8 ms·
Corruption Has Shaped History. Why Do We Still Ignore It?
- Glyptodon 5y agoThe appearance of corruption can't be differentiated from corruption itself - this should be embraced as a maxim and applied everywhere.
- yetihehe 5y agoWhy do we still ignore it? 1. Mass media is owned by wealthy people, who do not want other people to question how they amassed that wealth, so corruption is not a widely discuted problem. As long as it doesn't touch everyone personally, it will stay this way. 2. Changing it requires organising. That "organising" is typically called government. It's pretty hard to install a whole new government. Reinstalling government in too slow manner will just reinfect newly elected officials with corruption and won't rid of the disease. 3. After changing government, there are still many wealthy people who will try to corrupt new government. Preventing that requires whole new system of governance, but it is not invented yet. 4. Hard to find THE perpetrators. Too many officials and too many corrupters, which do not make big universally regarded as bad moves. They corrupt little-by-little aka boiling the frog. Many wealthy people and officials are not actually corrupted, we just don't know which are.
- lasereyes136 5y agoI would add that for many people that try to change the Government from within end up becoming what they start out fighting against just to be in the process.
- yetihehe 5y agoExactly. That's how point 2 works (exchanging too slow).
- mantas 5y agoEven if you install 100% new government, it's likely that some of the new people will arrive to same old conclusions sooner or later. Corruption is just too natural consequence of someone managing resources without being directly affected by outcomes.
- yetihehe 5y agoYeah, that's why I wrote several points. They are ALL working at once which results in hard to beat corruption. Fixing just one point will not help.
- recursivedoubts 5y agoThey constantly try to escape From the darkness outside and within By dreaming of systems so perfect that no one will need to be good. But the man that is will shadow The man that pretends to be.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoTransparency, and hence able to checked by others, is the only solution I can see.
- recursivedoubts 5y agoHere is what happens: people with appetites (easily blackmail-able) are promoted from early on and given access to resources like campaign funds and seats at the table. Morally strong people are shunned and elbowed out, or seduced. Then it becomes a game of "Well, play ball and keep getting the gravy, or don't and we show and tell." This is why we have the Denny Hasterts of the world: empty-suit nobodies who come out of nowhere to become speaker of the house, then are disappeared in a puff of hushed-up scandal when they are no longer useful or can't keep a lid on their appetites. It's ridiculous that this isn't discussed in the education system. Even if it isn't intentional (it is) at some level stupidity becomes indistinguishable from malice.
- lukebuehler 5y agoI used to hear this but not believe that people would be groomed so brazenly. Then I saw it happen before my own eye in several global organizations (not government), now I believe, as you do, that this is one of the greatest sources of corruption: the corrupt work hard to raise people behind them who are just as corrupt, if not worse, because they can be controlled.
- d_tr 5y agoOr they end up quitting in disappointment and disgust or not bothering to begin with.
- DennisP 5y agoAnd those who don't usually get kicked out. I used to know a couple former state senators who played key roles in getting a prominent state senator of the opposite party convicted for corruption. They immediately lost support of their own party and were voted out. One of them was badly frightened in the process and dropped out of the public eye entirely. They had a lot to say about the workings of our legislature, including that the conflict between parties was largely a sham, and that if you wanted to stay in office, you participated in the quiet deals by which they all divided up the spoils.
- meragrin_ 5y ago> Preventing that requires whole new system of governance, but it is not invented yet. The system has nothing to do with it. It is the people.
- yetihehe 5y agoYeah, I call "system of governance" the entirety of rules that are enforced between people. Just people without serious system of governance are called "a mob". People are the hardware for governance, but like computer without operating system, people without governance system don't do much besides being there.
- pibechorro 5y agoThe answer is to limit the concentration of power. That is the Libertarian argument, if there is no lever to pull, there wont be corruption issues with people fighting over that lever. Instead, order should arise naturally as an emergent system from the ground up, always voluntarily with mutual benefit and never under the threat of force. A small corrupt goverment is always better than a massive corrupt goverment, and all systems of control eventually corrupt.
- Kuinox 5y agoThat's doesn't solve it. In France there is a lot of corrupted mayors, even in small villages/cities, it's hard to limit make the power less concentrated, you need accountability and making harder to be corrupted without being caught immediatly.
