3 ms·
How very post-modern of you -- there's no truth, so let's not try to enforce it. Problem is, most of the recent distortions have been blatant, and easy to veri
by timr 18y ago
How very post-modern of you -- there's no truth, so let's not try to enforce it. Problem is, most of the recent distortions have been blatant, and easy to verify.
Case in point -- the Obama sex-education bill that you cite. The exact wording of the bill in question was:
"Each class or course in comprehensive sex education offered IN ANY OF grades K through 12 shall include instruction on the prevention of sexually transmitted infections, including the prevention, transmission and spread of HIV." (emphasis mine)
In other words, it's not mandating sex education for kindergarteners -- it's saying that any sex education that they do receive must have a certain curriculum. It also says that:
"All course material and instruction shall be age and developmentally appropriate."
In other words: if you're trying to suggest that it's actually impossible to determine the truthfulness of a charge, this example is terrible. It's an obvious, blatant distortion of the truth by the Republican campaign, and it can't be justified. Any reasonable, intelligent person can see that fact.
If, however, you're suggesting that political parties would cry like babies if held to a higher standard of debate, I can't dispute your assertion. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't try. If we can hold drug manufacturers to objective standards for truth in advertising, there's no fundamental reason that we can't do the same thing for political advertising.
- hugh 18y agoHere's a good guideline: in order to avoid looking like you're advocating for one particular candidate in these sorts of discussions, it's best to always use two examples: one which makes one party look bad, and another which makes the other party look bad. So if you're going to talk about an example of dishonesty on the part of the McCain campaign, you should follow it up immediately by an example of dishonesty on the part of the Obama campaign. That way, everybody stays happy, and it stops things from degenerating into political arguments.
- MaysonL 18y agoThe trouble is - the vast majority of the dishonest and dishonorable lies are coming from one side. Obama isn't deliberately lying - McCain and company are. Repeatedly. After the lies have been exposed. On national TV.
- hugh 18y agoIf you really believe the unlikely proposition that one political party is honest and the other is full of liars, then I'm sure you can find other sites upon which to put forth that argument.
- Retric 18y agoIf you disagree with someone's statement provide counter evidence of such things. Otherwise your attacking the person and not the argument. PS: The stance that both sides of a debate always deserve equal time pervasive and wrong. When someone says the acceleration due to gravity of an object is always 100km/s^2 they are wrong and there is little point in giving them identical amounts of time. Think about the coverage given to the anti global worming / evolution / science crowd and ask your self is this reasonable?
- timr 18y agoGiven that the parent post chose his examples to make one side look good, I don't think my response was inappropriate (in fact, all really did was counter his primary argument using his own example). It's important to be civil and logical; it's not important for every participant in a debate to make the other side's arguments for them.
- hugh 18y agoit's not important for every participant in a debate to make the other side's arguments for them Ah, but there shouldn't be "another side" in these sorts of discussions. I'm just trying to propose ways in which it's possible to discuss politics in the abstract without the discussion veering off into arguments about the boring minutiae of giant douche vs turd sandwich that is going to be infecting the rest of the internet for the next couple of months.
- DanielBMarkham 18y ago"I'm just trying to propose ways in which it's possible to discuss politics in the abstract" I believe this is called being mature. Good luck with your effort. It's tough, and if you make the slightest mistake (such as using examples that tilt against the same party) you're sure to be punished.