24 ms·
Hackers gaining power of subpoena via fake “emergency data requests”
- buildbot 5y agoThis seems like on of those ill-advised crimes that carries a huge federal penalty if caught right? Pretending to be a police officer feels like something that typically gets smacked down pretty aggressively if not officially sanctioned.
- elzbardico 5y agoWell that's just one of lesser things that happens for a paranoid society that trades freedom and privacy for what the oppression apparatus calls security. You don't have security, just a police-state, and to add insult to injury besides having less freedom now you also have less security too. And yes, let's pretend that only China, Iran and Russia are police states, let's keep singing star spangled banner while we happily slip through this slope towards the gulags.
- Forgeties79 5y ago>let's keep singing star spangled banner while we happily slip through this slope towards the gulags You had a point until "gulags." You honestly think we're on the verge of becoming a Stalinist state that imprisons and murders political dissidents by the millions? Maybe that's a tad alarmist?
- stuckinhell 5y agoI don't think so, America has a massive amount of political unrest. Both parties seem to adore violence on their political enemies these days, and most Americans think civil war is on the way.
- Forgeties79 5y ago>most Americans think civil war is on the way Source? Personally, if we survived the 60’s/70’s, I think we can survive this. They literally murdered college students in front of the world. I’m also not sure how any of this translates into Stalin-era gulags. People throw that term around too lightly, like “nazi.” If you’ve actually studied any Russian/Soviet history you should know how insane those were, even for an era with rampant fascism.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoAbsolutely correct. It seems in vogue to use words without understanding the actual meanings. Most people haven't read history and speak, loudly, of that which they don't know.
- thechao 5y agoRight; I think at worst we're managing to rewind ourselves to the `90s, at this point. I think a lot of people don't remember how much social change there was starting in the early `00s through the early `10s. I'm not pleased with the retrogression; I think Project Red Map has really uncovered a large scale hack/flaw in the US electorate that needs to be fixed quickly, but the political situation is certainly nothing like the `60s/`70s. My parents were activists in the 60s, and my grandparents were activists in the 20s & 30s. My parents mostly feared being beaten, with a background fear of being shot at. My grandparents feared being disappeared along with retribution to their extended family, friends, and neighborhoods.
- Forgeties79 5y agoRe: your grandparents, I really don't think people appreciate how easy it was to cross the government with your speech - especially in wartime - prior to late 20th century.
- stuckinhell 5y agohttps://thehill.com/homenews/news/467143-voters-believe-us-two-thirds-of-the-way-to-edge-of-a-civil-war-poll/ https://thehill.com/homenews/news/467143-voters-believe-us-t... The advent of increased population, social media, technology, and major american hyper polarization make the current times very different than the 60s/70s.
- pstuart 5y ago> Both parties seem to adore violence on their political enemies these days Let's stop with the both sides are the same bit, m'kay? Plenty to criticize on the left but please stick to facts.
- pstuart 5y agoI welcome valid examples that prove me wrong. The concern is legitimate, not hyperbole. And as far as Civil War goes, I'd posit that it's already begun.
- Forgeties79 5y agoWell I think many of welcome valid sources showing that “most Americans think civil war is on the way.” If a civil war has “already begun,” I guess I live somewhere else, because I don’t hear any gun shots. Frankly it feels a lot calmer around here than it did a year or two ago.
- pstuart 5y agoJust as we're no longer using muskets and cavalry, the method of warfare has changed in other ways. Perhaps meld in aspects of The Cold War as well. A key change this time is not to split apart, but to simply grab all the marbles and declare the game to be over. I wish I could be sanguine about this and would love to be proven wrong, but it's looking grim.
- elzbardico 5y agoThis is what we call an hyperbole.
- Forgeties79 5y agoPretty over-the-top example if you ask me
- maxbond 5y agoThis is sort of a dodge, isn't it? The question wasn't, what rhetorical device are you employing? It's, do you truly believe the situation is as extreme as you imply? If the answer is "no", then there's an implied invitation to lay out what you actually believe. If the answer is "yes", there's an implied request to justify why you think that way. Saying 'this is what we call hyperbole' seems to imply, 'my ideas stand so well on their own, I don't need to respond to your criticism; the problem is not with my ideas or how I've expressed them, it is with your inability to recognize a particular rhetorical device.' Which is both patronizing and wrong. Your use of hyperbole was recognized and is being interrogated. You're under no obligation to respond to that challenge, no one here has a right to your time, but if you're going to, it would be more productive for everyone if you did so in good faith.
