6 ms·
> If those two were represented as a single "NOTA" option, that option would have won the ballot in terms of votes. If the ballot were different, the results w
by toast0 5y ago
> If those two were represented as a single "NOTA" option, that option would have won the ballot in terms of votes.
If the ballot were different, the results would be too. You can't take the results of one ballot and mush them around to support a hypothetical result; see also counting of the 'popular vote' for US president, a ballot which has never been tried, and whose results are unknowable.
A vote for 4 says (to me, not a qualified voter) I don't like the current voting, and hiding identities is also undesirable; if this choice is selected, the status quo must be continued until a new alternative is voted upon, but there's clearly desire to do so. If option 3 were selected, the status quo had clearly won, and the issue should be considered settled for whatever timeframe Debian considers appropriate.
- dhzhzjsbevs 5y agoIt's a binary decision. The only way to properly poll that is either rank choice voting or a second vote after voting to change or not.
- toast0 5y agoDebian votes are ranked choice.
- cosmojg 5y agoSpecifically, they use the Schulze method[1] with ranked ballots, which is far better[2] than the IRV method popularized by FairVote[3] and currently making the rounds in the U.S. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method [2] https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSE/ https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSE/ [3] https://www.fairvote.org/ https://www.fairvote.org/
- treeman79 5y agoDiluting the vote of your opponent/position is quite common. https://www.newsweek.com/russian-politician-discovers-2-men-using-same-name-running-against-him-elections-1629808?amp=1 https://www.newsweek.com/russian-politician-discovers-2-men-...
- bigbillheck 5y agoI don't see anything in there about ranked choice voting.
- gregmac 5y ago> see also counting of the 'popular vote' for US president, a ballot which has never been tried, and whose results are unknowable. I don't follow this point. I'm not an American, but my understanding is counting via simple popular vote vs "electoral college" doesn't change the ballot itself, you still vote for the president directly; it just changes the way the ballots are counted. Are you suggesting either something on the ballot is different, or that people would making a different vote if it was counted differently?
- skrtskrt 5y agoThe point about the American election is that if people knew going into the vote that it was a popular vote across the country, voting behavior would change. Many people don’t vote at all because their preferred president has a 0% chance of winning their state and the vast majority of states are winner-take all with the electoral votes
- oneoff786 5y agoOr they don’t vote because their preferred president has a 100% chance of winning, which is more often the case given their community is already deeply red or blue
- mywittyname 5y agoMaybe they do vote because local elections are important.
- pessimizer 5y agoLocal elections can be important, but if all the candidates are bad, they're not.
- skrtskrt 5y agosure, the known set of rules causes some types of voters to be more likely to vote, and other types less likely. The point is that you can't possibly know how all those interactions among voters would play out if you did in fact update the rules
- kelnos 5y ago> A vote for 4 says (to me, not a qualified voter) I don't like the current voting, and hiding identities is also undesirable; if this choice is selected, the status quo must be continued until a new alternative is voted upon, but there's clearly desire to do so. That's a difference without distinction, though. If option 4 were to win, then, what would they then do? The exact same thing as if option 3 were to win -- keep the status quo -- no? The idea that an option 4 win might also get people to consider other voting systems isn't really relevant; you don't vote to consider things that you will then put to vote. You just consider them, and then have a vote. So the "legal" outcome of this vote would be identical if either option 3 or 4 had won. IMO the DPL is correct that this election was constructed poorly: they should have had either option 3 or 4 in there, not both. But I think that might just be a "too bad" situation: since there are no provisions in the constitution for a "do over", I think the only reasonable thing to do is to accept the results of the election, change the voting system, and then propose a new vote to potentially change it back, but this time more carefully consider the options on the ballot. Unfortunately, because of the supermajority requirement, this probably won't work as intended. Just because options 3+4 on the current vote (had they been combined into a single option) may have been enough to cause the supermajority requirement to fail, it doesn't mean that there will be a supermajority (in a new vote) to switch back to public voting. I think they screwed up, but in order to preserve confidence in their system, they'll have to suck it up and live with it.