5 ms·
There are schools that don't allow grad students to teach.
by kevin_thibedeau 5y ago
There are schools that don't allow grad students to teach.
- anonuser123456 5y agoThat’s a shame, because sometimes graduate students are better teachers than research faculty.
- Retric 5y agoYou can also go to a school where professors are employed for their ability to teach. Choosing to go to a research institution seems like such an obviously poor choice it’s strange people get suckered into it. But it’s clear education is a low priority for both students and collages.
- bachmeier 5y agoNot really. Small liberal arts colleges offer the chance to be friends with your professors and small classes. Research universities can offer classes that just aren't going to happen at a SLAC. For example, majors in our department have the option to take graduate courses before they graduate.
- Retric 5y agoMany small to midsized universities with masters programs aren’t research institutions. Higher education is very competitive with a wide range of business models. One of them is to have tight collaboration with industry to have undergrad and masters programs around Mining, Manufacturing, Medicine, etc focused on employability. Some are focused on night classes for government employees who get an automatic pay raise with a higher degree irrespective of what it’s in. Others are focused on continuing education requirements. The high prestige research institutions can be a good fit, but aren’t the only option outside of small liberal arts schools.
- ModernMech 5y ago> Choosing to go to a research institution seems like such an obviously poor choice it’s strange people get suckered into it. The best educations happen in research labs. Undergraduates should get a good foundation years 1 and 2, and then find their way as a junior research assistant years 3 and 4 if they want to make the best of their University years. These days you can follow along with any course you want on YouTube. At University you are paying to get access to top researchers and the work they do.
- nostrebored 5y agoStrongly disagree with this for CS. At top universities, you’re paying for access to similarly interested/capable students and top internship programs. Having done undergrad research, it was both underwhelming and worse experience than my friends who did internships at FAANG.
- leetcrew 5y agoI think GPs perspective is not wrong, but assumes (or maybe hopes) that students are at least considering graduate+ level education. like you suggest, I think this is mostly not true of undergrad cs students. if you have no intention of going to grad school, industry internships are a much better use of time outside of class. as a bonus, the internship is a lot more likely to pay enough that you can actually pay bills while in school.
- ModernMech 5y ago> (or maybe hopes) that students are at least considering graduate+ level education. I'm not necessarily assuming that. I think there seems to be an assumption here that the choice is research or internship, but not both. That is not the case. Students do research with me during a typical semester, and when they are done the school year, they often go and get industry internships over the summer at top companies around the world. We train them to pass the Google-style whiteboard coding interviews; our students are very prepared for those. I don't know of any students who do internships during the school year. Most of my students who do research with me do not go on to do graduate studies.
- popcube 5y agobetter on teach content of text book. But if someone want to learn how to research, they should learned it from who actually research each day
- jhbadger 5y agoPrimarily at what is known as PUIs (primarily undergraduate institutions), colleges and universities that either don't have grad students or have such a tiny graduate program that relying on them for teaching roles is unfeasible. In theory this is better for the students because the professors just care about teaching, but the down side is such institutions do little to no research and so the professors may be decades out of touch with current developments in their fields.
- throwoutway 5y agoNot doing research doesn’t mean they are decades out of touch. What gives you that conclusion?
- jhbadger 5y agoIf you are doing research you have to be up to date or you don't get things published. I'm sure there are some professors who don't do research who make it a point of personal pride or something to keep themselves updated, but there's zero pressure to do so.
- snowwrestler 5y agoNo, there is tremendous pressure to be up to date with your teaching because if you’re not, then your students don’t get accepted to highly ranked graduate programs, and that is a significant factor in undergrad college rankings. > If you are doing research you have to be up to date or you don't get things published. Only within the boundaries of your particular field of study, which in most cases is far narrower than the scope of undergrad classes.
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI personally think the truth is somewhere in the middle, but do you see how this explanation is based on a very loose relationship between action and evaluation?
- 5y ago