11 ms·
Right, you don't build affordable housing, and you don't even reserve housing as "affordable" (that's gratuitously inviting corruption via basically giving away
by zozbot234 5y ago
Right, you don't build affordable housing, and you don't even reserve housing as "affordable" (that's gratuitously inviting corruption via basically giving away underpriced housing as a 'gift' to cronies and associates). You build as much new housing as you can afford to, and let older housing filter down to "affordable" levels.
- dylan604 5y ago>let older housing filter down to "affordable" levels. you're forgetting the part where it is the older housing that is currently affordable that is getting demolished so that this new construction can use that land instead.
- lupire 5y agoThat is why the number that (should) matter for regulation is not price, it's net change in unit count.
- dylan604 5y agoI like this metric as well. However, if you displace X number of lower income residents with your new fancy schmancy high dollar condos, just increasing the unit count does not allow the displaced residents to be able to afford to live where they currently were. More than likely, they will be pushed further away from city centers. This causes more burden especially if the new location places them at a distance that mass transit does not reach.
- asdff 5y agoThat's not what I observe in my city. They tear out a few single family homes that you would need a deposit of $200k to even be competitive for, thats probably why its a developer buying it vs working people anyhow, or its like a few old tire shops occupying a parcel caddy corner from a subway station or a few bus lines that really should be repurposed into something more useful the the community anyhow. Hardly ever do you see multi family older housing being demoed and rebuilt because these things get more complicated with more tenants.
- HarryHirsch 5y agolet older housing filter down to "affordable" levels That's the theory. The practice is that much of the "older housing" is by now 50 or 60 years old, twice the design life, and at some point renovation is just not economical any longer, you are looking at a teardown and rebuild. That meme tells more about the profession of economics as taught in schools and universities. It doesn't tell you how the world works, but it provides support for the way things are. There's that old cartoon with a royal and a priest, and the royal turns to the priest saying "you keep them stupid, I keep them poor." That's applied economics.
- zozbot234 5y agoNot sure what your point is. If it turns out you have built lots and lots of the highest-density housing and there's nothing affordable in sight even after that, then guess what - you're basically in Manhattan. There are far worse problems to have when it comes to urban development!
- rtlfe 5y ago> If it turns out you have built lots and lots of the highest-density housing and there's nothing affordable in sight even after that, then guess what - you're basically in Manhattan. Your point is good, but it turns out that a lot of really expensive parts of Manhattan aren't anywhere near as dense as they should be, such as: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.744212,-74.0017042,3a,90y,346.54h,112.21t/data=!3m10!1e1!3m8!1sN6Kqlhbtflehd1MFFW39Tw!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DN6Kqlhbtflehd1MFFW39Tw%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D32.773224%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192!9m2!1b1!2i29 https://www.google.com/maps/@40.744212,-74.0017042,3a,90y,34...
- asdff 5y agoThat's because its not about the number of apartments, its about the ratio of jobs to apartments and it being completely out of whack which leads to only those making above average income winning in the housing market (rental or buying). Manhattan looks like it should be affordable since its so dense, but it doesn't have enough housing for how many jobs there are there, especially high income jobs.
- wan23 5y agoThere are two problems with this idea. The first is that the existing housing stock is already occupied, and the people who occupy it don't have much incentive to go anywhere. If we could build a massive amount of new, high quality housing then in theory the demand for the older homes might decrease but in many places we're in such a deep supply hole that the necessary amount of new construction just isn't going to happen given the political environment. The second problem is that filtering takes time, but people need homes today. There's an argument to be made that it's in the public interest to allow for at least some units to be made available that are affordable to someone on a teacher's salary. Also, building homes at any price point is a good idea.
- zozbot234 5y ago> There's an argument to be made that it's in the public interest to allow for at least some units to be made available that are affordable to someone on a teacher's salary. There's an easy way to do that - raise teachers' salaries, and let them choose whatever housing they want, not what you've arbitrarily designated as "affordable" (via a political process). This raises observable costs, but has plenty of less obviohs benefits.
