8 ms·
A better way to divide the pie
- gondo 5y agoReading the title, I thought this will be about a fair splitting of home cooked pie (or any dish). My go-to method for this is to divide the responsibilities. One party cuts (or decides where to cut in the case children are involved), the other party picks. Does anyone use a better, fairer method?
- papandada 5y agoFor 2 people that's fair. It only gets a bit more complicated with more people or other variations. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Envy-free_cake-cutting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Envy-free_cake-cutting
- delgaudm 5y agoPerhaps I got lost in the explanation, or the example is overly simplified, but isn't this just "splitting the difference"?
- HWR_14 5y agoNo. Splitting the difference could be a term invented to describe this, but it already has a different meaning. It's use is if I offer you two slices and you counter with a demand for six slices, then "splitting the difference" just refers to using the average value of four.
- tromp 5y agoIt is splitting the difference between Alice offering to take the whole negotiation pie at 10-2 and Bob counter offering to take the whole negotiation pie himself at 4-8.
- HWR_14 5y agoYes, if each originally maximally said "I want all 6 new slices" then it would be splitting the difference in their asks. However, in the case where Bob counters with an offer to split 6-6, it is no longer splitting the difference.
- hackernewds 5y agoNow it has been bastardized by "Never Split the Difference" which is what you now hear from a desperate car salesman now
- nhod 5y ago"Never Split the Difference" is also the name of an outstanding book by Chris Voss, the former head of FBI hostage negotiation. For shorthand, Voss refers to all biz school rational-actor negotiation theory (as espoused by the parent post, for example) as “splitting the difference.” He holds that such theory is useful to know in general, but that real-world negotiations are carried out by emotional, irrational humans. As a result, these rational theories often break down in the face of hubris, anger, fear, love, shame, etc, and as such, relying solely on these theories will not get you the results you want. Thus, you should "never split the difference." Instead, he then goes on to suggest a whole variety of ways one can achieve better negotiation results, starting with the most obvious: really, truly listening to the needs of the other. The book is fascinating. Highly recommended.
- HWR_14 5y agoHow would a desperate car salesman use that phrase?
- nerdponx 5y agoThe example is overly simplified. Imagine if it was a 24-slice pizza. The argument is that the "original" 6 slices should be divided according to the original preferences of 4 and 2, and the "extra" 18 slices should be divided evenly into 9 and 9.
- karmakaze 5y agoI imagine in many contexts, the more 'relative status-quo' outcome to the original would be 4+4 to 2+2, double-or-no-change. Bob wanting more than to double could be spiteful bargaining power which Alice could answer with spite.
- HWR_14 5y agoI saw it in the article and literally thought it was a straw man. I believed the author was arguing against a 6-6 division and introduced a more unbalanced shift to try to make their position seem reasonable. You're the first person I've seen suggest that this is a thing and I'm kind of shocked. What reasoning would there be for unequal division of the additional slices in A's favor?
- karmakaze 5y agoIt comes down to relative value of closing the deal. If both A and B want to increase their X, whatever it may be, an increase of 3 to A's 4 is not as much as 3 to B's 2 if we're talking about market share as an example. So already it's of more relative value for B to close the deal with +3's. Other factors apply. So it really comes down to how much each wants it, which is the status quo for negotiation. I don't think any business goes in saying "What's the fairest way we can make this deal?" As an edge case, let's say A has 1M, and B has 1k and there's 500k new units. Should B get 250k same as A? Would A go for that? Would B be happy with 100k?
- _v7gu 5y agoSo... Uhh... Just Nash bargaining? Or Shapley values result in the same outcome too in this case.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt's a modestly interesting point, but it certainly doesn't make sense in the concept of pizza. The author tries to appeal to fairness, but where the fallback positions are knowingly arranged randomly. Therefore, the naive 6-6 solution is just refusing to adjust for a superior random arrangement in the experiment, which was unfairly assigned. Therefore, I would expect the naive 6-6 to be chosen the plurality of them time. There's also a question of if there is any value to clam pizza beyond the initial four slices. That sounds like a lot of food that reheats poorly. Now, if you want to say this applies to something in the real world as a concept, I would say it's not a novel concept. No one expects a new employee to capture 100% of the value they add, nor do people expect the new employee to work for free.
