12 ms·
The Shaming-Industrial Complex
- hunglee2 5y agoShame is a powerful moderator of behaviour considered marginal or taboo in society, likely it forms an essential role in group cohesion. However, it may well be maladaptive at the scale of global society, where the mechanisms of shame - the 'calling out' of transgressors, the dogpiling that ensues following a successful call out - are chaotic, following no process or moderation itself. The inevitable result is self censorship, in order to mitigate risk, leading to the decline of the health of public discourse, and emergence of a 'self-police state' by stealth
- jsnk 5y agoIt's maladaptive for some, but also effective for some others. It can be wielded as a weapon to destroy one's competition and enemies. It works especially well against whichever group of population that has more tendency to self-reflect and have capacity to feel shame. Whereas if a population doesn't feel shame or less shame or construct the standard so that the shaming only applies to one group but not the other, it can thrive in this kind of environment.
- hunglee2 5y agoyes quite right, it even seems to be the case that being entirely shameless is a political advantage in a representative democratic system. Trump, Johnson, Bolsonaro, Modi - distinct politicians but all share the common theme of being able to avoid the penalty of shame but being conspicuously shameless
- KarlKemp 5y agoThat’s the kind of reasoning people want to be true, as in „I’m not lazy, it’s just my perfectionism…“ Can anyone tag some name onto these shameless and shameful tribes? Because I can’t come up with anything that I would want to be associated with.
- visarga 5y agoGuilt–shame–fear spectrum of cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fear_spectrum_of_cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fe...
- KarlKemp 5y agoThat's really interesting, thank you. I'd always considered guilt and shame to be correlated, as two sides of the same medal. And believe the person above also conflated the two, since their "shamelessness" is really an inability to experience guilt. So maybe the problem is that guilt (felt by the person without specific external input) stopped working, and shaming is taking its place?
- krageon 5y agoWhy do you believe a lack of (feelings of) guilt is a problem?
- akomtu 5y agoThis looks a lot like one occult classification of souls: there are 3 positive types (those driven by action/will, love/compassion and wisdom/knowledge) and 3 negative types (posturing, vanity and fear). Every cycle of civilization is started by the former types, and are gradually replaced by the latter types. This wiki page describes the 3 negative types, and the 3 different cultures they create. The posturing types want appearance of being strong and wise, they are those pseudo-scientists and fake saints, so they create a guilt society. The vanity types want to feel morally superior to others, they enjoy creating contrived dogmas and making others navigate these dogmatic mazes, and they create a shame society. Finally, the fear types create a fear society: in the final stage of every cycle, when the strongest of the fear types are ruling the world, they create a death cult, with dark temples and other attributes. The wiki page doesn't mention societies created by the 3 positive types, aka the "golden age" of every civilisation.
- roenxi 5y ago> However, it may well be maladaptive at the scale of global society There is a pretty good argument that it is maladaptive in any community bigger than a few hundred people. The most successful political innovations - legislative bodies & courts - have both taken strong measures to make it difficult to shame people into cooperation or provide effective ways to fight back against a shaming. Good political decisions come from getting representative of the relevant people in a room, enumerating the issues and engaging in just enough give and take that nobody is grinning when they walk out. That is the only way. Any other process doesn't reach the same standards of quality.
- hunglee2 5y agoyeah I broadly agree. Shame is a good small group policing mechanism, in my imagination I see a homogenous kinship group in a hostile environment. Shame works there, but not necessarily for anything larger scale.
- pjc50 5y ago> The most successful political innovations - legislative bodies & courts - have both taken strong measures to make it difficult to shame people into cooperation ?!? Legislative bodies used to rely on shame (the opposite of honor) as a means of enforcing unwritten rules. It used to be possible to shame politicians into resigning when they'd crossed a line. “Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?” -- Joe Welch cancels Joe McCarthy Remember that Nixon resigned. He wasn't impeached out of office for his crimes, he was shamed into resigning when they came to light. > provide effective ways to fight back against a shaming Please list some court sanctioned ways to fight back against shaming and how these are not an infringement of free speech.
