3 ms·
Storing hydrogen underground is, in fact, very easy and cheap. And, storing liquified hydrogen is likewise cheap. We can expect hydrogen to be produced on-site
by ncmncm 5y ago
Storing hydrogen underground is, in fact, very easy and cheap. And, storing liquified hydrogen is likewise cheap. We can expect hydrogen to be produced on-site at large airports from power delivered over transmission lines, stockpiled against low-wind low-sun periods.
Once hydrogen-fueled aircraft enter a particular air freight market, kerosene-fueled craft will be unable to compete, because with LH2's much better mass-energy density, the fuel mass dispensed with may be replaced with paying cargo. Furthermore, hydrogen fuel produced on-site electrically will be cheaper per unit joule than mined, refined, and transported kerosene.
I am surprised to see designs with inboard LH2 tanks. I would expect to see LH2 tanks in wing nacelles, minimizing piping to engines.
- nradov 5y agoProducing hydrogen is not very energy efficient. Electric power would have to get much cheaper to make hydrogen cost competitive with fossil fuels. While hydrogen has sightly higher mass-energy density, the tankage is larger and more complex so the total mass savings is limited and there's a significant drag penalty.
- credit_guy 5y ago> While hydrogen has sightly higher mass-energy density It’s not slightly, it’s three times as much, or more. Per wikipedia [1], Hydrogen has an energy density of 120 MJ/kg vs 43 MJ/kg for kerosene. That’s if you burn it outright. If you put Hydrogen in a fuel cell, and the output of the reaction is liquid water rather than water vapor, then the energy density is 142 MJ/kg. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_chemical_reactions_(oxidation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_chemical_rea...
- iamthemonster 5y agoThe mass density of hydrogen is very much negated by the fact that liquefied hydrogen needs to be in a 700 bar pressurised tank whereas kerosene is happy at atmospheric pressure. The more valid comparison is "hydrogen in a hydrogen pressure vessel" to "kerosene in a tank". I know cars are different, but the Toyota Mirai is actually heavier than the Tesla Model 3 even though it only needs a measly 5 kg of hydrogen to go as far as the Tesla.
- credit_guy 5y agoThey plan to use liquid hydrogen [1, page 2] "FlyZero has concluded that green liquid hydrogen is the most viable zero-carbon emission fuel with the potential to scale to larger aircraft utilising fuel cell, gas turbine and hybrid systems. This has guided the focus, conclusions and recommendations of the project." [1] https://www.ati.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/FZO-AIN-REP-0007-FlyZero-Zero-Carbon-Emission-Aircraft-Concepts.pdf https://www.ati.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/FZO-AIN-RE...
- zardo 5y agoI don't see why LH2 would need to be kept at 700bar. The STS LH2 tank was operated at ~1.6 bar.
- nradov 5y agoAnd what happens if ATC directs the airplane to hold on the runway for a few hours? The space shuttle used cryogenic fuel, and after loading they had to continuously replenish the liquid hydrogen due to leakage and evaporation for several hours until launch. That can work for a rocket with a huge operating budget on a dedicated pad but I don't see that working at a busy commercial airport. Jet fuel is much more stable. It can sit in simple fuel tank for months with no special cooling or containment measures.
- zardo 5y agoI suppose they have to flare off the H2. Or the plane itself has the capacity on board to capture and cool boil off.
- ncmncm 5y agoLH2 in tanks boils off and is vented. There will be different procedures for LH2 vehicles on hold than today. That might involve plugging in somewhere for active cooling while on hold. Or, it might just mean you load on enough LH2 to make up for losses while holding. The practical merits of Jet-A fuel will be traded off against the value proposition of LH2 fuel. LH2 will win easily where volume is high and profits are greatest. So, marginal routes and uses will be the last to switch over.
- ncmncm 5y agoEfficiency of electrolysis will only ever improve. In the meantime, it can be produced and banked preferentially during periods when power is cheapest.