3 ms·
Because open source is idealistic and altruistic to a fault; it is the antithesis to "got mine, fuck you", or that of the capitalist "fuck you, pay me". If you
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
Because open source is idealistic and altruistic to a fault; it is the antithesis to "got mine, fuck you", or that of the capitalist "fuck you, pay me". If you limit access to anyone it is, by definition, no longer open source. I mean there's probably plenty of licenses that restrict commercial usage of open source software.
That said, I'm all for open source software monetization; include messages in the README, code, or logging that basically says something to the tune of "If you are using this for commercial purposes, please consider donating / sponsoring / hiring". I think Github and co can do a lot more as well to encourage big corporations to pay open source contributors.
- harry8 5y agoCounter point: if bigcos are so damn stupid they avoid open source & Free software for idiotic reasons that creates space for less stupid startups who will do and be better. Why do we need to save the rich ignorant and prejudiced from themselves? They're not worthy object of charity.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> not worthy object of charity Most people, certainly productive people, are employed by companies. Take an extremist position on who your product works for and you limit the developer pool. An agnostic competitor would be expected to replace you.
- harry8 5y agoIt's not an extremist position to say you don't have to do much about big companies feelings about using Free software. You don't have to expend your scarce resources to make them feel comfortable. Note well here I am talking about nothing whatever of substance, this is all pure marketing. If big cos turn from Free software due to prejudice and ignorance about what it is, what it does and how to manage it, rather than riding it like Google, Facebook, Apple etc to untold riches (that were not obtainable to those companies without Free software), that's not any Free software developers' problem. The GPL, LGPL, BSD, Apache licenses have not changed. A rogue actions by any supplier comes directly under bargaining powers of suppliers in your corporate strategy risk analysis. If it happens you deal with it and you've already thought about it or you have no business in making decisions in a large company. If any big company runs away scared from Free software, bye. Google literally shot to glory when they went extra hard at using Free software when established big companies were scared. It's not a sufficient condition for their success but it was absolutely a necessary one. They don't get going if they have to pay for operating systems alone.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> I am talking about nothing whatever of substance, this is all pure marketing This is fair. Would note that one advantage to teams that do the outreach and accommodation can be support, financial and contributions. But that's speculative and not the right move for every team.
- harry8 5y ago>It wasn't that long ago that using open source software required a lot of politicking inside my clients, and we could easily go back there with enough spooked executives. That's what this discussion is about. You want to monetize your Free software project? That's a very different discussion to this one, about which nobody writing Free software need care. Note also the "protestware" or whatever nonsense this is didn't hit anyone with a support contract from the developer, or am I wrong with that guess? So big co.s are using a metric ship load of code that they didn't pay a cent for and don't bother even reading once. Just hit the auto-update while paying and contributing nothing,, then claim this is the fault of Free software somehow? Yeah. Ok. Bye. The value proposition sucks for them, apparently so they'll pay someone a lot of money to solve that. Nobody else need care - unless you're sliding into that space to solve that problem for them.
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoPart of being idealistic is standing up for what is right but without causing more harm than necessary. > If you limit access to anyone it is, by definition, no longer open source Licensing disagrees. Not everything opensource is permissive.
- dspillett 5y ago> Part of being idealistic is standing up for what is right but without causing more harm than necessary. Exactly. Setting off a logic bomb targetted at whole countries is not “without causing more harm than necessary”. Add wilful destruction to a protest, especially if that destruction is such that is affects innocent bystanders, and you no longer have a protest, you have a riot.
- rectang 5y agoI'm pretty sure the reference is just to the "no discrimination against people/groups/fields-of-endeavor" ethos. See OSI's Open Source Definition clauses 5 and 6. https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd