14 ms·
Vulnerability in Honda's Remote Keyless System
- post_break 5y agoTPMS is something you can sniff as well which I think is much more of an issue.
- boardwaalk 5y agoWait, reading or spoofing tire pressure is more of an issue than opening doors and starting the engine?
- montjoy 5y agoPotentially. You could put a dangerously high or low amount of air in the tire and then tell the car, “this is fine”.
- ctoth 5y agoMore disturbing to me is that most TPMS transmissions have a unique ID associated with them making it trivial to track a given vehicle. Many vehicles only transmit pressure when prompted, but I have definitely noticed those which constantly transmit. Usually Toyota.
- mywittyname 5y agoThat's how Toyota's proximity unlock feature works.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoIsn’t the range extremely close?
- kube-system 5y agoTPMS often uses a lower frequency range which can travel pretty well.
- coolspot 5y agoDepends on the size of your antenna. Russians might secretly built 10e10 sq.mi. antenna array field to read tire pressure of all US cars!
- sennight 5y agoI'd say so, from the perspective of utility and persistence. 4 (maybe 5 including spare) uniquely serialized radio beacons make a good target for dragnet surveillance with zero risk to abusers. I'm also more weary of scam extended warranties than I am of kidnap and ransom, even though one is obviously far more unpleasant than the other.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoHaving lived in big cities half my life, I leave my car's doors unlocked, and keep a waterproof seat cover on. Remote start is troubling though.
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoI used to leave my windows open on sunny days, to stop the car getting too hot or anyone breaking in to look for stuff to steal. When I did this at my office car park, well-meaning people would call security and ask them to help the person with open windows by earning them they were open. Or if they knew it was my car they’d seek me out to warn me that my windows were down. The reason they gave was always that they were worried someone would steal stuff from the car. There was nothing in it to steal. Eventually I got sick of wasting other people’s time for them and left my windows closed. So many of them complained that their cars were hot, and/or had them broken into by people looking to steal things. I think the only real solution would be for me to buy a car that lets me take the roof off. If your car is roofless, no-one comes to warn you.
- vuln 5y agoI’ve owned a few convertibles and I always left the doors unlocked and/or the top down. I’d rather someone steal the $100 radio than cut through the top or break a window. I did always keep the glovebox locked but that only contained my registration and proof of insurance. I have had a radio stolen once but it was just the faceplate. Not sure what they’re going to do with that.
- dharmab 5y agoIt is very common for Miata owners to leave the doors unlocked if they need to put the roof up because the roof is more valuable than the interior. (Since it is a common track/race car, every interior piece has an aftermarket replacement.)
- vmception 5y agoAs a courtesy to people looking for wheels? Or is this a reverse psychology thing where people are supposed to think it’s already been checked by others
- belter 5y ago"Hackers remotely start, unlock Honda Civics with $300 tech": https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/25/honda_civic_hack/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/25/honda_civic_hack/ CVE-2019-20626: https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2019-20626 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2019-2062... CVE-2022-27254: https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2022-27254 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2022-2725...
- Bud 5y agoPretty bad for a system as crucial as this to be this bad in 2020. Honda ought to know better.
- matthewdgreen 5y ago2017 and 2018 vehicles. That's pretty surprisingly recent! I understand that, in general, door locks aren't considered to be very high-security in vehicles: doors can be opened in other ways. But remote start is a very big deal. Article doesn't mention whether the car prevents people from driving away after it's been started. I would have loved to see a portion of the video where they tried to shift into D and move the car.
- PaulHoule 5y agoOnce you get the door open you can usually plug a programmer into the OBD-2 port under the steering wheel and pair a new key fob, then drive away. Back in the day it was pretty easy to get the door open like this https://www.wikihow.com/Use-a-Slim-Jim https://www.wikihow.com/Use-a-Slim-Jim
- macintux 5y agoI’ve been researching OBD-2 port physical locks, since I drive doorless most of the summer. Not much available.
- vgeek 5y agohttps://autocyb.com/shop/ https://autocyb.com/shop/ is this the leading contender?
- macintux 5y agoI don’t think I’d come across that one. It probably would be, but the website sends me to some 3rd party spam site every time I click a link.
- mh- 5y agoPretty sure their Wordpress site is compromised, it tries to load a malware domain sometimes. I accidentally lost the domain off my clipboard, but my uBlock rules caught it once. It had the word 'great' in it.
