6 ms·
Legal Scholars Are Shocked by Ginni Thomas’s “Stop the Steal” Texts
- duxup 5y agoI’m skeptical of Thomas, a lot. But I’m wary of holding him at all responsible for his spouse’s opinions. I would not want to be held responsible for my spouses opinions.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoHolding him responsible, no. Demanding he recuse himself: yes. His vote after a failure to recuse on a key judgement now looks extremely suspect, and he should be recusing himself not just to avoid a conflict of interest, but to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest. Failing to recuse himself has really caused him a level of reputational damage that non-lifetime appointees would not survive. Kind of a cosmic irony to me that after years of being the Supreme Court's most reliably banal, consistently aligned judge after a confirmation hearing where he was accused of sexual misdeeds, it's his long-suffering wife who might bring him down.
- sokoloff 5y agoHis wife is not responsible for his failure to recuse himself.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoThis is a very fair point and I have no idea why someone downvoted you for it.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoThe way downvoting works here is like a kind of silent geek bitchiness I will never understand. Grow some stones and say it out loud. This criticism of my point is legitimate. Ginni Thomas is responsible for her communications with Meadows, but she is clearly not responsible for Clarence Thomas failing to recuse himself. That is indeed all on him.
- usernomdeguerre 5y agoTo me it already seems like he has broken that appearance, from the article: "This January, Clarence Thomas was the sole dissenter in a proceeding in which Trump asked the Court to stop the House investigative committee from obtaining records of his communications relating to efforts to subvert the 2020 election results."
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoYes -- that's the one I am referring to. This is one of those things that, had it not occurred in the aftermath of more than four of the most norm-crushing, aberrant years in the history of the western world, could have brought down even the most popular person. (This sentence applies equally well to things that have happened here in the UK in the last few months, and in both cases the problem is the same -- a polarised system where one side has got used to constantly acting in performative bad faith.)
- bediger4000 5y agoThere have been a lot of articles about Thomas' conflicts of interest, even before the Trump admin. Ginni Thomas lobbied against the ACA: https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/142969-democrats-justice-thomas-should-recuse-himself-in-healthcare-reform-case?page=2 https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/142969-dem... That's a pretty distinct conflict of interest. It may not be illegal, or even against the rules, because the US Supreme Court is a unique body, but really? Seriously? Thomas should have recused himself on a lot of issues if his wife makes money lobbying one way or the other.
- gmoore 5y agoDo you believe he was aware ofher activities? For decades the two have bragged about knowing everything about the other, thinking with one mind, etc. You see no conflict in a Supreme Court Justice, being aware of a plot to overthrow the government and doing nothing?
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago> You see no conflict in a Supreme Court Justice, being aware of a plot to overthrow the government and doing nothing? I have no idea how you get the impression I see no conflict. The point is that even the appearance of the conflict ought to be enough to finish his career. It doesn't make him literally responsible for her actions, of course, if that is the point you're making.
- throw_away 5y agoIt's not just being held responsible for one's spouse's opinions (much less actions)— at least one of his own past judicial decisions now seems quite questionable in light of this: https://www.businessinsider.com/clarence-thomas-only-justice-dissent-in-trump-january-6-bid-2022-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/clarence-thomas-only-justice...
- aeturnum 5y agoHe's not responsible for her actions, but he should certainly recuse himself from cases before the court that pertain to the legal status of her actions. Like...if judges don't have an ethical responsibility to avoid ruling on cases that might impact their immediate family...what ethical responsibility to they have?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoIf he were a mail carrier? sure what damage could that do, but he’s a lifelong appointment to one of the highest positions in the country… and it also happens to be a role where conflicts of interest could impact the entire country. There are plenty of other well-qualified judges without this particular problem, and it’s absurd that he won’t recuse himself from issues his wife actively campaigns for (though not surprising given his own dodgy history).
