3 ms·
>Kinect => It's not dead ??? Is it alive? It very much has an immensely passionate community of students and hobbyists using it in ways well past its intended
by johnnyanmac 5y ago
>Kinect => It's not dead ???
Is it alive? It very much has an immensely passionate community of students and hobbyists using it in ways well past its intended use (e.g. it's some of the cheapest mocap hardware you can buy). But I don't think you've been able to officially purchase one for 4+ years now. Hard to call that "alive" in a business sense.
Honestly a real shame that Xbox hasn't pivoted it into some other team that can market it towards creators. In particular the whole "VTuber" phenomenon may benefit form a cheap(ish), dedicated motion tracking device instead of relying on a high end iPhone or fanagling with some generic webcam.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThere isn’t much money in selling to creators? And the niche the Kinect had with active gaming has been reliably filled by Meta/Facebook/oculus’s quest, it’s too bad Microsoft didn’t explore that more deeply.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoLikely not, not in its current form. I wouldn't be surprised if in 2010 that Kinect was being sold at a significant loss (as is the usual trend in the games industry). They'd need to tweak the device quite a bit to be B2B, but given the success of game engines, asset packs, and other tools I don't think it's impossible. Creators will absolutely pay a premium for such tech when the alternative goes for thousands of dollars (a quick google shows these devices selling on the order of 2000 to 7000+ USD). The SDK alone would generate much more value for such a product. VR definitely killed any interest in the "core" gaming market, but I think the uses of motion tracking is a completely separate audience from VR anyway. Without some dedicated apparel, a VR kit can only track your eyes and hands. motion tracking gives you so much more data to work with, for potentially multiple subjects as well. People working with that data will easily pay themselves back with whatever they develop with it, which is why maybe a licensing deal (similar to Unity/Unreal Engine) may be a better way to monetize .
- freeone3000 5y agoYou're describing the Azure Kinect, which does exist and you can buy.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoYes, someone else pointed it out to me. Thanks, it oddly doesn't show up at all when merely searching "kinect", so maybe that's my search engine bias's fault for being gaming skewed.
- jannes 5y agoThere are still games coming out with Kinect support (Just Dance 2022)
- ipaddr 5y agoThere are still games coming out for the c64.
- ______-_-______ 5y agoI'd call it dead I guess, but I don't see why that's a problem. It's a physical product, you can't keep manufacturing those forever. They supported it until the next generation of consoles came out. Would it be fair to make a site called "Killed by Nintendo" and list the Game Boy and Wii?
- User23 5y agoYes. They could release the specs if they wanted to. They choose not to so they're, at the very least, letting it die. I'm not offering judgment on whether they ought or ought not to, I'm merely observing that they have power and are exercising it as they choose.
- vanderZwan 5y agoAlso, it's still being sold as a product to the one market where it really was popular (researchers and hobby enthusiasts). That's not quite the same thing as being dead.
- chrisdirkis 5y agoThe Azure Kinect was released as a successor for the research and business applications[1]. I know one roboticist who has used one, but no one aside from that. Definitely dead as a consumer gaming device, but a product evolving towards a discovered usecase is a surprisingly happy outcome from MS. [1] https://azure.microsoft.com/en-au/services/kinect-dk/ https://azure.microsoft.com/en-au/services/kinect-dk/
- Aissen 5y agoThe page says "Call to order", which is quite a bit different from a publicly available product.
- CactusOnFire 5y agoWhen I saw "Killed by google" I came out of it with a general sentiment about how google can't commit to a specific roadmap. After seeing this site and then the comments here, I am coming out of this with the general sentiment that Microsoft is genuinely thoughtful about addressing end-of-life products.
- abandonliberty 5y agoGoogle is experimental. We're both the product and research subjects, not customers, for their free offerings. Their transition into the paid/enterprise space is very interesting. I'm very excited for them to find a non-advertising revenue stream, as it could help Google to stop being evil. They're still a very amazing company. However, their approach providing free services is a bit subpar. I've ran into so many table-stake bugs that simply don't exist in MSFT offerings (e.g. copy/paste between Google office applications often breaks formatting). Thanks to our mid-size enterprise contract, I can get someone to tell me that not enough people are complaining about it for them to fix it. Meanwhile, from asking my teams at work, everyone struggles with lack of polish across their applications.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoahh, thank you. I couldn't find any products when simply searching "kinect". Glad they actually did pivot the product. Really nice price too, while being (based on a bit of research) much more powerful than the old Kinect.
- russellbeattie 5y agoI think Kinect's technology of projecting infrared dots to figure out depth has been surpassed by better stereoscopic vision and lidar. I think. For example I know that Intel has a $400 desktop stereo camera and a $600 lidar puck which would definitely be the way I'd go nowadays for any projects. Kinect also had the body skeleton stuff built in, but you literally can get a JavaScript Open CV script to do that now. https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-technology/realsense-overview.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-tec...
- jamesfinlayson 5y agoI've seen Kinects used at an airport for scanning luggage size.
- darkcha0s 5y agoI don't really get it, it's just a product that has gone off the shelf. The xbox 360 isn't 'dead' it's just no longer sold. I don't think the kinect is any different in that sense, seeing as no new games use it.