8 ms·
Scientists may have solved Stephen Hawking's black hole paradox
- MaxMoney 5y ago
- pmichaud 5y agoIs there a link to the paper or a different article that contains information, instead of… not?
- kdavis 5y agoLinks to papers are at the end of the article
- raattgift 5y agoThere are two papers linked at the bottom of the not-so-fine article, both leading to "green lock" unpaywall https://research.lib.buffalo.edu/articleaccess/unpaywall https://research.lib.buffalo.edu/articleaccess/unpaywall https://unpwaywall.org/ https://unpwaywall.org/ destinations. The articles correspond to the following arxiv preprints: https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.05171v2 https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.05171v2 [Quantum Hair and Black Hole Information] which is an overview work published in Elsevier's Phys.Lett.B on an open access basis; and https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.09386 https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.09386 [Quantum Hair from Gravity] which is the main work (published to APS's Phys.Rev.Lett) that the not-so-fine article attempts to summarize.
- sampo 5y agoI find this a better explanation: > But the team's calculations showed there were differences in the gravitational field around the black hole. Specifically, information about the composition of the black hole was stored in gravitons, a hypothetical elementary particle that mediates gravitational forces in quantum gravity. "We found that quantum gravity enables us to find the difference in the gravitational field," Calmet said. "There's a memory in the gravitational field of what went into the black hole." https://www.livescience.com/black-hole-quantum-hair https://www.livescience.com/black-hole-quantum-hair
- astrange 5y agoI’m confused how you can find that something is stored in a hypothetical particle. Is it only hypothetically stored?
- Etheryte 5y agoThe particle is hypothetical in the sense that scientists hypothesize it exists, but it hasn't been proven to exist. If it helps, you might think of it similar to the Higgs boson before the Large Hadron Collider.
- sampo 5y agoThey do calculations using a theory where gravitons are assumed to exist, and then their results are valid in that theory.
- rbanffy 5y agoWouldn't that just prove the theory is internally consistent, without any further indication it can explain real-world observations?
- 2muchcoffeeman 5y agoI think the way to think about it is, they "invented" a particle that has all the right properties to explain real world data. Then they can say, if this is right, we can do such and such experiments to observe it.
- MeteorMarc 5y agoCan't you say that the blackhole as a whole maintains a quantum state that accounts for every particle in it? Then, the paradox does not arise in the first place, compared to considering a blackhole as a gravitational singularity only determined by its mass.
- wanda 5y agoIf I am not mistaken, I believe the paradox arises not when matter enters the black hole, but rather in the anonymity of its expression as Hawking radiation later in the black hole's lifespan. I was also under the impression that a solution to the paradox had already been discussed, just not conclusively or in detail. The linked article is pretty atrocious.
- kryptiskt 5y agoBut if the black hole then evaporates by emitting Hawking radiation, where did the state go when it has disappeared?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- simiones 5y ago> Can't you say that the blackhole as a whole maintains a quantum state that accounts for every particle in it? No - in current theories of black holes (GR), the strength of gravity (the curvature of space time) at the center of the black hole is such that there is no room for a single particle to exist, everything is condensed into a single mathematical point (well, it's actually a disk I believe, since it must be able to rotate). As such, a black hole is characterized by only three things: mass, charge, and angular momentum. If it has more degrees of freedom, it's not consistent with GR. Now, the clear assumption is that mathematical solutions that involve singularities indicate limits of a theory - that is, that GR breaks down inside a black hole, requiring some other theory of gravity to explain what goes on in there. But QM is not that theory, and there is no theory which encompasses both GR and QM - though there are a few incomplete candidates.
- codethief 5y ago
- hutrdvnj 5y agoCan someone provide an ELI5 of this quantum hair theory?
- davidgrenier 5y agoThere has been no experimental evidence for Hawking radiation, so does it matter all that much?
