6 ms·
The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
- davedx 5y agoSomewhere, sometime, the Great Filter lies waiting for us... It is patient beyond our fathoming
- xwdv 5y agoThe great filter could presently already be on it’s way to us. Perhaps in the form of a gamma ray blast crawling across vast swathes of space. Or a vacuum metastability event rapidly expanding and destroying reality from some point in the unobservable universe.
- 323 5y agoTechnically vacuum metastability would not be a great filter, since it will wipe out the whole universe, not just one civilization.
- pellmellism 5y agounless there is more then 1 universe
- nkoren 5y agoStill not the Great Filter, which by definition is the explanation for why there's so little evidence of intelligent life in this universe.
- nebula8804 5y agoUnless we have already passed it. Thats a possibility right?
- echelon 5y agoOnly in the bad sense, as we're still subject to the dangers of nuclear annihilation, cosmic disaster, vulnerable world hypothesis, etc. at pretty much every moment. We could have already exhausted all of the easy to obtain energy and resources, and that would make growth very hard to sustain at a level where we can expend extra effort on space exploration. Imagine an alien civilization that didn't have a Carboniferous period where energy was just left sitting around and accumulating for future use. Now imagine us exhausting it before we expand beyond our planet. That's the worry. Will we be able to tap into renewables in a way that sustains growth? Maybe. We're not there yet, though.
- alcover 5y agoI hear many minerals and fuels are past/near peaking. Recycling and thriftness will ease the descent a bit but I share your urgency. We have to go full-bore on space and nuclear.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThat's the most plausible alternative by many orders of magnitude. In fact, the filters on our past are things with odds of survival that we estimate by counting orders of magnitude. At the same time, you will have a hard time getting estimates of survival lower than 1% for the known filters on our future. Unless there is something really surprising with space travel, we are past the Great Filter.
- stormbrew 5y agoI think you have this precisely backwards? When humanity was scattered across the globe and unable to do any large scale geo-engineering or deliberately induce fission or fusion, we were largely incapable of dying by our own sword, so the only things that could eliminate the species are things that essentially would wipe out all medium-sized mammalian life on earth. Meteor strikes, absurdly large solar flares, a planetoid crashing into the moon, whatever. Now we still have basically all of those -- because realistically we're still not at the point where we have anywhere to colonize and survive long term without a living earth, even if we had the tech to try -- but we also have the ways in which we can eliminate ourselves, like causing our own climate crisis (which we are gleefully doing right now) or nuclear annihilation.
- gmuslera 5y agoIt is not waiting. We are actively building it. Of course, we can be hit by a big asteroid, or the planet sterilized by a nearby supernova or some other totally unexpected events out of our control, but we keep turning our present reality something unsustainable in many ways. We should not be surprised if we hit the barrier we built in front of us.
- swayvil 5y agoMorlock-Eloi style division of species. Except the Eloi will be billionaire supermen. And the Morlocks will exist within a totally controlled, synthetic, optimized THX1138-style reality where they work hard, but at least they have their pride. All progress will be bent to that end. The only alternative is something completely different. Wizards or something.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoRepublicans and democrats more like it. They don’t breed, after all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rmah 5y agoThe scenario where the destitute masses toil for the crazy rich few does not make economic sense in the post-industrial age we currently live in. That scenario only makes sense in low-productivity societies (and that was essentially how most pre-industrial societies were structured). Why? Because it is mass consumption of goods and services by the many that allows for the massive wealth of the few on top. If not for this mass consumption, the very rich would be orders of magnitude poorer in an absolute sense (though they may be much richer than the median in a relative sense). It is only by skimming from a huge economy that allows for the very rich as we understand them today to exist. And if the mass consumption exists, that means, by definition, that the majority are not destitute.
- boringg 5y agoComment irreversibly edited. Placeholder now.
- pdonis 5y ago> Universe has 5 Billions years per recent physicists estimates Where are you getting that from? Are you sure you're not mistaking this for the expected lifetime of the Sun as a normal star?
- boringg 5y agoNat geo
- Jtsummers 5y agoNat Geo article: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/101027-science-space-universe-end-of-time-multiverse-inflation https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/101027-sc... What it references: https://arxiv.org/abs/1009.4698v1 https://arxiv.org/abs/1009.4698v1 It's not the definitive sort of statement that GP initially (now deleted) implied it was.
- pdonis 5y agoThanks for the reference to the paper. Indeed, what is claimed is much more...nuanced...than what the GP was claiming.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- apocalypstyx 5y agoThe evolutionary urge for reproduction is all-consuming. So much for humanity's claims to have transcended nature. EDIT: (stealing a half-remembered quote from someone else) "Humans beings are unique in that they are the only known species who produce offspring in order to subsidize their fantasies."