- elzbardico 5y ago> Saying 'this is what we call hyperbole' seems to imply, 'my ideas stand so well on their own, I don't need to respond to your criticism; the problem is not with my ideas or how I've expressed them, it is with your inability to recognize a particular rhetorical device.' Well. now this is a strawman.
- maxbond 5y agoIt certainly isn't a strawman, it's how I interpreted your statement. I continue to believe that it is what you intended, but feel free to correct me; I'm listening. If you're truly being misinterpreted as often as you seem to imply, consider communicating more plainly without sarcasm and hyperbole. I personally find them to be poor tools for communication in general and on the internet especially.
- nahkoots 5y agoDon't forget that we very nearly had a successful coup, which would have spelled the end of American democracy. Are we on the verge of becoming a Stalinist state? No, not really. Could it happen? Absolutely, and we need to recognize that possibility to avoid becoming the next one.
- ipaddr 5y agoPlease forget whatever idea you came up with. America was never under a coup attempt. Hard to even attempt to call it a coup without weapons. Don't worry America is safe from farmers rallying at the white house.
- whateveracct 5y agoMaybe they're referring to the attempts to invalidate the 2020 election? No weapons, but what is a better word for a coordinated attempt to undermine the government?
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoHow about 'attempt to undermine the government'? That is much more accurate than coup. Words have meanings, and using the words inaccurate/the wrong meanings is saying one thing but meaning another, and the word for that is lying.
- jetpks 5y agoThis is the same verbal gymnastics confederate sympathizers use when trying to say that the civil war was about "states rights." All you have to do is follow the logic to its conclusion. What was the civil war about? States rights. What rights, specifically? The right of states to allow their citizens to practice slavery. Therefore, the civil war was about slavery. What was jan 6 about? It was about an attempt to undermine the government. An attempt to undermine what, specifically? The election process. Why did they seek to undermine the election process? So that the mob could extra-judicially install a leader of their preference. Another word for this is coup d'etat.
- mywittyname 5y agoWe'll get our own flavor of gulags. The USA already has a pretty nasty and oppressive prison system. We have pro-authoritarian politicians in office, in the police forces, and now throughout the court system. So it doesn't seem alarmist to me. I'm pretty sure the police could get away with murdering political rivals right now. But a few key court decisions are all we need to formalize that capability for the next 100 or so years.
- consumer451 5y ago> "I wanted to tell everyone that there is a cancer within the government and when I tried to weed it out, I got fired," Gilmore wrote. "It was just easier for government management to get rid of me rather than to deal with the underlying issue." https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/03/13/classified-us-intelligence-chat-rooms-dumpster-fire-of-hate-speech-says-ex-nsa-contractor.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/03/13/classified-us...
- frankfrankfrank 5y agoYet again I find myself in between rather detached perspectives. I agree with you regarding the trajectory because it is clear as day by all objective measures where this is all heading, yet I am left befuddled by your parroting of tropes about the “pretty nasty and oppressive prison system” that the very people are pushing who are leading us to the state where an equivalent of gulags will be created. The American prisons are not full of thought criminals just because you are being denied all the footage and proof of the violent crimes the people in US prisons commit, constantly. I realize that most people live in a negative bubble, where they have no idea what is happening because the truth has been withheld from them, but that does not change the reality most people are at least unwittingly ignorant of. But yes, the gulag system actually already exists in America, and the political prisoners in the USA right now already know that. Assange is also in that gulag system and can probably be considered the first, Prisoner #1 of the American Empire’s Gulag Equivalent System, even though it is on foreign soil.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 5y agoAmerica elected Trump and then Congress knowingly rejected evidence that he colluded with Putin to defraud voters and steal the election. He then occupied that office for four years, while additional evidence continued to mount against the increasingly obviousness of Russian interference. Not only did a sitting President betray people and killed millions with anti-masker/anti-vaccine rhetoric, he did so to aid a foreign country that is known for murdering political dissidents, and did so during WW2, during the Cold War, and the post-Soviet era that exists today; but also our Congress, most of those still occupying those seats today, aided and abetted him. What Trump and his Congress did is terrorism without being formally charged with it, and is hardly any different than the pre-Stalin era of Soviet Russia and the pre-Kristallnacht era of the Nazi occupation of Germany. So, please, I'd like you to tell me why you think people shouldn't be seriously alarmed? You sound like all the deniers in the history books: "Oh, the Nazis wouldn't kill Jews and political dissidents", "Oh, Stalin wouldn't (also) kill Jews and political dissidents", "Oh, Chairman Mao wouldn't just starve tens of millions to gratify his own ego". People keep saying this, it keeps not being true. History is a goddamned broken record.
