19 ms·
He purchased a TB monitor to plug into a device that doesn't support TB and says "it shouldn't be this hard". Commenters complain that it's 60 Hz but I don't k
by gumby 5y ago
He purchased a TB monitor to plug into a device that doesn't support TB and says "it shouldn't be this hard".
Commenters complain that it's 60 Hz but I don't know of an external interconnect that could drive that many pixels any faster.
HN is weird sometimes.
(I don't plan to buy this monitor either, but not for the reasons above. The LG 5K monitors are perfectly adequate for my needs. And like the post's author I was sorry to see target display go).
- searls 5y agoTough but fair.
- brigade 5y agoSamsung G9 is for sale now, and it pushes 5120x1440 at 240Hz without subsampling through DisplayPort 1.4, which is the exact same pixel rate as 5120x2880 at 120Hz.
- searls 5y agoImportant to note that this is a 110dpi monitor and therefore not retina nor suitable for integer resolution scaling, whereas the Studio Display is 218dpi. I care a lot more about resolution and dot pitch than about frame rates higher than 60hz
- noahtallen 5y agoThat’s fair, but the overall point is that Apple could have added a standard connector (normal Display Port) without sacrificing quality.
- fckgw 5y agoWhy would Apple add a connector that none of their computers use?
- function_seven 5y agoSo people like me would consider buying it. I have a Mac. I also have a work-issued PC. I have both machines connected to the same displays, and switch between them. DisplayPort isn't some obsolete technology here. I understand why this display doesn't have HDMI, or DVI, or VGA, or Composite, or S-Video, etc. But DisplayPort would be nice.
- stanmancan 5y agoApple hasn't been in the business of selling you things to use on non-Apple devices for a very... very long time.
- gumby 5y ago> DisplayPort isn't some obsolete technology here...DisplayPort would be nice. Type C is one of the standard interfaces for the Displayport standard, and Displayport is the standard video transport on a thunderbolt cable.
- technobabbler 5y ago...so, wait, DisplayPort is really more like DisplayProtocol, but there's also a physical port called DisplayPort? :(
- ThreePinkApples 5y agoThat's how data cables/ports work. There is a DisplayPort "protocol", then there are DisplayPort physical connectors and cables. Then there are other types of physical connectors and cables that also can be used with DisplayPort "protocol". Same thing for USB, or HDMI etc. Yes, it's confusing. But it's also a good thing as you can carry lots of stuff over the same cable and connector. A USB-C type cable and connector can carry USB, Thunderbolt, DisplayPort, HDMI, even analogue audio. Before USB-C, Thunderbolt was using mini-DisplaPort connector and cables.
- technobabbler 5y ago
- jolux 5y agoThunderbolt 4 is a standard interface, and it supports DisplayPort 1.4 as well as 2.0.
- noahtallen 5y agoThat’s a good point — what I meant was that the DP connector found on graphics cards is pretty common (“standard”), so should be included. As a frame of reference, a similarly priced monitor I have has 2x HDMI, DisplayPort, thunderbolt 3, and a few USB A ports if you use it as a thunderbolt hub. And it’s a 144hz ultrawide with HDR support. And while I acknowledge that Apple made a trade off for pixel density, they weren’t forced to make tradeoffs for other features that are common on high end monitors.
- jolux 5y ago> the DP connector found on graphics cards is pretty common (“standard”) So are D-sub connectors and HDMI. Should it have those as well? What about S-Video? Composite? > they weren’t forced to make tradeoffs for other features that are common on high end monitors They don't sell any products with DisplayPort connectors, nor do I think they've ever done so (certainly not recently). Selling a product with that connector is a commitment on some level to supporting what people plug into it, and as demonstrated by the OP, PCs are not really supported. It's also more engineering effort, but that's probably marginal. This is a standard connector with cheap cables that adapt it to legacy devices using the DP alternate mode of USB-C. Apple are known for getting rid of legacy connectors. USB-C is a superior technology, it's only a matter of time before it's used for everything, and I appreciate Apple's efforts to hasten that day.
