue text against a white background. It's been a while since I criticized the readability of a web page, but I think this page deserves a critique.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoOne of the simplest data model mistakes that seems nearly universal in music software is pretending that some things are single values when they're really lists. Take "artist". An album can have a compilation of tracks, each from a different artist. A given track can have multiple artists, eg a guest singer. There can be multiple composers of a track, there can be multiple writers of lyrics, and there are usually several performers (even if they all are part of the same band). An album can have multiple names, or no name at all (which often means people refer to it in different ways, giving it multiple effective names). Likewise with tracks. Albums and tracks get re-released, sometimes re-mastered, sometimes re-recorded entirely, without the names changing. The same recording of a given track might be released on multiple albums, eg as a single in a pre-release and then within the main album. Tracks might be mastered differently for different media (Radio vs CD vs background use in cinema, etc). Names of any of these things don't have to be representable in any existing text encoding, or even any combination of encodings. Artist name should be a list (or other multiple element structure). Track name should be a list. Album name should be a list. Etc. Assume a malicious artist will find a way to make the assumption that any field has a unique value incorrect.
- wolverine876 5y ago> or other multiple element structure Right. It's a relational database with lots of many-to-many relationships. We need to stop trying to make it a flat file. A FOSS SQLite schema that everyone can embed, or even a turnkey little db, would be wonderful.
- wdr1 5y agoI feel like musicians were doing Little Bobby Drop Tables long before the XKCD comic.
- joshspankit 5y ago100%
- joe__f 5y agoDoes anyone recognise the equation from the Aphex Twin track? ∆Mᵢ⁻¹=−α ∑ Dᵢ[η][ ∑ Fjᵢ[η−1]+Fextᵢ [η⁻¹]] With the ∆M and the sum over Fs, I wondered if it might be something to do with rocket dynamics derived from Newton's second law?
- trelliscoded 5y agoIt's pseudomathematical nonsense. The Fji term might be a hint about the image hidden in the track when plotted on a spectrogram, but the rest of it doesn't make much sense. You can see the original title here: https://i.discogs.com/YC8CLuli-NW3VB5z7eA9mALjnL2Qef4aGyDYH4u8mgw/rs:fit/g:sm/q:90/h:472/w:600/czM6Ly9kaXNjb2dz/LWRhdGFiYXNlLWlt/YWdlcy9SLTM4NTI2/ODMtMTM0Njk0MDQ2/Mi0zOTExLmpwZWc.jpeg https://i.discogs.com/YC8CLuli-NW3VB5z7eA9mALjnL2Qef4aGyDYH4... As an example, why would the index of the last term be inverted like that? Maybe it's supposed to mean something phonetically, but I'm not a music person so I can't figure it out.
- joe__f 5y agoOh I didn't realise the eta was the index, I was reading the sum as over i on the right hand side
- hamstergene 5y agoElectronic music is also full of remixes, for example: Artist: Moby Title: Simple Love (B-Motion Remix) The actual artist is B-Motion and any kind of browser/catalog must group this track with other B-Motion music, or in worst case both, because remixes are in entirely different genres than the original. So "Artist" is not necessarily the artist.
- ux 5y agoI wrote something similar a while back: http://blog.pkh.me/p/15-the-music-classifying-nightmare.html http://blog.pkh.me/p/15-the-music-classifying-nightmare.html
- joshspankit 5y agoIt's worth noting as well, that some of these edge cases are directly because of artists intentionally "messing with" whatever they perceive as hard rules. The reason I mention this is because you cannot simply look at a list of all edge cases, identify what schema you can use to encapsulate them all, and then build your service around the idea that the schema will never change. As a very simple (I hope contrived) example: You could decide to use a string delimiter so that you can capture "all the strings" and still use string interpolation. You then look through all the edge cases and see "No one has named anything with U+1F7F6, so we're safe to use that". 100% guarantee that as soon as someone sees that they will name a track or an album in the exact way they need to to break your system.
- kazinator 5y agoI don't think it's meaningful to talk about edge cases without a set of requirements connecting inputs to desired outputs: what you want to do with the data, or hope to get out of it. Features like long album names, empty names, or names with international characters from Unicode, are not hardly edge cases. Edge cases have to have some surprise to them. Coming from a blank slate, you'd never approach a problem with the assumption that all strings are 32 characters or less, confined to 7 bit ASCII, and are never empty and then paint your face surprised call "edge case!" when they aren't.