5 ms·
Mostly nonsense masquerading under math/science and missing forest for the trees. Rising temperature does not in itself make land arable or suitable for habitat
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
Mostly nonsense masquerading under math/science and missing forest for the trees. Rising temperature does not in itself make land arable or suitable for habitation. In fact it would probably have the opposite effect in sub-arctic regions by causing extensive desertification, forest fires, flooding, erosion, etc.
I can't speak for land in Siberia, but I can speak about land in the north here in my own country, Canada.
The limiting factor for arability in the north here is not temperature, but soil (or, rather, the absence of it.)
Most of the north of Canada, especially the near-north which is now mostly boreal forest, is shallow soil overtop of an almost (or fully) exposed granite base we call the "Canadian shield". It covers a huge portion of the country. It doesn't matter how warm you make it, you won't be able to farm it.
Warming the north also means massive forest fires, which we are already seeing.
In areas where the soils are decent and that aren't on the shield there's already farming quite far north. E.g. take a look at the Peace River etc areas of Alberta. There's quite a few crops you can grow quite far north. (Also much of Canada isn't geographically that far north anyways, when compared to Eurasia.) But you have to have dirt to grow it in.
As for the tundra / taiga / permafrost even further north, I don't know much about the potential soil quality of that land (I doubt it's great though, it's quite arid), but its thawing is already leading to massive erosion problems and population decline for native species.
EDIT: Just for context: The Canadian Shield is 8 million km^2. The total land surface area of the earth is 148 million km^2, thus: The Canadian shield is 5% of the entire land surface of the EARTH, 8% of the northern hemisphere's land mass and 80% of Canada's landmass.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoFully agree. Here's a soil map of my island[0]. And the key to each type of soil.[1] I really don't see an increase in average temperatures changing our podzols into a better soil. But yes, if the climate change predictions pan out, then we can grow more grapes further south on the east side without fear of frosts, yay! However, the climate change predictions also state that the eastern side of the island will experience far less rainfall, and mean far more frequent hot and strong winds[2] that a) strip soil moisture and b) blow away topsoil, while the west side of the island, which is already very wet, will see its annual rainfall increase significantly, and also experience far more frequent extreme flooding events which tend to be very bad for crops and animals, never mind the increased erosion or spoiling (via flood deposits) of land under cultivation. All thanks to the magic of orographic lift.[3] Climate change predictions I'm referring to are here. [4] All this due to a predicted increase in air movement from the west. [0]: https://teara.govt.nz/files/m-12777-enz.jpg https://teara.govt.nz/files/m-12777-enz.jpg [1]: https://teara.govt.nz/en/table/12301/major-soils-and-their-features https://teara.govt.nz/en/table/12301/major-soils-and-their-f... [2]: https://www.nzgeo.com/stories/the-canterbury-norwester/ https://www.nzgeo.com/stories/the-canterbury-norwester/ [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orographic_lift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orographic_lift [4]: https://niwa.co.nz/our-science/climate/information-and-resources/clivar/scenarios https://niwa.co.nz/our-science/climate/information-and-resou...
- thepangolino 5y ago
- jotm 5y agoWhy is the focus on arable land? Is it that important considering agriculture is ridiculously effective? Imo, any net gain would be offset by the massive energy use needed to offset climate change (in turn creating even more climate change), the destruction of natural habitats (animals won't just up and move to new land) and the unrest from mass human migration (humans won't want to settle that new land, either, instead opting for already developed parts).
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI mean I wasn't just focusing on arable land. I mentioned erosion, desertification, and forest fires as well. People aren't going to want to pack up and move to a place surrounded by a) smoke all summer long <see also the pacific northwest last summer> and b) with no economic life near. In any case in areas that aren't already settled industrial centres, agriculture is usually the first primary industry to develop. Though perhaps now it could be oil & gas and forestry as well.
