7 ms·
Bicycling Street Smarts, Chapter 6: Using Your Brakes (2001)
- Fricken 5y agoIn 30 years of commuting I've never actually had to rely on hard braking to avoid a collision. On many occasions I have swerved to avoid a collision. The one time a collision was unavoidable through swerving or braking, I jumped straight up, and deflected off windsheild rather than getting walloped straight-on.
- travgary 5y agoYour lucky, my disk breaks have certainly saved my life in SF more than once. The one that really sticks with me is watching the cyclist in front of me fly into the air from getting hit by a speeding car ignoring the no right turn sign. If I had not braked hard I would have hit the side of that car. I spoke with the police after offering to testify and they did not want to take a report even saying it was an insurance matter. I twisted their arm but later after getting in touch with the hit cyclist who was nearly killed again offering to testify found out they threw my report away. The injured cyclist was so traumatized he just wanted to put it behind him. I got lots of stories and have been hit multiple times, had a friend killed on her cycle. I hate that the narative is all about defensive cycling and not that cars kill and no one cares especially SF cops.
- unicornporn 5y agoOh shit, that's a grim reality. :( Weather in SF seems nice, but when it comes to bike commuting I'm happy to be in Scandinavia.
- Fricken 5y agoI try not to rely on luck. The accident I mentioned above; it happened because I was stupid, not because I was unlucky. I had ample opportunity to avert catashtropy but failed to recognize them because I wasn't directing my attention to the right things in the moment prior to the collision. I'm a big believer in situational awareness, experience and skill. I hear stories of cyclists getting into accidents and I'm aghast at all the hazards they didn't consider, and all the skills they didn't cultivate. It's not like I'm risk averse. Quite the contrary, I make a practice of engaging with it. I was a bicycle messenger for 2 years in heavy downtown traffic. I raced mountain bikes and BMX. I've had hundreds of wipeouts in non-traffic situations. There are skills I rely on daily while in traffic to stay in one piece, and I have a hard time convincing a certain subset of cyclists that these skills even exist. They think it's luck! There are so many opportunities to anticipate and escape bad situations that go unrecognized by less experienced cyclists.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoHoly victim-blaming, batman. They're crashes, not accidents, for starters. You can try to predict or anticipate people's actions and smugly think that you won't end up under the wheels of a truck because you're Mr. Pro Rider unlike those "certain subset of cyclists." At the end of the day, drivers are exceptionally unpredictable, their vehicles can accelerate, stop, and turn far faster than a bicycle can, and there are plenty of actions of others that are impossible to avoid. The problem is not that "certain subset" of cyclists aren't careful enough, it's that society has wildly different expectations from vulnerable road users compared to the people driving the dangerous machinery. Society expects someone on a bicycle headed to work to perfectly and expertly analyze everything in front of them and faultlessly predict the actions of others...while having no problem with a driver of a 4,000lb vehicle yakking on the phone while drinking a coffee and listening to the radio.
- pastage 5y agoDoesn't have to be victim blaming if you read closely, but I got that vibe as well. FWIW a car can not turn, accelerate and stop faster than a bicycle. I am sure our difference in opinion here is more about situation than facts. I do agree that they are more dangerous than bicycles and far less logical because of what you say.
- Fricken 5y agoI have no intention of embracing victim mentality. If you're prioritizing morals at the expense of physics while out for a ride, you're going to have a bad time.
- pastage 5y agoYou can not be on your A game all the time, so yes it's about luck. If everyone just made one mistake every week you would still have a high chance of seeing them all the time. For me being experienced in traffic means I try to act as a buffer for others mistakes. If you know all of those situations that lead to bad out comes position yourself so less experienced people are herded to the safe ones.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> In 30 years of commuting I've never actually had to rely on hard braking to avoid a collision. On many occasions I have swerved to avoid a collision. I agree with what you said, but I think the issue is one of experience, or maybe even skill. I can remember one crash I had when better breaks would have saved me. But I do recognize now that I could have just as easily swerved. I was around 7 at the time, so still had a lot to learn. But I think many casual cyclists will try (panic-)breaking when something unexpected comes up. But then again, if they're not used to strong breaks, they may crash on their own. Had this happen to me once while visiting Britain, and not being used yet to the brake levers being inverted.
- peatmoss 5y agoSwerving and threshold braking are the two maneuvers in our arsenals to avoid crashes when things have gone badly. Every season I start off with some quality time in a parking lot practicing both swerving and braking (EDIT: on my motorcycle—I get enough in-situ practice on my bicycle regularly). I'm not sure I'd be brave enough to ride a motorcycle or bicycle not having both of those skills polished.
