10 ms·
To me, computers used to be fun when you commanded them what to do, they did it, then they prompted you for another command. Now, more and more, computers are
by ryandrake 5y ago
To me, computers used to be fun when you commanded them what to do, they did it, then they prompted you for another command.
Now, more and more, computers are trying to tell us what to do. Notifications, unwanted ads, spam, recommendations, pop ups, accept this, subscribe to that, dark patterns trying to get me to do something… I never commanded my computer to do these things. Some product manager at some company 1000 miles away simply decided my computer should do these things, without even my input. Even my operating system! After booting up, it’s running hundreds of programs simultaneously. I did not tell it to run these things! It’s doing it all by itself out of the box. I feel less and less in control of my computer and more and more a bystander.
We (the software industry) have royally screwed up computers. Users used to be in control and now they are the ones being controlled or at least “influenced.”
- XorNot 5y agoAds in Windows. Just...the insane amounts of ads. There's probably a distro offering for Linux that should be made where is promise is just "I'm not contacting the internet unless you ask me too".
- tasuki 5y ago> "I'm not contacting the internet unless you ask me to" I think there kind of is? Like, most Linux distros actually? Yes, Ubuntu has snaps which try to talk to the internet and autoupdate, and yes this is absolutely terrible. Yes, sometimes a distro might notify you there are updates available. Yes, sometimes a distro talks to a ntp server to sync the time. But, generally, I don't feel internet usage is inflicted on me, I inflict it on myself. In what ways which bother you does your Linux distro contact the internet without asking?
- paskozdilar 5y agoUbuntu also has services like fwupd and unattended-upgrades that are configured by default to run periodically without asking the user. I do not know if there are any others. Fortunately, as long as the user knows about them, they are fairly straightforward to mask with systemctl. For people like me, who like having complete control and knowledge of everything their machine is doing, Arch GNU/Linux a good choice.
- jacquesm 5y agoAnd then you run Firefox and it starts calling home all by itself. That one still bugs me.
- pabs3 5y agoEvery distro has privacy issues, here are just the ones that we know about in Debian: https://wiki.debian.org/PrivacyIssues https://wiki.debian.org/PrivacyIssues
- throwaway684936 5y agoLinux from scratch doesn't ;) KISS, Gentoo, Alpine(not sure if it's desktop-usable?) are probably the most private.
- pabs3 5y agoIts unlikely that any of these distros including LFS systematically fix the sort of privacy issues that exist in open source software. For example, loading most HTML documentation in distros is a privacy issue because they often load resources from the internet.
- ryandvm 5y agoThis. How is it that I paid for Windows (begrudgingly) and yet it's constantly undermining my efforts to control it? Microsoft has at least a dozen shitty apps that no matter how many times you disable or uninstall them, always seem to come slinking back into RAM. What the actual fuck?!
- brimble 5y agoI miss when I could put Wireshark on an interface and nothing would show up until I pressed a button somewhere.
- coryrc 5y agoHere's one: someone wrote a battery status "middleware" which reports battery status on DBus. Fine. Then they coupled in "shutdown on low battery" and refuse to allow it to be disabled. https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/upower/upower/-/issues/64 https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/upower/upower/-/issues/64 So since xfce, gnome applets use this library, I either have no battery status applet or intermittently my computer goes into shutdown after resume because the battery falsely appears dead for a few seconds. (The kicker: it doesn't log why it decided to initiate the shutdown. Took years to find the bloody cause..)
- bhedgeoser 5y ago> Then they coupled in "shutdown on low battery" and refuse to allow it to be disabled Would you rather have your computer crash when it runs out of battery, or shutdown gracefully at 2 percent battery.
- ungamedplayer 5y agoWhy would there be a software fault (crash) at any battery percentage? What function of battery charge causes an error on a modern operating system?
- detaro 5y agoWould you rather have to pay a bit of attention or have a computer that just randomly shuts down when it gets confused about battery state, since that's the scenario parent is describing?
