5 ms·
Agree with the general principle, but it is important to identify what aspects of a current product's design is shaped specifically by fossil fuel dependency an
by paxys 5y ago
Agree with the general principle, but it is important to identify what aspects of a current product's design is shaped specifically by fossil fuel dependency and what evolved independent of it.
If you threw away all preconceived notions of how a car should look and feel and spent an unlimited amount of time and money to design a new perfect one based around electric power, it would...still look very similar to any other car on the market today. The reason is that the design of a passenger car (and all of the infrastructure around it) has evolved over many centuries independent of its power source – from a horse drawn carriage to a Ford Model T to a Tesla.
- sdoering 5y agoThis reminded me of a classical example of Chesterton's Fence [0]. I like the distinction between the sources that shaped a development. [0]: https://fs.blog/chestertons-fence/ https://fs.blog/chestertons-fence/
- afiori 5y ago> still look very similar to any other car on the market today Cars on the market looks wildly different compare a Smart (the brand) car with the new GMC humongous pickup truck.
- grp000 5y agoBarring the power source, you'll still have a beefy suspension and a bed in the back with a squashed looking frontend to keep the exterior dimensions reasonable on a truck.
- ashtonkem 5y agoPart of the reason why all cars seem to look the same nowadays is that maximizing aerodynamics, passenger safety, interior volume, and comfort doesn’t leave the designer a lot of room to work with. Very little of the “sameness” is driven by the propulsion mechanism; EVs are already becoming similar but with a frunk.
- gedy 5y agoYes and honestly, I think many people are not interested in buying and driving around in a "weird looking" electric car. Tesla, Ford, et al have been improving this and consumer acceptance. (Well unsure about the Cybertruck)
- dehrmann 5y agoYou can look at a Smart car to see what a minimally viable passenger compartment looks like. VW made Beetles and buses with rear engines. A lot of modern cars don't have very big engine compartments, you need crumple zones, and aerodynamics are probably better with modern shapes, so yeah, I don't see cars looking all that different. To your point, they're not even that different from stagecoaches--two people across, similar size.
- maxerickson 5y agoI wonder if stagecoaches are 2 horses wide.
- kennywinker 5y agoA minor correction. Much of the design of cars is about projecting the concept of safety - people buy escalades and other big cars because they feel safer in them - that fear is driven by the 30k deaths per year and many more serious injuries. I believe that safer designed roads and slower speeds would lead to very different vehicles. Personally I think a 30-40kph speed cap within the city would save thousands of lives, make cars cheaper and smaller, make everyone less stressed out, allow more people to be comfortable using alternate modes of transportation (bikes, scooters, etc) and would probably add well under 5min to most journeys (traffic being the limiting factor 90% of the time)
- usrusr 5y agoThat fear is driven by an arms race in projecting the concept of safety through intimidation. Speed has very little to do with it, unfortunately.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoWell, we do this with passenger trains as well. American trains share track with with heavy freight trains (and might collide with), and so are built to much different standards than European passenger trains that have dedicated tracks (or new exclusive use while they are running).
- usrusr 5y agoThe German rail system is also built with the assumption of tracks being shared by passenger and freight trains, with very few exceptions. Trains are generally not really designed to collide with anything at all (except maybe the occasional suicidal deer or human, but I doubt that this requires any particular design considerations), certainly not "train A is only designed to deal with stray passenger cars whereas train B should be able to deal with heavy freight". What might be a design issue, more for the network and operation procedures than for the rolling stock is confidence about not meeting anything like a stray car. Different approaches exist, including train-side boxes on the last car or axle counters in the network.
- jmcmaster 5y agoI suspect if you threw away all preconceived notions of local mobility and started with maximizing {effectiveness/efficiency/carbon/infrastructure costs/real estate/ healthcare/economic benefit/commute times/ opportunity costs} rather than an individual car you would end up with rapid on demand transit (think publicly funded ride-share minivans, light rail, bus rapid transit, autonomous golf carts, e-bikes and biking infrastructure) for moving people by default. Beyond that, you'd also see 15 minute neighborhoods where essentials are all walkable, and remote work for many commuters. Networked local mobility, denser mixed use planning, and hybrid work all do better at some of the same jobs that cars do today. Electric cars seem more about saving the car industry ecosystem, under the guise of saving the planet. I recognize a valid counterpoint is that because we already have car infrastructure* BEVs are a drop-in replacement culturally and physically where transit, urban planning, and remote work all require more systemic change and have long timelines and NIMBYism. Electric vehicles also make sense in most fleet situations (delivery, school buses, trucking). The backwards-compatability argument makes sense in the short term, but misses the sort of step change needed to recalibrate western lifestyles to become both resilient and sustainable. In the end, while BEVs are better than gasoline cars, and they may provide a stepping stone, the real investments must go well beyond the default individual car ownership model--to considering designing the best local mobility experience as a network and services rather than a thing parked in your drive. This is where user experience and service design can make a profound climate impact, in creating better, more desirable mobility experiences as alternatives to car ownership. Acronyms: BEV = Battery Electric Vehicle = electric car NIMBYism - Not In My Backyard-ism. The tendency of property owners to push against urban densification, rapid transit, and similar efforts in their neighborhoods.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I suspect if you threw away all preconceived notions of local mobility and started with maximizing {effectiveness/efficiency/carbon/infrastructure costs/real estate/ healthcare/economic benefit/commute times/ opportunity costs} rather than an individual car you would end up with rapid on demand transit (think publicly funded ride-share minivans, light rail, bus rapid transit, autonomous golf carts, e-bikes and biking infrastructure) for moving people by default. Beyond that, you'd also see 15 minute neighborhoods where essentials are all walkable, and remote work for many commuters. Networked local mobility, denser mixed use planning, and hybrid work all do better at some of the same jobs that cars do today. Yeah, sure, you'd see a lot of public transport in dense areas. However I disagree that the population would all be housed in dense housing. The only reason dense centers exist is because its walkable, bikable, etc. People who don't want to live in dense areas would still exist in significant enough numbers that the automobile as we know it would still exist. Densification occurred prior to the automobile; it was not sufficient to prevent the invention of the automobile as we know it.