7 ms·
Crickets from the usual crowd who would be crying "cancel culture!" on all TV and radio for weeks and calling for heads to roll had the tweet been about somethi
by paxys 5y ago
Crickets from the usual crowd who would be crying "cancel culture!" on all TV and radio for weeks and calling for heads to roll had the tweet been about something other than a cause they support (military worship).
Governments and companies continue to get more and more empowered to do this stuff because people always show that it has never really been about freedom but rather pushing their own views.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoI'm on the right, the far right even by HN standards. This response is either comically out of touch or disingenuous. Nobody in my circles is celebrating this, it has always been about freedom, and I have never encountered your straw man in real life or even on the dangerous alt-right forums where I was radicalized.
- pie_flavor 5y agoMostly because they spent all their time shouting about it when he was initially arrested. Why get worked up twice over the same issue? UK gonna UK.
- nailer 5y agoI normally cry cancel culture and I find this awful despite not sympathizing with the man's views. Likewise I'm concerned about the impact of 'nuisance' laws in the UK on legitimate dissent despite finding most protestors to be annoying.
- coolso 5y agoI think you may be looking for an issue where there is none on this one. While "the usual crowd" absolutely rightly believes in canceling the cancelers as pushback for anti-freedom policies like the cancel culture embraced by the left and progressives, I just Googled the guy's name and there's barely any news articles on it at all aside from a few tabloid-tech style sites like this one, starting a day or two ago. I'd chalk this one up to "most people have no idea this even happened".
- elliekelly 5y ago> While "the usual crowd" absolutely rightly believes in canceling the cancelers as pushback for anti-freedom policies like the cancel culture embraced by the left and progressives Unironically canceling the cancelers to pushback against cancel culture? Maybe the horseshoe theory has some merit after all.
- coolso 5y agoCertainly, it is the cancelers who are most upset when their behavior comes back around and bites them in the behind. Do you also have a problem with robbers being punished by the justice system and having their ill-begotten spoils returned to their rightful owners? It’s really no different.
- elliekelly 5y agoIt is different. Fundamentally different. One is retributive (A did it to B so B is “justified” in doing it to A, too) and the other is restorative (A took from B so “justice” is served by A returning it to B). Everyone is worse off in the first scenario (an eye for an eye and all...) while everyone is back to where they started in the second scenario. A better example might be punishing a murderer with the death penalty. But most people who oppose retributive “justice”, myself included, do indeed have a problem with that system so it’s still not a particularly persuasive point. If a person believes $action is wrong but are able to rationalize why it’s only wrong when others do it but it’s justified and permissible when they do it then it seems to me that the hullabaloo over $action is just a pretext and real issue they’re mad about is who is doing it rather than the $action itself.
- stale2002 5y agoYou are missing the point of the retaliation, in this eye for an eye way. The problem is that one side currently doesn't think it is wrong to do these attacks in the first place. But maybe they will start to understand the harm, if they are subject to the same thing. Yes, it is better for these cancel attacks to happen to nobody. But it simply isn't going to stop until people on all sides understand the harm that it causes, and likely the only way to do that is for them to suffer at least a bit of those same attacks.
- throwaway0x7E6 5y agobecause it didn't happen in the US. we've long since accepted that freedom of thought in Europe is a lost cause.
- farmerstan 5y agoWhat on earth would make you say this? There are plenty of people upset over this including myself and others that believe in free speech. This is unfortunately in the UK which doesn’t have the same protections as the US. This person would not have been found guilty in the US but the UK doesn’t have the same level of freedoms.
- lambertsimnel 5y agoI read the grand-parent comment as about the misrepresentation of free-speech in the media. Of course there are sincere and consistent free-speech supporters, but their cause is disproportionately used in the British media to favour opponents of other liberal/libertarian causes.
- liquidise 5y agoDisc: american commenting on uk legal matters. > people always show that it has never really been about freedom (emphasis mine) Which people? They always act this way? It was never about freedom, for anyone? Who could possibly say this authoritatively? I think the last ~5 years has put a bright light onto freedom of speech. It is a complicated topic with some surprisingly nuanced positions. Does it include the ability to say what you want wherever you want? Or without consequence? There are multiple vectors to it. I consider myself a free speech advocate. But i have no military fetishism that you claim is one of the root causes for free speech support (a weird combo). I support free speech because... i think people speaking their mind freely is a net positive. That appears to be increasingly controversial these days. That's fine, more room for discussion.