- DennisP 5y agoLimiting the opportunities for corruption is definitely important. The libertarian approach goes at it from another angle: limiting the damage that corrupt politicians can do, by limiting their authority over the rest of us. Seems to me that both approaches can work in tandem.
- Kuinox 5y agoIt doesn't works that's well, you often end up with bureaucracy nonsense.
- germinalphrase 5y agoI’ve always felt that this perspective entirely ignores that government is not the only source of extant power and that “order should arise naturally as an emergent system from the ground up always voluntarily with mutual benefit” is woefully idealistic (and functionally impossible) as we are not operating from a clean slate. There are already powerful people/entities that will take immediate advantage of governmental reduction in power to increase their own without any consideration of consent and/or mutual benefit. As an idea, sure - it’s lovely; but, if enacted, I don’t see how it doesn’t lead to something akin to feudalism. I’d even go so far as to suggest that it has the feeling of an ideological strategy by the already powerful to get the average person to ‘unilaterally disarm’ their own collective power. I’d love to be proved wrong, of course.
- boringg 5y agoI think you have some valid points however you also have one massive bias running through your statement: That the route of all corruption is wealthy people. I see you have found your scape goat to the problem. Wealthy people are just people - and there are many people who are not wealthy who are incredibly corrupt and more willing to take on the corruption risk. However it's much more convenient to paint wealthy people as the problem with the system then ascribe the problem to human nature as a whole or systemic problem.
- cute_boi 5y agoMaybe, corruption by peasants doesn't have that much impact compared to corruption en masse via wealthy people in the place where he lives? However, I do acknowledge that corruption is not just caused by wealthy people. The place where I live people have to do corruption if they want to live average quality life because the salary is so low. With the current salary, if they work honestly, they can't even afford a house for 15 years.
- Clubber 5y agoYou're conflating the people who commit the corrupt acts with the people who pay for the corrupt acts. Corrupt acts typically require some sort of payment, enough payment that it's worth the risk, so it would need to be significant relative to the salary. The poorer you are, the cheaper it is to get you to do a corrupt act. The wealthier you are in comparison, the cheaper it is (relative) to get someone to do a corrupt act. But to your point, it takes two to tango, the person paying for the corruption and the person carrying out the corruption. I think the OP's point is the wealthy are the ones paying for it and asking for the deeds to be done. Having said that, there are other types of corruption like CYA coverups we see in the news from police departments and justice systems. The Breonna Taylor grand jury result comes to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Breonna_Taylor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Breonna_Taylor
- yetihehe 5y ago> Maybe, corruption by peasants doesn't have that much impact compared to corruption en masse via wealthy people in the place where he lives? Exactly yes. "Peasant's" just don't have enough money to meaningfully bribe someone. > With the current salary, if they work honestly, they can't even afford a house for 15 years. Wow, that seems like a nice place to live. I built a house (started in 2019, finished this year) with credit for 30 years, but I earn about twice the average in my country. Building it was the cheaper option, it was projected to be worth 50% more after building, now it's worth twice more.
- giantg2 5y agoThis comment focuses heavily on wealthy people. There is also the potential for "normal" people in that new government to be corrupted by power or the chance to make extra money. At least in my experience, the local level politicians are more likely to be corrupt. Like city planners, district attorneys, etc. Their pay is lower so they are more likely to look for ways to make extra money. Or they might be doing improper things not for money, but for ideology/power (ie they might have joined despite the lower pay to make a difference, but they think they are doing the right thing even if breaking the rules). Like magistrates ignoring the law to rule against someone, or police and the DA holding a known incorrect charge against someone. Etc Just wanted to point out that it's not all rich people, that many times it starts out as normal or poor people who want what they never had, and to never return to being poor. Although, those people may be more likely to bebecome rich since they're playing outside the system, not paying taxes, etc.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Like city planners Where I live, the planners are widely considered to have been corrupt for decades. Planners are ordinary, medium-salary bureaucrats, dealing with hugely-valuable property and hugely-wealthy businessmen. Once the rot has set in, it seems to be really hard to remove it.