- throw0101a 5y ago> Would you rather have your computer crash when it runs out of battery, or shutdown gracefully at 2 percent battery. If I want my computer to crash then that is a policy I should get to make on my own. It is not the job of the software vendor/developer to dictate policy to me. If they have to have a default then they can pick whatever, but not being able to change a particular setting is a bug.
- Agamus 5y ago
- bheadmaster 5y agoI think it's important to always remember it's not the computers that are trying to tell us what to do, it's the people who build those computers and the software running on them that are trying to tell us what to do. Computers, in their fundamental nature, are exactly as you describe them. Such devices will always be available (if nothing else, in the form of electronic components). We just have to refuse to use the machines that want to control us. Also relevant: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html
- grumbel 5y ago> https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html Little side rant here, I think one area where Free Software has failed so far is build systems. You get the source alright and the GPL even requires you to include build instructions ("all the source code needed to generate, install, ..."). But in practical terms the amount of effort it takes to actually build software yourself is often insane, far from being automatic and often requiring a lot of manual work and workarounds (especially when you leave plain Linux and start cross-compile, etc.). Now with Github we even have a lot of the build infrastructure be proprietary, and while it runs automatically on Github CI, there is no way to run Github CI locally. There is effort put towards reproducible build now and some distros like NixOS seem on the right path. But I think we lost a lot of ground here by having the build process be filled with so much patch work and manual human intervention, instead of being 100% automated right from the start. We really need a "freedom -1" that requires software to be buildable fully automatic.
- bheadmaster 5y ago> I think one area where Free Software has failed so far is build systems GNU Autotools (also known as GNU Build System) is fairly standardized in the GNU world. The build process for most GNU packages is simple: ./configure make make install The FSF-endorsed GuixSD (a GNU system inspired by Nix) is also putting a lot of effort towards system bootstrapping[0] and deterministic builds[1]. Of course, there is still a lot of work to be done. But honestly, I'm very optimistic - the GNU system has gone a long way since its inception, and it's only getting better by the day. [0] https://guix.gnu.org/en/blog/2020/guix-further-reduces-bootstrap-seed-to-25/ https://guix.gnu.org/en/blog/2020/guix-further-reduces-boots... [1] https://guix.gnu.org/en/blog/2020/reproducible-computations-with-guix/ https://guix.gnu.org/en/blog/2020/reproducible-computations-...
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> computers used to be fun when you commanded them what to do, they did it > Users used to be in control and now they are the ones being controlled 2013 was the watershed for me. You can read about why here [1] There's a world of difference between using a tool and being a tool. That transformation from "It's more fun to compute" to "If you've nothing to fear you've nothing to hide" took place almost silently in the first 20 years of this century. The problem is that as "hackers" we don't understand computers. Retaking tech, by fully understanding and helping to culturally redefine computing is both the duty and prerogative of any real hackers left out there. As for the fun. It never went away for me. I am more passionate about technology, coding, networks and electronics than at any time in my life - precisely because the stakes are now so high. [1] https://digitalvegan.net https://digitalvegan.net
- jim-jim-jim 5y agoHey man, haven't read that book, but I love your other one. Thanks for writing it.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoThanks Jim. I enjoyed writing the "other one" too, cos Pure Data is just such awesome fun as a sound and music making language.
- lioeters 5y ago> Retaking tech, by fully understanding and helping to culturally redefine computing is both the duty and prerogative of any real hackers left out there. A powerful statement right there. As someone who grew up with computers from before the web, I feel that "cyberspace" has been colonized by business and political interests. It was supposed to be "our" space, I mean, by the people and for the people. Right now it's more useful as a tool for the dark empire. A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace - https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence I agree that the problem and the solution is cultural. It's about having fun, being weird and creative with how we use technology, to reclaim the magic and make it ours. Things like Tor, uBlock Origin, and dare I say some of the cryptocurrency and blockchain stuff, they feel like part of a larger decentralized underground-ish movement that has no name (and probably should remain so).
- kashyapc 5y agoSpeaking of computers commanding us ... a few years ago, I was visiting a friend's parents (practicing dentists). They told me in horror how Microsoft forcefully upgraded their work machines to Windows 10 overnight. And one of their applications stopped working due to the upgrade. That's the first time I learnt that Windows was using that approach (I'm blissfully away from Windows; I dwell in the Linux world.) It was painful to watch them ask "how come this machine does such a big task [upgrade] forcefully?"
