Personally I haven't seen "well looked after" Confluence spaces. I have experience with 4 different companies that used Confluence for their infra, and in my ex

Personally I haven't seen "well looked after" Confluence spaces. I have experience with 4 different companies that used Confluence for their infra, and in my experience it has always been a mess. The reason I advocated for ranking by popularity is that those messy Confluence pages are filled to the brim with obsolete outdated articles that nobody intentionally visits. For example, in many firms people post meeting notes to Confluence. So you have 10 000 pages of quality "notes from project abc weekly meeting 5.4.2014". Now, imagine yourself searching a Confluence space like that. You type in a particular phrase, and there is a perfect match in meeting notes from 2017, a perfect match from preliminary design document from 2013, etc. These results constantly drown out the actual pages you are searching for, which are typically more actively-updated, more recent pages. It would be a huge improvement to rank these pages higher purely based on their popularity.