19 ms·
Debian decides to allow secret votes
- darig 5y ago
- hans1729 5y ago
- INTPenis 5y agoI understand you, but you picked a strange hill to fight on. Lwn is such a simple website, and the article is just one paragraph. Also what is reader mode to you? Because in Firefox I clicked the little reader view icon in the url bar and it showed me a reader view with just the main content.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 0des 5y agoReader mode is an accessibility feature. Please do not question someone for needing help.
- INTPenis 5y agoOh you mean screen reader? That's confusing, but yeah screen reader is absolutely a vital accessibility feature. I have no idea how lwn handles that. Back when I was still writing HTML I was actually very keen on making accessible websites. But the last 10 years I've used frameworks and sadly have no idea how accessible the output is.
- bitcharmer 5y agoReader mode on mobile Firefox works fine for me on LWN. From my experience LWN has always been a very readable website that works pretty well on mobile too. Do you mind sharing what exactly you disapprove about how the content is structured without reader mode?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- detaro 5y agoReader mode works just fine here.
- the_lonely_road 5y agoApparently by a single vote and the legitimacy of the vote is in question due to some technicality I didn't care to reread until I understood. What I don't understand is why the project is NOT already secret voting? Do not most free democratic countries practice 'secret ballot' voting specifically because not doing so caused all kinds of problems like voter intimidation? I googled the first three that came to mind (france uk, usa) and they all seem to do so. Anyone associated with the Debian project have any insight on why voting is not secret and/or any other large os projects doing the same that could chime in?
- ckastner 5y agoThe legitimacy was questioned by a single person, so far all replies indicate that said person was simply mistaken on multiple counts, and in the meantime, said person no longer sees a problem. Reasons against secret voting were expressed in ballot option C: https://www.debian.org/vote/2022/vote_001#textc https://www.debian.org/vote/2022/vote_001#textc
- clippablematt 5y agoI was surprised too. You have to have secret votes to stop intimidation, and also collusion. If people can prove they voted a certain way then they can be bribed.
- danuker 5y agoI am not familiar with Debian's practices, but electronic voting can't work for a nation because: - centralization (there must be a central, corruptible place where the voters are authenticated or the votes are counted) - software is untrustable: https://www.win.tue.nl/%7Eaeb/linux/hh/thompson/trust.html https://www.win.tue.nl/%7Eaeb/linux/hh/thompson/trust.html The USA has had a Diebold voting scandal. Other countries are using a paper-based voting process which can be supervised by third parties. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premier_Election_Solutions#Security_and_concealment_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premier_Election_Solutions#Sec... Relevant watching: Tom Scott: Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkH2r-sNjQs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkH2r-sNjQs One possible solution could be ZCash ( https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/585.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/585.pdf ) but it has had its own problems ( https://www.coindesk.com/zcash-team-reveals-it-fixed-a-catastrophic-coin-counterfeiting-bug https://www.coindesk.com/zcash-team-reveals-it-fixed-a-catas... ).
- spondyl 5y agoA brief summary because I had to re-read this a few times to figure out what was going on. Debian had a vote with 4 options: Option 1 "Hide identities of Developers casting a particular vote" Option 2 "Hide identities of Developers casting a particular vote and allow verification" Option 3 "Reaffirm public voting" Option 4 "None of the above" (NOTA) The objection raised here is that Option 3 and Option 4 can be considered to be the same depending on how you interpret them (ie; "None of the above" vs "Keep public ballots" which can be said to implicitly suggest none of the above at the same time). If those two were represented as a single "NOTA" option, that option would have won the ballot in terms of votes.
- charcircuit 5y agoBy definition "none of the above" can't be the same as any of the above options.
- beaconstudios 5y agoBut then the question becomes, "if you don't want private votes and you don't want public votes, what do you want?"
- rossvor 5y agoSomething else which hasn't been suggested yet. Basically it could be that you are not opposed to the secret voting in principle, but you think current proposed options are not fully baked yet and you also think that current status quo is sub-optimal too.
- cailie 5y agoEliminate voting?
- remram 5y agoMaybe you want for some votes to be public and some votes to be private. Putting "all votes should be {public,private}" in the constitution prevents that.
- 5y ago
- vinsci 5y ago
- stemc43 5y ago
- pydry 5y agoFor anybody wondering why you might want some sunlight to disinfect the voting process a look at how the NSA has previously managed to corrupt internet standards: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/05/nsa-gchq-encryption-codes-security https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/... I'd be shocked if they didnt also have their claws into debian's operations for similar reasons. I'd not be very surprised if they were indirectly behind this push either. The fact that this seems to be inspired by the people backing the very obvious hatchet job done on Richard Stallman only makes me more suspicious that its motives are anything but pure. The biggest threat model here is probably the NSA using its assets to sway votes (probably unknowingly for most if not all, if they are influenced by a third party they dont know is fronting the NSA). Secrecy will make it that much easier to corrupt votes. Tolerating a bit of personal abuse and cracking down on it separately is probably preferable to the existential threat to free software this presents.
- josteink 5y ago> The fact that this seems to be inspired by the people backing the very obvious hatchet job done on Richard Stallman only makes me more suspicious that its motives are anything but pure. From the outside looking in, it looks like another obvious SJW coup.
- mlindner 5y agoYou're phrasing of "sunlight to disinfect the voting process" is rather disgusting personally... You try to twist something that's quite horrible, namely voter corruption through public opinion as if it is somehow "disinfecting" anything. The mob mentality of the internet is best kept away from any voting base.