- tiahura 5y agoCongress knowingly rejected evidence that he colluded with Putin to defraud voters and steal the election. You shouldn’t let your personal animosity towards Trump lead to believing misinformation. Mueller finds no collusion with Russia, leaves obstruction question open https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2019/03/mueller-concludes-investigation/ https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2... You should take this opportunity to consider what other things you know to be true about Trump may also be misinformation. The Washington Post corrects, removes parts of two stories regarding the Steele dossier https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/media-washington-post-steele-dossier/2021/11/12/f7c9b770-43d5-11ec-a88e-2aa4632af69b_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/media-washing...
- treeman79 5y agoIt’s also looking like some of the Bidens are going to jail for what they were accusing Trump. The entire Trump Russia gate was to divert attention from what Hillary / Biden were doing. Oh a laptop was found with solid evidence showing collusion between the Bidens and various countries. Well naturally the same response is to sensor anyone that wants to talk about it and to impeach Trump. https://legalinsurrection.com/2022/03/mainstream-media-outlets-ignore-new-details-in-hunter-biden-scandals/ https://legalinsurrection.com/2022/03/mainstream-media-outle...
- pyronik19 5y agoThere are influential media personalities calling for the jailing people who aren't towing the line on the war drum beat on ukraine/russia... that any narrative deviation is treasonous and thus a jailable offense. Yeah, so what if our gulags have rainbow flags and black fists murals.
- mrtranscendence 5y ago> There are influential media personalities calling for the jailing people who aren't towing the line on the war drum beat on ukraine/russia Source on these influential media personalities? I assume they're not fringe in any way, since you called them "influential".
- pyronik19 5y agohttps://twitter.com/KeithOlbermann/status/1503467489572921346 https://twitter.com/KeithOlbermann/status/150346748957292134...
- ashtonkem 5y agoIt is worth pointing out that the American penal system is already distressingly close to the scope of the gulag system in Stalinist Russia. The gulag system hit a high of 1.5m prisoners in the 1940s out of a population of 168m (pre war), or about 0.89%. America’s prison population peaked in 2009 at an estimated 0.754%. If you include parole that shoots up to 3.1%, but I’m not sure how to compare that to the gulag system Wildly different death tolls though. Our best estimate is that the gulag system had an 8.88% death rate, with that varying wildly on a year by year basis. Meanwhile the US prison system as of 2018 kills 344 per 100,000, or .344%. But unfortunately those numbers are getting worse, not better. I think the difference here is less about our system being more humane, and more the fact that food and antibiotics are cheap. Heck, just look at how the prison system responded to covid. I honestly think we’re a lot closer to a gulag system than people think. We’ve already built the majority of the machinery to actually implement such a system, and politically making the system harsher and less humane is very popular. There is also a bipartisan consensus that what we need is to fund the system even more. All that we’re missing is the jump to directly imprisoning political opponents, and we’ve already seen some calls for that although it isn’t quite mainstream yet.
- Forgeties79 5y ago>It is worth pointing out that the American penal system is already distressingly close to the scope of the gulag system in Stalinist Russia What do you know about the gulag system? Serious question, not baiting or anything. What are the broad strokes of what you understand to be "The Gulags"? Because like you, I am VERY concerned with the US penal system, but to compare the two is...a stretch for me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 5y agoThere's more than one road to hell. All or nothing nihilism, that makes no major distinction between the US & china, Russia and Iran is also a road to totalitarian hell. It's a favoured rhetoric style if Putin and many reactionary extremists.
- renewiltord 5y agoSpotify records all the songs I listen to. Last week 10 songs. This week 100. Next week 200. The week after? PRISON IN A FROZEN WASTE! I suffer endlessly from the data they have collected. Cold bits are thrown upon me every morning; I've lost my toes to frostbyte due to data in cold storage; I have made friends, nay fellow sufferers, in the bitcoin mines, as we hash out issues together. If only I could have seen this last week. L'horreur! L'horreur!