- davidmanheim 5y agoAlso, why is any pizza ever getting cut into 12 slices?
- rootusrootus 5y agoAside from small pizzas, I generally cut pizzas into 12 pieces. 8 slices ends up with unwieldy slices, 16 makes for overly narrow ones. Cut it however you want, of course, but for most average sized pizzas 12 makes for a nice sized slice.
- NeoTar 5y agoThat’s very much a cultural thing. An average European pizza is more of a ‘personal’ pizza and 8 or 10 inches in diameter. Twelve slices would be too much. I propose the Imperial/English pizza theorem. The optimal number of slices for a pizza is equal to the size in inches.
- HWR_14 5y agoA giant pizza cut so that each slice is a full meal (maybe two if very hungry) is optimal.Eating a slice of pizza should be enough.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gondo 5y agoThe naive 6:6 split tries to compensate for the original unfairness. In real life, starting positions are mostly hidden and therefore this problem is avoided.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- huynhhacnguyen 5y agoIf we can ignore the utility value of the negotiating pie (e.g. Alice may not want a 5th slice anyway), it is an interesting perspective. If only there were more examples and less explanation.
- c1ccccc1 5y agoIn general: Suppose the fallback positions are x slices for Alice, and y slices for Bob, and they get n slices total if they reach a deal. Then we can figure out the split by defining the gain, g, as the additional pieces they get if they reach a deal. So g=n-(x+y). Then the fair split should be x+g/2 for Alice and y+g/2 for Bob. Another kind of situation is if there are 3 people, Alice, Bob, and Charlie, with fallbacks x, y, z respectively. Suppose they all need to reach an agreement to get n slices. Then g=n-(x+y+z) and Alice, Bob, and Charlie should get x+g/3, y+g/3, z+g/3 respectively. Another possible situation is if there are 3 people, but they have unequal roles. Alice only needs to make a deal with at least one of Bob or Charlie, to get n slices. If Bob and Charlie both agree to the deal, then the total is still n slices. Intuitively, this would make Bob and Charlie less important, so they should get less of the gain. The split here should be x+2g/3 for Alice, y+g/6 for Bob and z+g/6 for Charlie, if they're all in on the deal. The reasoning there is that if we're adding games together, then we should also add the payoffs together. We can make a Alice&(Bob|Charlie) game by adding together Alice&Bob + Alice&Charlie - Alice&Bob&Charlie. Similarly, the payoffs should add like this: (g/2, g/2, 0) + (g/2, 0, g/2) - (g/3, g/3, g/3) = (2g/3, g/6, g/6)
- huynhhacnguyen 5y agoWow thanks for the very detailed explanation, mate, that is much appreciated. However, I still wish the author had delved into more real world examples, to let us have more sense of how this principle can be applied into more practical use cases. "Algorithms To Live By" https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25666050-algorithms-to-live-by https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25666050-algorithms-to-l... did a really good job at that. Of course an article cannot be at book length but a man can hope.
- hackernewds 5y agoEmployee compensation would hilariously soar so much if this were the model. Currently employees in reality, are provided 0.00001% of the company.
