9 ms·
Birth control pill for men could begin human trials later this year
- 1270018080 5y agoI feel like a headline like this has popped up every year for the last 15 years.
- MisterSandman 5y agoAs a gay man, it's always a lot of fun to watch discussions on birth control for men. I personally have my money on that if/when they do launch for the public, they will be too expensive/difficult to get for basically forever, and women will continue to have to bear the cost of preventing pregnancies. "Men using birth control" would become the "hippie" thing to do that you will only see people in LA/NY do. I am very glad this exists, though, and I hope I'm wrong.
- dankboys 5y agoMaybe, it’s a much harder job to produce male birth control for men owing to having much more reproductive material. I think the hippy option currently is getting the snip “for the sake of the planet”
- tshaddox 5y ago> "Men using birth control" would become the "hippie" thing to do that you will only see people in LA/NY do. Assuming it's relatively safe, reliable, and affordable, and especially if it's significantly better in any of those areas to the existing options for women, then it seems like a no-brainer for long-term monogamous heterosexual relationships.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw__away7391 5y agoI think this is probably well correlated to a man's socioeconomic status.
- brimble 5y agoLots of guys have gotten vasectomies for decades, and I don't see a lot of correlation between making that choice and being a "hippie", in my family & friends circles.
- emptysongglass 5y agoStraight man here. I have a solution to all this and it's the same solution many (though my understanding not all) gay men practice: anal sex. It's all my wife and I do together. No pill needed! (Practice safe sex.)
- Karawebnetwork 5y agoStill not 100% proof. Things such as internal fissures and external trickles can still cause pregnancies. Granted, the risks are very low.
- wbsss4412 5y agoTo be fair, birth control isn’t 100% either.
- vanattab 5y agoWait, women can get pregnant through internal fissures of the intestines?
- flobosg 5y agoNot exactly the same, but in the 80s a woman without a vagina got pregnant by a stab in the abdomen shortly after having oral sex with her boyfriend.
- philwelch 5y agoIMO that’s a similar tradeoff as condoms, though probably more cost-effective.
- emptysongglass 5y agoStrictly by pregnancy risk, I believe anal sex is far less likely to result in pregnancy than condom use. And that's only compared to perfect condom use every time, which is not what I'd consider realistic.
- to1y 5y agoI think you are incredibly out of touch with reality. It is men that generally worry about unwanted pregnancies. If there was an on/off switch, almost all men would set it to 'off' and it'd quickly turn into women using any techniques available to get them to put it into the 'on' position.
- DrinkDrinkDrink 5y ago
- mFixman 5y agoAs another gay man, I cannot help but compare the hypothetical case of a male birth control pill and the fast expansion of PrEP. Extrapolating from that I would guess that saving unwanted pregnancies will make most governments and healthcare systems give male birth control for very cheap, which will cause an increase in STDs and a _big_ decrease in unwanted pregnancies.
- 4oo4 5y agoThere I think are a number of viable male birth control options already, but most of them never come to market. This is because it's nearly impossible to get men to invest in preventing the risk of pregnancy. Aside from condoms, unfortunately the vast majority of heterosexual men are programmed to offload that risk mitigation onto women.
- insickness 5y agoYou underestimate most mens' willingness to avoid pregnancy. To a lot of men, there are few things more horrific than getting the wrong woman pregnant and being saddled with 18 years of child support payments and the ethical burden of 18 years of child-rearing.
- 4oo4 5y agoPersonally, I am a heterosexual male that would 100% take this if it's available, not sure why I was downvoted. This isn't my personal opinion, I am actually just stating the opinion of pharmaceutical companies. If you search for male birth control, you'll see lots of stories like this over the past 5-10 years. So you need to ask yourself why there aren't any that we can currently go to our doctor for? The science is there but attitudes and market research are not. We are a conscientious bunch here and not representative of the general population, sadly. Or at least, that's how pharmaceutical companies perceive that, and until that is successfully challenged I don't think any of these will be viable in a commercial sense, even if they are in a scientific one. Early trials of male hormonal birth control, usually in the form of injections, have shown that drugs are effective in preventing pregnancy, but pharmaceutical companies show little interest in developing or marketing them. But another obstacle is the unwillingness of men to endure the drug’s side-effects, and of the medical establishment to permit a drug with side-effects similar to those of women’s birth control from being given to men. I would be really curious how the side-effects compare to female birth control, which are already pretty bad to begin with, and we just expect women to put up with. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jun/05/male-birth-control-step-up-responsibility https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jun/05/male-b...
- 4oo4 5y ago
- endisneigh 5y agoThe article doesn’t explain what’s wrong with condoms. Edit: lol didn’t realize this was just a controversial question
- raziel2p 5y agoDoes it need to?
- endisneigh 5y agoI’m just curious what problem this is solving. If you’re casually dating your partner has no guarantee you’re on the pill, so you have to use a condom anyway. If you’re with another dude, you’d still want to use a condom for stds. If you’re in a long term relationship and don’t want kids aren’t there already better options than this? Under what circumstances would one use this over a condom?
- brimble 5y agoFor tons of people in committed relationships, the woman takes the pill and they don't use condoms. This just lets the guy do it instead (or in addition, if you want to be extra safe). I'm truly not following what's hard to understand about it.
- endisneigh 5y agoI didn’t realize people still took pills in committed relationships. My doc friends said a copper iud is pretty much the gold standard. Thanks for the info.