- xyzzyz 5y agoYes, use the front brake, it gives you a lot more stopping power than the rear brake. This is even more important on a motorcycle, where the front brake has something like 90% of the total braking force. One could even argue that it doesn't even make much sense to use rear brake at all on a motorcycle: while in some cases using rear brake only might be enough (e.g. when you want to just slow down a little), you still should be using front brake every time, to develop muscle memory so that you will use the front one whenever you need to break hard. Never using the rear one forces you to develop proper habit of always using the front one. The loss of braking force from not using rear brake is rather small, especially as you can't push on it hard when you're brake using front one, because you're risking skidding rear wheel, as almost all weight is on the front tire. Recovering from rear skid is not what you want to be thinking about when emergency braking. That said, using both front and rear brake on a motorcycle does make a difference, so if you've been practicing emergency braking (or have ABS on your bike) and are comfortable with a little bit of skidding, you can use both to squeeze some extra stopping power. Crucially, though, remember to always use the front one.
- mzi 5y agoAll braking will transfer the weight from the rear wheel(s) to the front wheel(s), regardless which brake you're using. So braking with only the rear brake will transfer wight to the front wheels until you loose traction on the rear wheel and just skids. But this shift in weight can be used to initiate braking: a touch of rear brake will shift the weight forward so that your front wheel gets more traction, and then you apply the front brake. This is even more apparent on a motorcycle.
- flyinglizard 5y agoThis is why you rapidly but gradually squeeze the brakes, to allowing time for the suspension to compress before overloading the tires. This is true for any vehicle.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mxwsn 5y agoYou can also move your butt behind, over the rear wheel, to help stay grounded against the force of a strong press of the front brake.
- gegtik 5y agothis is what i do in an emergency braking situation - stand on the pedals and lean back and down, and hammer the brakes as hard as I can
- atoav 5y agoAnd then as the bicycle goes front-wheelie be ready to exit on one side of the bike and run it out. The biggest damage anything took from three times I had to do this in the past 20 years was my bike (one time I had to exchange the handle bar).
- mvkel 5y agoThis covers emergency stopping well, but in regular conditions I'd modify it a bit. It's easy to overuse the front brake because it has so much stopping power. The outcome of that is you'll chew through your front pads and rims much more quickly than your rear. When approaching a stop, start lightly applying the rear brake -first- to bleed off initial speed, -then- apply the front. Your pads will last a lot longer, and they'll all wear evenly.
- unicornporn 5y ago> The outcome of that is you'll chew through your front pads and rims much more quickly than your rear. Most contemporary bikes have disc brakes (breaking won't chew on your rim) and wearing through the front pads faster than the rear pads can't really be considered to be a problem, can it?
- IneffablePigeon 5y agoI think 75-85% of the bikes I see around here (UK) still have rim brakes not discs. They're cheaper.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoI tend to brake with both if I'm not stopping urgently. It's not a big deal; brake pads are cheap and easy to change, lots of bikes are disc these days and pads/rotors are easy to change. Good rims take a long time to wear in regular conditions and most aren't that expensive anyway. What really wears rims fast is wet sand/dirt
- DantesKite 5y agoUnpopular Opinion: Bicycles are far too dangerous for humans to drive. Collisions are inevitable and when they do happen, they can be debilitating. For me, it's never worth the risk. Everybody I know who rides bikes long enough has a story to tell.
- zahma 5y agoDo you also not drive a car because of the risk? Humans have to get places quickly, and a bike is a great bit of technology. (I also just simply enjoy riding my bike.) Given the choice between choosing one mode of transportation for all, would you still say the same about bikes? The number of road deaths involving cars makes a pretty compelling case that cars are much harder for humans to control than bikes.[1] 38,680 people died because humans can’t be trusted in cars. I’d even wager that bike accidents and deaths would be fewer if cyclists didn’t share the road with humans in cars. 1-https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/2020-fatality-data-show-increased-traffic-fatalities-during-pandemic https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/2020-fatality-data-show...
- hawaiianbrah 5y agoAmen! It is all about choices and in the grand scheme I feel bikes are a fantastic choice.
- DantesKite 5y agoIt's not about avoiding risk completely. That's impossible. It's about considering trade-offs, looking at statistics, and deciding what a life is worth. Your odds of dying from a bicycle accident are much higher than dying from a car accident. In fact, you're twice as likely to die from a bicycle. The CDC did a study on this and a rather thorough one at that. The only activity more dangerous was riding a motorcycle.[1] This is because engineers have spent a lot of time trying to minimize the amount of energy a human absorbs during a car collision. It's not perfect, but it's superior to the lack of protection offered when bicycling. I'm not saying you have to stop riding a bicycle. I'm saying, you should know it is a dangerous activity and consider life insurance if you have a family. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/express/wp/2016/05/12/how-safe-is-bike-commuting-perhaps-less-than-you-think/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/express/wp/2016/05/12/how-saf...