7 ms·
A more accurate headline would be "it spares 93%–97% of people," though the interview meticulously omitted almost all quantifiable information. The hazard ratio
by kragen 5y ago
A more accurate headline would be "it spares 93%–97% of people," though the interview meticulously omitted almost all quantifiable information. The hazard ratios in the paper smitty1110 cited https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01689-3?s=08 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01689-3?s=08 are mostly 1.49–1.85, which as I understand it means that people with covid were 1½–2 times as likely to experience the condition, pericarditis or stroke or whatever, than thr control group. The exceptions are things that normally happen only once in a lifetime, like cardiac arrest (HR=2.45), so we're still talking about a tiny fraction of people.
This justifies the statement in the paper's abstract, "Our results provide evidence that the risk and 1-year burden of cardiovascular disease in survivors of acute COVID-19 are substantial," but (unless I'm misunderstanding the paper) shows that the interview headline is an irresponsible, sensationalist lie.
- exo-pla-net 5y agoFalse. > We went into it thinking that [the risk] was going to be most pronounced and evident in people who smoked a lot or had diabetes, heart disease, kidney disease, or some [other] risk factors. What we found is that even in people who did not have any heart problems start with, were athletic, did not have a high BMI, were not obese, did not smoke, did not have kidney disease or diabetes—even in people who were previously healthy and had no risk factors or problems with the heart—COVID-19 affected them in such a way that manifested the higher risk of heart problems than people who did not get COVID-19. They found that even mild COVID damaged otherwise healthy people's hearts so badly that their risk for heart problems are now comparable to those of obese people. In other words, it does damage your heart. That damage might result in a heart attack, reflected in the increased hazard ratio.
- bigfudge 5y agoNo, there's not enough data to be sure either way, but given that some/most people experience absolutely no lingering symptoms the simplest explanation is that even mild disease cases damage in some people. EDIT: to be clear. We have no idea if the outcome-generating process is continuous or discontinuous. You seem to think it's continuous, analogous to risks from smoking or obesity, but others would assume not.
- Retric 5y agoLingering symptoms isn’t a useful diagnostic tool in this case. Hart damage is generally invisible up until people have a significant problem. This is why young marathon runners occasionally die of undiagnosed heart problems and the elderly get in depth testing before voluntary medical procedures. Hypothetically, if 3/4 of population has the baseline risk and 1/4 the population has 8x the risk then you could say most people are at identical risks. But unless you can determine which population someone was in that’s irrelevant.
- margalabargala 5y ago> They found that even mild COVID damaged otherwise healthy people's hearts so badly that their risk for heart problems are now comparable to those of obese people. > In other words, it does damage your heart. That damage might result in a heart attack, reflected in the increased hazard ratio. This seems an inaccurate reading of what's in the study. They did not find that all people who had COVID had heart damage, which would be the case if "it does damage your heart" were true. Instead it found that some previously healthy people now had some heart damage.
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoWell put, I think this should be considered the prevailing consensus for this discussion, frankly. There’s a lot of noise here…
- hedora 5y agoHow did they know they were previously healthy? Did they have pre-infection health screens?
- cde-v 5y agoYes, they were all vets in the VA system so their pre-infection health had been documented.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 5y agoThanks for clarifying. What percentage of previously healthy people had heart damage from covid? Did they break this down by age and vaccination status?
- borkt 5y agoJust one person but i was an early case (family member went to Wuhan 1-2 times each month. During the firsr year of COVID, as early as march of 2020, i had serious issues with gut and hearth inflamation - repeated bouts that started as back pain, became chest pain, elevated heart-rate to 150 for ~3 days at a time, 24 hours a day. Gradyally the episodes became less frequent leading up to a stroke type event co current with a presumed second bout of covid. Was forced back to work about a week after the issue, and the only other coworker who was near me contracted covid about 10 days later. Following the Stroke type event I lost virtually all of my talent at writing, And ultimately my job, which was very humbling. Ive spent the past year working gig jobs when i can, and fortunately all long covid symptoms have gone away. I feel like my brain is close to 100% but i lack the confidence in myself, my memory, and my writing and am constantly second guessing myself and assume im wrong if in a contested discussion. It really sucks, yet im probably one of the lucky ones
- TrevorJ 5y ago>They found that even mild COVID damaged otherwise healthy people's hearts so badly that their risk for heart problems are now comparable to those of obese people. False. The study did NOT look for heart damage in the study population as a proximal cause for other cardiac events, it simply looked at incidence of cardiac events. Your interpretation is one possible explanation as to why this might be, but the study neither supports nor disproves this explanation.
