10 ms·
This sounds like a potentially great business clarity move: > We are a B2B solution, not the indie version of YouTube” But this part -- bait&switch, with only
by neilv 5y ago
This sounds like a potentially great business clarity move:
> We are a B2B solution, not the indie version of YouTube”
But this part -- bait&switch, with only one week to decide or move, (if that's accurate) -- is not what you want from your B2B solution provider:
> “I was already paying $200 a year, which I think is pretty expensive,” [...] if she wanted to keep hosting her content on the site, she’d need to upgrade to a custom plan. Her quoted price: $3,500 a year. She was given a week to upgrade her content, decrease her bandwidth usage, or leave Vimeo.
- bobitsaboy 5y agoIt's not even a sensible or pro-rated increase. Just a shakedown.
- kingkawn 5y agoExcept the point seems to be getting her to leave, not giving her a thoughtful way to stay.
- notatoad 5y agocoupled with the "we are a B2B solution" statement, i think they're trying to shake down patreon, not the individual creators - it sounds like vimeo wants patreon to start sending them money.
- apotheon 5y agoThis also seems like a great way to get everyone to leave. If what I wanted was a B2B platform, I wouldn't choose one with a history of suddenly changing its policies and only giving one week to catch up. In fact, it's often much more difficult for a larger business to move that quickly than an independent user.
- bobitsaboy 5y agoBingo!
- marcosdumay 5y ago"We want you to leave" is a pretty ok thing for them to say. "You have a week to leave" is not. It's sleazy and unprofessional, and it's a signal that it's best for anyone to avoid them in the future.
- kingkawn 5y agothey probably don’t want to be known as forcing users out unilaterally, so a false offer becomes the diplomatic move, now backfiring from public exposure.
- Ekaros 5y agoDepends on the contract in place. If they have a clause allowing termination in weeks time then it's entirely professional.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIf they negotiated that clause, yes, it's professional. If they hidden it there, no, it's not.
- hannasanarion 5y agoTell that to Sunny Singh, the other Vimeo user who was featured in the Verge article, who did the math himself and had to admit that he was costing Vimeo $2500/yr.
- chockchocschoir 5y agoAre you talking about this? https://twitter.com/hate5six/status/1481511608979533826 https://twitter.com/hate5six/status/1481511608979533826 If so, he is not saying that he is costing Vimeo $2500/year, he is saying what amount of bandwidth he has "consumed"/"produced" from Vimeo, which for sure doesn't cost Vimeo $2500/year, as otherwise they would be bankrupt by now. They pay static sums for the internet connection, no TB/$ crap that people using cloud are used to.
- ryanbrunner 5y agoA customer shouldn't really need to concern themselves with the profitability of a service provider though. The price Vimeo demanding is reasonable - what's not reasonable is hiding that prices could increase, and being basically as opaque as possible about the conditions to trigger that increase and what the increased cost was.
- computer23 5y agoYour comment is false. Singh did an analysis and used the analysis to negotiate to a $2,500/year rate. He didn't "admit" anything about what it could be costing Vimeo.
- KaoruAoiShiho 5y agoShe makes around $25k a month from her videos, so paying $3.1k for hosting doesn't seem like an unusual cost. However, it's obvious that she derives no benefit from being able to control her own branding or whatever value-add that vimeo provides over youtube so putting it on an ad-supported platform like youtube probably just makes more sense for her.
- bobitsaboy 5y ago$3500 for hosting on top of what they already paid for hosting for the current length of their plan, with 7 days notice to vacate otherwise. And then how much next week? The week after that? How could anyone trust Vimeo as a provider for their business after this?
- spicybright 5y agoTo add, this is why people serious about their business generally will enter into contracts with other businesses to ensure either side can't screw each other over. And it provides a clear transition plan if one party wants to leave.
- asdfaoeu 5y agoFor something thats $200/yr no one would be offering that.
- spicybright 5y agoThen you'd pay more to use service that would if the corner stone of your business can crumble overnight.
- longtimelistnr 5y agoNo but you would expect price changes like this to be given advanced notice and implemented only after a current contract ends
- throwaway81523 5y ago
- bryans 5y ago> "I was already paying $200 a year, which I think is pretty expensive," In other words, she has no idea what bandwidth or server costs are and doesn't realize Vimeo is definitely losing money on distributing her videos, but still arrogantly believes she is entitled to infinite bandwidth for free because "that's what YouTube does."
- hackernewds 5y agoI wouldn't read it as entitled since other companies have found models that can successfully support revenue scaling with distribution
- gundmc 5y agoNot for free, for $200.
- technobabbler 5y agoBut should it be her job as a content producer to understand Vimeo's costs and margins? Vimeo is one of those who liked to advertise seemingly unmetered bandwidth behind an fine-print fair-use policy, luring people into a cheap pro plan with the hopes that most of them won't take off and become viral. That was their bet, one that they're now regretting. They could've just easily put a bandwidth meter on every account and let people decide what to do if they get close to that limit. It's not even like the early days of Gmail abuse where people were using it as a cheap web disk, consuming way more storage and bandwidth than Gmail could've reasonably estimated. This person is just using Vimeo as they intended: hosting and serving videos. She wasn't trying to abuse the service, just using it the way they sold it to her, as a place to host videos for $200/year. Whose fault is it that they underpriced their plans as loss leaders on purpose, and the bet didn't quite pay off? If they want to up their price because they want to change their business model, you know, more power to them... but sheesh, at least give her 60-90 days to figure out next steps. Some home internet connections can't even download all those videos and reupload them within 7 days. (edit: to be clear, Gmail didn't offer unlimited disk, just a LOT of disk)
- gruez 5y ago