7 ms·
Daily coffee may benefit the heart
- iosono88 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kyleee 5y agojust make sure to filter it through paper, keep french press/chemex/cowboy preparations as a once in a while treat and maybe don't have 5 cups a day, shoot for one nice cup, maybe 2 sometimes
- cnasc 5y agoOne of the defining features of a Chemex is the paper filter it uses
- jrussino 5y agoDoesn't Chemex use a paper filter?
- jliptzin 5y agoYes. I am a huge fan of chemex coffee. I have tried a lot of different machines and the simple chemex always comes out on top.
- xupybd 5y agoCan I ask what role the paper plays? Is it that the granules cause health problems?
- tilt_error 5y agoThe filter stops cholesterols which are abundant in coffee.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoIt doesn’t block cafestol, which increases cholesterol synthesis. Fun fact: not all cholesterol is bad; it’s only the LDL, while HDL is thought to be good for the heart.
- anonuser123456 5y agoFunner facts; HDL is not protective. It correlates negatively with poor glucose control. That is, people with low HDL have impaired glucose control, but raising HDL doesn’t bring any benefit. LDL concentration isn’t meaningful at an individual level. LDL particle counts however are. Lots of small LDL particles are way more atherogenic than a few large particles, given a constant density.
- nkurz 5y agoI don't think this is true. While it's possible that coffee can raise cholesterol levels, it doesn't actual contain any. Here's what the top result off Google for [coffee cholesterol] says: Though brewed coffee does not contain actual cholesterol, it does have two natural oils that contain chemical compounds -- cafestol and kahweol -- which can raise cholesterol levels. https://www.webmd.com/cholesterol-management/coffee-cholesterol-connection https://www.webmd.com/cholesterol-management/coffee-choleste... So yes, filtering probably makes a difference, but not because it's taking out "abundant" cholesterols.
- brailsafe 5y agoAdditionally, dietary cholesterol doesn't increase blood cholesterol levels for the most part
- daveidol 5y agoWhat's wrong with french press?
- stubish 5y agoOther studies have shown a correlation with mortality and filtered/unfiltered coffee. Which goes a long way to explaining how some coffee studies showed benefits and others problems, because the studies tended to be regional and were studying slightly different things. https://www.wellandgood.com/unfiltered-coffee-study/ https://www.wellandgood.com/unfiltered-coffee-study/ https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/2047487320914443 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/20474873209144...
- karaterobot 5y agoWhat's the basis for those statements? Especially the "five cups a day" one. The article says otherwise, which is one of the interesting things about it. > Importantly, consuming any amount of coffee was not associated with a higher risk of heart rhythm problems, including atrial fibrillation (AFib) or atrial flutter, which Kistler said is often what clinicians are concerned about. I'm also looking at the Wikipedia article on the health effects of coffee, and it seems like 4 cups a day is sort of the sweet spot for a lot of positive effects, but I don't see anything about more than that being bad in most cases. > A 2012 meta-analysis concluded that people who drank moderate amounts of coffee had a lower rate of heart failure, with the biggest effect found for those who drank more than four cups a day. Five cup a day drinker over here, so I'd love to know if you have conflicting sources.
- esperent 5y agoThis term "cup" is kind of problematic though. 4 espressos? Which have about 120mg of caffeine each. Or 4 starbuck large size? Which have something like 400mg of caffeine.
- algoatecorn 5y agoThe general convention is that a cup of coffee represents 80-100mg of caffeine, usually in the form of 8oz drip coffee = 1 US cup
- ALittleLight 5y agoCaffeine can raise intraocular pressure which puts you at increased risk from glaucoma - especially if you already have a genetic predisposition for it.
- bmn__ 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22978219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22978219
- JimTheMan 5y agoIt's super addictive (at least for me). I'll go from one cup a day to 5 in a flash, and wonder why I'm anxious all the time.
- nojs 5y agoIt’s always interesting to reverse the direction of causality in these kinds of articles and see if it’s plausible. Could it simply be that people with heart problems drink less coffee?
- waterhouse 5y agoYup. Or: people who have decent jobs and are conscientious about them are more likely to decide to drink coffee daily to make themselves more productive, and these traits also make them more likely to (a) be more conscientious about their health, (b) have health insurance and be more able to pay medical bills. I don't have numbers on this, but I have the impression that many people drink coffee on weekdays in order to be awake for their job—and they probably wouldn't make it a daily thing if they didn't have a job—and therefore daily coffee drinkers will contain a much higher proportion of people who are healthy enough to hold down a job.
- ludicast 5y agoThis is always my thought as well. I believe coffee drinkers are less likely to commit suicide too, which definitely would align with the purpose a job gives you (fwiw).