- Retric 5y agoFalse… Increased incidents is in support of that conclusion, but does not provide direct evidence of it. An important but subtle difference.
- TrevorJ 5y agoLack of evidence supports precisely nothing.
- Retric 5y agoIncreased incidence is evidence as is the known link between viral infections and heart problems. Suppose your car doesn’t start. That supports the possibility of a dead battery, it also supports broken wire or anything else that’s a possible cause. What it doesn’t support is your car being in proper working order. If your car doesn’t start and you haven’t used it in 2 months, well it could be something else but …
- TrevorJ 5y ago>Suppose your car doesn’t start. That supports the possibility of a dead battery, it also supports broken wire or anything else that’s a possible cause. What it doesn’t support is your car being in proper working order. Yes, these are hypotheses. But they are not meaningful in a scientific sense until you design a study and set about to try to disprove them. OP's claim was in relation to precisely what a scientific paper did or did not prove. Therefore, the appropriate level of rigour we need to apply here is a scientific one.
- fallingknife 5y ago> In other words, it does damage your heart. That damage might result in a heart attack, reflected in the increased hazard ratio. Or it only damages the heart in a small number of patients, and that damage always results in heart conditions. It is not possible to tell the difference between these two possibilities without actually taking a sample and looking for asymptomatic heart damage in the affected patients, which this study did not do. These are the stats for heart conditions on mild covid patients from the paper. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01689-3/figures/5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01689-3/figures/5 They don't look bad at all. Where is it stated that this effect is as bad as obesity?
- bhk 5y agoFirst, the study does not even use the term "mild". They did look at three levels of severity: non-hospitalized, hospitalized, and admitted to ICU. The "non-hospitalized" group surely includes people who would describe their case as "worse than any flu", as well as those would describe theirs as "mild" (e.g. a few sniffles for a few days, like a number of my friends recently.) Second, the hazard ratios differ widely between the three levels of severity. For example, for MACE (major adverse cardiac events) versus the contemporary control group, hazard ratios are: Non-hospitalized 1.26 Hospitalized 2.41 ICU 4.36 One would expect a similar gradation of risk by severity among the "non-hospitalized" group.
- froh 5y agoIn the context of this and similar studies non-hospitalized means 'mild', even if it subjectively was 'real bad' Hospitalized is severe ICU is very severe / life threatening
- postalrat 5y agoIs "False." the new "Wrong."?
- JimTheMan 5y agoFalse.Incorrect.Wrong. Are all easy ways to tell if someone is about to speak like Dwight Schrute from the Office.
- wrs 5y agoThe headline is badly phrased but I wouldn’t call it a “lie”. The intended interpretation is that significant long term risks were observed across the broad population, including otherwise healthy people. I perceive pretty widespread belief to the contrary right now, which could be dangerous for public health planning.
- hedora 5y agoFuture experimental vaccines could contain tracker chips and cause autism. ^--- also not a lie. I'd expect John Hopkins to do better though.
- jah242 5y agoI would add that for the non-hospitalised groups it is substantially lower again at more like HR of 1.3-1.4 - (see supplementary tables - https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41591-022-01689-3/MediaObjects/41591_2022_1689_MOESM1_ESM.pdf https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415...) I would also add a few factors that likely mean that this is an upper bound: 1. As noted this is without vaccination 2. The mean age in the study is 60-65 (depending on the regression) 3. There is inherent bias in testing uptake (case ascertainment) over the period of the study early in the pandemic. This means the sample is inevitably skewed towards more severe cases (and will miss a very large fraction of asymptomatic cases) than either the population of Covid positive individuals or the sample of positive covid people today (as now testing is abundant). This is not to say that the study is wrong that COVID increases one's risk of heart disease but for me the language used in the interview does seem inappropriate.
