6 ms·
This is the game changer that could turn cities into EV dominated spaces. Imagine if every convenience store had a rack of these out front. It would be even fas
by asdff 5y ago
This is the game changer that could turn cities into EV dominated spaces. Imagine if every convenience store had a rack of these out front. It would be even faster to get a charged EV than even to gas up an ICE car at the pump.
These are the things that start becoming possible if we let our idea of an EV move beyond a 4000lb automobile to move your maybe 200lb self. You would have to use a technician to service a car sized EV and swap out the batteries even if they dropped right out easily, just due to the to weight of them. An entire infrastructure that would have to be built just to move around 3800 unnecessary lbs anytime you wanted to go anywhere at all. Meanwhile, if people were merely happy with something the size of an e scooter, converting the population to EVs starts getting a lot simpler just in terms of the physics of it all, and simple low hanging fruit innovations like this are possible.
- foolfoolz 5y agothis idea raised $850M and failed https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company)
- scythe 5y agoThose aren't scooters, they're cars -- and they showed up before Panasonic/Tesla attacked the battery-cost problem with roughly 100x as much capital.
- nradov 5y agoTesla also tried battery swapping several years ago but seems to have given up.
- ryukafalz 5y agoThose are also cars.
- bduerst 5y agoThat's because Tesla owners have disposable income and tend to charge in suburban or rural homes. Swapping is aimed more at lower-income segments or delivery/maintenance services in urban areas.
- microtherion 5y agoEdward Niedermeyer's book _Ludicrous_ spends some time on this subject. According to Musk's own statements, Tesla invited less than 200 customers to a trial, and then declared that there was insufficient demand. Niedermeyer points out that conducting even a single customer battery swap allowed Tesla to book about $100M in extra ZEV credits over the years; according to his own anecdotal observations, there was considerably more demand than Tesla claimed, but Tesla did not seem to be overly motivated to make the program work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- troymc 5y agoSometimes yesterday's failed idea can be today's genius idea. For example, if you tried to launch Squarespace in 1993, most people wouldn't care; they'd wonder who would want it and why. (The World Wide Web was a niche thing at that time.)
- wkirby 5y agoShai Agassi was on the cover of WIRED back in 2008 and college me thought he was going to save the world. Like a proto-Musk if Elon were actually in it to save the planet.
- hristov 5y agoUnfortunately this is not it. The game changer will be when they start closing off large parts of cities to cars and limiting them to small, slow and safe golf cart/scooter/bike type vehicles. Everything else will fall into place very quickly afterwards. We have the technology, we need the political will. These scooters are nice but few people will brave riding them in a busy American street, not to even mention a highway.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> the political will Which is another way of saying 'willing voters.' Who all own cars already, for the most part. And rarely vote to reduce their own quality of life even if there is a possibility that in the longer run it will be higher.
- schnevets 5y agoand are completely oblivious to the costs of their way of life (and certainly won't listen to a politician who mentions the existence of such cost)
- rootusrootus 5y agoOr they believe the costs are worth it. Trying to convince people to support extraordinary lifestyle changes requires extraordinary evidence that the net result will be positive.
- munk-a 5y agoIf innovation can't happen until the ignorant are enlightened we're never going to see innovation.
- sokoloff 5y agoInnovation is all around you. It's just not the type of innovation that requires elected government officials to participate (and in a way that will frustrate some of their supporters). You're likely reading this on a device that was invented while plenty of ignorant people were still not enlightened.
- nomel 5y ago> These are the things that start becoming possible if we let our idea of an EV move beyond a 4000lb automobile to move your maybe 200lb self. I see you live in an area with significantly more days of good weather than bad!
- a9h74j 5y agoThe Worldwatch Institute regularly put out 80-page studies in the 1980s. Disappointingly, they published one on The Future of the Bicycle which never once mentioned the word 'rain'. FWIW, the Aptera three-wheel EV design gets IIRC 10X better distance/kWhr than most EVs, and has a US classification as a motorcycle.
- oblio 5y agoAgreed! It's impossible to use anything but cars in places with bad weather. Science has proved it! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uhx-26GfCBU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uhx-26GfCBU
- missblit 5y agoThis reminds me of winter biking back in university in Idaho (fairly cold winters)... with a night shift that got off at 23:00. The path I was on wasn't really maintained with winter bikers in mind, and I never even thought of researching winter tires, and I wasn't a particularly skilled cyclist (I don't think I cleaned the chain once in several years). So I did what any stubborn-minded fool who had to bike to their job rain or shine would do: I simply fell over repeatedly until I started getting the hang of things (pro-tip: just don't turn at all and you won't fall over) Nowadays I'm too old to consider regularly crashing during my commute to be a particularly sane idea; though I still don't have a car and wish cycling infrastructure would get even a fraction of the attention that car infrastructure does.
- oblio 5y agoWell, for this missing scenario, public transport in theory would help. However there is a strong lack of will for it in many places. In many others the population density doesn't really allow it. As usual, it's a mix of things, just that the current default of "cars everywhere" should be turned on its head. It should be: "no cars everywhere, and then introduce cars where they are actually needed".
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoOr we could have, you know, buses and trams and metros? Riding a scooter in a car designed city sucks :-/
- Gustomaximus 5y agoWith a car I wonder if you could have 4 or 5 of these batteries as a range extender. So the main battery is fixed as current standard, but you can throw in a few of these to extend range or if you run out of power for a ~50km type extension.
- geenew 5y agoNot exactly the same, I know, but it's worth keeping in the common memory the fact that battery-swapping EVs have been around for a very long time. See this[1]. Quote: " the excessive noise of these vehicles annoyed residents of some of the wealthier areas of the town and so the company ordered 4 battery-powered buses, which entered service in June 1909; ... [buildings] held charging equipment, so that during the day buses could swiftly exchange spent batteries for ones that were fully charged, a change-over which took about ten minutes. " [1] https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1423929?section=official-list-entry https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1...
- zionic 5y agoHow is this top comment? Is this a joke?