- NhanH 5y agoNixon met with Congress members and was told that he would be impeached with certainty, so he resigned the next day. He was decidedly not resigning over shame. Without the pardon from Ford, it’s possible he would be charged and indicted with a felony even. So yeah, there is a whole lot more to him resigning than shame
- Razengan 5y agoAnd it carries over to the glorious new age of technological empowerment, where systems that was supposed to mitigate human ills instead perpetuate them: All forums, even vote-based ones like Reddit and HN, devolve into echo chambers where any dissenting opinion is buried before many even get to see it.
- hansworst 5y agoAlthough at least on platforms like Reddit (and I suppose the internet as a whole) it’s possible to create your own echo chamber where your opinion that was shunned elsewhere is allowed to exist and can gather a following. The echo chamber effect of these platforms is often called out as a bad thing, but in my opinion it may also be useful as a way of nurturing ideas that would’ve otherwise been squashed early because they’re too contrarian. The problem is, you can only find out whether an idea is good or not by exposing it to an increasingly large audience. And then I guess there’s the risk of allowing “dangerous” ideas to gain such a large following that they’re hard to stop.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>Although at least on platforms like Reddit (and I suppose the internet as a whole) it’s possible to create your own echo chamber where your opinion that was shunned elsewhere is allowed to exist and can gather a following. AKA the Toaster Fucker Problem! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25667362 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25667362
- sacrosancty 5y agoIs that really a problem? Even if toaster fucker is a euphemism for gay? Why shouldn't everyone find like-minded people to feel non-isolated with?
- AussieWog93 5y agoIt's not really any of those things. It's nothing more than a whimsical way to think about certain types of cultish online communities.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoBut this always happens. There is no culture which doesn't have a strong element of self-censorship for at least some of its members. But equally some groups/individuals will get the benefit of the doubt, while others will be aggressively bullied and scapegoated. And some groups/individuals will aggressively claim victimhood and martyrdom while actually being comparatively privileged. The question is more the extent to which social dynamics are influenced by dark triad morality. Cultures with very little are far less inclined to public bullying than cultures where it's foundational.
- forum_ghost 5y agoWhat are the examples of these shameless cultures? I'd like to join them.
- tetromino_ 5y agoTraditional American culture (as compared to traditional Japanese culture, for example). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fear_spectrum_of_cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilt%E2%80%93shame%E2%80%93fe...
- KennyBlanken 5y ago[flagged]
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI mean sorry but the Japanese have a pretty strong shaming culture according to most of the world, that the things you think they should be ashamed of are not those they are shamed by does not prove any different.
- erikpukinskis 5y agoTraditional American culture is rife with shame. The concept of “manly men” is based on shame. The concept that women are responsible if they attract unwanted male attention is based on shame. The concept that anyone can succeed so if you don’t it’s because you didn’t try hard enough is based on shame. I could go on?
- KennyBlanken 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yunohn 5y agoI’m not sure why you’re so heavily downvoted - this is common sense.
- ThrowawayR2 5y agoThey desire that those having bad opinions should be shamed and are therefore being given what they desired, in a classic demonstration that one should be careful what one wishes for.
- janto 5y agoWe are now at a stage where a twitter mob would see "men should not be allowed to compete in women's sports" as a bigoted statement. To the vast majority of people there are important differences between men and women, and will now have to awkwardly self-censors their speech. Or they will worry whether they are actually bigoted and attempt to signal that they are not really a bad person by relenting to the group. We are also at a stage where a US Supreme Court nominee under questioning was unwilling to hazard a guess at a definition of Woman. The risks for them personally was just too high. We're also at a stage where I (not American) get bombarded by this ideological pathology of the American Left when I end up on Twitter. How do I opt out?
- yunohn 5y ago
- bavell 5y agoWhy do you think biological men should be allowed to compete in sports against biological women at a professional level? Is that fair to those women? We can acknowledge and accept trans people without bulldozing millennia of human culture. This has nothing to do with "speech", free or otherwise.