- rockooooo 5y agoThe largest media outlets that beat the freedom of speech drum (fox, other right wing sites) never do so in response to people whose speech they don't like being silenced.
- SkyBelow 5y agoOne major factor is a disagreement in what counts as speech. I see this from people individually discussing topics and from official stances of platforms, even supposedly free speech platforms. One of the safer to discuss at work examples is how loud can speech be while still being speech. Is a concert playing loud music free speech? Is it still free speech when the music is at such a level it causes hearing damage for those attending? Even if some attendees are children? What if it is only temporary hearing damage? What level of loudness creates enough harm to another person for it to stop being considered speech? Where is the distinction between me causing you bodily harm with airwaves or with punches? Another example is bright lights. Having a sign up is free speech. But what if the sign is well lit up at night? How many photons can I send toward you before it stops being speech and starts being violence? Clearly aiming a powerful enough laser to cause eye damage would violate it. But what if it was a weaker red laser that I was shining through your window. If it is the aspect of targeting you that matters, then when if I set up a bill board and put a bunch of red lasers pointers that moved around randomly to draw attention, so it is no longer targeting just at you. Then there is all sorts of problems one can get into with photos and the numbers that represent them.
- karaterobot 5y agoI don't know about "crickets". This thread is full of people who think this is a bad move. Personally, I'm of two minds about it: this isn't a "cancel culture" situation, because evidently he did break a law. He's not being shunned by society, he's just getting arrested for a crime — however ridiculous the crime may be. The main argument against this sentence is that other people do the same thing all the time and don't get punished for it. That's not a strong defense. The other argument is that the law itself is inappropriately applied, which it probably is. But this guy wasn't engaged in civil disobedience, he was a drunken idiot who thought he could shoot his mouth off with impunity, and to his surprise he got caught in the system. He should appeal, and the law should be clarified, changed, or struck down, because it's being selectively applied and that's a bit scary. But, this isn't shocking, and the guy isn't a sympathetic hero.
- systemvoltage 5y agoI think this comment leaves a bad taste. It is dissing at partisanry where there isn't any. I personally know many republicans and democrats who have a staunch sense of free of speech. They all would be crying in unison. The problem with your view is 1) It is unsubstantiated - where do you see "crickets from the usual crowd"? 2) It is exaggerated and playing into partisan tribalism of people. 3) Creates more division than helps, does not address anything really except teach toxicity. You're flaming the fumes.
- throwaway684936 5y ago
- skippyboxedhero 5y agoThis is a partisan topic. The reason why this has happened is an old law that has been repurposed by the police to pursue these claims. In Scotland, which has a different govt to the UK on this issue, the hate speech laws are even more stringent (and the police even more aggressive in pursuing crimes on Twitter). This is always going to be a controversial topic with too sides. That isn't apparent in the US because there are such strong protections on freedom. But that doesn't change the fact that there are some people who believe they should be removed: those people exist in every society, they are a majority in the place where this occurred, and they are a majority in many other countries. Saying that someone is fanning the flames when they say they support freedom misunderstands the topic totally. There are people who believe free speech is weak and decadent, the First Minister of Scotland is a lawyer...these people are not crazies, they are people in govt today. And there aren't two sides to freedom, you are either for or against, there is no middle ground (I live in Scotland, the primary argument of people who want to supress freedom was your argument, word for word...my freedom is gone now).
- ethanpailes 5y agoIf the national review doesn’t count as the usual crowd, I don't know who does. https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/the-scottish-government-just-prosecuted-a-man-for-sending-a-rude-tweet/ https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/the-scottish-governmen...
- rsynnott 5y agoThe National Review is very much on the respectable ideologically consistent side of the Usual Crowd (TM). (I mean, don't get me wrong, it's awful, but it largely has the courage of its convictions). Rest assured that, like, the Sun and Daily Mail and Spectator aren't going to be decrying this.
- Joeboy 5y agoHere[0]'s the Spectator decrying it. You're probably right about the Sun and Daily Mail. [0] https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/sending-a-mean-tweet-about-captain-tom-shouldn-t-be-a-crime https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/sending-a-mean-tweet-abo...
- exolymph 5y agoSo you agree that cancel culture is bad, then? Delighted to hear it.