11 ms·
Crime scene investigators learn to dowse for the dead
- spacemanmatt 5y agoSounds like another way for cops to launder illegally obtained information.
- scanny 5y agoI wonder how something like this would hold up in a court case though, surely it would be torn to shreds?
- ceejayoz 5y ago> In particular, some experts are distressed that a Vass trainee recently got witching results admitted as evidence in a Georgia murder trial. As with most of these bits of pseudoscience, it's a probable cause generator. > Vass tells him it’s about a quarter mile. “The advantage of this is you don’t have to be on a property to scan it,” he says. “You can be on a public street and scan your suspect’s yard.” Oh, and while it can magically find missing people "as far as 75 miles" away, you can't get one. > One student asks, “Do you mean if you have a missing child, you can take that child’s DNA and put it in that and go to work?” > “Yeah, absolutely,” Vass says. “It doesn’t take long to find them.” > “How much does one of those things cost?” another student asks. “I’ll write a check right now.” > “I’m not selling them right now,” Vass says. “I’m just kind of assisting law enforcement when needed.” He says the device isn’t for sale because he’s concerned about national security issues. “I can tell you what room the president’s in in the White House,” he says. “ I can tell you which house has gold in it.” And, if it doesn't work when Vass is doing it, it's because a mouse died there. (Which probably describes... everywhere.) > With the excavation complete, Vass wants to discuss one last thing: the divining rods. “From the holes, it appeared to me that maybe an animal had burrowed down in there,” he tells Ponce. “If an animal like a little mouse died there, you’ll get a false positive. So just pay attention to that in the future.”
- spacemanmatt 5y agoCourts are shockingly slow to adopt the conclusions of science, especially when such conclusions would have wide-ranging exclusionary effects on rules of evidence. For more background, search for scandals related to FBI "bite mark" experts or disgraced former Texas detective Tom Coleman.
- LanceH 5y agoCourts work on procedure and appeal to authority, not science. Hopefully there is an overlap, but it's not required. Diligent application of appeal to authority by the more well funded party results in better outcomes.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoScience basically has to enter courts through consensus, which means only the most sensational and visible conclusions of science will reach the legal system. Seems like a bit of a bottleneck for a developing civilization.
- elliekelly 5y agoAnd shockingly slow to accept that the pseudoscience they’ve been allowing is bunk. See, e.g., shaken baby syndrome, and fire burn patterns supposedly indicative of arson. Heck, we’ve even know for years that breathalyzers are crazy unreliable and yet we constantly convict people based on the reading.
- GaelFG 5y agoI would assume because the technic is absurd but it was not important during the trial. The important fact was they did find a human corpse where they were looking. You probably need to say how you found the corpse, if was probably labelled 'vaguely' like 'using the technic "n#13" teached by the National Forensic Academy'and I assume no one really looked at it. (or they did but didn't care because they did'n wanted the culprit to get away with having a corpse in his backgarden or wathever happened. Total speculation of course.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoIt is an open invitation to "parallel construction" which is a practice the government is already 100% known to use.
- josefx 5y agoThey will get an "expert" with 40 hours of training to vouch for it. There are quite a few pseudo sciences in use that either have little to no proof or have been outright shown to be wrong most of the time. I think the supreme court even found that lie detector tests are barely above flipping a coin and still left their use up to other courts. Facts don't matter, legal concepts do.
- lupire 5y agoPolygraph data is almost never allowed in court without the consent of the victim/examinee. But it is often a permitted investigative/intimidation tactic.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI don't think they should even be permitted for that, it's essentially preying on society at large's poor knowledge of science to falsely present polygraphs as something they're not. They're in the same category of woo as dowsing rods and earthed bedsheets, I think it's unreasonable for them to be used in any official context.
- jusssi 5y agoSurely a "random person walking their dog near the site by chance" would be much more plausible for that purpose.