- mettamage 5y agoI'm not a physicist, so my explanation is most likely off the mark, simply see [1]. There was something recently about whirlpools that showed that Hawking's math worked out [1]. So yea, no experimental evidence, but at least the math works out for whirlpool-style experiments. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuIxSkD6wsA&ab_channel=Astrum https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuIxSkD6wsA&ab_channel=Astru...
- davidgrenier 5y agoVery nice, thank you for sharing.
- edgyquant 5y agoSure if it is being debated why not?
- davidgrenier 5y agoYeah I guess... so to me that's the analog of conjectures conditionally true on the Riemann hypothesis being correct. There is indeed value in it, though I'm not gonna hold my breath.
- transfire 5y agoI have always suspected that there is no interior.
- kdavis 5y agoThere is a ELIPhD student version here[1]. Personally, though I’ve not read the papers, I doubt that the description of a quantum eigenstate of QED with charge Q can just be copied over mutatis mutandis to describe a quantum eigenstate of quantum gravity with energy E, the theories are just too different. [1] https://youtu.be/Jn0hsZg_3sE https://youtu.be/Jn0hsZg_3sE
- Terry_Roll 5y agoELI5: Matter sucked into a black hole leaves a gravitational trace, meaning all black holes are gravitational data centres logging the neighbourhoods historical activities.
- edgyquant 5y agoWow that’s pretty awesome. Has this been proven?
- detritus 5y agoI'm not sure this Could Ever Be proven. Outwith some unknown hyperscience, at least.
- zardo 5y agoWe'll have plenty of time to develop hyperscience before we can watch any known black hole start shrinking.
- pdonis 5y agoNo. What the article is describing is a proposed theoretical model. There is no prospect of gathering any data to test it now or in the foreseeable future.
- andrewflnr 5y agoMostly just faint hope that Planet 9 both exists and is a primordial black hole.
- BobbyJo 5y agoSo the thought here is that particle spins/charges/mass/etc. are all encoded in the gravitational field of the black hole?
- danbruc 5y agoWhile the previous assumption was that black holes are completely characterized by only three parameters - mass, electric charge, and angular momentum - which is called the no-hair theorem [1]. This is at odds with the time-reversibility of physical laws as there are many ways to make a black hole with a certain mass, electrical charge, and angular momentum but given such a black hole it is not possible to go backwards in time and reconstruct the formation process of the black hole as you have only three numbers and therefore not enough information to figure out when, where and what was thrown into the black hole. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-hair_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-hair_theorem
- edgyquant 5y agoOther than to denote a hypothesis, why do these articles use the term “may.” I think it implies “have” to the layman and implies hasn’t to anyone with some math or science based education. If nothing has been proven yet what’s the story here? It seems to me, and I’m happy to be wrong, that science journalism is indulging in clickbait.
- endofreach 5y agoWhen i read „may have solved…“, i instantly think: „…but they didn‘t“.
- ffhhj 5y agoNewton "may" have solved what makes objects to fall, until Einstein gave a more complete explanation, and we still don't fully understand gravity. So it's always a "may" until you get a better theory.
- edgyquant 5y agoThis would be a measure of may I’m okay with, but the article isn’t denoting that since it is discussing theories about gravitational waves that have not been verified. If we roll with your analogy we’re at the Galilean period where we don’t yet even have methods to prove that reality reflects the maths we contrived. This is why I take issue with it. When I go to walk my dog in an hour I may solve the pieces to a theory of unified gravity. If I did it would be okay for me to make a claim like that, if I thought about how cool circles looked in space and solved some random equations for replicating those circles I don’t think anyone would appreciate me saying I may have solved an actual theory. Obviously I’m walking over the part where they actually do research, but only to drive the point home of it being clickbait (I see these titles more and more in r/physics)
- mannykannot 5y agoThis dichotomy - either it's proven or it's nothing - has been alluded to in several comments here, and shows up whenever similarly far-reaching hypotheses are raised on HN. The thing is, though, you need a hypothesis before you can get to a proof [1], and a hypothesis that is consistent with everything we think we know is a significant advance, especially when the absence of such a hypothesis has ben gnawing at the foundations of physics for several decades. The history of science provides plenty of examples. Take the atomic theory for example, where Einstein's Brownian paper theory is generally regarded as the step that silenced the positivist opposition. Does that mean that none of the prior work by Boltzmann and in chemistry was newsworthy? On the contrary, it paved the way to Einstein's paper, and was an essential part of the history. [1] Not that scientific theories are ever formally proven, of course, but that line of argument would be a diversion here.
