9 ms·
On Killing Tanks (2020)
- q_andrew 5y agoI find the asymmetry of force in vehicle combat very interesting. If a single foot soldier can take out a tank that costs millions of dollars, is it even worth using a tank? Obviously there are tactics to avoid this but I bet it's a pain in the ass to out-maneuver.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoGenerally, yes, and tanks usually roll with air support if not also infantry. Russia's neglect of this armchair-strategist type knowledge is making headlines.
- hef19898 5y agoTanks without infantry support are basically just targets. Especially in urban environments, the Turkish army showed that quite impressively in Syria (?) by loosing a couple of Leopard 2s.
- sofixa 5y agoThe Russians supposedly had a tank chassis with soft weapons ( machine guns, small cannon, grenade launchers) on top, to accompany tanks in urban environments, specifically due to lessons from Checnhya about the vulnerability of tanks against infantry defenses, especially in urban environments - BMPT. Supposedly the idea was to have them accompany tanks and support them. In reality, they are nowhere to be seen
- aerostable_slug 5y agoBMPTs were seen heading into theater on railcars. I've seen nothing since, but I suspect they're out there somewhere. I also suspect they would fare little better than a lone T-80 wandering around an urban environment without competent infantry support. Also, BMPT was designed around the Grozny threat environment: antiarmor teams on rooftops raining down RPGs and Molotov cocktails from above. The Ukrainians haven't been forced to resort to those tactics (yet) as they have advanced Western weapons to employ from greater distances and with greater lethality.
- josefresco 5y agoI'm no expert but ....I guess it's similar to an aircraft carrier. Alone it's massively vulnerable from asymmetric attacks, but when properly protected can be powerful and effective.
- liotier 5y agoYes. As in paper/rock/scissors, vulnerability is only part of the story. Glass has huge compressive strength but fails under very low tensile stress, diamond is the hardest material but will shatter easily under a (large) hammer...
- cf141q5325 5y agoTo be fair, the protection in this case is the threat of retaliation.
- simmonmt 5y agoThe same argument applies to airplanes, but both airplanes and tanks have certain advantages that on balance exceed the risk of them getting blown up.
- cf141q5325 5y agoIt doesnt. Modern military aircraft fly too high for MANPADs (shoulder fired ones like Stinger). You require actual air defense systems, and new ones at that. Extremely pricey, restricted and very big. I would also argue that the advantages of tanks no longer apply when you face anything but non state backed rebels, especially in urban environment. Syria showed it rather well with the few TOWs that the US provided to the rebels. With drones it became check mate. All they are are giant defenseless targets, just look at Azerbaijan. They are not much use for anything but crushing civilians.
- sofixa 5y ago> Modern military aircraft fly too high for MANPADs (shoulder fired ones like Stinger) Not if they're doing combat air support they don't, unless they only use precision guided munitions or cruise missiles, which are expensive.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoThis is why Russia is losing so many planes. They ran out of the good weapons, and so now they need to fly dangerously low to attack ground targets.
- cf141q5325 5y agoI really didnt think i would see this in in the current year. Jets arent cheap either after all. Thanks for the heads up.
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoOne on one a single soldier can take a tank, but war isn't one on one. First there isn't going to be one tank. There's going to be a bunch. The tanks are basically immune to small arms fire. Not true of an infantryman who is vulnerable to pretty much everything. So the guy with the Javalin has to steel his nerves while he hears the tanks coming towards him, then he has to pop up to take his shot and hope no one sees him and kills him. Then, even if he's successful he still might get killed afterwards. The tanks usually have infantry support as well. The article talks about the Javelin having greater range than infantry, but I doubt that is true in an urban environment (too many buildings).
- spywaregorilla 5y agoThe videos I've seen, which, probably do suffer from selection bias of what is filmable, show ukranians blasting tanks from extremely far away. Far away enough that I would reckon the tank drivers had no practical way to observe, or even counteract against the infantry,especially if they're under some amount of cover and hidden until they strike. The guidance on these weapons seem very impressive. Most attacks seem to be hitting the tanks while they're on a highway. The russian tanks are shitty, and have no infantry support. So its hard to draw conclusions about how his would work against a competent foe.
- yyyk 5y agoThe soldier's anti-tank missile also has costs, and it usually misses or hits without destroying the tank (or taken out by anti-missile active defence). When you add all these up, it turns out the tank/missile cost equation is close to balanced. The tank's problem is less that it's vulnerable to anti-tank missile, but its high visibility, now relatively weak weapons and vulnerability to air assets (which is also high visibility again).
- hnaccy 5y agoThe claimed kill rate for Javalin in practice is over 90%. NLAWs are even cheaper and easier to use but don't know their estimated kill rate.
- yyyk 5y agoAgainst badly run T-72 tank divisions maybe. Against a modern tank with an active defence system and infantry cover? I strongly doubt it. There are more than a few known cases of tanks getting hit by Kornets and surviving and Javalin is contemporary.
- chipsa 5y agoAnti-missile active defense (Active Protection System) is still in it's infancy, especially with respect to tank based defenses. Many of them only work against direct attack, not top-attack missiles, and it's also common for them to effectively attack as giant shotguns to destroy the incoming target, which is bad for nearby infantry. They're also expensive, have sensors that must be maintained to be effective (which are sensors that can get shot at before the ATGM is launched), and can potentially be depleted in a specific sector of attack.
- yyyk 5y agoActive defence has limits, sure. There's a long dance between attack and defence. My point was that the tank isn't doomed there - if vulnerability to anti-tank missiles was the only issue, armies would research and deploy active defences everywhere and the tank would be important as it was. I think the problems are elsewhere. When infantryman can deploy offensive power outranging the canon, one needs to ask why have the tank when the infantryman requires so much less logistics. If say, the tanks could use a heavy mobile laser, than the equation would be different.