- elliekelly 5y agoBut you can only use that excuse so many times before it becomes oddly suspicious.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoThey can't overtly communicate to large groups of officers that they should just make something up (e.g. dog walker) but directing the crowd to place trust in something which is verifiable nonsense gives them the cover of conventional wisdom.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dicroce 5y agoThe guy who dug the water well on my parents land used a dowsing rod. Interestingly, he chose to use the dowsing rod in the lowest point of the meadow... which probably saved him a few feet of drilling.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoi have heard a personal experience of a family member who says he saw the event himself so i kinda have to understand it can be something: "people were digging for water on a road because there was a pipe leak somewhere and it needed to be plugged. so here were bunch of men having dug an entire road section but nothing. this guy comes up. says to wait. he then holds rods (assuming dowsing rods) and says "here. dig here" and there was water there. it can be a fluke but these men were tired and suddenly there was excitement.
- Boltgolt 5y agoThe thing is that you don't know how often that guy has been wrong.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agono i dont know and i am not making any assumptions based on my single anecdotal evidence. i am saying, i know someone who can attest to seeing this pheonomeon. thats all. nothing more than that
- lupire 5y agoYeah everyone knows someone who knows someone who saw it.
- staticassertion 5y agok but why even bother saying that? A friend of yours heard a story about a guy who did a thing. Repeating it is a distraction at best.
- 5y ago
- hacktavist24 5y ago> “You can be on a public street and scan your suspect’s yard.” Well, if that ain't a great way to manufacture a warrant. What exactly is wrong with cadaver dogs, anyway? I'm guessing it's that cadaver dogs actually work on scientific principles. (Edit: dogs also can't smell a body from across the street. At least, I don't think they can.)
- lupire 5y agoAlert dogs respond to handler signals and are used to fabricate probable cause, much like witching.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThere should be a discouraging compensation paid to the suspect if their property is searched and nothing found. An "apologies for your trouble / time", and of course a hearty compensation for any damage done.
- AlexandrB 5y agoPaid by whom? In cases of police getting sued after a wrongful death, the municipality typically pays the bill. The police budget is unaffected. In such a system there's little incentive for police departments to be careful with which property they search, even if the owner is compensated.
- MPSimmons 5y ago>The police budget is unaffected I would have to imagine that after several such incidents, the police budget would begin to be affected.
- 0des 5y agoThat would be gamed in a heartbeat.
- 5y ago
- sneak 5y agoThere really needs to be an intersection between law and science/reason, just a few solid touchpoints. There need to be statutes that define a logical basis for what we do and do not, as a society with a legal system, believe to be true. It really feels like the American society (now including the courts apparently) is losing its relationship with objective reality and any semblance of a shared set of ground truth facts. Things have been trending that way for a long while, but it really feels like the Orwellian knob has been jacked up an order of magnitude in the last 24 months. If we can't agree on some basic rules about what is or is not true about fundamental reality, why even bother having courts or trials to determine higher level truths? A trial about the outcomes of magical/nonsensical processes is meaningless. This stuff obviously shouldn't make it into the courtroom. The fact that it has means the system is broken, even if these particular people stop peddling this particular bullshit.
- zorked 5y agoNot a recent thing, if anything things are getting better over time, just slowly. I remember reading stuff about how "forensic science" has been the realm of quackery for as long as I have known how to read. Police are incentivised to find whatever thingamajig will support their conclusions. Courts are not equipped to provide meta-review of every forensic claim. And for the bright, rational, scientific minds out there, working in forensics is relatively low-prestige and low-pay.
- JackFr 5y agoThe fact that this was ever used in a courtroom is disturbing, but before we start collectively clutching our pearls, remember that authors are selling clicks, and it us the nature of articles like these to overstate the problem. I am less concerned by the obvious nonsense like this, than I am about the far more dangerous nonsense that comes from legit, credentialed, FBI-endorsed “scientists” which a rational, informed, well intentioned judge or juror might give serious weight, (like bite marks, blood splatter, profiling, etc.)