- sfe22 5y agoAs long as we have automatic rulers (countries with automatically powerful government) corruption will be there. Basically corruption is profitable so that is why it happens. If we had democracy, it will go down significantly, because is is not profitable to corrupt the majority. You have to offer them more than the damage you will do to them with your actions, which is unprofitable, and maybe not corruption at that point since you made a deal with the “to be harmed” people, not their ruling minority.
- bloopernova 5y agoTo prevent corruption, you to change society. To effect change, you need power. Power corrupts.
- bell-cot 5y agoFor a lot of people, facing the facts about corruption - even if they’re not involved - is more emotionally painful than “ignore and pretend there’s no real problem”. The payoffs from fighting corruption are almost all large-scale and long-term, which are lesser priorities for most people. Fighting corruption is itself often expensive, in terms of political capital and limited trustworthy people to staff the effort. And those practicing it are usually very socially savvy, to make their activities feel “not so bad” now, vs. facing & stopping those difficult and painful.
- roenxi 5y agoWhat really floors me is that people can compartmentalise so well that they'll read an article like this, nod, agree and then argue at a dinner party that we should keep centralising more power into government bodies. There is no workable scheme to mix large government and honest government - and no shining examples that I'm aware of where it has ever succeeded. People can look at the system which throws out (in quick succession) Obama, Trump, Biden and seriously claim it should be the major system that controls: 1. ...healthcare 2. ...who gets a bank account, what money gets spent on 3. ...which countries to invade 4. ...a lot of other stuff I respect the position because I have no choice but how an entity that schizophrenic, over-stretched with responsibilities and mad with power is supposed to resist corruption I do not see. It is going to be a moral and administrative cesspit.
- yetihehe 5y agoTransparency+accountability seems to be best answer for corruption. If you can make deals for hidden reasons, you can hide from scrutiny. If you have transparency, you can start to apply accountability. Those making bad decisions should bear the consequences.
- civilized 5y agoTransparency and accountability are good but not quite what GP is talking about. The problem is that "we simply need to make the government good" is not realistic. That's the single biggest reason people want limited government.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI mean, there are other counties that do have large government that controls these things and also less corruption. There are also smaller governments with even more corruption, such as any small town with one racist or self-dealing sheriff. So idk, corruption and governing body size doesn’t seem correlated to me.
- civilized 5y agoI agree that it's not about small. I think it's about limited. There have to be limits on the government's power, whether they come from the constitution, the country's legal system, or the traditional culture and character of the people.
- Koiwai 5y agoWe ignore it so we can sleep at night.
- 0dayz 5y agoI think the point about America ignoring corruption is the most crucial aspect of corruption; the enablers, essentially laws, policy makers or systems that have unintented flaws (loopholes) or intended ones (legal bribery) is a huge part of why corruption succeed or even thrives. On another note its also important to point out that culture also plays a role, certain well off cultures you have corruption in the form of lavish events or gifts or some cases where it's in the gray area (like say you rub my back I rub yours).
- Claudus 5y agoPerhaps this is the reason that the American founders tried to limit the power of government.
- rocgf 5y agoThis may be true and it could actually be effective to do so, but whenever I see such viewpoints I can't help myself from noticing just how narrow they are. All systems conceived by man so far are deeply flawed and libertarianism-like systems have some pretty horrendous blindspots, if you ask me. You need cooperation at a society level in order to tackle many externalities and existential issues, and that requires people organically coming together (won't happen) or some overarching entity with some sort of stick and good intentions or maybe something else, just not sure what.
- tyjen 5y agoCorruption is a human tendency and will never not be a problem. Even with anti-corruption policies in place, without proactive measures to continually undermine corruption efforts, those policies attenuate across time. This is due to people figuring out how to circumvent the current rules of law or a degradation in integrity when following the the rule of law. Once anti-corruption institutions put in-place to investigate and prosecute corruption themselves become corrupted, then the system will rapidly degrade to cover up the favored de facto political power corruption. Depending on the system in place, this can occur either top-down or bottom-up. In the US, it appears to be occurring top-down. Political party loyalism always leads to corruption, which is why it's absolutely critical to have a multiple party system with strong de jure political powers to keep the de facto political power in-check. There are numerous historical accounts depicting what happens when you do not. In the US, both parties should be split up and serve as more representative components to their constituencies, and to keep each other in balance more so than what's transpiring today.
