6 ms·
Why should we be interested in an anti-woke perspective from the left, when it's just repeating what the right has been pointing out for a long time now? The b
by zozbot234 5y ago
Why should we be interested in an anti-woke perspective from the left, when it's just repeating what the right has been pointing out for a long time now? The basic point that "woke" ideology makes a mockery of genuine efforts to effectively address issues of prejudice based on race, sex or sexual orientation is far from new; indeed it has been raised many times before.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Why should we be interested in an anti-woke perspective from the left, when it's just repeating what the right has been pointing out for a long time now? The obvious reason is ad-hominem thinking is very human and natural, and people will be more receptive to the same message sent by someone otherwise aligned with them than someone otherwise opposed to them. Another possibility is that this article just plain expresses it better, more effectively, or captured an important nuance that your preferred people missed.
- zozbot234 5y agoBut the right has always been working to address prejudiced attitudes; their disagreement with the left on these issues is one of framing and preferred methods (e.g. not everything has to be a "struggle against X!" - and such rhetoric is in many ways a pointless distraction from more relevant dynamics), not so much broader social aims.
- shigawire 5y ago>But the right has always been working to address prejudiced attitudes Are conservatives not by definition trying to conserve the status quo?
- tablespoon 5y ago> Are conservatives not by definition trying to conserve the status quo? IIRC, in the American context there are very, very few conservatives like that. Everyone has some revolutionary project they're working towards, they're just very different and incompatible.
- germinalphrase 5y agoThis does not resonate at all with my experience growing up in a conservative region of the upper Midwest.
- dwater 5y agoI imagine in this context conservative refers to members of the conservative political class and not conservative-voting citizens, who are mostly irrelevant to the goals of the conservative political class.
- brimble 5y agoIt is very important, in some contexts, to distinguish between Republican voters and Republican politicians. What you hear if you talk to the former can be wildly different from what the latter deliver and even what they make planks of their party platform. Notably, the voters tend not to like neoliberalism and globalization and to be big fans of "why don't they just..." solutions for various problems—say, "why don't they just build a wall at the border?" Sound like any recent, prominent R politicians? Yep—he seems to have noticed the large gap between the Republican Party platform and what the average Republican voter you talk to at a diner says they want, then exploited that gap, which worked because the gap is very real and pretty large. This occasionally got a bit weird, like in some of his speeches about how he'd provide "beautiful" healthcare to everyone, which seemed strangely close to some kind of (very vague) messaging about adding a public option of some kind of universal coverage and was met with cheering by his audience. This is because left- and right-wing populism in the US share a surprising amount in common, but those issues and commonalities are often ignored or deliberately sidelined by party elites. This is related to how laws that get passed and policies that are enacted are disturbingly disconnected from public sentiment generally. (none of this should be taken as an endorsement of the former president, I'm just observing the lay of the electoral landscape and how he exploited that. I am also not claiming that a similar difference between typical voters and party leaders/platform doesn't exist for the Democrats—it absolutely does. This is all probably a result of our really shitty FPTP elections.)
- 5y ago
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoConservatives by definition are about hierarchy, privilege, and institutionalised bias in favour of some groups at the expense of other groups. https://kottke.org/21/02/conservatism-and-who-the-law-protects https://kottke.org/21/02/conservatism-and-who-the-law-protec... You could argue that progressive mechanisms like affirmative action are just the same in reverse, and it's true that progressive politics in the US still has a conservative tinge. But there are differences. AA is seen as a temporary rebalancing measure, while conservative privilege is seen as the natural and divinely ordained order of things, for all eternity. It's essentially personal monarchy, as against anti-conservatism which is more layered and complex.
- smm11 5y ago[flagged]
- DarylZero 5y agoThey're not trying to conserve the status quo as such, just conserve the status of the powerful (which may require changing with the times).
- seoaeu 5y ago> But the right has always been working to address prejudiced attitudes Do you really think this is how anyone on the left views the situation?! Folks on the left watch all the right-wing efforts to block LGBT rights, oppose Black Lives Matter, ban a religious minority from entering the country and conclude, "yep I disagree with those guys on issues, but it is true they're the ones working to fight prejudiced attitudes"?
