5 ms·
Why are people so upset about this? Somebody had to be the first to do gene editing on human DNA. I'm surprised Craig Venter hadn't done this already. Mandator
by Animats 5y ago
Why are people so upset about this? Somebody had to be the first to do gene editing on human DNA. I'm surprised Craig Venter hadn't done this already.
Mandatory XKCD: https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/old_timers.png https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/old_timers.png
- Gatsky 5y agoFirst of all it wasn't necessary. Vertical transmission of HIV can be dealt with in other ways. Why expose these kids to pointless risk? No medical researcher with an ounce of integrity or care would do something like this. Secondly, it was fraud, the guy falsified documents and misrepresented things. Thirdly, the whole concept was dumb. It doesn't make any damn sense. He wanted to edit babies for his own reasons (some mix of insanity and ego I presume), so he found a way to do it. That xkcd is one of the worst ones I've seen, by the way, it also doesn't make any damn sense.
- dekhn 5y agoI had hoped to be the first person to do germline editing in a human (in the late 1980s, as a teenager, that was my goal). I spent about 20 years learning everything I could about human health and the relationship between the genome and visible phenotypes (from molecular to organismal). I concluded that while in principle, you could do germline editing ethically, the technology, and people's ethical maturity are both not at the point where we can do this. Also, if we did it, it would be a group effort not a single scientist acting rogue who didn't even get the details right.
- causality0 5y agoYes, my thought exactly. A huge number of things are perfectly legal to do to children that are much, much worse than possibly screwing up an embryo while trying not to. You can get pregnant in your forties by a man in his seventies, drink and smoke while you're pregnant, and after giving birth have part of the child's genitals surgically removed and have their ears pierced. Why is trying to improve their genome where we draw the line?
- fartcannon 5y agoSo, because some people treat babies and children badly, no one should question the ethics or consider the ramifications of gene manipulation? Seems like a stretch.
- lotu 5y agoThat is a total straw man. The argument is that as a society we permit people to do lots of things to their children that have far greater ramifications that this gene editing. It is there for inconsistent to get upset about gene editing but not these other things.
- borklanm8 5y agoIt doesn't matter if it's inconsistent. If "lots of things" are immoral but permitted, and gene editing is also immoral, the correct conclusion is that all of them should be prevented. If the opposite is true - that if "lots of things" are immoral but permitted, things that are equally or less immoral should also be permitted - then you're arguing for more forms of child abuse to be legalized, in the name of "consistency".
- fartcannon 5y agoNo. It is not inconsistent to get upset about any individual thing we do to children. So gene therapy? Let's consider the consequences. Everything else? Let's also consider the consequences.
- ls612 5y agoIf people generally think X is worse than Y and X is legal then saying Y should be illegal is hypocritical to say the least.
- borklanm8 5y ago
- posnet 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]