- danso 5y ago> Vehicles Affected: 2016-2020 Honda Civic(LX, EX, EX-L, Touring, Si, Type R) I own a Honda model just prior to this date range — but I assume it's not necessarily the case that pre-2016 Honda vehicles used a more secure system? It may just be that they aren't specifically vulnerable to the exact same RF signal type as 2016-2020 vehicles?
- jeffbee 5y agoHow can this not affect the Insight that is based on the 10th-generation Civic? At least I always naturally follow the advice in the article: I use the passive entry system and I can't recall ever pressing the buttons on the fob.
- dharmab 5y agoOwner and modder of a nearly-classic Honda here. Yes, the older models have the same vulnerability. Please forgive the awful pun based on the author's mistranslated Japanese and focus on the technical part: https://github.com/HackingIntoYourHeart/Unoriginal-Rice-Patty https://github.com/HackingIntoYourHeart/Unoriginal-Rice-Patt... (Honda does not mean "Original Rice Patty." It literally means "Original (as in older) Rice Paddy", but you wouldn't translate Henry Ford's surname as "Shallow River Crossing.") Honda enthusiasts commonly store their cars in private garages, install hidden killswitches and avoid keeping items in their cars.
- zcmack 5y agoat least my dystopian future toyota keyfob subscription could be patched to fix this...
- pards 5y agoOr reducing/eliminating the $800 keyfob replacement cost on my 2018 Rav4. It's the worst case of vendor lock-in and customer fleecing.
- jjoonathan 5y agoThe subscription will be a lot more than $800 by the time it's done with you.
- nilleo 5y agoThat's assuming auto manufacturers will actually provide you with continuous updates and not just charge you for access to the core feature without ever bothering to update it. Much like how infotainment software can vary from one model year to the next while the hardware remains mostly unchanged--they're usually not giving you the option to just stop by the dealer for an update, much less let you do it yourself via USB or OTA. To be fair though, my example isn't absolute--as far as infotainment goes, Chevrolet has done free Android Auto/Carplay retrofits in the past if your older model hardware supported it, and Ford SYNC is upgradable by the consumer via USB. I don't know of any Toyota models that offer that same though.
- walrus01 5y agosee also, from just 4 hours ago: "Have a car with a push-to-start ignition? Here's how it could end up stolen and overseas" https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/marketplace-car-thefts-1.6396215 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/marketplace-car-thefts-1.6396...
- spbnick 5y agoInstead of using a faraday pouch to prevent this kind of attack, I added a kill switch to my key fob, a few years ago, and still use it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02M57GPix-4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02M57GPix-4 The problem is that manufacturers are using strength of signal to detect keyfob proximity, which is, of course, defeatable with a (somewhat expensive) amplifier. I wonder how hard could it be to measure response latency instead? That should solve the problem. I thought about selling those for a while (and got a few requests), but realized I can't easily design them for the many kinds of key fobs out there. I suppose the manufacturers are not adding them themselves because that would hurt the image of "security" of these key fobs.
- punnerud 5y agoIs there any fuse or something the owner can take out to use the key in manual mode? until there is fix
- dheera 5y agoNot a direct answer but something that might mitigate. I have these motion-activated alarms on my bike, moped, and in my backpack, and activate the alarms when I'm not within view of them. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0734QN8KR/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0734QN8KR/ I imagine you could probably ziptie one (or maybe a few, though you'd have to carry a few remotes) onto an inconspicuous location on the car. It would be a good deterrent for car thieves and possibly also towing companies. I actually want to work on a modification of this device where it shoots out fart spray in addition to the loud alarm.
- jmrm 5y agoI know people who use hidden or magnetic switches to being able to start the car because they have a relatively expensive and easy to stole car.
- walrus01 5y agopeople also do this on a DIY approach with old cars that are easy to steal (like a 2002 subaru or something) by wiring an ignition kill switch into the ignition fuse, and hiding it somewhere not obvious...
- willcipriano 5y agoAdam Carolla famously did with but with the fuel pump, the thieves would get a few feet up the road before the fuel in the line would run out.
- m463 5y agoThe trick would be to make sure the fuel pump doesn't lose power in a critical situation.
- rdtwo 5y agoIf a newer car gets stolen it’s just an inconvenience because it’s likely insured.
- p1mrx 5y agoEven if that's true, new cars tend to become old cars.
- kube-system 5y agoThis doesn't enable anyone to steal the car, unless they also have a tow truck. It would let someone steal the contents of the vehicle, which may not be insured, and I suspect it would be difficult to collect on without signs of entry to the vehicle.