- yakubin 5y agoThere is also the situation that is not created out of malice or greed, but out of lack of restraint and divergence of priorities between the authors and the users: compilation speed. When a piece of software makes me wait for it, I feel subservient to it. It feels like sitting in a state office, waiting until a civil servant decides to grant you an audience. Except there is no civil servant, there is only the computer. How much do I have to wait? It depends on the alignment of the stars, air humidity and will of the gods. When I used to work in office, there was this one time when I had an urgent ticket from customer to resolve, so I made the necessary fix and started building it. Normally builds would take something like 15 minutes, provided they were incremental and this wasn't the first (clean) one. But they could also take hours. It was at the end of the working day, I was working hard on this fix, didn't even take a lunch break. I started building it and waiting, because I wanted to share the fix with the customer as soon as possible. 15 minutes passed... 30 minutes passed... 1 hour passed... 90 minutes passed... 2 hours passed... And it was still compiling. At that point I gave up, went out and started walking home. But due to not eating the whole day and then staying late waiting for the build to finish, now I was so hungry that my hands started trembling on my way home and I felt generally weak, on the edge of being able to reach home. The next day I found out this build took ~4h 30min. The reason for this state of affairs: of course I shouldn't care that much about my work and just make the customer wait instead. Put my health and time above that. But another important reason is that the build times were so unpredictable: when I hit "compile", it could take anywhere from 3 minutes to 4.5 hours. There is no planning you can do around that. If it was just a fixed 3 hours, it would be even better, because then I could plan my day around it. But it being so unstable destroys everything. Of course, if every build took 3 hours, people making decisions would wake up and see that we've got a pathological situation and there is something seriously wrong with the project. But when you often hit 15 minutes, it's going to be brushed off. And for the C++ committee even though compilation speed may be an issue, it is never a priority. There are always going to be other issues which eclipse it. Personally, I think a build for even a OS-size project like that shouldn't take more than at most 1 minute. Even the incremental times in this one are a travesty. What I like about what was planned for Jai (still not released) is that it's designed to always make a clean build. And the clean builds need to be fast. There should be no reason to make incremental builds. They are hacks that make the situation worse, but make it look better. Suddenly you're dealing with weird bugs, because the build system did not detect a necessary recompile and used stale cache entries (happened multiple times to me). The compile times are unpredictable (see the above story of why that matters). I've seen some Delphi jobs in my country a year ago I think. Maybe I should switch there...
- 21723 5y agoWe (the software industry) have royally screwed up computers. Users used to be in control and now they are the ones being controlled or at least “influenced.” I think we naively believed that an increase of human technical capability would lead to such abundance that we'd achieve post-scarcity (at which point, whether we call it socialism or pretend it is liberalized capitalism, it doesn't matter) and permanent democracy... not the corporatized nightmare we actually got. The capitalists are right about very little, but they got this right: human nature can be shit. Most people are decent or want to be, but the ones who gain power in human organizations, especially organizations without purpose such as private corporations, are cancerous. We thought that problem would magically solve itself if we just made the world (in aggregate terms) richer, and we were wrong. It's like a martial arts instructor who earnestly but unaccountably believes he's teaching good kids how to fight back against bullies. He may be. Or, he may be teaching the bullies. In our case, though, we weren't training... we were arming... and we didn't always know we were building weapons, but that's absolutely what we were doing... all of our "data science" got turned into decisions that hurt workers and enriched executives. I'm speaking in past tense because we, as technologists, are no longer relevant. We've sold our souls. Capitalist hogs and their managerial thugs have won. Our moral credibility is deep in the negative territory. Power will either stay with those who currently have it, who have evil intentions, or move toward the set of people who work up the courage to overthrow the current system, who may or may not--it's impossible to know, as it hasn't happened yet--have ugly intentions.