- pydry 5y agoThese people are making decisions that affect all of us on our behalf. Decisions that affect the security and integrity of the software we rely upon every single day. It is not "disgusting" that we be allowed to question their decisions. Every introduction of democracy or futherance of democracy has been castigated by autocrats as rule by mob. The sickening irony here is that it looks like this was done to try and protect the identities of members of the mob who tried and failed to cancel Stallman.
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoWill they inform us who voted for this? Just a little joke. Interesting how on one hand personal attacks can and are being weaponized when they have nothing to do with software, yet on the other hand you have the potential for nefarious, ignorant, or incompetent decisions to be made without quickly understanding why and if you want to go along with it.
- gspr 5y agoYes, under "tally sheet" at https://vote.debian.org/~secretary/gr_vote_secrecy/ https://vote.debian.org/~secretary/gr_vote_secrecy/ Note that that still points to the dummy tally (a tally that lists who voted, but not what they voted for), but the project secretary usually publishes the real thing within a few days of vote ending.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- incomingpain 5y ago
- bayindirh 5y ago> It's clear what has happened to Debian and why it's in death spiral. Citation needed. I don't see anything dying for the last 15 years.
- incomingpain 5y ago
- goodpoint 5y agoYou are spreading FUD written by a notorious troll that has been expelled from FOSDEM, FSFE, Debian and other organizations as well.
- incomingpain 5y ago>You are spreading FUD written by a notorious troll that has been expelled from FOSDEM, FSFE, Debian and other organizations as well. I was asked for citation. I more than delivered with quite a few links there. All of which were unique folks with unique situations. It seems to me you are referring to one of these but I genuinely don't know which you are talking about. Something abundantly clear to me is that there's some serious harassment going on at Debian. No question at all to me. It also seems to me, the harassers are not gone. People are requesting secret votes to avoid harassment. So this "expelled" troll isn't the problem.
- goodpoint 5y ago> I more than delivered with quite a few links there. Random URLs from the Internet do not make reputable sources. > All of which were unique folks with unique situations. Wrong. Various websites belong to the same person. > It seems to me you are referring to one of these but I genuinely don't know which you are talking about. Then do some research before posting random stuff. > Something abundantly clear to me is that there's some serious harassment going on at Debian. Yes, and this is why an anti-harassment team has been created. > People are requesting secret votes to avoid harassment. So this "expelled" troll isn't the problem. The first sentence does not imply the second.
- cosmiccatnap 5y agoI think this is a great idea. Can't tell you how many times a very poor solution was implemented because a single person would flip out if you tried to ask them about alternatives because it was "their baby" This at least let's those people know they are in the minority without people feeling like they might get blacklash.
- coffeeblack 5y agoAdds even more politics to tech decisions. Seems obvious what the result will be.
- indrora 5y agoIf you don't want politics in your tech decisions, I implore you to find a nice commune in the middle of the desert where no language is used and only mute sustenance farming is practiced, no disease is spread, and violence of any kind is met with swift ostracism and/or death.
- evouga 5y agoIf Debian didn’t want politics in their tech decisions, they should have focused their scope on tech decisions rather than politics. Not that there’s anything wrong with an organization holding forth on “issues of the day,” per se. But there is an iron law, effective ever since GamerGate-style tactics of “collecting receipts” and cross-platform and offline hounding became normalized as righteous retribution rather than harassment and bullying: your organization can have at most two of (1) transparency, (2) candor; (3) broader social relevance.
- IntelMiner 5y agoPolitics exists in every facet of all of our lives. Snarky whining about it in "tech" just shows how disconnected you are
- _8j50 5y agoThis is good. Secret ballot empowers voters. Public ballot only makes sense if the voter is a representative of other people and they want their record public for continued support.
- jodrellblank 5y agoIt's fine to say "OSS developers don't owe anybody anything" in general, but Debian specifically has quite a strict vetting procedure before accepting people as developers and they agree to things like the Debian Social Contract[1] which includes: "Debian believes the makers of a free software operating system should provide guarantees when a user entrusts them with control of a computer. [...] Not hiding problems with the software or organization. [...] Staying focused on the users and the software that started the phenomenon." and a document of Developer Duties[2]. Seems like there should be few things the developers cannot do openly, but can do secretly if 'empowered', and there perhaps ought to be a public record and transparency around any incidence or accusations of vote-bullying or vote-buying. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Social_Contract https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Social_Contract [2] https://www.debian.org/doc/manuals/developers-reference/developer-duties.html https://www.debian.org/doc/manuals/developers-reference/deve...
- _8j50 5y agoDoes being secret not protect them from influence? If someone buys their vote, they can take payment and vote however they want? Or if they have an unpopular perspective any loud minority groups of devs would oppose them and cause backlash, they won't have to worry about it. Look at systemd, if you voted against having only one init system back in the day, you would be subject to backlash or it could be understood as support for the Devuan forkers.
- michaelmrose 5y agoDebian is apparently bad at democracy despite putting a lot of thought into the matter. The entire problem has to do with conflating 3 questions with boolean answers as 3 sets of answers to those 3 questions. 1. Should we have a vote to amend yes no higher threshold to pass. 2. If yes should we hide identities of developers casting a vote yes no 3. If yes should we allow verification yes no Arguably 3 is a ridiculous question so ought to be safely omitted. Arguably it would be reasonable to require more than 10% to cast a vote as well. All we know now is that a single digit percentage of Debian developers prefer to vote anon. Given the low turnout there is little reason not to respect the present result but have another smarter vote.