- tomrod 5y agoAgreed. There is more to soil than dirt, including microbes, fungi, and soil dwelling aerators like worms. Soil is a miracle of which we are the beneficiaries. Increasing the amount of available land doesn't result in improved soil quality.
- maerF0x0 5y ago> Soil is a miracle of which we are the beneficiaries. Soil is not a fixed quantity item though, we can make more of it. Part of the problem is the Cost of Living (and subsequently the cost of a marginal farm worker), and many of our ways of scaling farm productivity are tragedies of the commons (atmosphere, water & soil quality, fertilizer farming abroad) a long while back I heard Joel Salatin speak about various systems for rebuilding dirt to soil . Really roughly it involved inedible biomass like hay, animal fecal material, churning/aeration to get bacteria more active, and then distribution across and through the land by animals (ploughing) . Geoff Lawton talks about tools for permaculture and includes bird droppings -- for a small amount of food you can get bird droppings distributed into your environment to improve the soil quality. In many ways big machinery is disadvantaged in this system because of things like their waste goes into the atmosphere rather than the soil.
- imtringued 5y agoThere was a guy on youtube doing no till farming and he basically thought that commercial fertilizer and pesticide is a waste of money. Between growing seasons he is using a location specific mix of 18-20 cover crops to keep the soil covered. He didn't even clean up the residue from the previous crops, preferring to seed directly through a thickly covered bed. He barely had any problems with pests or diseases as he the predators of the pests survive and take care of the problem or he made sure there are enough mycorrhizal fungi and bacteria of the proper kind in the soil. The soil quality was getting better every single year. There are some obvious downsides. First of all, over the short term you will see lower yields as you aren't strip mining the soil for a short term benefit. Second, you actually need a huge amount of knowledge to do this properly. Third, it takes decades to build up high quality soil and only a few years to ruin it, it's like forestry in that regard.
- leereeves 5y ago> The limiting factor for arability in the north here is not temperature, but soil (or, rather, the absence of it.) According to Wikipedia, "Approximately half of Canada is covered by forest."[1] If the soil is deep enough to grow trees, why can't it grow crops? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_Canada
- EdwardDiego 5y agoBecause trees and human crops use the soil very differently. (And trees just doing their own thing use soils far differently to trees being grown for a silvicultural enterprise, for obvious reasons, we want more timber faster) Here's a very obvious example, the Amazon, there's reasons that slash and burn farmers there have to keep cutting down more forest, it's called "soil exhaustion". [0] Another example from an areas I can speak more soundly on, look at the forest in this photo[1], lots of trees, right? Some of them are 100m high. But they're growing on a podzol[2]. Good luck growing crops in that without massive amounts of uneconomic inputs. You'd need huge amounts of lime to reduce the acidity, huge amounts of organic material to increase fertility, never mind the question of managing water retention - too much is bad, too little is bad. Oh, and of course you might need to add additional minerals like selenium or cobalt. [3] Soil science is a separate discipline for a reason. It's complicated as hell. [0]: https://www.dw.com/en/the-amazon-nutrient-rich-rainforests-on-useless-soils/a-50139632 https://www.dw.com/en/the-amazon-nutrient-rich-rainforests-o... [1]: https://hikingscenery.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/P1050707-1024x362.jpg https://hikingscenery.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/P105070... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Podzol#Characteristics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Podzol#Characteristics [3]: https://teara.govt.nz/en/document/14187/bush-sickness https://teara.govt.nz/en/document/14187/bush-sickness So sure, once you've cut down all the trees, and then spent millions remedying water retention/drainage issues of soil structure, millions adding organic material, millions changing pH, and millions remedying any mineral deficiencies, sure, you can grow food there. Although, have you thought about erosion? And why removing trees can render soils far more prone to erosion?
- maerF0x0 5y agoMany reasons including PH, Soil retention under weathering (tree roots hold soil, and reduce wind erosion from leaves too), preferred fertilizer mix (nitrogen for example). This all said, there are plenty of farming techniques that can make the land productive, it's just not as simple as clear cut + plant.