- the_lonely_road 5y agoSalary is often the single largest expense on the income statement, and especially so for service based companies. This expense will frequently massively outstrip the profit line item. So no employees are not getting 0.000001% of these companies, they are in fact getting the majority of the money flowing through these companies. You are noting that the employee line item is split up amongst 50,000 employees and the smaller profit number is behind split up among 50 owners. So an individual owner makes massively more money than an individual employee but missing that employees as a class are still getting more of the money than the owners.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Currently employees in reality, are provided 0.00001% of the company. 0.00001% of Amazon's entire revenue (not profit, but revenue) last year would be about $14,000. Fortunately, every one of their full time employees is paid more than that. Entry level engineers make 10X that amount and the best engineers make 50X that or more. At some of the most highly paid companies like Uber, paying employees according to the value they create would actually make salaries go down in every scenario, because the company is still fueled by investor funds and can't self-sustain on revenue alone. After round-tripping from IC to manager and back a couple times, I've come to realize that the value given to engineers especially is extremely high. Many initiatives in the tech industry don't ever turn a profit for the company or investors, yet we get paid six figures all the same. If anything, I would expect such a hypothetical initiative to redistribute more of the wealth away from engineers like us and toward people like the customer support team who are fixing all of the problems created by products that don't work quite right. The person on the phone with grandma walking them through a support issue arguably contributes more to the LTV of that customer than anyone else. Stepping outside of tech, I think people imagine profits to be much higher than they are in reality. Grocery stores are a common example of a business that has very narrow profit margins (some times a couple percent) that don't actually have large amounts of leftover profit to distribute to employees. Regardless, it's all hypothetical. The employment market is supply and demand, and that's why engineers are paid so highly. End of story.
- beowulfey 5y agoI was trying to think of an alternative example; the initial condition (the fallback) seems kind of contrived. So let's say there's some investment opportunity where someone has $4,000 to put in and I have $2,000. The investment requires $6000, so neither of us can access it alone. If we agree to invest, let's say the value is guaranteed to increase, in this example by 200% to $12,000. The power analysis way of distributing that increase would be that the other person gets $8000 and I get $4000. Using this pizza analysis, it would instead be distributed as $7000 and $5000 -- splitting the increase of $6000 equally. It's an interesting concept. Certainly I, with only $2000, would be more inclined to contribute. And the other party would certainly benefit more than if we had decided to not go through with it at all. I think it comes down to how much the person with the weaker power is likely to want to contribute. It's a good way to convince them if the power is fairly offset, but when they are close it's not really necessary to convince them. I think this is partially touched on in the article itself, and it makes sense. It comes down to what seems fair to the parties involved!
- tromp 5y ago> let's say the value is guaranteed to increase, in this example by 200% to $12,000. Still kind of contrived:-(
- silisili 5y agoThis example system starts falling apart as the amounts shift. If one party has 5999, and the other 1 dollar, is that type of split still fair? It would never benefit anyone to be the higher of the contributors, a system of everyone looking for suckers.
- beowulfey 5y agoNo, of course not. That's why I pointed out that at the end of the day it comes down to what seems fair, and what the two parties are willing to negotiate.
- hansvm 5y agoIf there really were a contrived scenario where exactly two people are allowed to contribute, the full 6k does need to be provided, and one person has no means to exceed 5999 then the split is still fair in some sense (and is the only "fair" allocation in the sense described by Shapley -- efficient, symmetric, and linear). What you're seeing in this hyperbolic "counter-example" is that the assumptions of that model don't hold; the person providing 1 rather than 5999 is probably very replaceable and would be willing to settle for much less profit due to market forces, the person providing 5999 probably has the means to at least temporarily acquire another 1, the deal probably wouldn't fall through in the first place if it were for slightly less than 6k, and so on.
- wyager 5y agoDuh. The hard part is that negotiators will lie to make it seem like the difference is smaller than it is.
- reggieband 5y agoOne thing I learned in a class on negotiation was that many people look at negotiation as a one-time thing. Examples like buying a car happen for most buyers once every 5 to 10 years. It is also a negotiation that most often happens with a new sales agent / sales manager combo for every transaction. However, a large number of negotiations in business happen with the same group of people over and over again. The example was a set of directors in a large org negotiating over budget. That kind of thing might happen every single business quarter between a stable set of peers. Whenever I see strategies like these I consider those two cases since they have influence on how negotiations are done. In the car-sales case, there is an incentive to get the most out of the individual negotiation since you almost certainly will never see each other again. In the business case you are incentivized to prioritize the relationship with your peers over any individual negotiation. So I don't agree with the simplistic conclusion in the article. It seems to only consider fairness within the context of a single transaction/negotiation. It does not consider what happens when this strategy is repeated between actors across multiple negotiations.