- NateEag 5y ago> There need to be statutes that define a logical basis for what we do and do not, as a society with a legal system, believe to be true. Laws don't define that, though. Wanting everyone to approach the world with a scientific, evidence-based mindset doesn't mean they do. We can't legislate belief any more than we can legislate the value of pi.
- adenozine 5y agoI saw a movie where they used a device to make a forceful impact in the ground, and there were probes staked in the ground that imaged underground based on the acoustics. It was an alien movie, so I’m not hopeful, but is there not technology like that being worked on? Sonar for underground?
- foxFather81 5y agoDidn't they do something like that in the beginning of (ok, scifi) Jurassic Park as well?
- dTal 5y agoYes, although the script incorrectly calls it "radar". And needless to say it was not a realistic depiction of the technology or its capabilities.
- ceejayoz 5y agoYes, we have that. You have to already know roughly where you want to look, though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-penetrating_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-penetrating_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seismic_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seismic_source
- doctor_eval 5y agoDo you mean a seismic survey? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflection_seismology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflection_seismology
- RicoElectrico 5y agoAnd Polish police did use some help of clairvoyants, as news reported in the past. https://www.polityka.pl/jamyoni/1727668,1,czy-jasnowidz-moze-pomoc-policji.read https://www.polityka.pl/jamyoni/1727668,1,czy-jasnowidz-moze... https://wiadomosci.onet.pl/tylko-w-onecie/jasnowidze-w-sluzbie-policji/7ppmnck https://wiadomosci.onet.pl/tylko-w-onecie/jasnowidze-w-sluzb...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 0des 5y agoAmerican police use psychics too.
- giorgioz 5y agoI recommend the book Paranormality from Richard Wiseman: https://www.amazon.com/Paranormality-Why-what-isnt-there/dp/0956875653 https://www.amazon.com/Paranormality-Why-what-isnt-there/dp/... Essentially if any of these powers were true, they could be reproduced in a scientific experiment and then reversed engineer on why they actually work. There is even a foundation with 1 million dollar price for whoever proves to have paranormal abilities. No-one has ever been able to prove scientifically to have paranormal power and won the prize for decades.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI mean the one with the sticks should be really easy to study scientifically, just have a group of diviners with no prior knowledge of an area find the corpses or water or whichever. Simple to do, statistically sound, etc. That said, I wouldn't use water as an example; I'm no geologist but I'm fairly sure you'll find water in most places if you dig deep enough, there's not going to be underground rivers that are very location specific for which you need divining so much.
- Geezus-42 5y agoThey have done statistical analysis on diving for water and it didn't go well for the diviners, so of course they made up a bunch of excuses.
- BrandoElFollito 5y agoThe tests that were done were with pipes buried in an area. The 'divinators' (I do not know how they are called in English, the ones that find water with a stick) agreed that the test is fair. They did not find anything that wild be above statistically expected results. I will add a source if I find it, but it is at least 20 years old
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- matthewdgreen 5y ago
- cainxinth 5y agoPolice forensics is rife with pseudoscience: https://bostonreview.net/articles/nathan-robinson-forensic-pseudoscience-criminal-justice/ https://bostonreview.net/articles/nathan-robinson-forensic-p...
- shp0ngle 5y agoWitcher Sense is a good ability though
- white_dragon88 5y agoAs an Australian…. What in the hell is this? Dowsing rod evidence being admissible in court? I can’t even believe it’s a suggestion let alone someone with authority in a school who would teach this. Where is liability here? Where are the watchdogs or regulators?
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoThis isn’t just in America. I googled “Australia bite mark analysis” and it looks like cops are using bunk science in Australia too.
