14 ms·
Sergey Brin: The Facebook phenomenon is a problem (2007)
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> Finally, we (or basically I) have not done a good enough job of high rewards for high performance. 15 years later, this is still a widespread problem everywhere. People don't capture the full value of their labor (which makes a sort of sense, given imperfect information and how risk is allocated), which leads to people not being incentivized to increase the value of their labor. We've all heard stories about people being extra efficient and getting rewarded with raised expectations and maybe a paltry raise. If people were really incentivized to do their best work, I imagine we'd get a better world.
- sytelus 5y agoThis is the entire foundation of capitalism. The idea is that people who own capital only reward other people for their time who help add to their capital. If companies distributed all of the gains in terms of stock awards to employees, you will see very different asset distribution in our society.
- gojomo 5y ago'Capitalism' is neither theoretically, nor in practice, limited to "only reward people for their time". Some industries where the labor is low-skilled trend that way.
- SequoiaHope 5y agoThe basic concept of capitalism is that there are capital owners, and they hire workers who use that capital to generate value. The capital owners receive all of that value and then pay the workers for their time. This is not a comprehensive description of capitalism but it is the low level idea. Obviously there is a distribution of real world behaviors.
- AYBABTME 5y agoCapitalism is about trade and industry being done by private owners, instead of by the state. It's a decentralized economic system that acknowledges a state's inability to fully plan the economy due to imperfect information. It's not anchored in labor exploitation.
- SequoiaHope 5y ago> Capitalism is about trade and industry being done by private owners, instead of by the state. It's a decentralized economic system that acknowledges a state's inability to fully plan the economy due to imperfect information. > The basic concept of capitalism is that there are capital owners, and they hire workers who use that capital to generate value. The capital owners receive all of that value and then pay the workers for their time. These are both true.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- davmar 5y agocapitalism cannot differentiate between efficiency and exploitation
- heavyset_go 5y agoState capitalism exists.
- kqr 5y agoThis is incorrect. You can have state capitalism as well as non-state non-capitalism (worker-owned cooperatives are a common example of private non-capitalism). As the person you're responding to said, capitalism is the philosophy that concentration of capital should be rewarded. It's that simple. Whether the state or private magnates concentrate the capital and get rewarded for it is irrelevant.
- gojomo 5y agoThat's only the 'basic concept of capitalism' at a reductionist Fischer-Price level-of-understanding by its detractors. That's just as impoverished a model of the real world, in its own way, as simple microeconomics analyses of 'perfect competition'.
- qsort 5y agoYou would also see much fewer companies to begin with. Maybe there's a better way to reward highly skilled people than beating this extremely dead horse?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sytelus 5y agoCapitalism has nothing to do with fewer or more companies. A founder can currently be rewarded as much as 1000000X than an average employee simply because the arrangement is that employee gets paid for time (a highly limited quantity) while founder gets paid for capital (virtually unlimited quantity). Assume that you forced founders not to capture all of the capital gains generated by employees such that the founder was rewarded "only" 1000X more than average employee. I don't think this is so badly under-rewaeded that founders will just stop being founders.
- zozbot234 5y agoA founder that's rewarded 1000000X is cashing in on a lottery ticket. That's all there is to it. Just as in most lotteries, even most founders are losers.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>If companies distributed all of the gains in terms of stock awards to employees Then there would be no incentive for investment.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoExactly. And investment includes buying the tools that lets the worker be productive enough to create a surplus. There's three people (or entities) in this: the one who makes the tool, the one who buys the tool, and the one who uses the tool. All of them need some of the rewards from the increased productivity that the tool empowers, otherwise we stop getting tools that let us be more productive, and we're all worse off. So you have to pay both the capitalists and the workers. Now, you can argue that the pendulum has swung too far in the direction of the capitalists. That's a defensible position. But the answer is not to move to "the workers get 100% of the gains". That's going to leave everyone worse off, including the workers.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThere would be if employees themselves were worker-owners.
- tw600040 5y agoThat would be fair if companies can also distribute losses if any and are able to get money back from employees
- steveylang 5y agoMaybe so, but stockholders aren't responsible for company losses either.
- tw600040 5y agoThey are. They lose their money / investment if companies go bankrupt or don't do well.
- sfblah 5y agoNot in the past 5-10 years...
- umeshunni 5y agoHuh? A gentle look at WSB will tell you a lot about stockholders who lost money.