- zasdffaa 5y ago[flagged]
- jka 5y ago> One thing I learned in a class on negotiation was that many people look at negotiation as a one-time thing. Examples like buying a car happen for most buyers once every 5 to 10 years. It is also a negotiation that most often happens with a new sales agent / sales manager combo for every transaction. You may have been implying this already, but just to reinforce the message: it's an asymmetric event frequency. For the buyer, it occurs once every few years. For the seller, it's occurring on a weekly or perhaps daily basis. That means that the seller is fairly likely to know most of the common weaknesses and opportunities for buyers, and the ways in which those buyers communicate (or fail to communicate) them. Sellers can choose to do what they want with that information advantage. To me the question is a broader one: why are Alice and Bob accepting to enter into some byzantine challenge where they have to co-operate in order to receive a larger amount of pizza? And why is there an entire book for sale on the topic, when at first-glance it seems to closely (~80%) resemble what can be defined as the prisoners' dilemma within a paragraph? I think Alice and Bob should publish the ridiculous situation they've been faced with at the pizza restaurant and find somewhere else to go to eat, and I don't think they require a book to teach them that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chociej 5y agoDid anyone think to ask "who's hungrier?"
- littlecosmic 5y agoAs you say, Alice is not in desperate need of pizza, so she’ll just wait for a deal that gives her the most. The power to say no to deals is the true advantage of greater wealth.
- chociej 5y agoYou assume Alice isn't the hungrier of the two and cares little for Bob's hunger, which sort of outlines my point: give more to who's hungrier.
- m3kw9 5y agoThis example seem like a lesson for bob on how to not get screwed by Alice’s seemingly higher leverage by focusing on what is actually at stake to negotiate, the 6 extra slices. And also recognize Alice does not actually have more leverage just because the fallback is to her advantage, she would still have lost out up to 6 slices, making any type of deal would be better for her.
- zw123456 5y agomaybe a little off topic, but.... https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2021/10/14/yales-endowment-reaches-42-3-billion-posting-highest-rate-of-return-since-2000/ https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2021/10/14/yales-endowment-re... I am thinking maybe t yale could spend a little time on finding a fairer way of slicing up that pie? It seems like they could easily educate a lot more people who cannot afford their tuition. And I am not just picking on Yale, Harvard and a lot of others could add to a fund, what if all those schools with multi-billions dollar endowments could give half of it to fund the education of anyone who wants it? This is not a meant to be a rant just a humble suggestion that occurred to me when they were talking about giving away half a pizza.
- HWR_14 5y agoEducation doesn't scale. Great professors don't scale. The endowment is used for funding the tuition of people who cannot afford it. And, to the degree it does scale (Edx, coursera) well endowed universities were at the forefront of putting classes online.
- zw123456 5y agoOK, so if I am understanding your point correctly, education does and doesn't scale, and big universities with huge endowments have done enough because they put classes online and subsidizes tuition for a small number of lucky people. So, it's OK for them to hold onto $42B endowment fund, for... something?
- HWR_14 5y agoSome parts of education scale, some parts don't (see Customer Service and 100 other examples). Universities are doing a good job using tech to scale when they can. It's unreasonable to expect in person attendance to be able to even double and maintain close to the same quality. Yale gives a scholarship to any students for the amount in between the expected family contribution and full cost of tuition/room/board/books/activity fees/small spending stipend. More than half of Yale students get such a scholarship and the average value of that scholarship is higher than tuition and books alone would be, meaning most students are only paying for housing and food. (Okay, it's an average and an average, so it's possible only like 40% of people are having their entire tuition covered, but also their entire room and board and another 17% are getting a dollar.) But, yes. In general you summarized my points correctly. But I take issue to "small number of lucky people". And, of course, with the sarcasm clearly coming from your post.
- hammock 5y agoThere is a whole book about this? The dark slices are each party's BATNA (best alternative to negotiated agreement, from Getting to Yes). Makes perfect sense that the negotiation is over the remaining pie
- stavros 5y agoThe point is that the remaining pie should be split evenly between the two parties, because they both have equal power in creating it.