- kiliantics 5y agoPeople practicing the earliest forms of democracy knew that party politics would lead to problems so they structured it using the only actually democratic process: sortition
- tawaypol 5y ago
- Proven 5y ago
- temp8964 5y agoFocusing on corruption is just bluntly stupid on many fronts. It’s a prestige from someone comes from a constitutional republic but lacks understanding of local context. It is extremely ignorant to claim corruptions shaped history when corruptions were always the symptom not the cause. This superficial worldview caused horrible errors in American foreign policy decisions. The US gave up Chinese government during China’s civil war, so let the communists took over. Did the same thing in Vietnam. Similarly in Iraq and Afghanistan and many other places, given up the government and let terrorists took the country. All because the corruptions in their governments. The fact is that those governments were deemed to be corrupted no matter who is in charge. You cannot just command them out of corruptions. So instead of living with the imperfect reality of the historical and cultural context, we choose to let the worst to take over so that we can close eyes and make nice postures.
- ganzuul 5y agoBodycams on police are a great start.
- tvanantwerp 5y agoSimple case of distributed costs and concentrated benefits. Imagine a corrupt bureaucrat who demands a small bribe from every person who needs them to perform a service. It's a pain, but the bribe is small and it's just this one bureaucrat this one time. The bureaucrat, of course, is doing this to everybody, so they amass a great sum even though every person pays a small amount. The bureaucrat can put a lot of effort into maintaining his corrupt position. But for the people who pay the bribes, it's not worth it to upend their own lives in a crusade against that one corrupt official over the matter of a small bribe.
- newsclues 5y agoThe powerful don’t want to give up their position, so accountability will never be a priority for them, because it’s a threat to their power.
- kkfx 5y agoCorruption is the "real full-market" society, where anything is on sale. That's why neoliberal world dislike to speak about it. Formal dictatorship on the other side do not like talking about it except to justify some move against opponents because corruptions as illegal thing means that their rules can be breached. Morale and corruption are kind of opposite elements used to form a society, "self"-imposed gates between the direct personal interest and the society-wide interest as also a personal long-term interest. Issues arise because most do not really "master the society they live in" so they can't know implications deeply enough to decide and other who master the society enough can abuse those who don't for their own sake. My view is: culture shape the history, the more culture the more just society so the less corruption. The more corrupted society means less culture, less justice, something unstable that can made few rich an many poor BUT not only rich the skilled and poor the less skilled, in a far more unbalanced, casual and bad for evolution manner.
- sudden_dystopia 5y agoBecause of propaganda, deception, and manipulation.
- GartzenDeHaes 5y agoI lived in Korea prior to Chun's liberalization in the late 80's and the traffic police would ask for bribes instead of writing tickets. This money flowed up to the local chief of police, who became very wealthy, and across to politicians. Complaints were hushed up or ignored. People who complained too much and journalists who didn't play ball just disappeared. what changed this was the end of media censorship, which people knew was real because the guys you called to deal with media problems stopped answering their phones. Corruption in the US has gotten quite bad and there's still a long way to go.
- froh 5y agoHow did Chun's liberation then come about and end this? I mean, it did, did it?
- GartzenDeHaes 5y agoThe rumor was that liberalization was a condition for hosting the 88 Olympics. Media censorship ended, elections were held, and there were lots of demonstrations and turmoil.
- artemonster 5y agoTransparency is the solution. Really. If you are on the display, there would be no room to commit crime. Dash cams, body cams are all great examples, where trabsparency prevents power abuse. I would suggest that if you‘d have to forever open all of your bank accounts and history whenever you assume a high ranking public service role - there would be only a little way for corruption „services“, as you cannot hoard non-monetary goods as much as you can hoard cash
- ttyprintk 5y agoThere’s another kind of transparency that’s harmful. We have a face-recognition database that can conclude a particular woman was arrested for sex work. There might be some suggestion she was trafficked, and that conclusion comes from her activity trying to keep a low profile. Celebrities (who otherwise have no background in the side-effects) promote this technique and police departments in large, religiously conservative countries use it. I wonder if it harms more than it helps.