- sleepdreamy 5y agoIf I'm not mistaken, unlocking the doors is half the exploit. The vehicle can also be started which..means you just drive it away. This is very dangerous and crazy if true. 300 Bucks for tools is nothing -
- kube-system 5y agoModern vehicles factory-equipped with remote starters prohibit the car from being shifted into drive when the remote starter function is used via the long-range remote. (so random people walking down the street can't hop in and steal it) Hondas are no exception to this. There is another radio exchange that happens inside of the car with the key before you are able to shift into drive. This example doesn't demonstrate that being broken.
- arajesh 5y agoLuckily, driving away with the vehicle is impossible unless you are able to mimic the PKE system, which incorporates a 4 way handshake. There has been some research where a similar system was broken but I haven’t had the chance to try it on the civic.
- 5y ago
- ctoth 5y agoUnrelated but does anyone know of a good and available replacement for the HackRF One? The LimeSDR Mini looks good but is impossible to source because of the chip shortage. HackRF is getting a little long in the tooth these days.
- meatmanek 5y agoThe ADALM-Pluto a.k.a "PlutoSDR" is a pretty good alternative; it's similarly spec'd to the LimeSDR Mini and appears to be in stock at Mouser. It's currently $230 but I think it occasionally goes on sale for significantly less.
- exabrial 5y ago> Utilize a Faraday Pouch for the key fob. Sorry to ask a dumb question, but how does this help?
- rmetzler 5y agoI think this only helps against relay attacks. To use the key to open the door the owner probably has to take the fob out of the pouch and then replay attacks might be possible.
- exabrial 5y agoI still don't understand I guess how the pouch mitigates anything
- jcrawfordor 5y agoRelay attacks seem to be in use in the wild by sophisticated car thiefs, although I'm not sure how commonly. Given general trends, it's probably more common in Europe than in the US. More to your question though, the issue is that proximity key systems rely on the limited radio transmission range. If a thief uses something like an SDR to "amplify" or repeat the transmissions, they can get the car to think the key is much closer than it is... and potentially unlock the car in your driveway by "using" your key fob inside your house. A faraday pouch makes this very difficult by significantly attenuating the signal from the key fob.
- chiph 5y agoI'm assuming it attenuates the signal so that someone parked nearby has a more difficult time capturing the code. Downside is you can't use your remote start from inside the house anymore - you'll have to be very close before the remote will work (which raises the question of what good is having a remote if you're close enough to just use the physical key). But with the faraday pouch, at least the car won't have been stolen. For the MITM attacks on the modern proximity car keys, drop your fob into a metal tin (like the Danish Butter Cookie ones) when you walk in the house to block the signal. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2017/11/man-in-the-midd_8.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2017/11/man-in-the-mi...
- devin 5y agoI have a Flipper Zero and so far cannot reproduce on my 2017 model.
- vuln 5y agoI’m still waiting on mine. I suppose that’s what I get for ordering the black one instead of white.
- alexk307 5y agoHow do you like your Flipper? Seems like a great tool
- devin 5y agoI'm a fan. It has great battery life, has more heft than I expected. The second day I had it we went to my mother-in-law's new apartment building. Her call button wasn't working to let people into the building, so I asked if I could try to copy her FOB since we needed to get some things from our car and boom, it worked just like that. Also had some fun mucking around with raw NFC and emulating them. Took a bit of tinkering, but it was pretty cool to see it work. The #sub-ghz channel on Flipper Zero's discord blew up a little bit today with this news. So far though, the couple us with affected model years according to this CVE have been unable to reproduce. FCC ID matches. The precise frequency was added to a modified firmware, and we are using FSK modulation, but still no luck.
- jeffbee 5y agoNot going to get all worked up over this because I remember that I owned a 1985 Mazda and the key for it would open and start every 1979-1985 Mazda in town. Objectively we've come a long way.
- 1024core 5y agoCan you monitor the frequency 433.215MHz via GnuRadio a standard RTL SDR DVB USB device?
- mytdi 5y agoMaybe it's similar to the TPMS (tire pressure monitoring system) as talked about here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30619612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30619612
- runjake 5y agoYes. You can even listen to the warble of the codes. And those of my, well your, neighbors. I did my own research (albeit not as far as this person) a couple years back and the 2018 CR-V is also vulnerable.