- sumedh 5y ago> They lose their money / investment if companies go bankrupt or don't do well. The CEOs of such companies get multi million dollar packages for leaving.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoWould it? As I understand it, most companies don't distribute losses to owners either. I believe that's the core of "limited liability" corporations. Except for capital losses for shareholders, but employees are already paid in RSUs too, so I think that's relatively moot.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rmbyrro 5y agoProblem is the employees aren't willing to bear the risk that early investors were willing to. If the entire society had a similar level of appetite for risk, we'd see a different asset distribution in society. Since most people are terribly averse to losing anything, they also shut down the perspective of winning big.
- noncoml 5y agoIt’s not about being willing, it’s about being able too. Imagine there is a lottery where for every 10 million tickets you buy you get one that is giving you 20 millions back. No brainer, right? Except if you don’t have the 10 million to spare, buying lottery tickets instead of food doesn’t make sense. Labor/job is your single lottery ticket. Investors can afford to buy all tickets to make sure they win.
- robrenaud 5y agoMake a lot of friends, buy up the tickets together, and split the winnings. Applied another way, everyone in a given class of YC should share a bit of ownership with everyone else in their YC class, and then everyone of them is likely to end up a millionare.
- twojacobtwo 5y agoThis is where the analogy fails, I think, because it assumes a static market price, or a lack of competition for the tickets. Where the price changes or competition changes availability, we run into the same issues where those who already have power/money are more able to exploit the system than those who have to collude just to have a shot.
- robocat 5y agoFYI this is an analysis of your average returns at YC: https://80000hours.org/2014/05/how-much-do-y-combinator-founders-earn/ https://80000hours.org/2014/05/how-much-do-y-combinator-foun... I still wish that YC would provide some more concrete figures, and ideally include separate figures for first employees as well as founders. From link: “Most of the returns have gone to a tiny minority of super-successes. The founders of AirBnB, Dropbox and Stripe are worth about US$7 billion, about 80% of all founders’ equity, although they account for 0.5% of the companies. Outside of the most successful companies, it was still possible to earn significant returns. 12% of companies from the first five years of Y Combinator are now worth US$40 million or more, and a further 10% have sold for US$5-40 million. The remainder probably earned little more than their (low) salaries.”.
- mrh0057 5y agoIt’s suppose to be the value you added. The investors get payment for the risk they take by investing in or loaning money to the company. If a company has monopoly power and/or gets bailed out by the government consistently there is no risk to investors. What ends up happening is rent seeking a behavior by theses companies and they will also take unnecessary risks since they are incentivized to.
- buzzdenver 5y ago> People don't capture the full value of their labor (which makes a sort of sense, given imperfect information and how risk is allocated), I think it is primarily due to de-risking. You agree with your employer that the biggest percentage of your income will be fixed and independent of how much value the company produced (be it profits or share appreciation or whatever). This makes sense because your life has high fixed costs, and your cash-flow cannot allow for years when you make zero (or even a negative amount), even if in the next one you would make 5 times your current salary. > which leads to people not being incentivized to increase the value of their labor. Don't think this is necessarily true. I would love to walk into an apple orchard now and spend an hour picking if I could keep 25% of the apples.
- vhiremath4 5y ago> which makes a sort of sense, given imperfect information and how risk is allocated This doesn't just make a sort of sense to me, it makes perfect sense. People trade their labor at a lower rate for higher stability (less risk). The people who start companies, find capital, and distribute that capital in ways that increase the value of the company have taken on more risk (how significant varies case-by-case and usually is a natural market cap ceiling to the total value the owners can extract ahead of employees). If the company I work at gives me shares in that company, I want the company to pay less for my labor (and everyone's) if my belief is that collectively all employees output will accelerate my own wealth creation when I sell my shares in the company. The share becomes a transitive store of value I believe my own labor alone will never be able to keep up with, and I want to make sure the value it's accumulating is not diminished because the company is paying out the full capital value of everyone's labor. Then there would be very little incentive for me to take the shares in the first place, and, honestly, very little incentive for anyone to start a company (why take on that risk if there's no payout in excess of just joining another company?).
- myroon5 5y agoFeels like many are stuck in this dichotomy between choosing stable rates or venturing out on your own where more middle ground should probably exist. Employee incentives should probably align more
- honorious 5y agoIsn't RSU the middle ground already? You can part of your compensation in salary, part in ownership of the company. If you work and the company does well, you do better. The % of comp in RSU raises as you get promoted to higher levels, where you (theoretically at least) actually have more impact on the success of the company.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoIf my contributions increase the value of a $100M company by 10%, there's no way my RSUs' value is going to increase by $10M (unless I own 100% of the company). In a realistic scenario of $100k/yr of RSUs, even this near-impossible mythical single-person contribution of 10% would only net me $10k/yr. RSUs go a long way, but don't totally align the incentives.