- brimble 5y agoIUDs or injected, persistent "pills", yeah, I'm not sure literally taking a pill every day is as common as it once was now that they can inject something that lasts months and doesn't require remembering to take it, but some form of drug-based contraception is still fairly common (among the ones not using IUDs for whatever reason).
- zinclozenge 5y agoUp until now, all/most male birth control pills have centered around exogenous testosterone + progesterone/something else. Ignoring the other compound, exogenous testosterone supplementation would lead to all sorts of potential abuse since it's an anabolic steroid. There's also the fact that any oral formulation of testosterone (see dianabol for example) is extremely toxic on the liver, and leads to much higher levels of estradiol (which has its own side effects) due to homeostasis. The secondary compounds also have their own significant side effects, to the point where it really makes me wonder how bad hormonal birth control can be for women. So this compound blocking vitamin A is a pretty novel approach.
- bufbupa 5y agoThe problem with male birth control pills is that it's the women who bear the bulk of the risk/responsibility when it comes to pregnancy. If a woman says "trust me, i'm on the pill" and lies -- they're the ones that get pregnant and likely get stuck raising the kid. Sure the father might be on the hook financially, but if the woman lied about their birth control and went forward with the pregnancy anyway it's not absurd to imagine the father bailing on the situation. Flipped around the other way, if a man says "trust me, i'm on the pill", now a woman has to trust this man even though they're the one's at risk of getting pregnant. What's worse is that the woman can't easily verify if they did in fact take a pill. At least with a condom you can be check that it's being used properly.. This asymmetric risk profile makes me think think that male birth control pills won't work outside of trusting long-term relationships, and then there's better options than a chemical pill for those situations already.
- bobro 5y agowhat better options do you mean?
- melony 5y agoA financial medallion
- bufbupa 5y agofor long-term birth control a copper (non-hormonal) IUD might be a better option. You don't have to remember to take pills, and it's less chemically disruptive to the body. Or better yet a vasectomy if you never want kids.
- FalconSensei 5y agototal anecdotal: a couple years ago, I went to a gender reveal party. The wife had IUD, but it was not properly put, iirc. Then talking to another couple there, they were expecting a baby. Guess what was the birth control of choice? In the end, all methods can fail. Combining male + female controls is the best, since both would have to fail for a pregnancy to happen.
- beezle 5y agoWill be interesting to track the increase in STDs as condom use by men declines with uptake of male birth control pills.
- adalu 5y agoWhy would I take poison to make me infertile? This is beyond stupid
- beegeearreff 5y agoDon’t worry too much about this topic. Having sex is a requirement for it to be relevant.
- TSiege 5y agoIs there any reason that the medical industry is pushing medicinal therapies to prevent pregnancy when a very promising procedure called vasalgel is just hanging on the vine? It is 1) highly effective, 2) non-hormonal/non-medicinal just a minor injection into the vas deferens 3) long lasting and reversible 4) dirt cheap. It's mind boggling how this has been able to progress beyond animal trials even though it's performed so well and been studied for over a decade. I've been waiting for any sign of progress but it's glacial. This could really improve the lives of men and their partners. Women wouldn't need the pill, which so many of the women I know hate and as a one time procedure is much more error free. https://www.revolutioncontraceptives.com/vasalgel https://www.revolutioncontraceptives.com/vasalgel
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y agoI came here to post the same thing. I don't understand what's holding vasalgel from becoming ubiquitous and approved by various medical institutions out there. It's been in the works for what feels like forever.
- janitha 5y agoProfitability? A cheap one time procedure (ie. vasalgel) is far less lucrative than a pill that need to be bought repeatedly.
- tcj_phx 5y agoThis problem is solved, just not in pill form. There's an old solution that allows men to reduce their sperm count, down to an effective-zero: raise the temperature of the testicles to be body temperature. In ancient times bread bakers were known to not father as many children, until they stopped working the ovens. The heat shock protein disrupts sperm production for longer periods of time. HSP forms at 104 degrees, iirc. One of my previous comments about this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28023798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28023798
- akvadrako 5y agoSounds like playing demanding games with a laptop on your lap would also work.
- simonblack 5y agoThe thing about Birth Control for Men is that there's no penalty for lying. Men aren't the ones who get pregnant after saying "Of course I'm on the Pill, darling." Women who believe that are as bad/stupid/dumb as the ones who believe a man who says "Trust Me".
- cozos 5y agoIt would for sure be an asshole thing to do, but men don't really have anything to gain by getting a woman pregnant right? If anything it's a liability (child support payments)
- cosmodisk 5y agoI think you'd be surprised how many out there just want to 'sow the seed' for the sake of it.
- staticman2 5y agoAn abusive man can try to prevent a woman from leaving him by getting her pregnant. Even if she leaves she'll have to continue to interact with him if he gets partial custody. He can also threaten to make sure she has her child taken away if she leaves him and threaten to lie to the court about her fitness as a parent. This works better if the local religion or government is anti abortion.
- Justin_K 5y agoThe same could be said about women. They get pregnant and are entitled to child support.
- powersnail 5y agoWhat would be motivation, though?
- DrinkDrinkDrink 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoWhat I love about reversible male birth control is that all of the conjecture simply disappears after it becomes available 90% of the comments if this thread simply become comedy In any case I’m very curious about this Vitamin A solution
- vmception 5y ago> experimental compound that blocks proteins from binding to vitamin A, also known as retinoic acid thoughts? anything we should know about retinoic acid?