7 ms·
I think about this question a lot. I’m from a third world country (my dad was born in a village in Bangladesh). I think it’s tremendously important for academia
by rayiner 5y ago
I think about this question a lot. I’m from a third world country (my dad was born in a village in Bangladesh). I think it’s tremendously important for academia to study what factors have allowed certain countries to develop stable, prosperous democracies.
Unfortunately, I think we will see no progress in this area for political reasons. I was browsing the “racial literacy” curriculum used by my daughter’s school. Most of it is fluff, but the fourth grade unit is a doozy: https://secureservercdn.net/50.62.198.70/b51.f3f.myftpupload.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Racial-Literacy-%E2%80%93-Final-Lessons-Grade-4.pdf https://secureservercdn.net/50.62.198.70/b51.f3f.myftpupload.... It chalks up the differences in development between countries to “geography” giving some countries a “head start.” This is absurd to anyone who has studied a little history. Countries like Bangladesh had a huge head start. In Bangladesh, food just jumps into your basket. Meanwhile Europeans were hacking away at soil that freezes for large parts of the year. And that doesn’t explain why certain countries became rich in the 20th century. How about a unit on how Singapore went from poor to rich in a single generation? The effect of colonialism, etc., can’t be ignored. But Bangladesh had been rich relative to Britain in the past. Yet by the time the British East India company came to India, Britain was more than twice as rich per capita as India, and the Netherlands more than four times as rich. I want to know how that happened. The British will never write a $42 trillion check for what they allegedly siphoned off from India. But understanding how the British (themselves the victims of repeated invasions) came to have the economic and military advantage that allowed them to do that would be valuable.
Unfortunately, there is no politically correct answer to this question that allows study of what Bangladeshis could have done or could do differently. We’re raising an entire generation of kids who will be socialized to believe that the challenges facing the third world are due to factors outside the control of those people, and that the only route to development is paternalistic aid from the first world.
- ionwake 5y agoI have read a factor is populations that depend on yearly planning, were successful, so areas where winters will kill you was a requirement for this process. However I dont understand why civilisation thus started and grew in Egypt / Babylon and not in say Norway. If someone has any any ideas as to why specifically do let me know, I havent hard time to read the rest of the comments so please take this with a pinch of salt.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoEgypt required yearly planning based on the flooding of the nile I believe. Very hard to farm on floodplains if you aren't really planning ahead.
- Gwypaas 5y agoTaking the "yearly planing track". What about the yearly flooding of the Nile? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flooding_of_the_Nile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flooding_of_the_Nile
- anovikov 5y agoCivilisation started there because they had, however limited by area, places with extremely good soil fertility that allowed agriculture to appear there first. Agriculture meant excess production, excess production meant possibility to have organised society by using that byproduct to feed priests/military/bosses, that in turn organised system of laws and their enforcement, and jumpstarted development. Quickly they realised that flood control on rivers greatly increases availability of fertile land further improving their returns, and that required centralised control - so they had both ability, and incentives to build centralised states.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- girafffe_i 5y agoRight, the "fertile crescent" was a cornucopia of abundance. It provide everything to support a rich food chain and allowed energy to be redirected from hunter gathering towards agriculture and domestication. It's thought that the Sahara Desert is the result of human overgrazing and overfarming, which would create hardhsips which required problem-solving different than those in harsh climates with large seasonality. My US education is rife with hidden biases, I'm aware the British Empire fed it's engine through exploitation, but how did it start? The BE stole from India but that was because it had the muscle power already: my original thoughts were, if people lived in harsh climates and the food didn't jump into your basket, then there was more competition to survive in general, and those who could corral people to take over other resources were granted control of their own fiefdom. Rinse and repeat over royal generations and the bigger fish swallows the smaller, until they set sail around the world. This doesn't explain why Africa did not take a similar path in history.