- hbn 5y agoI have one and somehow managed to get it into a mode where the UI was an appropriate size and it ran at 120Hz. Worked perfectly for almost a year, then I updated to Monterey and cannot for the life of me get it to run in HiDPI mode at my old preferred scaling. Tried all the third party monitor controlling apps (EasyRes doesn't have the scaling I'd like in the HiDPI list of resolutions) I might just get rid of the monitor. I'm not convinced I loved it for my workflow anyway compared to 2 monitors where I can switch my Mac workspaces independently
- alwillis 5y agoYes—give me the resolution vs refresh rate if I have to pick.
- account42 5y ago110dpi can work without any scaling depending on your eyesight.
- naoqj 5y ago1440p for 49" in 2022? You can probably pick the pixels with your fingers.
- cehrlich 5y agoI don't think the person you're replying to was comparing those two monitors, just pointing out that 5120x2880 at 120hz is the same amount of data as 5120x1440 at 240hz.
- ihuman 5y agoIt's an ultrawide, so its really two 1440p 26" screens next to each other
- naoqj 5y agoDoesn't change anything at all. It's a shame that they are selling that. And it costs 1600€! It's insane.
- nohr 5y agoThat renders your complain null and void, what's wrong with you?
- Rebelgecko 5y agoAre there any alternatives you'd recommend? When last I looked I was surprised how limited the options were for 2160p + higher refresh rates (I guess maybe cables/ports/GPUs need time to catch up?)
- ninkendo 5y agoUnfortunately there are no monitors sold by any company other than Apple (and LG for that one 5K display they made specifically _for_ apple) that have a “retina” pixel density, which I would define as >200 PPI. (The Studio Display’s is 218.) Every ginormous “4k2k” or whatever display is just that: ginormous, so the actual pixel density is much lower, and is comparable to a typical (smaller, 1440p, etc) display. I suspect this is because the fabrication of the LCDs is tuned to a particular pixel size, so if a company wants to make a 4K monitor, they scale existing LCD production up to a large enough size that they can get it 2160 pixels tall (by however wide), and that’s the size of the display. They can advertise having both a large display (which people like) and 4K (which people like), so there’s no downside to the manufacturers. But if you want actual high pixel density, 200+PPI, your options are basically an Apple monitor (LG’s apple-sold display notwithstanding), or a smartphone. (I’d love to be proven wrong on this! My holy grail monitor is 200+ppi, 120+Hz, large (27”+), and ideally ultrawide, but alas, such a thing doesn’t exist.)
- frankchn 5y agoDoes it use Display Stream Compression or something? Raw 5120x1440 x 240 fps x 8 bits x 3 colors = 39.55 Gbits/sec. DP1.4 has a maximum data rate of 25.92 Gbits/sec. DP2.0 on the other hand does 77.37 Gbits/sec.
- artimaeis 5y agoThe Samsung G9 is only capable of achieving 240Hz with display stream compression (DSC). Source: https://www.rtings.com/monitor/reviews/samsung/odyssey-g9 https://www.rtings.com/monitor/reviews/samsung/odyssey-g9.
- cehrlich 5y agoApple's $5000+ Pro Display XDR uses DSC when you plug stuff into the rear USB ports, so I think it would be fine to use it on the Studio Display also.
- brigade 5y agoEven without anything plugged in, or any other displays downstream of the host thunderbolt port, XDR will preferentially negotiate one HBR2+DSC stream if the host supports it. (17.28gbps) Which yes, means that a hypothetical 6k120 could be done at the same compression level as current 6k60 by using both HBR2 streams that a Thunderbolt 4 host port is required to support.