- wahnfrieden 5y agoIt’s a dog whistle for stuff like mens rights activism, all lives matter nonsense
- antiterra 5y agoImagine you are playing a soccer match and there's an unfair referee who gives the other team 30 undeserved goals. You protest and, at the half, they replace the referee with a genuinely fair referee. Is asking for further remedy to make up for those 30 undeserved goals the other team received 'prejudiced?' Player A joins the match for the other team after the half, but does not have the opportunity to make a goal that puts his team in the lead because the team's score has been adjusted from the unfair treatment. Has Player A been unfairly discriminated against? Should your team just be happy they are now in a fair meritocracy and just get on with making goals instead of whining?
- marcosdumay 5y agoYes, the one thing you can count on the Real World is for it to be simple and measurable... But let's keep the soccer metaphor. Player A's game is long ended. They won't even play again. But it's a long championship and they are winning. Now your team is on the last round and will tie with them on points if you win, but will lose on the goal-count tie-breaker. Should the referee grant you 30 goals on your game with an entirely different adversary? And your adversary is on the same situation, they will also tie with A's points if they win. Now what should the referee do?
- antiterra 5y agoThe point of the original metaphor isn’t about disadvantage being simple and measurable, it’s simply about it existing and worthy of attention. A solution here is largely academic, and not readily reached due to massive amounts of missing information. However if the question is simply, is it fair for someone to lose first place because the second place categorization was biased? Sure, it definitely can be.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Why should we be interested in an anti-woke perspective from the left, when it's just repeating what the right has been pointing out for a long time now? Critical use of the term “woke” originated within the Left before the critique was superficially adopted by the Right and then the term was stripped of all meaning and used as a generic term for everything non-Right by the Right; much the same as happened with “political correctness”, which it became a drop-in replacement for on the Right, before it.
- dusted 5y ago
- antiterra 5y agoBecause calling something 'woke' is often a lazy cudgel used to dismiss any progressive idea one disagrees with. If someone agrees with the fundamentals but has an issue with the socialization of those fundamentals then it's less likely to be tainted by bias. One example would be people who are elevating Zelenskyy to superhero status. It's quite likely that Zelenskyy is a flawed person, like the overwhelming majority of us, and making weird lionizing memes of him echoes the same shirtless horse-riding personality cult stuff that preceded Putin's actions. Yet, however overblown the worship or however ineffective 'thoughts & prayers' may be for Ukraine, there's an actual population of people being invaded by another country for reasons most people find entirely objectionable. This stands regardless of whether or not someone is suggesting we boycott the YMCA for not putting a Ukranian flag emote in their twitter profile.
- 30761722 5y ago>Why should we be interested in an anti-woke perspective from the left, when it's just repeating what the right has been pointing out for a long time now? Because two groups can agree on the problem but disagree on the solution. For the left, the solution to the "woke" problem is de-centering identity in order to further the cause of anti-racism, anti-sexism, anti-homophobia, etc; for the right, the solution to the "woke" problem is to deny that any of the problems raised by the "woke" are problems at all -- and in fact to center identity.
- specialist 5y agoI, for one, am interested. My understanding is that "woke" started as shorthand for criticism from POCs towards their nominal white allies (progressives, Democrats, etc). "I know you're trying to help. Please stop." One recurring affront, of allies doing more harm than good, that I've observed many times is "white knighting" (correct term?). A white person will argue in defense of a black position (or cause). While there's black people present, trying to be heard. The correct action would be for a white person to concede their time to a black person. So that we can hear first-hand their input about policies and decisions impacting them. "I don't know. Let's ask a black person what they think." My criticism of wokeness, as a middle class white blue hair, is that maybe haranguing people is not the most effective strategy. Just like how fat shaming back fires. Personal example. I have a friend whose compulsion is to correct my misgendering of others, while I'm talking. Each and every time. Are they really listening to me? Or are they just waiting for me to fuck up and pounce, demonstrating their greater virtue? It's exhausting. Sure, I want to get the genders correct, and certainly don't want to inadvertently offend any one, especially not punch down. But decades of habit don't change over night. And how the fuck am I supposed to know when someone's picked a new pronoun for themselves? Is there a gender registry some where I can reference in real-time? I can't comment specifically on the reactionaries' criticism of wokeness. I assume whatever they're fluffed up about is just part of another grift.