- guuggye 5y agoGuns, Germs and Steel? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns,_Germs,_and_Steel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns,_Germs,_and_Steel Which tries to answer the question: > Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own?
- sdoering 5y agoI would balance it with 'Why Nations Fail'. I can understand the critique it received while still thinking it a good introduction for the question.
- karpierz 5y agoThat's essentially a book of just-so stories/post-hoc hypotheses. Edit: See a more specific critique here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6meq1k/a_detailed_rebuttalalternative_to_the_one_that/dk6htc0/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6meq1k/a_det...
- k__ 5y agoNice. I read the book and found it quite good. It seems at least the conquest part is wrong, but that part didn't interest me that much. What I found most interesting was a thesis at the beginning of the book. That real innovation (revolution instead of evolutio ) is mostly accident and not facilitated by personal virtue of the innovator.
- CPLX 5y agoI’m all for rebuttals of just-so stories but that comment is wholly unconvincing. He just says “actually it didn’t happen” in 5 different ways. But, like, they speak Spanish in Lima and Mexico City and they don’t speak Aztec or Quechua in Madrid. The Europeans did in fact colonize portions of the entire world. There were German armies in Namibia and Dutch in Malaysia and Spanish in Patagonia. That seems... notable? I literally have no unique insight at all into why that happened. But it does seem like an interesting question. I guess the answer could be “no reason” or “it was the result of a non-determinative complex adaptive system and the concept of why isn’t really relevant or repeatable” which are fine responses. But that comment you posted seems to just be refusing to engage with the question.
- amirkdv 5y agoThe document you shared is a great example of the education system acting as a vessel for inculcating children with sterile, polite thoughts. I can imagine the room full of well-meaning adults who think they must protect children from dangerous ideas like racial superiority and end up building an edifice of useless ideas. Maybe we shouldn't even try to explain such an overwhelmingly complex topic like "development of civilization" in grade 4? A charged topic where reasonable sounding yet deeply flawed ideas are known to dupe entire generations of adults. Alas, our education culture still prefers a feeding tube of narratives over an actual education that equips children with a robust understanding of basics (history, economics, ...) and the ability to question content in front of them. The same sadly applies to science education I think, but with less dramatic effect.
- Gollapalli 5y agoI think about this a lot too. My grandmother had an interest in it as well and studied the history of the British kings for an answer (she was a teacher in India). In my own readings, it seems that at the time of the Roman conquest, Brittania was a backwater of illiterate (in the Roman conception) ugly brutes. It was only after three conquests by the first the Romans (who left), then the Anglo-Saxons, then the Normans, that the British had a chance of mattering in the world in any meaningful sense. It was only after the Normans in England became differentiated from the Normans in Normandy, marrying the locals and speaking the local language that something like Britain emerged. I think (pardon the non-sequitor) that the key to all of this is theft. The British elite, for almost a thousand years after the Norman conquest still had their children learn French and acculturate to French norms of the elite. The Romans did much the same stealing copiously from the Greeks. So for that matter, did the Arabic civilizations. And America stole copiously from all of them. Rather, you might call it learning and extending the achievements of the past, often the achievements of those who conquered you, often of those you have conquered.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 5y agoYou might be on to something with “stealing.” A remarkable thing about Western European culture, to me, is that it’s a fusion of a middle eastern religion with a Roman (mediterranean) civil society. The Bible, even the New Testament, is all about middle eastern people. What other culture subscribes to a religion which is centered on some other ethnic group, and their own is mentioned only peripherally?
- tptacek 5y agoThe ethnicity of biblical people is mentioned only peripherally in European Christian practice. Actual representation of the ethnicity of people in the Levant is a trivia question, an amusing aside in Western Christianity; Jesus is blonde. I'm just saying, don't run too far down that line of thought.