- justinclift 5y agoWait until the next free trade agreement has America pushing on the other participant as well. Same as they've been doing for their other bunk (copyright & patent rules, etc). ;)
- evancoop 5y agoThe subtitle of this article should read, "when science is performed irresponsibly, pseudoscience is treated like science." Academia has a reproducibility crisis. Forensics has endured its own struggle with credibility. The media is undergoing similar scrutiny. When that which is expected to be trustworthy is proved unreliable, then how does society distinguish between that which is unreliable in design (e.g. dowsing) and that which is unreliable in execution (e.g. academic publications)?
- AlexandrB 5y ago> Academia has a reproducibility crisis. Isn't that largely isolated to psychology and related "soft" sciences? I have not heard of a physics or chemistry reproducibility crisis. Not to mention that dowsing violates basic physics/chemistry that predate any "reproducibility crisis". You may be right though that people trust science less. This is really funny considering how much science (that has to work) underpins something like an iPhone.
- deadbeeves 5y agoYes, the reproducibility crisis affects just about all disciplines. When researchers are pressured to aim for impact and citations in their publications that doesn't leave room to reproduce other people's results. So as you say in the soft sciences we have that results are failing to reproduce, but in the hard sciences we have results that we don't know if they would reproduce or not, because no one has attempted it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Malic 5y agoThis... this is a Monty Python sketch. (facepalm) https://montypython.fandom.com/wiki/Probe-Around_on_Crime https://montypython.fandom.com/wiki/Probe-Around_on_Crime
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWhat else do you expect when you have IQ tests to prevent anyone that's too smart from being a cop?
- hackernewds 5y agoMind elaborating?
- Deukhoofd 5y agohttps://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/st...
- lalopalota 5y agohttps://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/st... "... on the theory that those who scored too high could get bored with police work and leave soon after undergoing costly training."
- danShumway 5y ago> One student asks, “What’s the distance?” > Vass tells him it’s about a quarter mile. “The advantage of this is you don’t have to be on a property to scan it,” he says. “You can be on a public street and scan your suspect’s yard.” So this guy is claiming he can track someone in a closed house from room to room from a pretty reasonable distance away. Ignoring the more obvious problem that this isn't true, if it were true would this require a warrant? I guess it might depend partially on the mechanism of how it works? Which is of course convenient since there is no formally defined mechanism of how it works. But it's funny to me that the way that the police are getting around needing a warrant is to say, "oh, it's fine, we had probable cause because someone magically invaded your privacy on our behalf." It's a bit like saying, "we have probable cause to search your house because we heard you say something suspicious after we bugged it."
- ceejayoz 5y ago> if it were true would this require a warrant? Almost certainly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyllo_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyllo_v._United_States
- gumby 5y agoApparently dowsing is still used in California's Central Valley to determine where to drill wells (the valley sits on top of an aquifer, though it is being drawn down unsustainably). I asked a farmer about this and he said that yes, he uses a "witcher" and that they are good at finding water though they can't tell you how deep (!!). Of course I assumed he was pulling my leg but I later encountered someone on that property wielding a coat hanger to tell this same farmer where to drill.
- ceejayoz 5y agoKinda like promising your dowsing rod can find books in the library. Well, yeah... (I'd bet there are surface features that give hints to the underlying hydrology, too.)
- gumby 5y ago> (I'd bet there are surface features that give hints to the underlying hydrology, too.) Hard to imagine but I’m no geologist. But the vally sits atop an aquifer so if you’re willing to drill arbitrarily deep you’re pretty much certain to hit water. Thus I find the refusal to specify depth hilarious.
- ceejayoz 5y agoCertain types of strata absorb water, and certain kinds don't. Locations of water sources, slopes, etc. will all matter. Some of these things will hint on the surface at what lies below.
- gumby 5y agoI think the deepest people drill is not much more than 300 ft (still takes a lot of energy to raise a head of water) so maybe you’re right. It doesn’t seem that deep in geological terms so seeing traces on the surface is plausible to me(but again, I’m no geologist). Fun to think about.
- watmough 5y ago
- exabrial 5y agoUnless proven scientifically, it's a way to falsify evidence.
- MPSimmons 5y agowow.