4 ms·
All insider trading should be legal. Imagine the opposite case. You know your company is doing poorly but the government forces you to not sell your stock and t
by charcircuit 5y ago
All insider trading should be legal. Imagine the opposite case. You know your company is doing poorly but the government forces you to not sell your stock and take a loss.
- sp332 5y agoIt's only illegal if you're using secret information. The company can't report info to some shareholders and not others.
- charcircuit 5y agoIn my example the company is not reporting to any shareholders. You are doing trades based off of information that you have collected yourself.
- sp332 5y ago-
- notch656a 5y ago>If you're using information anyone could get with some research, then it's not illegal. If I am willing to give out information gained during employment of the company to anyone asking as part of their research, then by this definition it's not illegal, as anyone can get the information with some research.
- ethbr0 5y agoSee fair disclosure requirements https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/fair-disclosure-regulation-fd https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-ba...
- notch656a 5y agoAt best that would only require you to disclose to everyone once asked by someone performing some research, or through the outlined regulation FD mechanisms. It still holds that using your own definition, all it takes is some research to gain what the employee who is willing to give up information knows, and that giving up the information can be done in a way that avoids violating regulation FD.
- ethbr0 5y agoIf you want to play chicken with the SEC like they're a D&D DM you're rules lawyering, be my guest. Because while they may not prosecute often, I'd still rather stay off their radar.
- charcircuit 5y ago>If you're using information anyone could get with some research, then it's not illegal. Then why were these engineers being charged? They used a role which very likely was open to anyone in the public to apply to do research into the performance of the company.
- sneak 5y agoNo, it's only illegal if you are using secret information accessed with privileged insider access. If you do research and deduce nonpublic (secret) data and use that, that is fine. The classic example is inferring sales data from customer traffic by observing the parking lot utilization at regular intervals.
- kasey_junk 5y agoThis is an American interpretation of insider trading laws which are very much not about keeping markets fair rather they are about preventing shareholders (or those working on their behalf) from stealing from other shareholders. Other jurisdictions have different presumptions about what insider trading laws are for and may thus interpret them in different ways. This was a US jurisdiction filing so the former standard applies but on an international message board it’s worth remembering people have different intuitions about this stuff for good reason.
- nullc 5y agoI'm curious if there are places where monitoring how busy business parking lots and trading on your analysis would be unlawful insider trading?
- syshum 5y agoif you are in the position of knowing secret data of a publicly traded company, and you are uncomfortable with the position of possibly losing money because you can not act on the secret data, I would suggest you not hold stock for companies you know secret data about No insider trading should not be legal
- derekp7 5y agoSomething I was always curious about, but I lack the legal background to find the answer. What if public information showed that you should sell the stock, but you decide to hold it instead (i.e., not do anything at all) because you have insider information that the company will be doing much better than expected? The "not selling" part (assuming you bought stock prior to having insider knowledge) is a form of insider trading, but I can't see how that could be enforced (i.e., how would the SEC be able to prove that you would have sold if you didn't have that positive insider knowledge?)
- smegma2 5y agoNot a lawyer but holding should always be fine. No trading is happening therefore it's not insider trading.
- usrusr 5y agoOr more to the point: insider trading isn't quite as victimless as some people might like to believe. The only victim "insider holding" could have would be people betting against a trend caused by public information (who would win even more if the "insider holder" would sell with the herd), either out of pure gambling desire or because their trades are insider trades. Neither seems particularly worthy of protection.
- syshum 5y agonot a lawyer, but inaction should never be criminalized.
- 5y ago
- rossdavidh 5y agoIn those countries where insider trading is either explicitly allowed or laws against it are never enforced, nobody without inside information wants to play, because they know the game is rigged.
- vmception 5y agoYeah? Any analysis I can read on that? Its kind of low hanging since the US has such high trading volumes far beyond every other market, but I cant accept that as causation alone.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- decebalus1 5y agoAs opposed to the game being always rigged but without everyone knowing... just the insiders.
- rossdavidh 5y agoTruth.