- 5y ago
- eternalban 5y agoTrade shifted to seas from land. Beyond the obvious economic impact, this highly reduced the flow of information, new knowledge, etc. to Asian societies (sans the various ports, of course). Beyond that, Europeans, beginning with the Dutch and the English, incorporated the emerging financial and merchant classes into the governing/elite class. This both enabled scaling effective reach of central governments, and also affected the inclusion of a larger (though still minority) subset of the populations (families) to be stakeholders in the governing system. Finally, from a Marxist point of view, the transition from feudalism (which remained the norm in Asia) to capitalism was an advancement that (as we can see) hugely contributed to production power of Europe. This historic progression, in conjunction with the greater class mobility that it afforded, provided meaningful social utility to creative, productive, competent people. [And p.s. so this couple of hundred years head start which resulted in industrialization in Europe, placed the rest of the planet behind a very steep curve. As we can see with the experiment in China, Asians/whoever can only catch up on that curve when the capitalist class in Europe (West) decides, for whatever reason, to massively transfer capital, technology, and know how (which is how China went from Maoist basket case to Superpower status in 30 years, and of course the Chinese Communist Party deserves credit for taking full and effective advantage of this completely historic opportunity).]
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoI just wanted to add one cent here to the conversation - European climate is harsher, and this difficulty of survival drives people to cooperate and innovate. That would be a good reason why countries where “food just jumps into your basket” did not outpace Europe. As in my thought here is that technological progress and cooperation isn’t in our human nature by itself. Discomfort could have been a big driver in that case.
- yunohn 5y ago
- Eldt 5y agoI'm seeing some logical leaps here... I suggest asking clarifying questions instead of making strange assumptions.
- yunohn 5y ago
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoBecause the site guidelines call for charitable interpretation. And because most of the rest of us didn't read it that way, so your interpretation is likely to be the one that's off.
- gxt 5y agoExactly, surmontable challenges makes one achieve. When everything is easy, why change?
- user_7832 5y ago> ...difficulty of survival drives people to cooperate and innovate I can't comment about then innovation aspect that much, but Bengal (particularly East Bengal, present day Bangladesh) absolutely had/has a huge culture of sharing. People would share meals and socialize even when they themselves were barely able feed themselves (and this was mostly reciprocated). This may be more of generosity than strictly cooperation, but I would say they're quite related. Source: The stories I've heard from my grandparents (I'm Bengali)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danans 5y ago> In Bangladesh, food just jumps into your basket. Meanwhile Europeans were hacking away at soil that freezes for large parts of the year. What you state as a contradiction could instead be seen as the explanation. When food "jumps into your basket", you don't need to focus as much on efficiency and on driving towards automation, which arguably was the ultimate drive of the industrial revolution, upon which most of the modern wealth of Europe was built. The lower effort to food ratio in warm humid places also allows you to support more population, which in turn reduces the need for automation because of the plentiful labor. The spectacular populations of China and India despite their less developed past is basically due to the incredible caloric productivity of rice agriculture. Also, there is the general stability of most of Europe with respect to weather. It is a northern climate but tempered by the gulf stream.