- ctoth 5y agoWhat you're looking for is RTL433[0]. [0]: https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433 https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433
- prova_modena 5y agoYes you should be able to, or with slightly more friendly software like gQRX or SDRSharp. It also looks like you can receive and decode the key signals using rtl_433[0] with option -R 64. Although it's a bit confusing looking at the source for the honda key rtl_433 decoder, as the author states it does not decrypt the rolling code.[1] According to the CVE there is no rolling code. [0] https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433 https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433 [1] https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433/blob/master/src/devices/hondaremote.c https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433/blob/master/src/devices/...
- atdrummond 5y agoThis makes me think of another vulnerability with these door/key systems, this time actually acted upon by bad (yet creative!) actors: the creative relay system thieves used to nick Tom Cruise's BMW X7M - https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tom-cruises-bmw-x7-was-stolen-right-from-under-bodyguards-nose-168149.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tom-cruises-bmw-x7-was-st...
- throw0101a 5y agoThere's an industry standard (?) for Digital Keys: * https://carconnectivity.org https://carconnectivity.org * https://carconnectivity.org/digital-key/ https://carconnectivity.org/digital-key/ Perhaps moving to that will help with security since everyone won't have to re-invent the wheel. (Of course implementation bugs are still possible.)
- NL807 5y agoBut then if there is a vuln in the industry standard system, then all cars will be affected.
- sodality2 5y agoWe do the same with TLS, SSH, etc. As long as we have smart people at the helm I don't see a reason to be worried.
- BeefWellington 5y agoThe threat model and security considerations there are too different between those examples. TLS and SSH are not generally run on disconnected systems that may never get firmware updates, as just one obvious difference.
- sodality2 5y agoThere's The Update Framework (TUF) for that, so maybe at some point cars will be able to update easily.
- kj4ips 5y agoSounds like a case where formal methods might be both appropriate and funding might actually be available for that.
- devin 5y agoI wrote another comment saying I couldn't reproduce but since this is on the front page, I do have a lot of questions for the authors of this CVE. Under their "prevention" section they say manufacturers should use rolling codes. This implies these FOBs don't use them, but per my previous understanding, they do. Perhaps there is more to the setup of this CVE than they're talking about. Is it possible they're doing a rolljam attack + replay? The CVE is really scant on details, so while I believe they did manage to get this to work, they don't really say how. If rolling codes are implemented, it should be pretty simple with the right gear to prove it.
- emerongi 5y agoDefinitely hard to believe a 2020 Honda is not using rolling codes.
- olyjohn 5y agoPretty sure that even my garage door opener used rolling codes back in 1995...
- philliphaydon 5y agoI remember watching the news like 20 years ago about garage doors where thieves were buying universal door openers and driving down the roads pressing the buttons to find houses where it opened to rob them.
- danielheath 5y agoGarage door openers often last 15-20 years, so I wouldn’t be surprised if that were true, but a new system in 95 would definitely include them.
- colechristensen 5y agoSince there are various values attached to getting a CVE published, they just aren't always of the highest quality. Lots of "vulnerabilities" which are actually impossible to exploit or irrelevant in other ways in a real attack scenario, other low quality or misrepresented issues like we might be seeing here.
- liveoneggs 5y ago1990's hondas all used the same keys. You could, literally, steal a car by accident using your own key.
- marricks 5y agoAny source for this? That's completely wild.
- liveoneggs 5y agoaside from my high school parking lot google for terms like "honda civic same key" :) https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-1/why-can-another-civics-key-crank-up-my-civic-1244168/ https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-... https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-1/honda-civic-keys-96-00-a-3156783/ https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-... https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-1/help-any-key-can-open-my-car-1803965/ https://honda-tech.com/forums/honda-civic-del-sol-1992-2000-... I guess the real answer is that any key/lock that isn't 1-year-new is worn down enough to fit any other honda. I'm not sure they take security that seriously.
- marricks 5y agoAhh, I searched 1990s Honda same key and it was too broad. That is hilarious
- johnvaluk 5y agoDid you lock your keys in your trunk and need your key to unlock the trunk release? No problem, just pull off the casing with your hand and poke the mechanism with a stick. Let's face it, car security is generally a game of rock, crowbar, towtruck.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoBlew my mind when a locksmith, presumably taking some pity on me for locking myself out in the cold, showed me how I could pop the manual lock (this technique only works on manually driven locks, not electronic/automatic ones) on my pickup by unscrewing the antenna off the front and and using it to perform a rather simple maneuver in my door lock.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoThis is a joke... For a 2005 vehicle this would be understandable. For 2016-2020 model years absolutely not.
