3 ms·
I'm not convinced by this test. I am pretty sure higher apes can grok shape sorting tests with complex 3D geometry to win food prizes, They have both the dexter
by ggm 5y ago
I'm not convinced by this test. I am pretty sure higher apes can grok shape sorting tests with complex 3D geometry to win food prizes, They have both the dexterity and motivation. the shape sorter bucket square peg in a round hole problem? They get it.
The test as I understand it posed 2D representative choices, and the abstraction may not work well. There are stories that some initial west/tribe interactions fell down on 2D drawings of 3D things, they were "read" incorrectly. Performing the uplift "thats a perspective line drawing" is arguably culturally informed at times.(this may be urban myth. I am still looking for the references to this)
Many spatial geometry problems in predator-prey involve speed estimation and interception to target. From the start point, for the two vectors of predator and prey, thats a triangle, under continuous re-calculation: their present positions, and the intercept point. I don't see how the animal can be held NOT to understand this.
Parellax in vision, Auditory response to binaurial signals (echo location) all consider triangles.
Look at the positions animals take to each other in times of stress, distribution to minimise risk. The choices of arrangement will form the apex of a minimum surface be it square or triangle or polygon, depending on how many of each type of risk present.
Maybe I'm over-thinking it, but I think this is a classic solipsist "know" problem: the authors don't "know" what the ontology of knowledge really is, with respect to animals other than humans.
- raxxorrax 5y agoGiven the computing power needed for 3-dimensional perception alone, it is astonishing how bad we are at basic geometry in the first place. But if the complexity of geometric and non-geometric forms can be increased and there is a difference in extra effort for animals and humans, it should be testable.