- qiskit 5y ago> I think it’s tremendously important for academia to study what factors have allowed certain countries to develop stable, prosperous democracies. It's no mystery. You need a politically united elite. You need political stability/authoritarianism. You need a nationalistic elite that take a nation's wealth and develop it rather than fly to europe and waste it there. And you need to become rich before you become a democracy. Democracy is a luxury for the wealthy. It's not something you want as a poor or developing country. The british celebrate democracy in india/etc not because they love india. But because they hate/fear them. The relationship between britain and india has always been that of a master and a slave. Ask yourself, why do the british malign china, which has developed immensely, but praise india which has 300 million without electricity? They praise india because india is undeveloped and weak and they malign china because they are developing and getting stronger. The master never wants their slaves to usurp them. The easiest way to tell if india is on the right path is if britain and the west start denouncing india. Like we did after india developed nuclears. > It chalks up the differences in development between countries to “geography” giving some countries a “head start.” It's true. Geography is destiny. It's why britain was of no importance until the americas was "discovered". When mediterranean trade was dominant, it was mediterranean countries ( rome/greece/egypt/etc ) that was wealthy. When the new world became the focus, spain/britain/france/etc became the wealthiest empires for a reason compared to italy/greece/poland/etc. There are other factors involved for sure, but geography is absolutely significant. > Yet by the time the British East India company came to India, Britain was more than twice as rich per capita as India That's because britain had the colonies to offload most of their people. Also the british was the largest atlantic slave traders for 100 years before they arrived in south asia. > The British will never write a $42 trillion check for what they allegedly siphoned off from India. Not unless india conquers britain and takes it back. If you look at opportunity cost, then they siphoned far more than $42 trillion. If india was free to develop/industrialize like say japan did in the late 1800s, India today would be a $60+ trillion economy. It's mindboggling that india still hasn't gone full-throttle with their industrialization like America or Europe did in the early 1800s, japan did in the late 1800s or china did in the 80s. What is india waiting for? It seems like the indian elite prefers pat on their heads for being a democracy by the west rather than industrializing their country. > But understanding how the British (themselves the victims of repeated invasions) came to have the economic and military advantage that allowed them to do that would be valuable. It's not rocket science. Imagine if bangladesh finds a piece of land that is 100000000X the size of bangladesh and has infinite more resources. Imagine if bangladesh was able to send 80% of its population to that land and transport the resources of that land to bangladesh. How do you think that would affects its per capita GDP? Geography made britain ( aka its proximity to north america ). I don't think bangladesh is going to find such luck. They should look at how japan, south korea, singapore, etc developed. Bangladesh needs a united nationalistic elite because a nation is developed by the elite. The rise of china lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty and represents the greatest humanitarian achievement to date. If south asia ( which has nearly 2 billion people, far more than china ) can get its act together, it would be the greatest humanitarian achievement for all time. No region could surpass it because no region has that many people.
- mrorangewebsite 5y agoThank you for your insights. This was really 'eye-opening' for me as someone who is sympathetic to rhetoric around colonisation. > there is no politically correct answer to this question I would love to hear your opinions on the true answer to this question. I hope HN is a place where we can engage in this type of discourse sensibly with open minds and hearts. Thanks again for your well-articulated thoughts.
- PKop 5y agoDifferential of average IQ by country might have something to say in this regard, but also this is very controversial (even if a meaningful and true contributing factor to differential between national achievement). Of course then the question is what produces this differential? Culture and environment producing some sort of selective pressure perhaps, with both feeding back into each other. Certainly the heritability of intelligence argues this is a biological phenomenon to some degree.
- tim333 5y ago>there is no politically correct answer to this question that allows study of what Bangladeshis could have done or could do differently I think a lot of what makes the difference is cultural. Places like Singapore have a culture of hard work, rule of law, free trade and so on, mostly brought in by its founder who got a lot of that stuff from books and learning. There is hope to replicate those sort of things gradually. It's not so much about race - Singapore is quite the mix - the founder was Chinese but studied in England and the people are a mix of Chinese, Malay, Indian, Westerners and other.
- rayiner 5y ago> It's not so much about race An axiom of liberal thought these days is that culture is coextensive with race. Hence the dichotomy asserted in the curriculum materials I linked: disparities must be geographic in nature; any other theory is “racist.” (Likewise, most of what’s attributed to “whiteness” is really Western European culture. They don’t seem to distinguish the two concepts at all.) There is no room for the possibility that different societies developed different cultures for various reasons, and certain cultural traits may be better adapted to economic development than others. Fun fact: Lee Kuan Yew’s (the founder of modern Singapore) birth name was Harry and his first language was English.
- tim333 5y agoHa. I didn't know that. Sowell used to write very well on race and culture stuff eg https://www.amazon.co.uk/Race-Culture-Sowell/dp/0465067972 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Race-Culture-Sowell/dp/0465067972 He could get away with saying things that would otherwise be regarded as politically incorrect as he is black himself. It's a shame there doesn't seem to be much of that quality any more.