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt hasn’t been a ‘paradox’ since at least 2001 when people found fuzzball solutions. Today we get a headline that somebody resolved this ‘paradox’ every month or so and each time they make it sound like this is something new. There are many ways to describe a quantum black hole, none of them lose information because QM is unitary. If you think classical mechanics is real than yeah there is a paradox, but that’s like asking why electrons don’t spiral into atoms radiating UV radiation —- no paradox there, that’s what they do in classical mechanics, but we live in a quantum world.
- bryan0 5y agoSabine’s post on this topic might be relevant here: http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2020/11/the-black-hole-information-loss-problem.html?m=1 http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2020/11/the-black-hole-info... > The Black Hole information loss problem is unsolved. Because it’s unsolvable. > The black hole information loss problem is not a math problem. It’s not like trying to prove the Riemann hypothesis. You cannot solve the black hole information loss problem with math alone. You need data, there is no data, and there won’t be any data. Which is why the black hole information loss problem is for all practical purposes unsolvable.
- ericmay 5y ago> "You need data, there is no data, and there won’t be any data." Why won't there be any data? Is it just physically impossible to collect or is it an engineering problem?
- zehaeva 5y agoBecause data comes from experiments. Unless we figure out how to create a black hole in the lab (spoiler, you wouldn't want to) or could get close to a natural black hole (spoiler, you wouldn't want to) you're not going to get any data for this.
- vl 5y ago>create a black hole in the lab (spoiler, you wouldn't want to) Current understanding is that there is nothing dangerous about creating black hole in the lab: it’s going to be so small that it will evaporate quickly, and event horizon is so small that it will be very unlikely to capture new matter.
- a9h74j 5y ago> Current understanding I.e., if a tiny black hole had formed at LLC and swallowed the Earth, that would have been data. Recall all the arguments quoting rates of Hawking Radiation from small black holes as if it were proven fact.
- prmph 5y agoI'm a noob here,and maybe this is not a meaningful question, but why is it a paradox that matter falling into a black hole causes information to be lost? Are there not many other physical processes where this happens? For example, if a sound is made, does the universe permanently keep a record of it? I would imagine the waves would die down, until at a certain quantum level, they will stop entirely. Or, if two particles annihilate each other, is it possible from the resulting particles/energy produced to know which particles were involved?
- danbruc 5y agoYes, the known laws of physics are time-reversible - two distinct states A and B evolve over time but they stay distinct, i.e. they will never evolve into the same state C. If the the universe is also deterministic, then there is also also only one possible way a state can evolve over time. In the examples you mentioned, like sound waves dissipating, the energy just gets spread out over countless particles as heat. If you could measure all the particles in the air and environment precisely enough, you could in theory reconstruct the sound.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIs that true? Here's a chamber with two equal halves, with a wall between them. I put air in the left half or the right half, and a vacuum in the other half. Then I remove the wall. Once things reach equilibrium, how are you going to determine which half had the air in the beginning? So it looks to me like, even apart from black holes, no, you can't reverse things. Am I missing something here?
- mywittyname 5y agoEquilibrium is local in your example. Globally, the rush of air from one side to the other would result in detectable oscillations whose released energy could be used to determine which chamber was initially empty, assuming one can find and isolate the information.
- 5y ago