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoAnd yet, industrialized countries fall below replacement level and world population plateaus. Clearly, it isn't all-consuming. Also your quote is blatantly false. Consider bees. The queen produces offspring literally to build her hive and feed her young.
- Kye 5y agoI always wonder about what goes on in the heads of people who claim that. I've never had any desire to have kids. Is it a case of something like pluralistic ignorance, or do they really feel a strong overriding drive here?
- ASalazarMX 5y agoHow many of us who didn't want children have siblings that had children in our place? The drive for reproduction wins, even without considering that without the drive for reproduction of our parents we wouldn't even exist. More so, the drive for reproduction isn't necessarily about kids, but sexuality. Sex sells. A big chunk of our civilization is about food and sex.
- jl6 5y agoNot having children is very common and always has been, and yet seems to me a somewhat radical decision when you think that you represent an unbroken line of reproduction going back 4 billion years, and somehow that line ends with you.
- 5y ago
- 323 5y agoGiven recent events, I'm starting to think we are going to blow ourselves up one way or another. First a lab leaked virus, then one man with a giant ego and a nuclear button. As tech becomes more powerful, it becomes easier and easier for one accident or deranged person to kill us all.
- thicknessing 5y ago
- techer 5y agoMaybe kill…but probably enslave??
- wussboy 5y agoI definitely understand your sentiment. But I can't help but think whatever nuclear angst we are experiencing right now can't have been anything compared to what was experienced in the 50s and 60s.
- stormbrew 5y agoI think we're still far more likely to kill ourselves slowly than quickly, though the slow but accelerating erosion of our ecosystem could certainly accelerate things that would lead to a quicker end. Either way, 800k years feels very optimistic right now. We need to stop thinking about a trillion potential future people over a million years and start making things better for the few billion or so who will live in the next 20-100 years if those trillions are ever going to exist. We're really really bad at this near-medium horizon, endlessly shuffling the costs of our choices onto them and their children as if we can amortize it forever.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoLab leaked? I'm more concerned with the rise of 'Idiocracy' to be honest
- rmah 5y agoCivilization is far more resilient than most people today seem to believe. History shows that utter devastation can tear through a civilization, killing as much as one in three people, but civilization will rebound within a generation or three. If an apocalypse happens, it will certainly be horrific for those who experience it, but humanity will not just survive, it will rebuild quite rapidly. You may not live to see the new renaissance, but will happen.
- jl6 5y agoThat graph showing poverty reduction in the last 20/40/60 years is wild, and very encouraging. This is so important, because it’s almost impossible to get people to cooperate on solving long term existential risks while their own short term existence is at risk.
- d0mine 5y agoThe very first plot is a textbook and misleading. If we consider only recorded history (~10k) then today the more people alive than ever lived
- fritzo 5y agoThis reads like a 1950s ad envisioning a future filled with unimaginably many vacuum tubes.
- revolvingocelot 5y agoOne of the problems with thinking about "the future" is that one generally only has "today" to think about it with.
- deepzn 5y agoThat is a rather large caveat..."if we avoid a major catastrophe", have you looked around the world?
- shadowofneptune 5y ago> A catastrophe that ends human history would destroy the vast future that humanity would otherwise have. And it would be horrific for those who will be alive at that time. The people who live then will be just as real as you or me. They will exist, they just don’t exist yet. They will feel the sun on their skin and they will enjoy a swim in the sea. They will have the same hopes, they will feel the same pain. I agree with the idea of preserving opportunity in the future, but the way it is posed in this article is strange. It treats these unborn billions as if they exist right now, and to change the future is to betray them. Focusing so much on the number of unborn people also makes it seem like the author thinks a larger world population is inherently better, morally better. Say the world population instead stabilizes at six billion by the year 2700. That leads to trillions less people being born than in the author's scenario. Is that a lost world? Would the people alive then care?
- pmoriarty 5y ago"Focusing so much on the number of unborn people also makes it seem like the author thinks a larger world population is inherently better, morally better." From a utilitarian perspective, which values the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people would consider more happy people to be a good thing.
- stormbrew 5y agoI think you're reading some moral judgements in that aren't there. We have very little control over the future population of the world, especially over a 1 million year time scale. Nothing in the article says "it would be good for there to have been 100 trillion people in 800 thousand years", it just says there might be. However you tweak the numbers, unless you assume a much more significant depopulation than just the current 8 or so to 6 billion people, it's many trillions of people either way. Even with a massive depopulation, if human life continues until then the number will unquestionably dwarf the current population. So it's posing the simple question: If your actions cause pain for future generations, how many people will it effect? What's an acceptable number of future people to hurt for whatever you're doing now? This is a moral question, a kind of ultra scale trolley problem, not an answer.
- 5y ago
- MrYellowP 5y agoIs this an ad for the Great Reset ?