3 ms·
Let's simplify the moral calculus. You are a public health official with total authority over messaging. You are faced with a public health issue that could p
by dekhn 5y ago
Let's simplify the moral calculus. You are a public health official with total authority over messaging. You are faced with a public health issue that could possibly be existential- that is, there is an estimated nonzero risk that if you fail to act, all of society could be wiped out. Do you: allow for free speech, risking total annihilation (because your freedom of speech principles are more important than societal existence), or disallow free speech during the emergency, while also agreeing to suspend it when well defined criteria are reached?
I pick the latter. However, COVID itself was never existential (some fracction of people are immune, or get sick and then don't die, but instead reproduce, and over time, genetic immunity increases due to natural selection), although it was absolutely a threat to a healthy global economy (which in turn determines how much health care is available to society). So the calculus is more complicated. Probably, it's best to: promote the correct message, while allowing dissenting opiniions to be stated, but firmly refuted, and people who are saying things that are outright risky ("inject bleach") are shut down with the full force of law.
- edmcnulty101 5y ago> However, COVID itself was never existential Covid was not existential. Here's a though experiment for you: If a group completely blew something out of proportion with massive restrictions on the world...would you want to know about it, to regain your freedom? Or continue to be lied to in order to save face for your ideological peer group?
- dekhn 5y agoI don't know... did that happen? Or is this a hypothetical? It didn't happen (large scale intentional lying), but if my government openly lies, I will complain about it up and until they restrict my freedom of speech, and I'll use the mechanisms I know (using social media, salon discussion websites, etc) to promote my message.
- disambiguation 5y agothe calculus is not as simple as you suggest, given "free speech" and "institutional message" are variable, too. your example implies "free speech" = some advice that will get you killed and "institutional message" = some advice that will definitely save your life it also implies that "officials" only act rationally and morally.