7 ms·
I thought I knew all about the Lagrange points, but then JWST took up an orbit around what was supposed to be an unstable one, and all I thought I knew went out
by ncmncm 5y ago
I thought I knew all about the Lagrange points, but then JWST took up an orbit around what was supposed to be an unstable one, and all I thought I knew went out the window.
- jakear 5y agoDo you place your telescope at the top of the mountain with boulders falling away from it in all directions or at the bottom of a crater with boulders falling towards it from all directions?
- burnished 5y agoThe latter. Adversity encourages strength.
- tux3 5y agoOne statement often applied to others, seldom for oneself. People don't choose adversity, they only like to dispense it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoPositioning of telescopes is about "how good is the view from here?" it favours hills, but that is not driven by the hazards. However the hazards up on hills are more typically those of exposure, altitude and isolation, not incoming gravitationally-propelled objects.
- ncmncm 5y ago"How do you keep warm, up on a mountain top all night?" "We don't."
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoI learned that at University; the students who were doing Astronomy / Astrophysics would make pilgrimages to the Big Telescope, which was located over 200 miles away, in a remote and sparsely populated area on a high plateau, known for clear skies, low rainfall and cold nights. Cold cold nights. Not much for students to do outside of work either; the nearest town had 3K people, whose interests included farming and churchgoing.
- WithinReason 5y agoL2 is neither a mountain or a crater, it's more like a saddle point
- jakear 5y agoThanks, didn’t know that. Turns out there are no “crater” Lagrange points, so the analogy doesn’t really hold. But that also means there are no stable Lagrange points, so the question doesn’t hold either!
- WithinReason 5y agoIf by crater you mean having a "local minimum", then the L4 and L5 points are actually like that and can even capture asteroids: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trojan_(celestial_body) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trojan_(celestial_body)
- jakear 5y agoHm, I cannot unify that claim with this diagram: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lagrange_point#/media/File:Lagrange_points2.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lagrange_point#/media/File:Lag...
- harpersealtako 5y agoFrom that wiki page: >Although the L4 and L5 points are found at the top of a "hill", as in the effective potential contour plot above, they are nonetheless stable. The reason for the stability is a second-order effect: as a body moves away from the exact Lagrange position, Coriolis acceleration (which depends on the velocity of an orbiting object and cannot be modeled as a contour map)[20] curves the trajectory into a path around (rather than away from) the point.[20][22] Because the source of stability is the Coriolis force, the resulting orbits can be stable, but generally are not planar, but "three-dimensional": they lie on a warped surface intersecting the ecliptic plane. The kidney-shaped orbits typically shown nested around L4 and L5 are the projections of the orbits on a plane (e.g. the ecliptic) and not the full 3-D orbits.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoThe article mentions that - "unstable" is not that unstable - small deviations result in a slow drift and can be fixed with small corrections, so with a few thrusters a craft can stay in place there for years. > Webb will need to conduct occasional small thruster burns for "station keeping" and "momentum management" to retain its proper location and orientation in space. > should have enough propellant to allow support of science operations in orbit for significantly more than a 10-year science lifetime https://www.space.com/james-webb-space-telescope-fuel-lifetime https://www.space.com/james-webb-space-telescope-fuel-lifeti...
- mjevans 5y agoI wonder what the end of life plan is, just stop correcting and drift about randomly?
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoI mean, either of us could easily google it, but if we're going to wonder and speculate, it seems more Nasa-like to reserve the last x amount of fuel for a burn that sends it off into deep space to be safely out of the way. Likely won't need much fuel for that.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThat's what iirc all satellites need to have, a decommissioning plan; IIRC geostationary satellites, when they retire, do a thrust to put them in a (higher?) parking orbit. There was a project and/or company that was looking into building a spacecraft that could make its way to geostationary satellites about to retire, latch onto them (by putting a docking rod into their exhaust for example) and act as its new engine, to extend their lifespans. Which is neat, and even though they may be 20-30 years old, they're still antennas that can transfer data around.
- thombat 5y agoIt very much depends upon what "deep space" means to you: * escape from the solar system altogether? That requires a big change in velocity, about half as much again as what it took to get to its current orbit. * chuck it into the sun? needs more change than escaping the solar system * or just a different orbit to the current one with less chance of being inconvenient? then you may as well leave it where it is - there are already a bunch of Earth Trojan asteroids around the Lagrange points which pose a similar likelihood of becoming inconvenient and being much bigger pose a greater hazard.
- matja 5y agoI mean, its as unstable as balancing a broom upright on your hand is... unstable but not impossible.
- ncmncm 5y agoThe halo orbit JWST is in is much more stable than that.
- pfdietz 5y agoHalo orbits around the L2 point are stable, I think? https://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1984CeMec..32...53H https://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1984CeMec..32...53H
- guywhocodes 5y agoIf it was perfectly stable, wouldn't you expect to find a bunch of crap there like in the "pacific trash island"?
- ncmncm 5y agoStuff would have to both (1) get there, and then (2) lose enough energy to stay. Doubtless millions of rocks have achieved (1), but have no means to achieve (2). In any case, it's not perfectly stable. Occasional perturbations are bigger than the energy needed to leave. So, things put there don't stay long without help.
- KolenCh 5y agoIt’s not the first time satellites are sent there so I’m a bit surprised it is a surprise. Eg Planck satellite.