11 ms·
From the 12+ Years on HN I know this is an unpopular opinion. I dont like GMO / Genome-edited cattle / food or crops. Even if it could theoretically occur thro
by ksec 5y ago
From the 12+ Years on HN I know this is an unpopular opinion.
I dont like GMO / Genome-edited cattle / food or crops. Even if it could theoretically occur through a natural breeding process. You can cross breed all you want. GMO is not cross breed as many on HN somehow believes last time we had this discussions. You can do Data Science and other controlled environment in providing better yield as in EUR ( Or specifically the Dutch ). And we may soon have Cattle labeled as GMO / Genome-Edit Free as selling point, as US likes to do with Antibiotic Free and Growth Hormones free labels. Part of the reason why EU has never been keen on US Beef import.
To add some other context, US Beef export rank third in export volume and first or second in export revenue.
- ekianjo 5y ago> Even if it could theoretically occur through a natural breeding process. You can cross breed all you want. I'm no fan of GMO products either, but the whole point is that it gets you there faster , and in a more predictable way, than doing cross-breeding. Economics at work.
- Thorrez 5y ago>And we may soon have Cattle labeled as GMO / Genome-Edit Free as selling point A lot of food I buy has labels saying GMO-free on it. Although maybe that's just to distinguish from GMO plants currently.
- klondike_ 5y agoThere are actually very few GMO crops available commercially. Mostly corn and wheat. The "No GMO" label is meaningless for most products that don't use these ingredients
- ksec 5y agoAnd potatoes.
- ben_w 5y agoMost of the hard cheese I eat was processed with genetically modified bacterial rennet, and would otherwise not be vegetarian.
- exhilaration 5y agoYup. I would say at this point 99% of the cheese consumed by Americans is produced with GMO bacterial rennet. I've contacted maybe a dozen cheese producers and they've told me the same thing. It's not just about lower cost, but that is the biggest factor, one producer told me it's also about bacterial rennet being much more consistent and predictable.
- bluGill 5y agoThere is no GMO wheat available. Lots of corn and a few. Others, but so far no wheet
- kickout 5y agoOther have also commented, but this is mostly a marketing ploy. Non-GMO is not a regulated term and most things we eat have do not have a 'GMO' alternative.
- gruez 5y ago>Non-GMO is not a regulated term and most things we eat have do not have a 'GMO' alternative. Source? A search turns up: https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/09/21/new-allowances-including-non-gmo-statement-certified-organic-meat-and-poultry https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/09/21/new-allowances-in...
- kickout 5y agoOrganic is the regulated term. Again, GMO is not a regulated term. The fact you see companies using it to try and extract a premium is the result of marketing, not a defined technical certification.
- epgui 5y agoI’m a biochemist, and I’d feed GMOs to my kids all day if I had any. Or to my mom. They’re totally fine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- karmakurtisaani 5y agoFor me the idea that a company can claim intellectual property rights to a genome sounds pretty awful. To be fair, I don't know if that's a real threat or not, but I could totally see it happening.
- epgui 5y agoYeah I agree, but I also feel the same way about software patents. I think it’s important to distinguish that objection from health scares, technophobia and such: imagine if the public’s objections were targeted at the real problems instead, how much more productive it would be!
- karmakurtisaani 5y agoThat gives me a pretty cynical idea: the companies pushing GMOs should start funding and supporting groups who are vocal about the claimed adverse health effects of GMOs. That opposition is easy to argue against in public debate, and the resulting noise conveniently drowns out the real problems. Controlled opposition I think it's called. Not surprisingly, I've learned about this concept from the Russian government.
- speed_spread 5y agoI believe that's exactly what they are doing. They're drowning the big political issues of their model into the noise produced by the scientifically debatable issues. Ultimately, it's about bringing back up a feudal regime that can't be bypassed.
- vanattab 5y agoI am not a big fan of idea of GMO beef ether, not because I fear it will be dangerous but because I fear it will taste like crap and be unhealthy for the cows. Today they will make the cows hair shorter so they stay cooler for when they edit them tomorrow to grow an extra couple of hundred pounds of rapidly grown muscle.
- gruez 5y ago> because I fear it will taste like crap OTOH I can plausibility imagine engineering to improve marbling for instance. > and be unhealthy for the cows Todays cows are already really unhealthy because of feedlots.
- klondike_ 5y agoYou don't provide any argument for why you dislike GMO food here. What bothers you so much about GMO food? The fact is that humans have been breeding plants and animals to increase efficiency and palatability for thousands of years, and GMO is the next technological step.
- mping 5y agoUnknown unknowns
- Tenoke 5y agoThere's always unknown unknowns and by now those have been reduced significantly for GMOs. Any reason to think the risk in this case might be higher than the benefits? Are you sure you are not overestimating the unknown unknown risk just because GMO sounds scary?
- rocqua 5y agoUnknown unkowns are much more dangerous in any revolutionary change. Because previous experience is much less useful in a revolutionary change. GMO, with its large increase in potential interventions, is quite revolutionary.
- kleene_op 5y agoThere will always be unknown unknowns, whatever the subject at hand. This is not specific to GMOs and certainly not a good argument against them.
- Timwi 5y agoWhy are you not worried about the unknown unknowns in literally any other area? Like, using microwave ovens, having TV broadcast signals, or wearing silk? Personally I'm reasonably confident that any significant adverse health effect would have been found by experiments by now, so Bayesian reasoning tells me any unknowns that are still unknown are probably negligible.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoFurther your assertion by discussing the real concern: uncertainty. It seems to take generations for health problems with novel products that humans ingest to materialize. We have millennia of experience with cross breeding, animal husbandry, etc. Why trust these salesmen of genetically modified organisms, the same gentlemen who gleefully introduce pesticides into the environment, when we know that traditional hybrid crops and selectively-bred livestock provide ample nourishment? Is optimizing for per-acre yields at the risk hazard the environment and human health worthwhile?
- sokoloff 5y agoThat depends in large part on whether a world population of 8B can be fed at the lower per-acre yields. If the alternative is “everyone eats, but food is a little more expensive”, that’s OK. If the alternative is “billions live with insufficient food and 100s of millions die”, then I think the balance of the risk equation shifts.
- rocqua 5y agoTo avoid malthusian traps we do need per-acre yields to be higher and higher. Increasing yields is not just about farmers profits, also about feeding the world. That does not mean it is a good idea to trade long term damage for short term yields. But yields are still important.
- imtringued 5y ago>To avoid malthusian traps we do need per-acre yields to be higher and higher. Increasing yields is not just about farmers profits, also about feeding the world. This is illogical. The only places that experience excessive population growth are those that haven't developed their basic agricultural sectors and rely on labor intensive subsistence farming which means having children who work on your farm is not a drag on your household. The reason why those people do subsistence farming is actually quite ironic, because they cannot afford to run commercial farms as those would have to compete with hyper optimized western farms so instead every poor nation is forced to sell its raw resources and cash crops and then buy food from developed countries. You can't sustain a population on vanilla but since western and asian countries cannot compete on e.g. coffee or vanilla production in Madagascar that nation can use the proceeds to import rice. The problem isn't an inability to grow rice, after all, people do subsistence farming and live off it their entire life.