- hammock 5y agoIn the simplistic example it could be argued that they have equal power. In a real scenario they likely don't. In a real scenario, the dark slices may or may not be irrelevant; Bob must also consider making a deal with Charlie, who was left out of the example and has 6 dark slices of his own, or with David, who has 3 dark slices. There is also the pizzeria across the street to consider which gives Alice and Bob each 3 dark slices.
- 11235813213455 5y agoReminds me of https://www.google.com/doodles/celebrating-pizza https://www.google.com/doodles/celebrating-pizza
- est31 5y agoThe base case, in which Alice and Bob don't reach an agreement, has a specific name: BATNA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_alternative_to_a_negotiated_agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_alternative_to_a_negotiat... Also note that it's two humans agreeing on a deal, and the way of looking at things described in the article might not be shared by both. If your other party is convinced that 6/6 is the most fair distribution, it is to your advantage to agree with that notion, at least if you are Bob. If you are Alice, then you should absolutely make the case. Of course if the game is repeated and you don't know the future game's distributions, this might come back at you, if the roles are switched and the other party goes into the game with that memory.
- tomcatfish 5y agoAnother formulation (unless I misread the article and it's the same thing here) is the Shapley Value [^sv], where you divide up the extra spoils according to the value added by each agent. This works pretty nicely with high numbers of agents too, as well as makes sure it's in everyone's interest to join your sharing scheme even if they're not already in it. [^sv]: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_value
- jldugger 5y agoYea, it seems the author is aware of it, covers it in the book[1], but decided against mentioning it in this article. [1]: https://www.splitthepiebook.com/resources-2-1 https://www.splitthepiebook.com/resources-2-1
- joshuajomiller 5y agoThis is not a new idea. It was written about thousands of years ago in the talmud: http://www.talmudology.com/jeremybrownmdgmailcom/2016/9/27/bava-metzia-2a-game-theory-and http://www.talmudology.com/jeremybrownmdgmailcom/2016/9/27/b...
- jldugger 5y agoKeep in mind this article is basically a Yale professor pitching their new book in an alumni magazine; not a great place for scholarly citations. Browsing the table of contents, the book itself has an entire chapter on this.
- rishabhjain1198 5y agoAbsolutely incredible! I haven't felt the feeling of insight after just reading 3 paragraphs in a long time.
- thenerdhead 5y agoI've always come to the same conclusion that "tit-for-tat" strategies are the simplest and most effective. You agree to cooperate at the start. Then you follow whatever choice your opposition made the previous move. The even better approach is to add in generosity randomly as a means to "forgive" misunderstandings. Maybe just me, but this article seems to add more complexity to the problem.
- NAR8789 5y agoThis reminds me of how I used to split rents with my roommates: Identify surplus value, and split that value evenly. 0. Given a prospective rental house. (And therefore a known set of rooms and a known total rent) 1. Each person "bids" by pricing every room in the house. Goal: each person should be looking for "break-even" pricing. Try to price such that all the rooms feel "equally good" at your given prices. 2. Just one restriction on the pricing: each bidder's room-prices must sum to the house's monthly rent. 3. Reveal all bids. 4. Choose the room-assignment that yields the highest total price. Because of the restriction in [2], we're guaranteed a surplus over the true total rent. (Unless everyone somehow put in identical bids) 5. Split the surplus evenly. Everyone gets a room at the price they bid for that room, minus 1/nth of the surplus. Effectively, everyone gets an identical surprise discount. We lived together for over 10 years, through 5 different rentals. We split up when it came time to start families and buy houses.
- exo-pla-net 5y ago0: Total rent is $10, for ten rooms, to be split among ten people. 1: One person who really wants a certain room bids $10 on it, and he assigns $0 to the nine other rooms. His roommates bid a neutral $1 on all rooms. ... 4: The person gaming the system gets his special room. 5: The surplus is $10 + 9*$1 - $10 = $9. Split evenly, $0.90. Thus, the gamer pays $9.10 for his special room, and everyone else pays $0.10 for their rooms. He has clearly made a terrible mistake. He's covering the cost of the entire rental nearly by himself. Next time, he bids $1 + one gummy bear on his special room, and he bids $1 on the other rooms. He imagines that now he'll merely have to buy one gummy bear every month, split it in ten, and give everyone a slice. He's outwitted his roommates, he thinks. However, much to his dismay, he overlooked that one of the rooms in this next rental was underground. Furthermore, the room was next to a leaky sceptic tank. Everyone else bid $0 on it. The gamer handily wins the sewage room, instead of his special room, and he hardly gets any discount for putting up with it. Oops, foiled again. All of this is to say, your system seems robust. There's danger in over and underbidding on your assessment of a room's value. You want to be very careful in deciding how much a room is worth to you. I think I'll use this system for renting Airbnb's with friends in the future. Thanks!