- deepakhj 5y agoIf we want to fix teacher's salaries, we need to reform prop 13. The OUSD funding issues could have been solved if prop 15 was passed.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoOUSD spends over $20k per student per year. ($746MM for 36k students.) That's $480k per class per year. OUSD owns its buildings, so none of that money needs to go to rent. Why isn't $480k per class per year enough?
- bradleyjg 5y agoI think prop 13 should be fixed because it distorts the housing market but why is it necessary to pay teachers more. The state legislature can supplement school funding with income tax money. No referendum needed.
- Schroedingersat 5y agoBut the key is the new stuff has to not take up more land than needed and not have features that make it cost more than needed. 700 square foot condos in a fourplex or 2 story cottages in a cottage cluster or row houses could be built for a fraction of the cost at 4x the density. But in many areas they are prevented by setbacks, minimum lot sizes, coverage rules, parking requirements, and so on. Internal material and design regulations similarly don't optimize for things that are safe/functional and affordable.
- Plasmoid 5y agoCalifornia requires solar panels on new construction. Adding $20k worth of electrical systems doesn't make the house more affordable.
- burnished 5y agoMost of those systems pay for themselves and make great investments right?
- epistasis 5y agoThat's right, the solar panels decrease monthly utility costs more than they increase the mortgage payment. The law is written to mandate only energy efficiency that saves money, and it's necessary because contractors are too tied to tradition to actually examine what results in lower cost homes.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoWhere do those panels go? In Seattle, the current style is townhomes with almost flat rooftop decks, I don’t see a place for them, but we aren’t exactly the best place for solar.
- burnished 5y agoI imagine the roofs are still probably the best places for them. I doubt you want to set them directly onto the roof anyway, so if you need a little scaffolding to get them arranged in a particular fashion then installation is probably the right time to do that. Yeah, I guess the angle with the sun or something for most of the year makes solar a little more difficult up here? Thankfully we've got a lot of hydro-electric.
- opportune 5y agoI completely agree. The idea that X% of new housing has to be sold at under market rate makes no sense to me. It just artificially increases the cost of the market rate units. You would build more housing if it were all sold at market rate (since it’s more profitable to build, and then more will get built/developers will be more incentivized to build) and have lower market rate prices. It seems fairer for the “below market rate” housing to just be the not-new housing at the actual market rates. For some reason California is obsessed with the idea that housing is too expensive, so we need to force new construction to subsidize middle-middle class housing via a lottery system, which keeps housing expensive
- bckr 5y ago> California This comment made me realize that maybe powerful people actually want to push lower income people out of the state, or metros at least.
- opportune 5y agoI don't think it's that insidious. They probably just don't want the value of market rate housing to go down because that's popular with voters
- bckr 5y agoI wouldn't even describe the situation I'm describing as insidious, but I see what you're saying. Yours is also a more likely answer.
- MichaelBurge 5y agoWhy don't they rezone everyone's land as commercial then? Not sure about California, but in most places that would double or triple the value of the land. If you did everyone all at once, it probably wouldn't be so extreme but would still be an increase.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago
- bombcar 5y agoExactly. Imagine ten people in various wealth from very poor to very rich - if you build a new better house for the richest, they can all move up like hermit crabs for not much comparatively- and the poorest house now opens up for someone who didn’t have one before.
- rasz 5y agoHaha. Old houses become presents for rich persons grandchildren, so they can put them on airbnb while studying abroad/living in another country altogether.
- epistasis 5y agoAnd why do they have the power to charge rent? Because there's a perpetual artificial shortage caused by the wealthy restricting building.
- zaroth 5y agoYou can rent virtually any durable good of value. “Power” has nothing to do with it, ownership does.
- epistasis 5y agoI'm talking about market power to charge rents high enough to keeping capital tied up in a home, rather than some more productive use of it. That sort of ownership of the land rents is exactly the problem, as it incentivizes the local land owners to use their political power to en chance their market power to charge high rents.
