4 ms·
> Instead of malware, a better approach to free expression would be to use messages in commit logs to send anti-propaganda messages and to issue trackers to sha
by ekianjo 5y ago
> Instead of malware, a better approach to free expression would be to use messages in commit logs to send anti-propaganda messages and to issue trackers to share accurate news inside Russia of what is really happening in Ukraine at the hands of the Russian military, to cite two obvious possibilities
How about not taking sides instead of acting like a kid believing one side is black and the other white with absolutely no gradient in the middle? Also, propaganda goes both sides, just like in absolutely every conflict in History. Stop being a tool of your own government.
- _Nat_ 5y agoA lot of folks are just anti-war and are protesting the invasion for being an act of military-aggression.
- matsemann 5y agoNot taking a side is agreeing with the oppressor.
- ekianjo 5y agoNo, not taking sides is just not taking sides. There's no need to turn such a position into a shortcut to something else. It's as stupid as the kids saying "if you are not with us you are against us". Typical populist bullshit.
- Cederfjard 5y agoAre there limits to this, or do you think ”not taking sides” is a morally defensible position to have regarding everything? Is it ethical to be neutral when it comes to the holocaust?
- mwcampbell 5y agoI think it's OK to refrain from taking sides about anything that we don't have firsthand knowledge about. There's no shortage of political and moral busybodies in the world, especially now that we have the Internet. I'm sure I've been one at times. So I think it's not so bad if we start going in the other direction, just minding our own business and sticking to things we can actually do something about. I should get back to that.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoIt's perfectly ethical to not be loudly and publicly performing an anti-holocaust view 24/7/365, and failing to do that does not make one "pro-holocaust". The list of Bad Things is endless, and failing to address any one of them does not make you in favor of that Bad Thing. It just doesn't. You're just trying to bully people into spending their time amplifying your particular protest, and bullying in itself is a Bad Thing.
- slackfan 5y ago
- matsemann 5y agoHow hard is it to just say "I think Russia is wrong for invading Ukraine and killing people"? That's all you have to do. Just write it. If you can't do that, but still want to engage in the discussion on the topic, your standpoint is clear. You're not some holier person not taking a stand. You have taken one, you just don't dare to spell it out.
- ekianjo 5y ago> If you can't do that, but still want to engage in the discussion on the topic, your standpoint is clear. That's not the topic at hand. The topic is, you don't need to pollute every thing you work on out there with your preachy opinions on every single topic, especially when you are whole-fully ignorant about what's actually happening, the in-and-outs of the conflict, because you are in a state of constant propaganda, whether you are in Russia or in the West. And this is not just about the conflict at hand, it's about this disgusting habit these days of bringing politics in all walks of life where it was not before.
- matsemann 5y agoYou can't blame people for doing whatever they can when they are literally being bombed. Same with BLM mentioned in another subthread, it's easy to don't care when the issues don't affect you, but for other's it's their daily life. Of course it colors what people do. People who claim there were no politics before, were just oblivious to others' struggle. Which is ok, but it still happened, you were just sheltered or privileged.
- ekianjo 5y ago> You can't blame people for doing whatever they can when they are literally being bombed. I can't remember when people cared about the bombs falling everyday in Yemen. How absurd is it for people to suddenly care and cry publicly about one country's conflict while another much bloodier one, not too far away, is being completely ignored. Is their blood less red? Are their children worth less? Systemic racism maybe, since these are not white people? Mass media (including social media nowadays) is what shapes what people care and feel concerned about. It's not about people's values, this goes on to say a lot more about how easy people can be manipulated to project violence onto anything they had no clue about 5 minutes ago, as long as you repeat it all day long.
- slackfan 5y ago
- cryptoegorophy 5y agoNot silent when it is ukraine, but other non white part of the world - it is ok to be silent, right? BLM “peaceful “ protest also ok to be silent? Since when do we switched from Covid experts to ukraine experts? Can you even find ukraine on the map? The only non silent thing should be engraved in anyones head is - war is bad.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThen you better be a well informed person or otherwise you will quickly become the latter.