- dang 5y ago"Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- riskable 5y agoThe statements about this being "unfixable" are utter nonsense. If someone claims to be from a particular law enforcement agency it is trivial to just call up said police department and ask to speak to that person. If no one answers or the person can't be reached you don't approve the request. The only thing that's "unfixable" about this is that it's not something you can automate. You need an actual human being to perform the verification step(s).
- rosndo 5y agoHaha. It’s also trivial to create a fake police department in some small town, set up google maps entry etc… What then? What about when you operate internationally and have to accept requests from 100+ jurisdictions?
- comrh 5y agoGet the police department phone number from the town's government and not google maps.
- rosndo 5y agoAnd how do you identify the real government for some small town? There are many that don’t even have websites. Contact the state government to ask? There’s a good chance nobody will be able to provide the answers you seek on short notice.
- Forgeties79 5y agoIf you're in a community that's so small it has no online presence for their government, then chances are you already know who to call anyway.
- voxic11 5y agoSo google gets one of these requests and supposedly its from a police force in a small town that has no government website. How do they know who to call to confirm?
- darig 5y ago
- tiahura 5y agoI’ve been doing a fair amount of subpoenaing phone records lately. It does seem like AT&T, for example, just sends the records (late) without any sort of verification.
- ttyp3 5y agoHow about requiring phone verification that routes through a public number/central source? If it's a true emergency, someone should have no difficulty being available for a call. (The main number could be compromised too, but come on...)
- nomercy400 5y agoYea exactly. Maybe we can give it a name, how about multi-factor authentication? So you verify who you say who you are through a different factor/channel. And making a phone call to actually talk to a person in real time.
- photochemsyn 5y agoI wonder if an 'Emergency Data Request' to Amazon by a law enforcement organization has to go through all the hoop jumping described here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30820424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30820424 relevant comment: "I had to click through more than 100 links to download all the data, how can this be acceptable? Specially coming from Amazon. How hard is it for them to create an archive with all the data? This is ridiculous, I can't imagine how was the meeting when they decided to produce purposefully such garbage UX." This would indicate that Amazon has some kind of internal interface for these Emergency Data Requests for law enforcement that just dumps all the data to them immediately without all those barriers to access. Makes one wonder why that's not also available to Amazon users? Also, are these Emergency Data Requests ever subjected to post-mortem court review of any kind? Is anyone in law enforcement ever subjected to discipline for bogus requests?
- CaptainNegative 5y agoJust a guess, but perhaps Amazon responds to EDRs only with potentially meaningful data rather than how many minutes into your third viewing of The Simpsons S16E4 you paused the video last, how often you've clicked on but never carried through with that Roomba purchase on woot.com, or the full history of Amazon App Store promotions you took part in back in 2015 to get free coins added to your wallet that you've completely forgotten about.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> This would indicate that Amazon has some kind of internal interface for these Emergency Data Requests for law enforcement that just dumps all the data to them immediately without all those barriers to access. If they scratch the government's back, chances are the government will scratch Amazon's back, too. > Makes one wonder why that's not also available to Amazon users? There's a benefit to giving law enforcement whatever they want, but little to no benefit to giving users the freedom to move their data out of Amazon's walled garden. Amazon is the same company that is creating partnerships with law enforcement agencies all over the country with their Ring products and surveillance network[1][2]. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/31/22258856/amazon-ring-partners-police-fire-security-privacy-cameras https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/31/22258856/amazon-ring-part... [2] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/06/amazon-ring-must-end-its-dangerous-partnerships-police https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/06/amazon-ring-must-end-i...
- indymike 5y agoThis one is easy. Require a warrant.
- exabrial 5y agoAh stole a move from Politicians and fake emergency powers
- throwbigdata 5y agoIf only there were a way to cryptographically verify such things.
- ibejoeb 5y agoThis bill was introduced last summer: https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/The%20Digital%20Authenticity%20for%20Court%20Orders%20Act%20of%202021%20Bill%20Text.pdf https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/The%20Digital%20A...
- rootusrootus 5y agoEvery time I start to feel despondent about the state of the US Congress, I remember that Wyden exists, and I feel a twinge of hope.
- Avamander 5y agoLet's hope what was proposed comes to fruition while remaining interoperable with the EU. It would be such a "two steps forward, one step back"-move if it doesn't.
- vimax 5y agoRight. There should be agency run certificate authorities for this. One to issue certificates to law enforcement, and one to issue certificates to judges A valid warrant would include the intended judge and be signed by the department and the issuing officer before going to the judge, then signed by that judge’s cert to be authorized.