- dalbasal 5y agoA lot of shame relates to things outside of one's immediate control. "Son of a whore" is a old shame accusation. Shame by familial association is a very "traditional" part of shame. People who have suffered attack, especially rape, often feel ashamed. Failure is shameful. STDs are shameful. Being illiterate or inumerate. Etc. Shame in these cases isn't about altering behaviours directly. It is about creating social hierarchies, structures and such. It results more in hiding. So sure, shame has always been a part of culture and has good, along with bad effects. I don't agree that the internet "broke shame." Shame was always pretty broken. The internet just delivered it to new places.
- danielvaughn 5y agoIt also requires a society to be fairly well-aligned on where the margin lies. In the USA, at least, that is decidedly not the case.
- mikevm 5y ago
- jmeister 5y agoThese NYC media establishment orgs are the #1 enablers of “shaming”. How many employees have they fired because of social media shaming campaigns?
- ganzuul 5y agoOops how did this get here I'm not good with computers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Seberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Seberg
- AussieWog93 5y agoYes, what happened to her is bad too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tgv 5y ago- So, what would be the opening paragraph? - I thought we'd recall some unsavoury history and reshame that person, but clouding our own superiority complex with philosophical sounding objectivity. - Yeah, that'll keep 'm hooked.
- AndyMcConachie 5y agoThe New Yorker is itself part of this Complex the author talks about yet attempts to speak objectively about this Industrial Shaming Complex. It belies a complete lack of recognition that outlets like The New Yorker may be part of the phenomenom being discussed. The New Yorker isn't some neighborhood zine, it's a prime mover in American highbrow discourse. I have the same problem with any articles about 'The Media' written in a popular medium. At least recognize the difficulty of objectivity and your role in the subject being discussed.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agohttps://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/on-middlebrow https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/on-middlebrow >Both Harper’s and The New Yorker have often been viewed as prime examples of the middlebrow: both magazines are devoted to the high but also to making it accessible to many
- andrewclunn 5y agoInternet shaming is selectively applied and therefore more a tool of oppression and compliance than valid social signalling. "Politeness" and "political correctness" are entirely distinct, and the internet has no concept of that. Or to use their own language, internet shaming is Californian imperialism, attempting to impose it's values on other cultures.
- lazyeye 5y agoExactly. Advocates for diversity love all its superficial forms (skin color, gender, sexual orientation etc) and absolutely loathe the only form that matters...diversity of thought.
- tehwebguy 5y agoPeople are still feeling the effects of an entire group, all Black people in the US, being prohibited by law from acquiring property, wealth or education during the nation’s most formative years. The opportunities afforded to the various groups you mentioned are still super unequal. It’s built into society and didn’t just go away when the Civil Rights Act was signed (Title VII doesn’t even apply to companies of less than 15 employees) and that was less than 50 years ago. Some states protect classes like religion, political party membership, marriage status, illness & orientation by statute. Most states don’t. What is meant by “diversity of thought?”
- KennyBlanken 5y agoPolitical party membership is not a protected class. Ditto for "illness" (I think you meant 'disablity'?)
- tehwebguy 5y ago> Political party membership is not a protected class. It’s a protected class in at least a few states (looks like NY & CA plus DC & PR, with a hilarious exception in CA). > Ditto for "illness" (I think you meant 'disablity'?) I mean any medical condition that falls short of ADA protection (which also doesn’t apply when there are less than 15 employees)
- akomtu 5y agoI'd call it a more poetic name: the shaming demon. This is an unconcscious virtual creature that lives in our brains, like a botnet lives on PCs, and it watches restlessly for non-conforming behavior. The key feature of this demon is that it can be activated by a special whistle, and its wrath can be easily directed at your enemies. The weakness of this demon is inability to focus on many things at a time: if your enemies are many or they change frequently, the demon's wrath won't do much.
- nathias 5y agoShame is internal, so when people shame others they are recognizing and alarming others about something the shamed also knows and agrees with, the result is the shamed stops the bad action and societal harmony is reestablished. But with journalism for clicks, shaming is used to "try" to shame people who obviously don't share their values, so it has the opposite effect. When a group of people who think wrong is right is attacking you, you don't feel shame, you just feel right in what you are doing and the two groups are more divided as a result.