- swat535 5y agoEstonia, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland,.. remained neutral during Wolrd War II. Are you saying they were agreeing with the oppressor? It must take some serious mental gymnastics on your part to write such statement.
- bitcharmer 5y agoRussia's aggression is pretty one sided. Not taking sides is like turning you eyes away.
- slackfan 5y ago
- Errancer 5y agoHow about taking sides instead of acting like a kid believing the existence of gray negates the existence of white and black. Perspectivism is the beginning of inquiry, not the end of it. Stop being a tool of your own social superstitions.
- boffinism 5y agoUsing the existence of shades of grey to deny the existence of black and white is equally childish in my opinion...
- GranularRecipe 5y agoOpen source is driven by many opioniated and idealistic people who also worry about the current geopolitical development. They might make their opinions known in a non-destructive manner. You might not like it, fair enough, but expressing one's opinion in commit messages is neither childish nor an instrumentalisation by any government.
- ekianjo 5y ago> expressing one's opinion in commit messages is neither childish nor an instrumentalisation by any government. It's childish because it's incredibly naive to think that commit messages are going to change anyone's mind. Instead they will look like someone preaching for no reason. Next, how about doing an online petition as well? /s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoWas this also your stance during BLM protests? Asking for a friend.
- dmos62 5y ago> How about not taking sides instead of acting like a kid If you have the power to do something and you don't, that's taking a side. You either oppose something or you enable it. At least own that. If you're saying you're neutral, you either agree with the unpopular side and are scared to admit it, or you can't form an opinion because you're uninformed and thus uncivil, or you feel unaffected by what's happening and thus discompassionate. Either way, that's pretty much the definition of "acting like a kid". By the way, everything is not propaganda: anti-propaganda can just be the truth.
- ekianjo 5y ago> If you have the power to do something and you don't, that's taking a side. Pushing political commit messages is not "power". If you like like everyone around you you are not a rebel, just a conformist. And using indiscriminate IP-location malware to annoy people is the textbook definition of evil child behavior. I'm not sure what exactly you are trying to defend here. > By the way, everything is not propaganda: anti-propaganda can just be the truth. How do you know what the truth is when you have no foot on the ground?
- dmos62 5y ago> Pushing political commit messages is not "power". I'm not debating whether it works or whether it's the right form of activism. I'm responding to your comment. Namely you saying that taking a side is childish. > If you like like everyone around you you are not a rebel, just a conformist. If your goal is to follow the herd, that's bad. If it's to go in the opposite direction, that's the same thing. I'd encourage a person like that to think about more than himself. > How do you know what the truth is when you have no foot on the ground? Are you disputing the recent Russia's invasion of Ukraine?
- mwcampbell 5y ago> Are you disputing the recent Russia's invasion of Ukraine? Not the GP. I don't specifically dispute that. But in a time when many fictional stories can be told through video, I think it's reasonable to be unsure and neutral on things that we don't have direct knowledge about. Put another way, I think being neutral and silent by default is a necessary defense against manipulation.
- pvaldes 5y agoCut the BS. One part has been reported mass butchering newborns and pregnant women in hospitals. I hardly could think in anything more wrong than this. There is not 'I can explain it' or 'this is not what it seems' or 'they must have a reason' or 'just kidding' here. This is not normal behavior in humans. There is not any gray area about the war crimes of the Russian army. Had been videotaped, narrated, proven and reported extensively. Each building is a proof. And now they are talking about using chemical weapons to speed up this genocide. Seriously, what Russians were expecting? A clap? Not taking sides? We are animals brain-wired to develop a strong reaction of seek and destroy in this cases. In less civilized times the murderers would be hunted and mashed to grinded meat. Not more excuses. Don't call us kids, silly, ignorant, inconvenient or Russophobes. We are furious. We want this to stop. Right now.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThere are no "two sides" to imperialism.