- radicality 5y agoHey, would you have some details/info on how I can figure out what exactly my XDR is ‘doing’ (find its connection type like you explained, and pixel depth that the graphics card is outputting - 8 bit vs 10 bit). I have the M1 Max 14”, and also bought the XDR around a month ago for the extra 6k screen real estate. One thing I noticed is that I can’t figure out what pixel depth it’s running at on my M1 (intel shows 30 bit framebuffer in System Report, M1 shows nothing). SwitchResX software is reporting that it’s running in “Millions of Colors” (8 bit), but I’m not sure if that’s true. The same setup is reporting Billions of Colors on an intel MacBook. It overall seems to be there’s things missing for the XDR <-> M1 interactions :S
- liquidise 5y agoDSC was arguably the hallmark change of DisplayPort 1.4[1]. To say something is "only capable of achieving" its performance by utilizing the very tech it is built on feels like there has been a misunderstanding somewhere. To be clear, Display Stream Compression is different from Chroma Subsampling[2], which the parent referenced. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#1.4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#1.4 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chroma_subsampling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chroma_subsampling
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cma 5y ago> Commenters complain that it's 60 Hz but I don't know of an external interconnect that could drive that many pixels any faster. Displayport with DSC (Display Stream Compression) should be able to drive it faster than 60.
- MBCook 5y agoDSC isn’t lossless. It’s fine for games or watching video, but might show artifacts on lots of text. Depending on what you’re using the monitor for (and your personal standards) that may or may not be acceptable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- na85 5y agoNot only that but: >I ordered one the minute that they hit the store in the hope I would receive what I thought I had purchased in 2014 One would think that he'd think twice before dropping that much money on a peripheral. Or at least do some research first. That satirical video where the guy wishes Apple made books so he'd know what to think wasn't far off the mark.
- gumby 5y agoYou get two weeks to return anything you buy from apple, no questions asked. I see why they do it: I bought an apple watch 0 figuring I'd get an idea of what the fuss was about and then buy v3 when they got it figured out. Instead, within the first week, I turned around on my way to work because I hadn't put my watch on. OTOH I got an M1 ipad pro when it launched and ended up returning it and getting an air which was just as good for my needs. As it happens the pro had some hardware bugs anyway but if I'd liked it I would have just asked them to swap it.
- na85 5y agoI guess, but it just seems like the height of disgusting consumerism to spend several thousand dollars on the off chance a monitor has $feature, while planning on returning it and doubling the carbon footprint via shipping, when you could instead just, you know, search the internet.
- snapcore 5y agoTo be fair, in the past when going from DVI, Display Port, VGA, HDMI, etc. to other standards, you could just buy a simple cable. Video card manufacturers would even provide convertors in the box. So it makes sense that people may have expectations for simplicity based on their prior experiences.
- eek2121 5y agoRight. The monitor is a thunderbolt monitor. Furthermore, your GPU must be part of that. With Thunderbolt 4, most people mistake USB-C for Thunderbolt. They are not the same, even if the connector is.
- gumby 5y agoJust to make life more interesting, USB4 is TB3. TB4 is basically TB3 with higher speed floors. None of this is visible through inspection — you have to query the cable or device. When people were farting around with the “one cable to rule them all” a decade or so ago it seemed like a great approach at the time. I don’t remember anybody predicting this downside.
- mschuster91 5y ago> He purchased a TB monitor to plug into a device that doesn't support TB and says "it shouldn't be this hard". For what it's worth, it shouldn't be hard from a purely technical point of view to create a DisplayPort-to-TB adapter - all that should be needed is a Thunderbolt chip with a DP connector for input and a TB connector for the output. The problem is Intel has had exclusive control over TB chips [1] and never released datasheets or made the chips otherwise widely available if you did not order a ridiculous MOQ and signed on for an expensive NDA and got their blessing to implement something like this. Maybe we will see something like this in the next years, now that the TB spec is pretty much an open standard - eventually some third party will finally be able to develop a TB chipset. [1] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-motherboard-asrock-first-thunderbolt-certification-intel https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-motherboard-asrock-fir...
- gumby 5y agoTB & USB 4 (which are the same these days) carries video as DisplayPort by default so a Tb-DisplayPort cable is a relatively simple device and is widely available.