- Avamander 5y agoAnd such an approach would absolutely work, at least one country has used PKI for such purposes for almost more a decade. This attack vector from the article? Unheard of clownery.
- rahimnathwani 5y ago"KT said fake EDRs don’t have to come from police departments based in the United States, and that some people in the community of those sending fake EDRs are hacking into police department emails by first compromising the agency’s website. From there, they can drop a backdoor “shell” on the server to secure permanent access, and then create new email accounts within the hacked organization." This sounds extremely unlikely. Maybe in 1999 someone would have hosted their mail server on the same server as their web site. But today?
- detaro 5y ago> But today? Today they use the same crappy hosting company as in 1999, that does the same thing it's always done, just only slightly newer hardware. Especially on a municipal level, there still is not much of a standard when it comes to such things.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoHmm... it seems trivial to do a lookup of the A records for @ and www, and see if there's any overlap with the MX records. If so, then it was likely set up a long time ago and not maintained well.
- CrazyMusicians 5y agoFrom: https://twitter.com/briankrebs/status/1508819347963363329 https://twitter.com/briankrebs/status/1508819347963363329 Some backstory that's not in the piece. I originally started reporting this about six months ago, when an anonymous tip suggested people were creating fake police department .org domains and sending requests from there. Spent ridiculous amt of time chasing that to no end. As part of that research I looked at all new police dept domains in the last year. Found so many I was sure were fake. They were all real. Some were half-done. Some completely wide open, security-wise. It was depressing to learn after that there are > 18k police depts nationwide.
- ellen364 5y ago18k police departments is mind blowing. I looked it up because I wasn’t sure it was plausible, but a Department of Justice publication confirmed [0]. Meanwhile the UK has 48 police forces [1]. 330,000,000 / 18,000 = 18,500 Americans per police force 67,000,000 / 48 = 1,396,000 Brits per police force Not sure what to make of that. [0] https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/nsleed.pdf https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/nsleed.pdf [1] https://www.police.uk/pu/contact-the-police/uk-police-forces/ https://www.police.uk/pu/contact-the-police/uk-police-forces...
- rvr_ 5y agoOne way to approach crime is to make the risk too big. What about punishing with death those who do identity theft and impersonation? Our society tolerates too much crime.
- nullc 5y ago"Hi, I'm rvr_ member of law enforcement, someone's life is in danger, please provide customer details for IP 1.2.3.4 immediately!" ... ignoring those double impersonation swatting problems, enforcement against crimes online is really hard due to global scope. Police won't even investigate because all they find is that the hacker was some russian and they can't do anything about it.
- IncRnd 5y agoIn methodology this is similar to an ancient scam, where scammers would send fake yellow page/phone book invoices to companies. Many companies would just pay the bills.
- judge2020 5y agohttps://www.npr.org/2019/03/25/706715377/man-pleads-guilty-to-phishing-scheme-that-fleeced-facebook-google-of-100-million https://www.npr.org/2019/03/25/706715377/man-pleads-guilty-t...
- psychlops 5y agoAll this high speed life or death information and yet the clearance rate of solved homicides in the US has dropped from 70% in the 1980's to 50% today.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoI expect this is true, and shows the ridiculous scope creep of government snooping and stalking on individual privacy for what it largely is, power grabs by individuals in government drunk on the power of control. That said, do you have a source?
- psychlops 5y agoI had read it previously elsewhere, then recently re-read it here: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2022/01/12/as-murders-spiked-police-solved-about-half-in-2020 https://www.themarshallproject.org/2022/01/12/as-murders-spi... I imagine the picture is a lot more complex than the charts make it out to be. For example, I'd be curious about rate trendlines of false imprisonment.
- ivanhoe 5y agoWouldn't it be better if federal government would open a service for handling all EDRs nation-wide, and then forward the legit ones to the IT companies as needed? It would simplify the verification, maybe scare some hackers away because it'd become a federal crime to fake it, and also allow for some stats on how many such request are really urgent, and how many (I presume a lot) are just used to circumvent the law because courts would reject them.
- goodluckchuck 5y agoThat might work great if the federal authorities were reliable, motivated, and their interests were always aligned with state authorities. However, there are often disputes where the feds do not what to prosecute certain groups or individuals, and might interfere with state / local authorities. (e.g. police in a Democrat-run state prosecuting allies of a Republican president and vise versa, or investigations into federal informants who are violating state law). This would also allow make it easier for the feds to perform on-path attacks where they "forward" EDRs from state / local authorities that were never issued by those state / local authorities.