- pluc 5y agoCivics too, which (used to be?) one of the top cars sold in North America (or at least in Canada)
- sequoia 5y agoHeadline is confusing: the vehicles are not sending signals, key fobs are sending signals (on click) and those signals do not change, so if someone records & plays back your "door unlock" signal they can unlock your door. The way this was written, I thought cars were sending signals to one another somehow. Furthermore, the "vehicles sending the same signal" refers not to a single signal shared between vehicles. It means vehicle X consistently relies on "the same" (unchanging) signal X, vehicle Y consistently relies on "the same" (unchanging) signal Y etc. As written, it sounds like every single honda of the same year & make uses one, shared signal which is not what is meant, unless I'm mistaken.
- asdff 5y agoIt seems like there is a lot of security in just physical stuff. A car that needs you to use a key to unlock the door vs a signal that can be intercepted. A scrap of unimportant looking paper containing passwords vs a compromised password manager. It makes the attack surface so much smaller since, unless you are some VIP, chances are no one is going to ever root around your home for internet account passwords on scraps of paper. Software used by thousands of people presents an attractive target given the work vs reward ratio is so much more favorable, and imo its not a matter of if, but when, these systems do end up compromised. Maybe security in the future starts looking less like obfuscated software solutions, and more like simple analog solutions that ultimately require an operator on location, and are therefore too expensive to carry out to the scale that electronic crime has taken place in the past few decades.
- arajesh 5y agoHi all, the POC does not use rolljam attack+ replay. It is solely based on the replay attack. Unfortunately, these key fobs do not implement rolling codes, I had tested the same on the 2022 civic and it does seem to have rolling codes, but the 2018 does not. I highly recommend that you test out the same vulnerability using GNURadio, the reason why I cannot explain every step is due to the fear that this could be used with malicious intent. Please note that you CANNOT drive away with the vehicle since that relies on the PKE system which is separate. As someone pointed out, it could be possible to drive the car using other methods, but this exploit solely focuses on the RKE. I would be more than happy to explain and clarify any doubts, you may email me at arajesh@umassd.edu :)
- xyst 5y agoI remember seeing this exact attack portrayed in season 1 of Mr. Robot. Very similar setup too.
- therein 5y agoThe POC video looks like it was shot in Champaign, Illinois. But I guess it is UMass.
- langsoul-com 5y agoSeems that this requires a signal from the car FOB, remember seeing Tesla car getting jacked the same way. Would storing fobs in RFID restricting material prevent this?
- danw1979 5y agoMy dad had an early 1990s Renault Espace that used an IR remote opener with fixed codes. I know this because my best friend had one of those cool Casio programmable IR watches and we cloned the opening code from the Espace key fob, and the watch was able to reliably open the car years later… even after it had been sold to a neighbor, who, yes, woke up to find all his car doors wide open one morning after we were old enough to drink alcohol but also old enough to know better.
- dehrmann 5y agoNot a Honda owner, but I park in SF often enough to keep absolutely nothing of value in my car.
- armanzdi 5y ago
- hulitu 5y ago> A hacker can gain complete and unlimited access to locking, unlocking, controlling the windows, opening the trunk, and starting the engine of the target vehicle I think those guys shall make some research before. Starting the engine requires either an immobiliser or a Passive entry functionality. Rolling codes are implemented from a long time. (from some time the RF communication is also encripted usually with AES-256) Will be nice to tell us if those are original dealer vehicles or modified. Basically all the keyfobs produced in the last 15 years have rolling codes, relay attack protection and most of them also encription. At the level at which this article is written i see no need for Honda to make any comment. Source: worked on keyfobs in automotive. Honda is a customer with strict requirements.
- hoppla 5y agoI had an issue where I could not unlock the car or disable the electronic theft prevention. I guess I pressed the alarm button too many times while I was away from the car, and it went out of sync with the car. This was a tx only key fob. This would mean that the car needed to keep track of the rolling code, but to not lock the user out if he accidentally press the button while away from the car, it will need to accept current rolling code state plus some more (a window of accepted codes). Once the car gets a code within the window, it knows the state counter on the key fob and can synchronize. Not sure what to do, I kept pressing the key until I saw the car alarm turn off - it must have been hundreds of presses. But the code must in fact be rolling, because everything worked as normal after that.