- bushbaba 5y ago> If people were really incentivized to do their best work, I imagine we'd get a better world. Assuming wages are a function of the free market. And the less mobile people are, the less job-applicants exist, and the higher wages need to be to poach. Incentivizing for good work might have diminishing returns after a certain point.
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoI love it, we need everyone to have poverty wages and be insecure in case the poor multinational corporations might have difficulty underpaying people
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> People don't capture the full value of their labor Why would you expect people to capture the full value of their labor? Imagine you operate a business. You do the math and determine that hiring a new employee will cost you $100K/year, but it will bring in $100K/year of revenue. In other words, the employee would capture the full value that they create (assuming nothing goes wrong). Do you hire that employee? Of course not. It doesn't make any business sense. It's more work for you, more risk for the company, and most importantly it provide $0 financial value to the company. It's an easy no. Now if you can hire someone for $100K and their addition will bring in $150K, that's a different story. You can't expect to capture the full value of your labor as an employee. However, you're also free from capturing the full value of the losses you might create. If you fail to ship your objectives or you accidentally drop the main DB and cost the company $100K, you don't receive a bill for the negative value you created. You get to keep your paychecks. > which leads to people not being incentivized to increase the value of their labor. This doesn't make sense at all. People increase the value of their labor all the time because it leads to more and better opportunities and gives more leverage in future negotiations. You don't have to capture the "full value" of your labor to have an incentive to improve.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AussieWog93 5y ago>Do you hire that employee? Of course not. It doesn't make any business sense. It's more work for you, more risk for the company, and most importantly it provide $0 financial value to the company. It's an easy no. That's what the model predicts, but it's unfortunately not how companies beyond a certain size work in practice. Hiring decisions are not made by the business owner to increase profit, but middle-ranking members of the hierarchy who have their own parallel goals. Businesses can, and do, regularly hire employees that bring in zero or negative value. Often, these people will make up more than 50% of the company by headcount, and the only reason the company still turns a profit is because their existence is subsidised by a small minority of hyper-productive people.
- 5y ago
- dan-robertson 5y agoIs it actually a problem everywhere? I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s not written about much on HN, but my guess is that at least some of the big tech companies will sometimes do large off-cycle performance bonuses. It may depend a lot on the work though, e.g. doing the thing the company actually cares about vs what they say they want or needing to fight one’s case a lot, or needing to have product focused improvements rather than some equivalent savings from efficiency.
- throwaway54976 5y ago> People don't capture the full value of their labor If it does it's no longer capitalism.
- paxys 5y agoWhat this email doesn't say is that Google's solution for fixing retention problems was to reach out to Apple and many other large tech employers and sign illegal agreements to not hire each other's employees. The subject of this email (Facebook) famously declined to participate however.
- gnachman 5y agoIf you got an offer from Facebook they would beat it. I did this in 2012 and instantly had 10x the RSUs. Some Googlers thought it was immoral to do this. It was at this time that comp for engineers radically changed.
- paxys 5y agoI signed a job offer in late 2011 and was due to start a couple months later. Two weeks before the start date, the hiring manager emailed out of the blue to say that they were bumping up my starting salary by 10%. It was a wild time to be in tech (although the situation today isn't all that different).
- pavlov 5y agoZuckerberg is widely despised on HN, but he should get some credit for standing up to the Silicon Valley wage cartel. As your example shows, it put potentially life-changing compensation within the reach of a much larger group of software engineers. Previously you pretty much had to get lucky as an early engineer through IPO, but in the past decade it's been possible to save millions by working at FAANGs. And those millions trickle down into the ecosystem: people can afford to start their own companies, do angel investments, etc.
- Teever 5y agoYou don't give despicable people credit for doing the right thing because they happened to the right thing only because it benefited them.
- 5y ago
- dekhn 5y agoAfter this Google started giving $1K in cash every christmas and one year gave everybody at the company a 10% bonus. Those times are gone.
- emtel 5y agoThe $1K christmas bonus started no later than 2002. You say those times are gone, but have you seen what FAANG pays people now?
- paxys 5y agoYeah, back in the 2000s or even early 2010s a $1K+ employee holiday bonus would be a "holy shit!" event that would make the news. Doing so today, even after adjusting for inflation, would be met with "yeah, whatever" by everyone, including new grads.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI don't get the phenomenon of piddling bonuses. I worked for Amazon in the 2000s. And we got an employee discount. 10% off anything on the site. Capped at a maximum of $100 / year. This is a discount that feels like they're going out of their way to spit in your face. What if you raised my annual pay by... $100? Who would notice or care?
- dastbe 5y agofor good or for bad, one of the things amazon does is focus on providing benefits that can apply to ALL employees, i.e. the six figure devs all the way down to the fc employees.