- zaroth 5y agoThis makes no sense. The “capital tied up in the home” is the reason that the home was built — obviously someone had to pay for it. So what you’ve stated is effectively a tautology. Either ownership embues the owner with the right to rent their property, or you don’t believe in ownership at all. You vote where you live, not where you own. The “local land owners using political power” is a trope posted here often, but I’m pretty sure it’s the renters who are electing the local politicians.
- fbernier 5y ago> You build as much new housing as you can afford to, and let older housing filter down to "affordable" levels. In many larger cities, older housing occupy prime location where the value of the land is twice the value of a new building you could build on it, so all these would never filter down to affordable levels.
- yellowapple 5y agoThen it's time to break out the one-two punch that would specifically address the land being disproportionately valuable: a land value tax + a citizens' dividend (a.k.a. universal basic income). If anyone's to benefit from that land being valuable, it should be the citizenry as a whole, not some cartel of landlords who lucked into it.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoCould that really work at a local level where people can freely move cities? Local UBI seems hard to implement in a non city state. But if we are talking city states, why not take the Singaporean approach? Just have the government build apartments and subsidize sale to citizens? Everyone gets a flat eventually.
- yellowapple 5y ago> Could that really work at a local level where people can freely move cities? Local UBI seems hard to implement in a non city state. Only if you overthink it. An "open border" LVT+UBI system is self-balancing; a flood of immigrants would drive up demand for land, which drives up its value, which raises LVT revenue, which raises total UBI disbursement, which keeps each individual's UBI stable. That said, it would work even better at a state level, and better still at a national/federal level. > why not take the Singaporean approach? The Singaporean approach (IIUC) includes land leases, which is in practice equivalent to a 100% LVT (assuming the government prices the lease at the land's full value).
- andreareina 5y agoI'm in Singapore and that's missing a lot of context. The supply of government housing is not nearly enough to meet supply and there are restrictions on who can apply and even then it's a lottery. Property is still considered an investment, and no wonder when resale prices for the HDB flats are significantly higher than the purchase price. IMO the HDB flats should not be saleable on the open market and can only be sold back to the government (subject to inflation and depreciation adjustments that no-one's going to agree to) but I'm an expat and not eligible to partake in the upside so I might be a bit biased. All that being said they have done a better job than most of making government housing both accessible and appealing even if it means that I'm having to find a new place to live in the middle of an inflationary period (even as the country is seeing net emigration for the first time in decades, wth is going on??)
- yobbo 5y agoThe market price of houses has almost nothing to do with the buildings themselves, and the cost of internal surface materials has essentially no relevant bearing on the price either. To get the market price for housing down; even a supply glut would not help as long as mortgages are subsidised, and defacto function as economic stimulus and retirement funds.
- krisoft 5y ago> You build as much new housing as you can afford to, and let older housing filter down to "affordable" levels. The question is what sort of housing you build. You have a piece of dirt ready to be developed or re-developed. You can put there a mansion which will house one family with enough garden to picnic a whole village and still have space to land a helicopter. Or you can build four detached homes with plenty of garden at the same place. Or you can build two 3-story buildings with 6 flats each and have space for a small comunal park between them. And we can’t say that the market should figure out what kind of houses should be built, because we already have tax laws, and building codes, and etc which heavily influences what kind of building gets built. The question is not “should we put our finger on the scale” but “which direction should said finger push”?
- zozbot234 5y agoYou should build whatever puts the land at its "highest and best use". In any area with high housing costs, this will generally mean building the two 3-story condos. Which is why flats are generally found in cities where housing costs a lot, and large mansions are common in rural areas - market choice does a fine job of this already.
- rdtwo 5y agoYeah they problem is that highest and best use is probably also highest risk and longest flow so most builders just opt to put up a McMansion or 2, make their 20-30% and move to the next project
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoWhat do people that need shelter in the meantime do?