- penneyd 5y agoDid you not read the article? Justices are subject to a federal law that prohibits them from hearing cases in which their spouses have “an interest that could be substantially affected by the outcome of the proceeding.” The statute, 28 U.S.C. section 455, also requires them to disqualify themselves from any proceedings in which their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned.” How can you argue this isn't applicable?
- mypalmike 5y agoThey clearly did not read the article. None of the top level posters defending Thomas did. There's really no point in engaging with such bad faith "arguments".
- tablespoon 5y ago>> Justices are subject to a federal law that prohibits them from hearing cases in which their spouses have “an interest that could be substantially affected by the outcome of the proceeding.” The statute, 28 U.S.C. section 455, also requires them to disqualify themselves from any proceedings in which their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned.” > How can you argue this isn't applicable? It really hinges on how exactly "interest" is defined, and if it's so broad to cover a desire to see/advocacy for certain political outcomes. Should a liberal judge recuse themselves from all abortion cases because their spouse made a donation to Planned Parenthood or wrote letters to their representatives advocating against some anti-abortion law that may come before the court?
- markoman 5y agoHow does making donations to a charitable activity constitute an interest? On the other hand, Mrs. Thomas was coordinating with POTUS's Chief of Staff Meadows in illegal activity (a coup attempt) that her husband may likely have to decide on later. Further, her activity has the appearance that she was funneling legal advice (or legal coordination) from her husband and to Meadows. These acts (of hers) call for her husband's recusal at a minimum, but SCOTUS justices conveniently aren't ethically accountable to anyone and so it is enforceable only by impeachment. However, impeachment of a judge won't require a 2/3's majority.
- jzb 5y agoOpinions is a very mild way of saying “attempt to overthrow the government.” Let’s not sugar coat this. She wasn’t taking a side on this or that issue where Justice Thomas might have to vote. She was trying to overthrow the government and he’s tasked with protecting it. He either needs to get divorced or get off the Court. And he’s already ruled on a case where there’s direct conflict of interest between his spouse and country - and choose spouse.
- trothamel 5y agoIn your opinion, where's the line between "petitioning the government for a redress of grievances", and "attempt to overthrow the government"?
- quantified 5y agoIf the congresscritters had any balls and stayed in chambers to confront the crowd, we’d be a lot more clear as to whether this was “petitioning by motley fools” or “violent insurrection”. As it is, they made it easy to claim it was nothing more than hijinks in the chambers.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoSeems like "balls" would be a counter-evolutionary trait. Avoiding mobs is like, survival 101.
- quantified 5y agoThat’s why no one remembers Tiananmen Square tank guy, right?
- mcphage 5y agoYeah, maybe it was a fun mob!
- quantified 5y ago
- spacemanmatt 5y agoWhen you are a Supreme Court justice, we stop pretending like their spouse's opinion is not relevant. It's relevant.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoarchive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/20220326040214/https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/legal-scholars-are-shocked-by-ginni-thomass-stop-the-steal-texts https://web.archive.org/web/20220326040214/https://www.newyo...
- cagenut 5y agoanyone "shocked" is telling you more about how loudly they've been humming with their fingers in their ears for years now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- duxup 5y agoOpinions are one thing. Involvement with administration/ the scale seems new.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoIt's new if you have been humming with your fingers in your ears.
- duxup 5y agoThe text messages are new.
- happytoexplain 5y agoShock/outrage does not necessitate logical surprise nor ignorance. The two categories of emotion are constantly conflated for the purpose of criticizing people for tangential reasons (e.g. their politics).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- logicalmonster 5y ago
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago
- compsciphd 5y agoyou're right, but for jan 6 cases that come before the supreme court, does he have a conflict of interests? or he has 0 interests in his wife's doings? (even if say her texts are part of the evidence?).
- throw_a_grenade 5y ago> I’m no biologist, so I might be wrong about that though. Yeah, it's almost as if you should prepare to be corrected by verified Twitter accounts.