- Jedd 5y agoPrima facie this seems an unlikely causal direction. After about ten days of drinking {an amount} of coffee, your tolerance adjusts, and you're aligned to someone who does not drink coffee at all. You're effectively just maintaining a new baseline, but have developed a regular expenditure / tactile ceremony. The 'make themselves more productive' claim would need some citations to back that up, as I suspect most is self-reporting anecdata.
- anyfoo 5y ago> After about ten days of drinking {an amount} of coffee, your tolerance adjusts, and you're aligned to someone who does not drink coffee at all. Is that really true? I'm speaking from a position of ignorance here, but then that's a very strong statement with non-obvious validity to me. I know that substance tolerance exists (at least it's a very common idea), but is it so generic that it applies to a) all effects and each of those effects in its entirety, and b) to all effective substances that make up coffee? And as a more specific example, I don't think I've ever taken something like "heroin addicts need to take heroin just to feel normal again, and more to feel a high" so literally that I thought they would function "normally" as in exactly like a non-heroin user would when taking an exact dosage to counteract their tolerance.
- adwi 5y ago> “Because coffee can quicken heart rate, some people worry that drinking it could trigger or worsen certain heart issues... We found coffee drinking had either a neutral effect—meaning that it did no harm—or was associated with benefits to heart health.” I’ve often wondered this effect as it relates to widely prescribed prescription stimulants (ie adderrall)… is an artificially elevated heart rate damaging or strengthening the system?
- caleb-allen 5y agoMy totally uneducated guess would be that whatever long term health effects that stimulants have on heart rate are minor compared to other stimulant effects (like blood pressure, appetite changes, etc)
- hnuser123456 5y agoI was on prescription stims for about 8 years. My heart rate was significantly higher in gym class than most, despite being relatively in-shape. However, I was apparently on them for so long that my RHR was permanently elevated. I almost never go below 85, over 10 years later. I doubt this was a net benefit for heart health.
- stubish 5y agoIt seems plausible that the increase in heart rate, blood pressure slightly make up for our general lack of exercise. And when you are studying heart disease and end-of-life, pretty much everyone being studied has a lack of exercise by definition.
- retrac 5y agoWell, there's a reason a screening EKG and sometimes periodic monitoring is recommended for people taking stimulants. There seems to be a general medical opinion that stimulants tax an already-taxed heart. It seems more ambiguous for people with healthy hearts. And given that obesity and drug addiction are common consequences of untreated ADHD, even if they are mildly cardiotoxic, they may still reduce the risk of heart disease when properly prescribed. (I'm no doctor, FWIW.)
- throw7 5y ago
- AreYouSirius 5y agoCoffeine is increasing chance of dissociation happening without outside stimuli, increasing likely hood of non substance addiction hundreds of times..... not worth risk. combined with most games and tv shows that are "casino like " yeah, you lose money long term drinking coffeee / tea. Do not forget to buy energy drinks to your teenagers for long term effecs, having affecting them sooner in their lives! More space / money / profit for non drinking people.
- abrichr 5y ago> Coffeine is increasing chance of dissociation happening without outside stimuli, increasing likely hood of non substance addiction hundreds of times Could you please provide a source for further reading?
- AreYouSirius 5y ago
- jet_32951 5y agoYagh. Today coffee is good for you. Yesterday and tomorrow it is bad for you. The thread running through nutritional research is "yep, could be good or bad for you", so why not do what pleases you?
- anyfoo 5y agoTo be fair, and maybe it's my bias as a coffee drinker speaking here, but from what I've observed so far, moderate coffee consumption seems to much more often be assessed as positive, health-wise, or at least "not bad". And this seems entirely in contrast to, say, alcohol.
- throwaway889900 5y agoPâro!
- mjklin 5y agohttps://www.theonion.com/eggs-good-for-you-this-week-1819565159/amp https://www.theonion.com/eggs-good-for-you-this-week-1819565...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- esperent 5y agoScientists have been collectively saying coffee is good for you, with more and more confidence, for about 30 years now. If you keep hearing that's it's bad, it means you need to improve your information sources.
- qiskit 5y agoMy first thought was I could have sworn I read something about coffee being bad for you not too long ago. Second thought, I wonder who funded this study. Thirdly, there was research showing that most nutrition research is nonsense. Everything we were told about cholestoral, fat and food pyramid turned out to be nonsense. I just ignore most of these nutrition "studies" and just stick to moderation and live my life.
- bin_bash 5y agoNote that this article is talking about "coffee", not "caffeine". Many of the benefits can be had from decaf. As I understand coffee is one of the major sources of antioxidants in standard American diets which is probably a big reason for this.