- visarga 5y agoGuilt is internal, based on moral thinking. Shame is external, based on society. Cultures tend towards shame (mostly in Asia), guilt (mostly in the Christianity) or fear (authoritarian regimes).
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoAnything by Cathy ONeill is worth a read to me. OK admittedly i am downloading the audiobook but at least I get to listen to her for a few hours as well - intelligent and still caring - a great social commentator
- tomlockwood 5y agoOnly Americans would draw a parallel between the military-industrial complex, which dictated foreign policy for the last fifty years and caused countless suffering overseas, with online drama within America.
- heresie-dabord 5y agoIf we follow the money, the major "social media" businesses are mostly American. The economic interest to promote these businesses as the only medium for discourse. The "shaming machine" monetises strife. It is a new, lucrative medium.
- tomlockwood 5y agoYour comment doesn't appear to address what I'm saying.
- heresie-dabord 5y agoThe military-industrial complex was/is a lucrative venture. I think the "shaming industry" is similar. (Can't edit original comment.)
- tommek4077 5y agoThat's why you shouldn't use your real name in the net. To me it still feels.strange when Facebook started and suddenly all the the pseudonyms vanished.
- dalbasal 5y agoI think "shame" is the wrong anchor point. I don't like the "industrial-complex" framing much either. The design of twitter, FB or whatnot have something to do with this phenomenon. But, I don't think this is the main point. I'll (heavily) paraphrase the prophetic Douglas Adams. Social media gave us back our "normal" mode of human communication: unmediated many-to-many. With it, we got back all sorts of negative social behaviours, like mob behaviours. Dynamics where violence, hatred and such overcome moderation are... human. They have negative consequences, so we develop social machinery to deal with them. That machinery doesn't exist in brand new spheres. Most people that came across the aids tweet didn't dunk on Justine Socco.. just all people that weighed in. That's a ratchet. When a mob forms to beat an apple thief or promiscuous woman in the street... most people dont join the mob. Most people walk on by. Very few are going to try and moderate the mob. Same kind of a ratchet. Spontaneous anger is a much stronger phenomenon than spontaneous moderation and restraint. Something external needs to prevent mob violence. Maybe you need police, with an explicit mandate to break up mobs. Maybe you need a court system, so the mob might deliver the apple thief to justice instead of DIYing it. Maybe you need an explicit anti-mob belief system, so that an anti-mob mob can form to balance out the anti-thief mob. That kind of cultural machinery is reactionary. It appears as an eventual solution to a problem. Our modern cultural frameworks (like twitter) evolve so fast that we never reach maturity though.
- BenoitEssiambre 5y agoThe article kinda misses a major point: > Flanagan calls shame accompanied by progressive values “mature shame” I would argue that shaming used to promote your political views is often the most damaging kind of shaming because on top of being the most divisive, it is likely counterproductive, an offputting move that damages your brand and often creates a powerful backlash against it. Now there's some subtlety here. It depends who you target in your shaming. The article does mention that shaming is considered more acceptable when punching up than punching down, which I would agree with, but you have to be very careful how you define that. Some people tell themselves they are punching up, when they are clearly punching down. One group this is clearly not privileged are the uneducated people who have always struggled at learning and understanding the world, who's grasp of morality is limited and requires weekly reminders by moral leaders, who fall for internet conspiracy theories, who have no chance of having the academic understanding of race and gender that seems to be increasingly asked of people. These people who struggle in educational settings, are comparatively handicapped, often don't have access to good stable jobs, are the first to become unemployed during recessions so are some of the most vulnerable people out there even when they are white. Advanced morality about things like race and gender is complex and not within everyone's reach. Advanced empathy involves multilevel recursive counterfactual meta-cognitive logic ( https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/K4eDzqS2rbcBDsCLZ/unrolling-social-metacognition-three-levels-of-meta-are-not https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/K4eDzqS2rbcBDsCLZ/unrolling-... ) and sometimes, academic understanding of past history. Asking some of these people to understand these things is asking people in wheelchairs to run and run away they will. If you shame them for their handicap they will fight back. It's fine to shame the villainous leaders who manipulated these people for their evil ends, but if you shame the people for falling into the traps, you actually push them further towards those evils.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoShame is a blunt tool. It's inconsistent. It has no moral value in and of itself. The funny thing about shame is the mental gymnastics that are gone through to justify who should or shouldn't be subject to it and on what criteria. The "villain" is whoever happens to be unpopular or undesired. Vulnerability is spun as a vice or saving grace in the interests of the shamer and his agenda. To paraphrase Cardinal Richelieu, it only takes a few words for one to find a reason to hang a man.