- yetihehe 5y agoYeah, we should not strive for transparency everywhere, but for those in power. More power = more possibilities for corruption = should be more accountable. Ability to do SOME level of against-law things should be upheld, because law itself is not perfect and doesn't predict every situation.
- Koiwai 5y agoTransparency can not be implemented effectively against power, since power is power. On the contrary, it could be easily implemented on people not in power to prevent uprising.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThe author doesn't connect with one of the most harmful characteristics of corruption: the way it spreads, like rust, or dry rot. If your boss is a crook, then he's not going to mind if you're crooked too. In fact he'd prefer it - he won't want goody two-shoes as his subordinate, and having the dirt on you will enable him to control you. And so on, down the stack of turtles. A clean policeman in a corrupt department, refusing to take the payola, runs the risk of getting no backup when he's in trouble. Author notes that corruption in an army results in the hollowing-out of that army - equipment, men and supplies that are recorded on the books are fictional. But entire societies get hollowed-out; this is why corruption ought to be stomped on early and hard. Unfortunately, a fish starts rotting at the head. Who's to do the stomping, if the chief is a crook?
- ttyprintk 5y agoAt the bottom of the article are 24 points supporting this.
- jrsj 5y agoBiggest thing I don’t see mentioned about this: the only people in a position to deal with individual cases corruption are themselves corrupt and only wish to do so in order to pursue their own political agenda. Anti-corruption is more often than not nothing more than an excuse to achieve some other goal.
- ttyprintk 5y agoWell, the article gets quite tricky with the Supreme Court decision that let McConnell off the hook. It does look like he did not commit the overt corrupt act at the definition of the statute, and the judge instructed the jury badly. The article claims this is complicity in the Supreme Court, but I’m not so sure. Cases of corruption since that verdict have been interesting: https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4829&context=ndlr https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4...
- HPsquared 5y agoIt's quite a hard thing to even define in the first place.
- ttyprintk 5y agoThe article sticks to “Power for Sale” but I think people would recognize other, harder to define, corrosive arrangements of injustice as corruption.
- nickpp 5y agoBecause corruption is a characteristic of public ownership of resources. It happens when valuables are administrated by employed officials. "Western" administrations keep corruption under control through education and culture. Non-western administrations have often included corruption in their culture. Private property and free markets quickly root out any corruption.
- bannedbybros 5y ago
- DennisP 5y agoThis probably also explains a lot about Russia's difficulties in Ukraine, including poor equipment maintenance and lack of basic supplies.
- ttyprintk 5y agoThe general who committed suicide was accused of embezzling 80% of the budget. I can’t imagine how he could have done that alone.
- alephr 5y agoCorruption definitely exists as people are periodically convicted for it, but outside of those convictions the majority of talk about it seems to be a cope for the failures of systems we create freely. This writer references a corruption conviction but then misrepresents its overturning by the supreme court as more corruption when the court unanimously just set a probably agreeable definition and allowed the case to be persued under this definition. Once you do any digging on most claims of corruption you find inconvenient constraints and facts that most people have no understanding of that take the righteousness out of the claims. Corruption is overwhelmingly an easy scapegoat you can gesture towards and have people agree with you without much effort. If we think there's something that is corruption that isn't covered by the legal code we can agree on what that is and push for it in the legal system. If we think our executives aren't enforcing our legal code we are the ones who elect them. If the problem is that no one cares enough to make the "right" decisions then whining about elites isn't going to do anything.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt has taken a long time, but the US is now, arguably, the most corrupt nation. The final straw was when the US Supreme Court made secret political bribes legal. It is not because other nations, like Russia, would not like to be more corrupt; they just don't move enough money to compete. China is the only serious rival to the title, and is openly organized for corruption, first and foremost, where the US still pretends. If we want to become less corrupt, it will be a long and hard road. But thus far we, instead, elected an out-and-out grifter to the Presidency, and then held our noses and elected the father of another to replace him. So, it will take a change of direction we seem not to want. Too many think they have a chance to get on the gravy train, and would hate for it to stop while still have the chance.