- esperent 5y ago> Many of the benefits can be had from decaf. The problem with a statement like this is that their have been decades of studies with normal coffee while there have been far fewer with decaf.
- stubish 5y agoThe article is talking about both coffee and caffeine. Quoting from the article: "Decaf coffee did not have favorable effects against incident arrhythmia but did reduce cardiovascular disease, with the exception of heart failure. Kistler said the findings suggest caffeinated coffee is preferable across the board, and there are no cardiovascular benefits to choosing decaf over caffeinated coffees."
- bin_bash 5y agoThe article does not discuss caffeine on its own. You're making an assumption that because caffeinated coffee seems to have more benefits than decaf therefore it must be caffeine itself that has the benefits. The article also states: > People often equate coffee with caffeine, but coffee beans actually have over 100 biologically active compounds. These substances can help reduce oxidative stress and inflammation, improve insulin sensitivity, boost metabolism, inhibit the gut’s absorption of fat and block receptors known to be involved with abnormal heart rhythms.
- anonuser123456 5y agoGiven that caffeine inhibits PCSK-9, this would be expected.
- reducesuffering 5y agoOne of the possible major problems with decaf are the extra processing steps. You're wading into "processed foods" territory. "The most-common methods of decaffeination involve chemical solvents, usually ethyl acetate or methylene chloride. In the direct method, the coffee beans are steamed and then rinsed repeatedly with the chemical solvent to flush away the caffeine."[0] It is not a given that the coffee doesn't have extra unhealthy chemicals or is stripped away of vital nutrients besides caffeine. [0]https://www.britannica.com/story/how-is-coffee-decaffeinated https://www.britannica.com/story/how-is-coffee-decaffeinated
- stubish 5y agoYay, a study that actually talks about instant coffee too. Does anyone know where instant coffee sits in relation to filtered or unfiltered coffee in other studies? Yes, I'm a complete barbarian.
- vmurthy 5y agoHmmm , from memory , instant coffee is usually Robusta type of bean which is more acidic. The study you are looking for , then, are studies which track robusta v/s arabica. I doubt someone could get funding for this , though :)
- atchoo 5y ago> Robusta type of bean which is more acidic Other way around. It's more bitter - partly from much higher caffeine. Classic Robusta would be bitter/smokey/earthy whereas as a citrusy/fruity/acidic coffee would be Arabica.
- baby 5y agoEvery time this comes up, I ask this question: is this because people with stronger hearts can drink coffee, and people with weaker hearts can't. My body definitely cannot tolerate coffee.
- xelxebar 5y agoHas anyone else developed caffeine addiction from a daily coffee habit? I used to drink one cup in the morning every day. However, after a couple years of this, I started experiencing lethargy and mood depression which would both be temporarily alleviated with the morning coffee. Then my girlfriend at the time surreptitiously replaced my coffee grinds with decaffeinated ones. After a week of headaches and cold-like symptoms, I returned to "baseline normal". These days I cannot have even small amounts of caffeine without the next day turning into a blur of mental fog and apathy. Am I just extraordinarily sensitive, or is this a thing?
- CoastalCoder 5y agoThis is a very common issue for working-age adults.
- maxlamb 5y agoYep that’s classic caffeine withdrawal symptoms for you. At least going from one coffee to zero is not too bad, some people who try to go from 5-6 cups/daily to zero will have a much harder time
- jostmey 5y agoI would not tolerate someone switching my drink on me without my permission
- na85 5y agoI'm fairly certain that caffeine addiction is quite common in North America at least. I myself develop debilitating headaches if I don't have my first coffee by 8:30 or so. I usually require a second around noon. I have young kids so sometimes you just gotta have that third cup, ya know? I have a little bialetti stovetop coffee maker. It's not quite espresso but it's thick and strong, just how I like my legal addictive stimulants.
- rthomas6 5y agoI am in the midst of caffeine dependence, and have been for years. I don't feel bad the next day though, I just need my morning coffee to feel functional. And an afternoon coffee. I am slowly reducing the caffeine by switching out the afternoon coffee with two cups, and now one cup of tea. Even that is not easy. When I tried to quit cold turkey, I lasted about a week, and the depression part of the withdrawal symptoms were just too much for me. I felt terrible every day, and it didn't seem to be easing up when I gave up after a week.