- jacquesm 5y agoAmazon would notice because paying their whole workforce $100 extra per year would cost them significant money whereas that sum of all those discounts would work out to a small fraction of that amount.
- Barrera 5y agoThat part about "a social networking bubble of imitations and tag alongs" is ironic, given Google's numerous failed attempts to tag along on the social networking bubble.
- karaterobot 5y agoWhat does "rainy weather and a few GPS misalignments" mean?
- SnowHill9902 5y agoI would understand that some employees are not following the exact path that they wish.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoHe could be implying google engineers are fickle. Ie they might leave if there is bad weather. Small exaggeration.
- azundo 5y agoI would posit rainy weather means some lower performance quarters in terms of stock price or performance in some way and GPS misalignments are strategic missteps with the overall direction of the company.
- J_cst 5y agoI think this should not be over-read. I believe that that's a form of sarcasm / ironical phrase, meaning _few minor incidents plus some planned retirements_ . As of he's implying that the employees tend to get overworried/annoyed easily for any minor incident. Sorry I don't speak English natively (and to make things worst, I'm Italian!!) and I'm not sure I was able to express my thoughts in a comprehensible way! Please feel free to rephrase if you can do it better then me! Thanks! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoShould have bought WhatsApp, and fitted it with Gmail search features.
- bogota 5y agoIf they had done this no one would be using WhatsApp today. Google has shown they don’t understand and can’t get chat right.
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoYeah, well, I was thinking of leaving the free-SMS-maybe-with-pics thing well enough alone and just letting you find "Chris aluminum siding" items ... Might be worth a few cents for their advertising side-business, I dunno.
- archontes 5y agoI was enthused for wave. Too bad.
- crossroadsguy 5y agoNope, WhatsApp works just on phone number, not an email. It would have given them perpetual anxiety. So they would have made WhatsApp work only with “Gmail” addresses instead - with Google Login and in a Chrome Desktop app only (of course) - and they’d have then shut it down after few years. Or people might have stopped using it before the shutdown.
- lupire 5y agoThe G+ login nonsense all happened in response to Facebook and Messenger (and iMessage). Before that, Chat was open XMPP.
- asd88 5y agoThen just kill it after a few years
- Apocryphon 5y agoIt's amusing that one of the concerns is Google employees leaving or potential candidates not applying at all because they'd rather "get rich by having a popular fb app." Just what happened to Facebook as a platform, were they just completely superseded by smartphone apps? Incidentally, the decline of their platform is one of the reasons why I believe it is unlikely there will ever be a serious Meta third party App Store competitor on iOS- Facebook isn't very good at managing a developer community.
- alanlammiman 5y agoThey discovered it was more profitable and less hassle to focus on selling ads than trying to be a 'social OS'
- Apocryphon 5y agoThe highlights from the 2021 F8 conference look- riveting https://about.fb.com/news/2021/06/f8-refresh-developer-conference/ https://about.fb.com/news/2021/06/f8-refresh-developer-confe...
- snickerbockers 5y ago> Instagram is not only a cultural and social hub — it’s a place where people come to discover and connect with brands. im so glad i never even tried that one
- mrkramer 5y agoYea you discover stuff and get connected by blackbox recommendation algorithms. No thx.
- ehnto 5y agoI think devs were more cognizant of the platform risk on FB, and the developer experience was absolutely pants. I dreaded every moment working within their platform, maybe it's different now. As well FB apps were necessarily less interesting, because they were so tightly integrated into FB it limited the potential experiences. It just wasn't worth it when a developer could reach people on FB with ads instead, and point to their mobile app, where you can attempt to fully capture the value of the customer rather than just rent them from FB. Forgive me for the business speak there, I'm no longer in that space thank the stars.
- wanderingmind 5y agoBefore FB came into picture, Google, Apple and other big techs colluded to artificially keep the pay low [1]. Every dev with a massive TC needs to thank FB everyday for refusing to become part of the cabal. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-google-settlement-idUSBREA3N1Y120140424 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-google-settlement-i...
- DeathArrow 5y agoYes, and, inspired by that, Alphabet tried to introduce its own problem: Google+.
- benreesman 5y agoWhen I joined in 2011 the core infrastructure staff was so heavily ex-Google that the build files were valid Blaze. There are a lot of factors that went into FB’s meteoric rise in the 2006-2014 range, but I think more than anything it was Sheryl telling the wage cartel that they could get fucked. High-end Google hackers could walk across the street and TCO 2-5x more with negligible increase in risk.
- mrkramer 5y ago>There are a lot of factors that went into FB’s meteoric rise in the 2006-2014 range The main factor was MySpace being a mess, something like Twitter is today but nobody bothered to get it right except Zuckerberg.