- sydthrowaway 5y ago
- gfodor 5y agoShould judges be forced to recuse cases based entirely on the political activity of their spouse? Everyone supporting this seems to be saying “yes.” I guess we should apply that consistently then? Does it end at spouses, or extend to children and parents?
- penneyd 5y ago"Justices are subject to a federal law that prohibits them from hearing cases in which their spouses have “an interest that could be substantially affected by the outcome of the proceeding.” The statute, 28 U.S.C. section 455, also requires them to disqualify themselves from any proceedings in which their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned.”
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoNo, people are not saying judges should recuse because of the political activity of their spouse. If that was the standard he should have recused himself much earlier because she's always been a) crackers and b) extremely political. Everyone's always known it; it's never been that much of an issue. This is not about politics, it's about a serious conflict of interest. Ginni Thomas actively pushed the executive branch to illegally overturn the presidential election, and Clarence Thomas had to rule on decisions that could expose that. That's not politics, it's potential criminal exposure for one or both of them, depending on what she did.
- mypalmike 5y agoShe is a party to the suit. It's not complicated.
- quantified 5y agoIf their business is politics, yes. Same as if their business is coal, cannabis, HR, media, airlines, whatever.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoExactly, yes (except this should only apply to spouses). The point is to not put judges into a position where they might have to choose between the spouse and the law. No one should have to wonder which way they chose. It's nothing to do with the political persuasion of the spouse, only to do with not putting judges into that position.
- politician 5y ago
- bigtex 5y agoYou are getting downvoted but your response is accurate. Hunter Biden’s dealings with Ukraine didn’t matter because he was a private citizen but the opinion of a judges wife matter because politics.
- quantified 5y agoWhat’s the sword, exactly?
- kgwxd 5y agoThis has nothing to do with husbands and wives, only judges and spouses.
- tablespoon 5y ago>> On the one hand, husbands are not allowed to tell their wives what to do on a whole host of issues sensitive to the progressive left. > This has nothing to do with husbands and wives, only judges and spouses. OK then. So should a judge be able to tell his spouse what to do? This idea that Thomas should recuse himself because of his wife's political activity raises some interesting questions. Like does marrying a judge de-facto remove political rights from their spouse, or what happens in a Kellyanne Conway/George Conway situation, where the spouses have opposite views. Could one spouse weaponize the relationship to tip the balance in some important case?
- orwin 5y agoI don't know how US courts work, but can't he recuse himself only on the subjects his wife work on? It's like standard procedure in my country.
- gmoore 5y agowhy is anyone surprised - she's been like this for her entire career....pletny has been writen about it.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoPlease don’t hold me responsible for my wife’s actions. I have no control over her.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoNo one is holding him responsible for her actions. He should recuse himself to avoid the appearance of impropriety, and that's what most of the conversation is about. It's hardly controversial, but there are lots of commenters who think somehow Clarence Thomas is being or can be punished for anything to do with this.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoThen if he’s not responsible then he doesn’t have to recuse himself. It doesn’t quite work that way. If that were the case, then maybe we need to start monitoring the text messages of the families of the other justices. Just so we’re sure when they need to recuse them selves we can tell them.
- Ekaros 5y agoI'm actually starting to think that absolutely all communication by elected and public officials should be made automatically public and should not be hidden for any reasons.
- stevenalowe 5y agoseriously? is Ginni Thomas expected to face any charges over this? i see no crime, only emotion If Justice Thomas had texted this, perhaps there might be grounds for recusing him (but even then probably not - activist opinions are protected speech). Ginni's actions are of no consequence/relevance.
- kthejoker2 5y ago"Caesar's wife must be above suspicion" - Caesar (apocryphal?) In a neutral world, this would be easy grounds for removal. There are only 9 lifetime positions on the Supreme Court, an institution dedicated to impartiality, fairness and justice. There's simply no room for this impropriety. Replace him with a conservative even! It's not about his judicial philosophy at all. The Supreme Court needs every quiver in its pack to seem immune to modern day political realities. This is literally about as far from that as you can possibly get.