- caymanjim 5y agoThis is, to me, the only real solution. We can't have the onus be on individual companies to vet requests coming from random podunk police departments nationwide. Companies will err on the side of caution/CYA and honor requests they shouldn't, lest they find themselves responsible for causing harm by inaction. But companies don't have the resources or legal authority to make those determinations, nor vet the authenticity of requests from every time government entity that might make one. There's also plenty of reason not to trust some small town police force that might not have adequate internal controls, or might have a rogue officer far exceeding his authority. The feds need to own this and all requests need to flow through them. It wouldn't be hard for them to have a small staff available 24/7 to confirm requests and forward them on to businesses, and then the business only needs to trust a single entity. There may still be disputes over the legality, but those disputes will need to be defended by the central federal authority, rather than putting the burden on every company.
- sonicggg 5y agoIt sounds like EDRs shouldn't really be a thing. If police needs a court-issued warrant to enter my home, why can't they enforce the same for data access? If there's one thing I learned from practice in programming is the more "exceptions" you make, the more room there is for bugs and security flaws. The same applies for everything. Keep rules simple. The more "if this, then that" you add, the more loopholes you may find.
- bhk 5y ago> “One of the problems you have is there’s no validated master list of people who are authorized to make that demand” It sounds like there isn't even a well-defined policy for who is authorized.
- bhk 5y agoBut Apple says "Any government agency seeking customer content from Apple must obtain a search warrant issued upon a showing of probable cause.” So what's up?
- Jerrrry 5y agoFaking EDR's and GDPR is the newest way to take over anyone's account, for many platforms. just the effort companies made to support the requests allow for shenanigans. if you cant take over the account - you request it be deleted, then remake the account with the username/email desired.
- phendrenad2 5y agoInteresting. And since you can't even store the email address, you can't detect that someone is recreating a deleted account. Hashes to the rescue though. You can just return a cryptic "email/account name not accepted" message.
- Jerrrry 5y agoIs storing a hash not also invasive? I don't store your IP or SSN. I store the Md5 hash of it. If the bit-space is easily enumerable, it is just as bad... but is it?
- cwkoss 5y agoI've always wondered how many fake national security letters have been sent to companies, and what the success rate on them is. Cant LEO get things in front of judges in hours? Is bypassing courts ever actually necessary?
- upofadown 5y ago>“The only way to clean it up would be to have the FBI act as the sole identity provider for all state and local law enforcement,” Weaver said. “But even that won’t necessarily work because how does the FBI vet in real time that some request is really from some podunk police department?” There are already preexisting systems for solving this sort of problem. For example the FBI could set up a PGP based certificate authority[1] for email. Then the FBI signs the identities of the podunk police departments ahead of time. All the service providers would need would be the FBI identity (PGP public key) which they would sign once to authorize it and then they would be able to verify emails coming from any of the podunk police departments with no extra work on their part. This example comes with a revocation system that actually would work in this case. All secret key material would remain under the control of the specific FBI department acting as the certificate authority. No third party involvement would be required. [1] https://sequoia-pgp.org/blog/2021/05/12/202105-hello-openpgp-ca/ https://sequoia-pgp.org/blog/2021/05/12/202105-hello-openpgp...
- mef 5y agowouldn't this just shift the trust from the police email address to the police email PGP signer? wouldn't hackers then just target that part of the infrastructure?
- Avamander 5y agoThat would be significantly harder, especially with hardware key storage.
- willcipriano 5y agoThe alternative is due process, where a judge issues a court order and the police have to wait a few hours for that to happen.
- 300bps 5y agoProbably take 5 minutes to find an example order online from most judges in the country. Make a fake document to look just like it saying whatever you want. Send it in - how do they authenticate it?
- therein 5y agoThis is hilarious. That email with Vinny Troia, and fast-flux... I received that email at my previous employer. We had a good laugh about it with our security team at the time.
- Ekaros 5y agoWhy not make federal service for this? Give access to all relevant authorities to file such request there and then make it possible to cross-reference it? Leaks of access can be tracked more easily.