- dghughes 5y agoI had to stop drinking coffee that I made in a French press. I think it was harming my liver I had a dull ache in my right side upper abdomen. I've stopped drinking coffee from a French press and just have regular drip brew. My theory is it was the cafestol and/or kahweol oils since most other coffee brew methods filter the coffee out oils. The French press coffee is very silky compared to drip coffee it's as if you put glycerin in it. Caffeine never bothered me which is odd since I used to be very sensitive to it. One sip of coffee just one tiny sip used to make my heart race. Now my usual time is (was) to have my coffee at about 7pm or 8pm. I got used to it and it never bothered my sleep.
- brailsafe 5y agoI love french press, but don't often make it because it's a little messy. I tend to do filtered pour overs more often. If you're interested in getting a bit of both worlds, you might want to try the Clever Dripper, which uses immersion brewing like the french press, and a paper filter like a pour over. Haven't tried it myself, but I hear it's great.
- boppo1 5y agoWhen I try to quit coffee the "withdrawal" doesn't go away. I went without for a MONTH and felt consistently like garbage the whole time. It's too bad too because my doctor says I gotta try to lower my BP.
- tsol 5y agoIt should only last about a week. Caffeine discontinuation shouldn't be that long. Ever try decaf?
- dustingetz 5y agotry copious amounts of black tea
- freedomben 5y agoJust in case it helps even one other person, caffeine was causing me to have severe anxiety. It took me years to realize it could be the caffeine and to try abstaining. It's a subtle and inconsistent link, but there's no doubt in my mind now that caffeine was the cause (or at least an exacerbating factor). I love caffeine and coffee, so I had to prove it to myself repeatedly before finally accepting it. If you suffer from anxiety, try quitting caffeine. It will suck for several days (in my wife's case a couple of weeks) but if you eliminate or reduce your anxiety, your life will improve more than realize.
- d1str0 5y agoSame. I have yet to fully quit but it definitely exacerbates my anxiety more than it seems for most people. My very first anxiety attack was also about an hour after coffee and was definitely a factor. I try and just get hot chocolates nowadays. :)
- abledon 5y agoGlad you figured this out. I find it wild that so many people otherwise really smart/logical, struggle with connecting their diet to their emotional mood. goes to show how still misunderstood our bodies are. Another symptom I've noticed is coffee will increase the 'cracking' of joints. (I think this is due to it interfering with calcium/acidity levels in the body). The only time I ever had flashes of anxiety was after a 2-month long, 2 pots of coffee / day diet. Interesting from a philosophical perspective that kidneys and the neighbouring adrenals are affected by caffeine, and in ancient eastern texts, the monks had identified kidneys as 'the seat of fear' (i.e. anxiety).
- gjhh244 5y agoI recommend testing Yerba Mate as an alternative to coffee. For me drinking even one or two cups of coffee can give a bad, anxious mood later in the day as caffeine withdraws. Meanwhile Mate seems to give similar energy, but the withdrawal feels more gradual, not giving me such bad mood. Just get green, non smoke-dried version if you can.
- dt123 5y agosame here, it worries me how many people are unaware of this :(
- unrealp 5y agoI have a rare eye condition related to caffeine. If i drink caffeine for a few days (any form - coffee/coke/,,) i get retinal stroke. basically some capillaries in the eye block and i develop blind spot. I see noisy spot for a few days in vision and the visual system adjusts in software and i no longer see the noisy spot. This stopped happening completely since I stopped all caffeine. Some years back I drank coffee for a few days and happened again. Since the topic is heart related I am wondering of there is a connection to blood vessels damage. Maybe caffeine acts as a mild stressor? mild stressors are known to trigger the protective systems and thats why we see the benefits with respect to heart?
- hcarvalhoalves 5y agoI get the same effect on the vision when I drink more than espresso a day, or if I drink on empty stomach and the absorption is quicker. It goes away in a few minutes, but it’s scary the first time. I believe it’s because caffeine has a vasoconstriction effect, it can reduce blood flow to the retina, the same happens on the brain (lots of small capillaries), that’s why people get headaches on coffee addiction too.
- unrealp 5y ago
- fumblebee 5y agoJust don’t go drinking too much! Beyond the surface level issues associated with too much coffee (dependency, sleep issues, skittishness, etc), it’s known that coffee does contain small amount of the carcinogen acrylamide. And while the jury is still out on the extent of the risks, it probably won’t increase the risks of cancer in the long run if you’re an average coffee drinker. This article gives a good overview [1] [1] https://theconversation.com/amp/fact-check-does-coffee-cause-cancer-95387 https://theconversation.com/amp/fact-check-does-coffee-cause...
- m4rc3lv 5y agoWhen I have one cup of coffee my stress hormones increase. When I would drink coffee every day then my cortisol level would be high all the time. So this study does not apply to me.
- octobus2021 5y agoStrong vibes of "a glass of wine per day" study/ies. Would be curious to see who funded this one...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]