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago"Factors outside the control of people" seems like a pretty good summary of human history, but you feel it's morally damaging in some way to think that, even if it's true?
- rayiner 5y agoI don’t think we know whether it’s true or not. I think the inquiry in this area is distorted by liberal assumptions that require disparities to be explainable by blaming chance (or white European people). That is damaging because if those assumptions aren’t true we are denying developing the opportunity to help themselves, and condemning them to a state of dependency.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWe do know that it's true. What your're proposing is just a form of the Just World Hypothesis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis The nations that found themselves on top of oil or coal or the fertile crescent at just the right time in history did not plan that. It might make people feel more in control of their lives to think that bad things only happen to bad people but it's clearly not true.
- rayiner 5y agoIs it a “form of the Just World Hypothesis” to say that say Google did things that are responsible for its success that other companies could study and copy? > The nations that found themselves on top of oil or coal or the fertile crescent at just the right time in history did not plan that. Doesn’t that undermine your point? Because Bangladesh doesn’t exactly look to Iraq, West Virginia, or Libya as the symbols of affluence and development. Conversely, the UK, Sweden, the Netherlands, etc., aren’t replete with oil and minerals.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI think you missed the 'right time in history' part of my point. If Australia found the biggest coal seam in its history today, it would be more economically wise to put solar panels on it. So all the countries with plenty of sun are going to get lots of cheap energy independence soon. I guess we should cargo cult from whatever they did to achieve this amazing success? I know the liberals want to claim it's geography and 'hours of sunshine' or some other politically correct nonsense but really I think it's all about the wide brimmed hats they wear and avoidance of the corrupting influence of ice hockey. But they won't teach that in schools! And close to home examples like Google should make this more obvious to HN readers. You can't separate them from the early dot com era and what their competitors at the time we're doing, notably monopolist Microsoft trying to kill the internet rather than embrace it, yet accidentally inventing AJAX. There's the whole conversation about the 'Good to Great' book and how the business lessons from these success stories were obviously bullshit with just a tiny amount of hindsight. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_to_Great https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_to_Great
- zozbot234 5y ago> Unfortunately, there is no politically correct answer to this question that allows study of what Bangladeshis could have done or could do differently. Development economics studies this question, and the general answer is still the one Adam Smith came up with in the late 18th century: good institutions matter the most, even more than geography. There's a few easy case studies, like comparing North Korea with South Korea. Same geography, same historical heritage, same ancestry... Why do they achieve so differently? "Different institutions" is the sensible answer to that question.
- Osiris 5y agoYes. I studied International Politics and we definitely studied the question of why some countries are more prosperous than others. The expand on your point about institutions, removing corruption (rent seeking by public servants) is a key part of strong institutions because corruption decreases their effectiveness. The other institution that is extremely necessary for a prosperous country is free press. Free press is critical to removing corruption and strengthening institutions by criticizing when things aren't going right.
- zozbot234 5y agoThere is no one institution that's "most important". You're most likely right that "having a free press" helps countries at the leading frontier of development, but many countries are very far from that level. Famously, many East Asian countries managed to become fairly prosperous while being basically dictatorships from a political POV.
- rayiner 5y agoBut what creates good institutions? My dad was a university student when Bangladesh became independent. He has high hopes for a secular, constitutional social democracy. It was all there on paper. And two decades later he left the country disillusioned to raise his kids in America.
- zozbot234 5y ago
- bennysomething 5y agoThis looks as though Jared Diamond's theories being taught as fact. I read guns germs and steel and came away unconvinced. His theory on Easter Island has been pretty much debunked too. There's something really strange about that curriculum, it seems to have a racial agenda rather than a factual one.
- selimthegrim 5y agoNot having seen one, does magur walk or jump into one’s basket?