- cycomanic 5y agoI have to admit I find this whole situation (and also Krebs article bizarre). The problem seems to be that tech companies approve EDRs without much checking. Then the argument somehow becomes it is essentially impossible for them to check because there could be any of the thousands of police departments in the world requesting the EDR? Why should MS in the US somehow respond to a request from police department in Cuxhafen in Germany? I think the argument being made here is one of those "we can't make a perfect solution so no solution works", which is nonsense. Simply don't answer requests from police departmenents you can't verify. I bet you if a police department would request some business sensitive information they would not hand it over without going over the subpoena with a fine toothed comb. The issue is just that they don't value their customers privacy high enough to do a proper check.
- chockchocschoir 5y ago> Why should MS in the US somehow respond to a request from police department in Cuxhafen in Germany? If a non-US company does business in the US, most people would expect the business to also answer to US law enforcement. You can't just operate in a business and not follow the law of that country. Same applies the other way around, you do business as a US company in Germany, you better follow German law. Hence companies tend to have HQ in one country, and then subsidiaries in other countries, who know how the local market and laws work.
- verve_rat 5y agoThat's the point though. MS US headquarters is not responding to these requests. MS {local country} branch is responding. And I'm sure the people that work in country X know how to contact country X's police. This is really a non issue being blown up in to some unsolvable conundrum by people in this conversation that want to find problems in using a phone book.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoAre you sure? So much phishing potential in the links below. I know every GP surgery in the UK that uses a windows server is accessible online and Shodan can give away so much information, lets hope people like Cisco and netgear dont have any zero days. https://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2010/02/microsoft-online-services-global-criminal-compliance-handbook.pdf https://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2010/02/micro... https://cyberlaw.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/microsoft-spy.pdf https://cyberlaw.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/microsoft... https://info.publicintelligence.net/MSN-Compliance.pdf https://info.publicintelligence.net/MSN-Compliance.pdf https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/outlook_com/forum/all/give-and-get-details-of-an-account-for-a-police/cb276407-5cf1-4687-9c2d-e510cddab006 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/outlook_com/forum/all/gi... https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/outlook_com/forum/all/hotmail-law-enforcement-needs-contact-info-please/2b42cf7a-e716-40ba-9117-53c089f321b0 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/outlook_com/forum/all/ho... https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/law-enforcement-requests-report https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/law... https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/us-national-security-orders-report https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/us-... https://leportal.microsoft.com/home https://leportal.microsoft.com/home https://sendersupport.olc.protection.outlook.com/pm/policies.aspx https://sendersupport.olc.protection.outlook.com/pm/policies... https://undisputedlegal.com/how-to-serve-legal-papers-on-microsoft-corporation/ https://undisputedlegal.com/how-to-serve-legal-papers-on-mic... https://customers.microsoft.com/en-us/story/843015-nep-uk-police-modern-work-case-study-government-microsoft-365 https://customers.microsoft.com/en-us/story/843015-nep-uk-po... https://www.transformation.police.uk/ https://www.transformation.police.uk/ https://www.transformation.police.uk/what-we-do/national-management-centre https://www.transformation.police.uk/what-we-do/national-man... https://www.transformation.police.uk/what-we-do/identity-access-management https://www.transformation.police.uk/what-we-do/identity-acc... https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252493673/UK-police-unlawfully-processing-over-a-million-peoples-data-on-Microsoft-365 https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252493673/UK-police-unla... RING.com LEO portal support page. https://support.ring.com/hc/en-us/articles/360031595491-How-Public-Safety-Agencies-Use-Neighbors https://support.ring.com/hc/en-us/articles/360031595491-How-... https://help.publicsafety.ring.com/hc/en-us https://help.publicsafety.ring.com/hc/en-us Facebook LEO portal https://www.facebook.com/records/login/ https://www.facebook.com/records/login/ Yahoo https://www.eff.org/files/filenode/social_network/yahoo_sn_leg-doj.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/filenode/social_network/yahoo_sn_l...
- einpoklum 5y ago> It involves compromising email accounts and websites tied to police departments and government agencies, and then sending unauthorized demands for subscriber data while claiming the information being requested can’t wait for a court order because it relates to an urgent matter of life and death. Ah, very simple then: Ignore such demands for as long as you can, then, if approached by actual law enforcement, tell them you were told such messages are phishing attempts from hackers.