- heyda 5y agoIf you think the USA is the most corrupt nation, you clearly haven't traveled enough. The corruption in the USA may be numerically the most, 5%~ gdp of the richest nation on earth lost too just healthcare corruption [1. But compared to literally not being able to drive down a road without a 'police officer' pulling you over for a bribe and all the roads having massive potholes because the tax money was 'lost' someplace. The USA pales in comparison. At least we have functional utilities in almost every city, the water can be drank, the electricity stays on, ect. Thinking the USA is the most corrupt nation on earth is laughable. https://infogram.com/mirror-mirror-2021-exhibit-3-1h7k230dkllmg2x https://infogram.com/mirror-mirror-2021-exhibit-3-1h7k230dkl...
- ncmncm 5y agoOther countries have mostly retail corruption. The US has, instead, wholesale corruption, wired into its institutions. China, even moreso.
- eadmund 5y agoBe careful what you wish for. In the absence of corruption (a state in which people do things for material advantage) one gets ideology (a state in which people do things for ideological advantage). With a corrupt individual one may buy him off to ensure peace and tranquility; with a true believer in an ideology there is no way to buy peace and tranquility other than to obey his ideology. Addendum: and if there are two opposed ideologues, there can be no peace and tranquility.
- lamontcg 5y agoOr with descent into corruption there comes the predictable turn to ideology which promises to clean it up (and make the proverbial trains run on time). So if you don't want ideologues coming to power, don't tolerate corruption.
- 21723 5y agoIt's not fashionable to actually read long articles, since to take the time means one will be slow to comment and likely be buried (like this comment will probably be) but this article is worth it. Especially valuable among the "24 theses" are: Corrupt capture of political and economic institutions and the culture at large is not a historical constant. Victims have reversed it by penalising perpetrators and enacting systemic reforms. Or by establishing new forms of government. We don't have to accept the status quo. We don't have to keep letting foreign criminals who don't even live here (for any value of "here", since this is a global problem) buy our real estate. We can take that shit back. "Property rights" were not invented by God. People made them up and people can unmake them if there are good reasons to do so. But corrupt networks are resilient. When challenged – and even after suffering such blows as the fall of a government or the prosecution of leading members – they usually succeed in maintaining or reinstating the corrupt system. That's what terrifies me. Look at how quickly the worst people in the Soviet bureaucracies turned into cappie criminal thugs--and, in Putin's regime--murderers. "Communist" systems (the USSR never claimed to have achieved communism; the cappies started calling an extremely flawed country "communist" to discredit the idea rather than the implementation) had more than a few bad leaders, but capitalist systems have only bad leaders, and we pay a lot more for this shitty "leadership".
- egberts1 5y agoDid this kind of corruption all got started when the US Court declared that corporations are people Not much precedence to go by in the history of mankind on that, specifically. Just wondering.
- redmen 5y agoWe don't ignore it. It's hard to know what to do about it.
- redmen 5y agoWe don't ignore it. We just don't know what to do about it..
- riskneutral 5y agoCorruption is the natural state of human affairs. Anyone who has spent enough time in a developing country knows this. I recently read that, in pre-war Ukraine, the majority of Ukrainians obtained a driver's license by bribing an official. If you tried to get a driver's license legitimately, you would spend a whole week going through a maze of bureaucracy that was designed to encourage you to give up and bribe someone. I point this out because street level corruption is not commonly heard about in European countries. People who live in developing countries run up against street level corruption on a routine basis. So it is obvious to people in those countries that there is corruption at much higher levels, if not the highest levels. The developed Western countries have been very successful in stamping out street level corruption (most Americans are not used to bribing a cop if they get pulled over, for example), but they have turned a blind eye to corruption at higher levels. The general population in these countries are left with an impression that corruption either doesn't exist in their country, or that it is quite rare and limited. A cursory review of the state of international banks' performance in "enforcing" anti-money laundering laws, or the recent bribery record of Western insurance, energy, mining, and civil engineering companies should give pause to any thoughtful observer. Indeed, the rich, Western world's form of corruption seems far more insidious and far reaching than the stories of street level corruption in places like Afghanistan or Ukraine.