- xorfish 5y agoThe increased risk affects everyone, even if the risk doesn't materialize for everyone.
- jdmichal 5y ago"At increased risk for being at increased risk" is theoretically meaningful, but practically nonsensical unless you can tell which group someone falls into. If you can't, you may as well collapse all the probability into either being at increased risk or not.
- xorfish 5y agoYou have no way of knowing if the increased risk materializes for you. Saying that playing russian roulette doesn't affect you if you don't get the bullet is nonsensical.
- jdmichal 5y agoNo, see, that's not a good comparison. You're already doing exactly what I said, which is compressing to a single probability. There's only one probability in russian roulette. The prior is that you pulled the trigger. The probability is whether you got a bullet. There's two layers of probability in this instance. The prior is that you had COVID. The first layer is whether, due to your infection, you're at increased risk for the various heart diseases. The second layer is whether you actually get heart disease. If you cannot determine which group an individual is in for the first layer, then insisting that it exists doesn't really help except for "well akshually". "You're at risk for increased risks of heart disease." Just collapse the probabilities to a single layer, "You're at increased risks of heart disease."
- dash2 5y agoI now feel much less happy than I did. "Significant increase" could mean anything. A risk ratio of 1.49-1.85 is a huge increase. These conditions are rare but not that rare. Now I should be twice as worried about them? Oosh. Will someone at least tell me that Omicron's not so bad?
- timr 5y ago1.5 is a small increase, particularly when the baseline probabilities are small (as they are here). For context, a "big" increase would be something like smoking, where the effect sizes are measured in HR multiples of ten.
- kragen 5y agoI think it matters a lot whether we're talking about a relative hazard of 1.5 over a lifetime or, as in this case, over a year. If, year after year, people who suffered covid in 02020 and 02021 continue to have 1½–2× the risk of developing pericarditis or stroke or congestive heart failure or all these other health problems, or if people keep getting covid every year, well, because of the high lifetime base rates of those problems, that would be a bigger health problem than anything since before AIDS, bigger than smoking, maybe bigger than anything since the Black Plague. On the other hand, if, say, 1.8% of people develop ischemic heart disease in the year following covid, while 1.1% of people without covid do, and then in the following years they don't get covid again and the hazard rate declines to the base rate of 1.1% per year or whatever, that's still a significant public health problem, but it's not nearly as big as the people covid killed outright. (Those numbers are from Supplementary Table 3 in https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41591-022-01689-3/MediaObjects/41591_2022_1689_MOESM1_ESM.pdf https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415...: "COVID-19 burden" of 18.47 cases of "Ischemic heart disease" at 12 months, and "Contemporary control burden" of 11.19. The other supplementary information is at https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41591-022-01689-3/MediaObjects/41591_2022_1689_MOESM2_ESM.pdf https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415... and https://github.com/yxie618/longCVD https://github.com/yxie618/longCVD.) Though I'm no virologist, I don't know of a plausible mechanism by which covid could cause people to get ischemic heart disease, pulmonary embolisms, etc., after 5 or 10 or 20 years of not having covid. More likely, what's happening is that people who haven't fully recovered from covid are getting blood clots, and that's damaging their organs and sometimes killing them, but after a few months they do fully recover and so these problems stop — unless they get covid again. Given that we now have numerous effective vaccines and a few effective palliatives, it seems likely that even though covid has become endemic, people will be able to avoid suffering this level of damage year after year. But I have to admit it's an open question.
- throwaway22032 5y agoIt's baffling that a public health institution would discredit themselves so obviously in this way. I don't understand the world that these people live in. It's like they don't understand the concept of trust _at all_, they're a few iterations of doubling down on just going into some sort of echochamber nonsense. The headline isn't even true in the superlative sense (e.g. maybe it spares the odd person, but we make a reasonable allowance for that in colloquial speech.). It's in fact the case that it spares the vast majority - most of us have zero detectable symptoms, both during infection and after the fact.
- everybodyknows 5y ago> It's baffling that a public health institution would discredit themselves so obviously ... Here's your proximate cause: The article's author is "director of public relations and marketing". This may go some way toward explaining why there's no link to the actual research document in the article.