- aaron695 5y ago
- einpoklum 5y ago> shaming is a national pastime, and yet shameless conduct persists. Wouldn't that be "shameful conduct"? > In 2013, when people still nursed high hopes for the salvific effects of the Internet and cancellation was a fate reserved for poorly rated TV shows People were already being harassed, arrested and prosecuted for saying things governments didn't like on Social media, in 2013 or thereabouts. Prominent example for 2015: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dareen_Tatour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dareen_Tatour > Now she was a globally known racist. She is certainly not globally known (and whether she's a racist or not - one can certainly not know based on her tweet). > Our social fabric has since frayed considerably... our transformation into bloodhounds I wonder who is "us" for the author of this piece.
- PeePeePooPooMan 5y ago
- mark_l_watson 5y agoIt is a good article, but this is an important topic. I prefer the more in depth book “The Shame Machine” by Cathy O’Neil that I bought last week (book was just published). Human nature will be human nature, but I feel we need to recognize corporate owned automated profit systems and not fail to understand the threats they pose.
- arcticfox 5y ago> I prefer the more in depth book “The Shame Machine” by Cathy O’Neil that I bought last week (book was just published). About half of the article is dedicated to "The Shame Machine" and O'Neil so I don't think it's an either-or. The article is contrasting her thoughts with those of others.
- motohagiography 5y agoThe shame machine has created a disequillibrium, and personally I won't miss it when societies correct. More gravely, I think there is a coming generation of young men who will also wake up one day and say, "I don't need your redemption, it has no value." And like that, they will no longer avoid or deny shame, or be governed by it because redemption is a hustle, the carrot to shame's stick. When they see that they have been raised and kept in an extended nursery of deceptions produced by subtly fabricated narratives, designed to subjugate their identities and replace the cognitive tools they have for experiencing and understanding themselves with constructions of a simulation, they will also likely discover the power of force. Iterating down that timeline gets really grim, really fast. We've accumulated a reality-debt, suspended by academia and tech, leaking into appendent institutions like media and government, and the most interesting problem now is how ot unwind it without triggering a chain reaction, imo.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AitchEmArsey 5y ago> ...an extended nursery of deceptions produced by subtly fabricated narratives, designed to subjugate their identities... Parklife!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zzzeek 5y ago> I think there is a coming generation of young men who will also wake up one day and say, "I don't need your redemption, it has no value." And like that, they will no longer avoid or deny shame This "coming generation" you refer towards is already present and is otherwise known as "the status quo of maleness for basically all of recorded human history".
- lliamander 5y ago> the status quo of maleness for basically all of recorded human history I'm pretty sure that's completely false. Consider the white feather campaign in Britain during WWI. So much of male behavior throughout history has precisely been about preserving honor and avoiding shame.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoWow. Lotta dead comments. I don’t think I’ve seen this many, in a single article, before.
- nostrademons 5y agoCounterpoint (which I'm surprised didn't make it into the article, given its pop-psychology virality and 5.8M YouTube views): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psN1DORYYV0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psN1DORYYV0 It's also interesting to contrast recent Pixar portrayals of shame in Encanto and Turning Red, where shame deeply pathologizes a family and leads to a lot of dysfunction among younger members who can't let their true selves out.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt means sarcasm is dead. In most public shaming events I have heard of, the shamed expression was meant to mock people who actually believed in the idea expressed. It would not be surprising if the majority of those performing enforcement were exactly the ones being mocked.