3 ms·
Of course this is no surprise to anyone whose family hunted or farmed or went to war within living memory. It wasn’t because of arbitrary gender roles that my w
by rayiner 5y ago
Of course this is no surprise to anyone whose family hunted or farmed or went to war within living memory. It wasn’t because of arbitrary gender roles that my wife’s grandpa was the one in charge of dressing the deer carcass and hauling it to the truck. Likewise it was my uncle that killed a bunch of Pakistanis to win his country’s independence, not his sisters.
I must admit I’m a bit puzzled by the (I must assume fringe minority) of folks who insist that the equality of men and women is literal, not moral. We’re lucky today that most jobs don’t implicate men’s natural advantage in strength. It’s not relevant to doctors and lawyers and engineers. So what’s the point of denying the obvious? I sometimes wonder whether it’s motivated by a need to make the past seem more irrational and unfair than it really was. (Traditional gender roles probably seemed much more fair when men were regularly getting injured bringing home game animals or dying to protect the homestead.)
- bobkazamakis 5y ago
- rayiner 5y agoWhen you read a study saying “grass is green” do you try to put aside your preconceived “worldview” and be prepared to “reconcile your stance with new data?” Also, I’m using the terminology correctly. The point is that gender roles are shaped by real sex differences in physical strength.
- throwaway6532 5y agoYou would if you were Japanese for whom the grass is "blue". But me? I like to call a spade a spade myself.
- gamblor956 5y agoIt sounds like you are just trying to make an unnecessary point about gender roles which isn't actually universal. Among many Native America/First Nations tribes, dressing a carcass was a task performed by women...
- rayiner 5y agoI said “dressing and dragging”—my wife’s grandpa would field dress the deer and bring it back home. Her grandma knew how to dress the deer, which doesn’t require much upper body strength. But she wasn’t the one who was dragging it back to the truck and loading it on. To my knowledge Native American women weren’t doing that either.
- happytoexplain 5y ago>folks who insist that the equality of men and women is literal As far as I can tell, this opinion, held without qualification, is beyond fringe - it is vanishingly rare, and frequently pointed to as a strawman in arguments about [in]equality (see the dead sarcastic comment in this very thread: "This is considered highly controversial in 2022"). I hate to say "non-existent", because somebody will find some example, but even then, usually when I see a supposed example of it, it is actually an example of something dramatically lesser, like "women can be as strong as men", or "women are just as [metaphorically] strong as men", not the ridiculous "women and men have no inherent differences, literally", which can only exist as a form of provocation, not an earnest opinion. It seems like a distraction to insinuate otherwise, designed to create an easily mocked image to be projected onto people who don't actually match the description.
- JamesBarney 5y agohttps://twitter.com/shereebekker/status/1504899936843935746 https://twitter.com/shereebekker/status/1504899936843935746 Just saw this tweet this morning. A professor arguing women's sports exist to protect men from having to compete with women.
- bennyelv 5y agoYou have either misunderstood or misrepresented this. My grok of what has been said here is quite different. The tweet author has pointed out some quite legitimate examples of when women have been excluded for reasons that can't be justified by "different strength capabilities": - Skeet shooting - Womens professional football being banned - Figure skating I don't agree with her broader points, but I don't think this is an example of what this particular thread is about.
- dekhn 5y agothe literal physical equality things was a sad side effect of the gender/sexuality wars of the mid-to-late 2010s. IIUC it came about because of twisted logic tryng to say that "women and men are capable of doing all the same jobs" and following that to a logical conclusion, rather than questioning the premise. for a while it was hard to even push back against this (for example, inside a large FAANG filled with employees who are terrified of the progressive wing) and there is even a fair amount of scientific literature (mostly opinion articles in nature) that seem to continue to propagate these ideas.