- gnicholas 5y agoI'd be curious how many people were surprised to be greeted by a picture of a pizza after clicking a link that refers to dividing pies. I'm from California, where "pie" refers exclusively to the dessert variety. I expected the article wouldn't be specifically about pies, but rather about negotiation in general. Did anyone (from areas where "pie" can mean pizza) think that this was going to be an article in which pizzas were used to illustrate the point?
- praving5 5y agoI learned about this in the negotiation course [0] by Prof. George Siedel. It is also called as BATNA - Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA). This is evaluating what is your best alternative if the deal does not get through. In a negotiation, you would want to strengthen your BATNA and weaken other's BATNA. The course was amazing. [0] - https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation-skills https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation-skills
- ColFrancis 5y agoI think the example problem has many issues with it which confuse the issue. There is a pervading assumption that more slices is better. What if Alice only wants 5 slices? Then her fall back is quite close to what she needs but also she doesn't mind how the pie is divided so long as she gets one slice. It's not clear what everyone's utility function is. If a sales person is nearing a quarterly target, their utility function might have a giant kink in it, or if they're at the start of a period it might be very linear. The marginal pie, more often than not, has multiple dimensions which different agents care different amounts for. Thankfully I've never been in a negotiation without a decent BATNA and so just chat about it until either we decide it's not going to work out, or we are both happy. People who negotiate too hard by playing stupid games and trying to max out themselves without any quarter given are tiring and push me to the first option. Why would I want to work with you if you're a pain to deal with before we even start?
- draluy 5y agoThis article is so infuriating I had to log in. All this article is underlined by the fact that Alice and Bob should try to get the most out of the negotiation regardless of needs. This is a rightist way of seeing the world, and in my mind childlike. With any level of maturity people should realize pizzas should be divided according to who needs it, whatever the definition of need is. How about this way of dividing the pie: Alice and Bob describe theirs needs to a third party, and the third party gives each one what is needed. Or if no third party: just describe and justify your needs in an envelope, open both simultaneously, and share the pie. The logic that "of course, everyone should take as much as they can" is an impasse. It doesnt make anyone truly happy, makes the person with the worse fallback an inferior to the other party during the negotiations, doesnt guarantee fairness, etc. And worst of all: it doesnt allow for human values such as empathy. This article is an algorithm between programs, not any reasonable way to treat a person, valuing their feeelings and needs.
- atoav 5y agoI grew up in a small village. I always like to think how my village would look when theories like these would be applied. Would my village be a happier, better place if the one or two families who already own most land used it as an leaverage to extort as much resources as they could from the others? Quite definitly not. The idea here is that the individual cannot trust the group to consider their needs. This is not a theory it is a collective lifestyle choice. There are countries and regions where the opposite (people looking out for each other depending on their needs) works out just fine. In German we speak of something called the Gesellschaftsvertrag — the implicit contract each individual has with society. It can be extremely enlighting think about whether someone subscribes to this contract and if not, why. E.g. someone who has been convicted for years of prison for a minor drug charge while bankers who steal billions go free, might just stop to believe it pays off to honor the rules of the contract. Someone who thinks everybody else is just a fool to extract money from probably even thinks of society as something with implicit rules. However every human society, even societies with slavery, genocide, etc had these implicit rules of what a wealthy person was expected to provide, what a poor person was expected to endure. Break the contract on a large enough scale and you get a violent change of power or a revolution.
- pagutierrezn 5y agoI'curious why the last time this appeared in HN it didn't receive a single comment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30140493 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30140493