- rnk 5y agoI doubt the public is aware of the very large number of different electronic requests for their information, and how many can be faked, from dmca takedowns to these fake emergency data requests to requests from the feds for your email etc in the name of 'national security'. Somehow we need to get this out there better, and get more lawmakers aware. It's doubtful in my lifetime that the addiction of law enforcement to these easy electronic requests will cease. The fact that such requests can't really be authenticated reliably without a human in the loop (because as Krebs says, you can just create real email accounts on the police dept email server) and there are so many of them is terrifying. You could put our entire society (in the us) into chaos just be pushing this more and more until our law enforcement is just overwhelmed. If we were in a war with Russia or China, why wouldn't they do that?
- woah 5y ago> You could put our entire society (in the us) into chaos just be pushing this more and more until our law enforcement is just overwhelmed. What? If the attack you describe was going on, there would be a very simple remedy: Stop requiring people to comply with possibly-false subpoenas.
- freeone3000 5y agoThis would require police departments to give up their power to illegally obtain information. I'm not going to hold my breath.
- theknocker 5y ago
- tlogan 5y agoThe only way to verify that something is send by certain perosn to contact that person over “secure line” and ask them about it. The “secure line” can be just a phone call to police department and ask for officer with badge number xyz.
- 8organicbits 5y agoSome challenges here are how you'd discover the police departments phone line and what happens after hours when no one will answer. Keep in mind, not all police departments have websites where you'd be able to look up the info. E: lots of police websites on .com as well, so you can't even depend on .gov. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3A.com+police+department&t=fpas&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3A.com+police+department&t=fp... https://www.anchoragepolice.com/ https://www.anchoragepolice.com/
- tlogan 5y agoThere is an easy fix for Thai: if a department have a way to verify the request (secure phone line) then that department cannot issue an emergency request.
- rootusrootus 5y agoTrying to find more information about Emergency Data Requests leads in large part right back to this discussion and the original Brian Krebs post, with a few hits to various private organizations that explain what it takes to use an Emergency Data Request with them. I'm having trouble finding any basis for this in law. Can anyone help clarify that? Are EDRs just 100% voluntary compliance on the part of some private organizations who are choosing to divulge customer information without an actual court order? If that's the case, why are we lamenting the existence of the hackers and not publicly shaming the companies complying with these nonsense EDRs? Real court orders aren't that hard to get, and at least there'd be a more blatant crime to prosecute if anyone forges them.
- judge2020 5y agoIt does seem to be fairly voluntary. https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/pdf/requests-2020-H2-en.pdf https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/pdf/requests-2020-H... > An emergency request must relate to circumstances involving imminent danger of death or serious physical injury to any person. If Apple believes in good faith that it is a valid emergency, we may voluntarily provide information to law enforcement on an emergency basis. I imagine this is a middle ground between 'governments always have instant access to customer info' and 'i don't care, get your warrant', because in the latter scenario real harm can be done in the hour/hours it can take to process even a FISA warrant. With this, Apple can deny requests if there is not obvious imminent harm, while probably pretty good at identifying legitimate requests and delivering helpful information within a few hours to keep lawmakers from creating more types of warrants to force Apple's hand. (apple ~= all the other data providers with an emergency request system)
- logifail 5y ago> Apple can deny requests if there is not obvious imminent harm, while probably pretty good at identifying legitimate requests You're saying the privacy of my data depends solely on providers being "pretty good" at identifying legitimate requests from people trying to get their hands on it? I feel better already... /s
- TeeMassive 5y agoGreat, the privacy equivalent of swatting.
- AceJohnny2 5y agoThere's an old truism about computer security that "it is easier to automate bad behavior than to police it." I think more people who build systems that will be used by 3rd parties at scale should be aware of this. Unfortunately, it seems the Venture Capitalist drive to Grow First means we keep ending up with large systems with terrible moderation.
- purplejacket 5y agoDidn't we see this ago on Mr. Robot? https://www.theverge.com/2016/9/7/12835320/mr-robot-hack-report-s2e9-hidden-process https://www.theverge.com/2016/9/7/12835320/mr-robot-hack-rep...
- lvs 5y ago
- KingOfCoders 5y agoSad that I've toyed around with signing emails with PGP 30 years ago. Now decades later we still haven't got that working. Perhaps something like this will push email signing.
- edent 5y agoHow would that help? If you've compromised someone's email, chances are you'll also be able to grab their private key and password.
- jdrc 5y agoLooking at it from any side, data is a liability
- nijave 5y agoSeems like the solution is in the article: use strong 2FA. The article mentions getting access to email accounts with 2FA is significantly harder.
- zardo 5y agoWhy would you not just decline any request for customer data from any source? Turn that emergency request into an emergency warrant.