- zozbot234 5y ago"We" (meaning technologist culture) have never worked to promote centralized, monopoly services. The users did it to themselves, largely in pursuit of short-term convenience. "We" are now building the federated, interoperable platforms that users will hopefully come around to when the obvious problems of centralization (including widespread censorship, non-existent customer service and non-transparent AI's/bots run amok) start seriously biting them in the ass. In many ways, it's already happening.
- llimos 5y agoIt needs to be a library and it's turned into a framework.
- dionidium 5y agoI would pay twice the going rate for a Macbook that ran a version of OSX that always immediately responded to my commands. When I hit Cmd-Q I want the app to close. Not when it's ready. Not after showing a dialog. Not after asking me if I'm sure. Not after cleaning up. Not after preparing to close. Not after doing some background processing. Just close. I want to issue a command and I want it carried out immediately. If the software can't do that gracefully, then it's bad software.
- erezsh 5y agoSame problem in Windows. Also, there is no reason for the operating system UI to ever be stuck. If the program fails to redraw, show it blank, but don't prevent me from moving/sizing it. Even if the CPU is at 100%, I want my commands to get 1st priority. Too many times I had to spam Ctrl+alt+del just waiting for something to respond.
- ryandrake 5y agoOr a computer you can actually power off. Used to be: You throw a physical switch on the computer, it interrupts the power circuit from the power supply, and the computer went off instantly. Today: You have to do it in some software menu, but invoking this, you're not even powering it off. You're requesting your computer to "pretty please, with sugar on top, turn off my computer when you're not too busy." Then the OS goes and does god knows what, maybe it decides to flush some caches, maybe it decides to do an entire operating system update, who knows--you're not the driver, you're just along for the ride. Even the physical power button on the computer doesn't break a circuit anymore. It... you guessed it... sends a software signal begging the almighty operating system to please shut down. And when you point this stuff out, all the excuses start coming out: "Bbbbut the OS has to flush its caches! Bbbbut the filesystem needs to write things to disk that are in-flight! Bbbbut applications need to gracefully shut down and free their memory (which is about to have the power cut). Bbbbbut there may be a critical background task still running that needs to...." I don't fucking care! I didn't command my computer to do any of these things. It's gotten to the point where if you want to shut your computer down instantly, you need to pull the power plug or remove the battery. I expect we software engineers will fix that one some time soon, too.
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoYes, and now everything is on the cloud so you don't even own your files anymore.
- uhtred 5y agoHave you tried using a Linux desktop? I personally find that it doesn't have all the negative things you mention.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoIt has fewer, but unfortunately the mentality of developers believing they should be able to tell the user what to do is so pervasive that even FOSS developers do it. From what I can tell, GNOME is the most prevalent Linux Desktop environment and it is notorious for this. Ubuntu is, if not the most common distro, the most commonly recommended one and Canonical is also notorious for forcing things on the user they don't want like Snaps and auto updating.
- uhtred 5y agoI use Fedora+Gnome, and I haven't ever felt that I am being told what to do. Plus you can totally just install Fedora with a different desktop if that is the case.
- flyinghamster 5y agoAnother little picky example: gnome-terminal is my favorite of the various spiffed-up xterms. Start up a KDE session, and gnome-terminal does not appear in the menu even though the full GNOME is installed on the system. I have to run it from the menu's search function. At least, this is the case on Ubuntu Focal. Anyone else using KDE and gnome-terminal? ETA: I can't even make a quicklaunch for it in KDE.
- throwaway684936 5y agoAvoid desktop environments like GNOME. Stray from the guided path and use bare window managers and other alternative software. The additional effort required is overblown to a ridiculous degree. The software does what I say, when I say. If it doesn't, it gets wiped from my system.
- michaelgrafl 5y agoThat's a great explanation and one I'm going to steal.
- drdeadringer 5y ago> To me, computers used to be fun when you commanded them what to do, they did it, then they prompted you for another command. This is a good portion of why I switched to Linux full time over 10 years ago. My computer does what I tell it to do, when I tell it to do it, as I tell it to do it. I fuck up? It's my fault and I know it and I have to fix it myself. No more "What the fuck just happened?" bullshit.