- R0b0t1 5y agoTanks help anchor infantry to the front line. They are mobile fortification. But they are more for open field combat than for urban combat. You're not the only one seeing tanks as partially obsolete. Force projection via planes is typically much more important.
- weinzierl 5y ago> If a single foot soldier can take out a tank that costs millions of dollars, is it even worth using a tank? A foot soldier with a weapon that costs a tenth of a million to fire. The asymmetry is given in Ukraine because they have enough Javelins but I doubt it exits to that degree in any conflict.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoEhh I think that's not quite right. A javelin costs a tenth of a million to fire, but you can just hand a few shots to a guy and send him on its way. As I understand it, it's pretty easy to use. A russian T-90 costs ~$5M to buy, but also requires a crew of ~3 trained people, plus munitions, plus a good deal of fuel, and logistics support to move it around. The asymmetry in Ukraine is first and foremost Russia having way more troops to burn. Economic and manpower held equal, rocket infantry certainly seem like they have a higher return than tanks on total operating costs
- weinzierl 5y agoGood point, I haven't thought about the personnel and operating costs of the tank.
- ineedasername 5y agoThey are still effective if deployed correctly. That entails using a "combined arms" approach where the tank is supported by infantry, stationary artillery, advanced recon, etc. Aerial support from helicopters can be very useful in spotting and taking out tank killing teams, although they have their own vulnerabilities: if the opposition has javelins they also probably have some type of SAM. But that's where recon and good Intel along with infantry come in: address the threats to heavy hitters like tanks and air support so those heavy hitters can do their job. It's hard to know exactly what's gone wrong for Russia in Ukraine, but the reports we're getting point to a huge failure to properly implement combined arms & close support tactics. It seems Russia either didn't anticipate the need-- thought they'd flatten their way to Kyiv so fast it didn't matter-- or their forces consist too much of undertrained non-professional conscripts. The conscript tour of duty in Russia is really too short to hammer home complex tactics and discipline for this sort of thing. 12 months is just too little time to game out the variety of scenarios they might encounter, and so when the one they were (presumably) trained for in this invasion meets initial resistance they don't know how to react. And that's before the logistics issues enter into things... Unfortunately that means Russia may fall back to simply bombing things to rubble and picking up the pieces. It looks like their plan was to take the country & install a friendly government fast enough to keep infrastructure and cities mostly intact, but now that that has failed it looks like they're moving towards the "rubble" approach which does not require the same level of ground training and tactics. Air superiority and long range artillery by Russia can do that.
- TekMol 5y agoI am surprised Ukrainians do not use remotely controlled mines. I don't know anything about weapons. Would it be hard to create a detonator that is remote controlled? Then one guy - let's call him the controller - could watch over a street in which a bunch of mines with such detonators are buried. As soon as an enemy vehicle is over the position of such a mine, the controllers selects it on his app and destroys the vehicle. If the signal can be sent over a distance of - say - 100m or more, then that would be a very comfortable way of defense against tanks, wouldn't it?
- spacemanmatt 5y agoMy guess: It's just not worth trying to guess/hope where a tank will roll over your mines.
- kspacewalk2 5y ago> I am surprised Ukrainians do not use remotely controlled mines. They do use mines, not sure if remote controlled. E.g. https://twitter.com/nashaniva/status/1503762953148919809 https://twitter.com/nashaniva/status/1503762953148919809
- TekMol 5y agoBut then you have to either put it there shortly before an enemy vehicle will pass it, or you have to somehow make sure no friendly vehicles will ever pass it.
- blaser-waffle 5y agoThey're fighting a defensive war, not a war of maneuver. Easier to use IEDs and mines when you're bunkering down and the fields are mud -- necessitating the use of a handful of roads. I'd bet my hat that the reasons the Russians are surrounding the cities and blasting them down is because they know they'd run into tons of IEDs + NLAWs if they rolled into a city.
- spywaregorilla 5y ago
- fasteddie31003 5y agoI think tanks are becoming a liability more than an asset in modern combat. I personally would rather be an infantry member with an e-bike, a personal recon drone, and a long range rifle.
- hef19898 5y agoUntil you encounter tanks supported by helicopters and infantry.
- Ourgon 5y agoOK, add some rocket launchers or drone-bombs to the equipment to take care of those. Manned tanks will go the way of the dodo, they are too vulnerable. The same will probably happen to carrier groups once hypersonic projectiles are common and accurate enough.
- hef19898 5y agoGiven how vulnerable carrier groups are already against submarines, I don't expect that to change anytime soon. Same goes for tanks so, they are still useful systems. Infantry is walking around anymore, a tank is good in taking out the APCs and IFVs used by mechanized infantry for example. Thing about war is, losses and fatalities are part of the game. Nobody is assuming to have a silver bullet that is undefeatable and invulnerable.
- Ourgon 5y agoSubmarines are slow, hypersonic projectiles are fast. Fast to deploy to the conflict area, fast to reach their target. Battleships went out of fashion because they were too vulnerable to submarines. Carriers will go out fashion because they're too vulnerable to hypersonic projectiles. What comes next? Maybe a fleet of destroyer- or frigate-sized drone carriers? Submarine drone carriers? Something which makes it harder to disable the task group with a few good hits.
- 5y ago
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.ph/tvKzW https://archive.ph/tvKzW
- perlgeek 5y agohttps://archive.ph/tvKzW https://archive.ph/tvKzW since the original URL doesn't load right now.
- sklargh 5y agoI don’t think the the utility of a tank is completely obviated. At a minimum, a heavy force needs them to assault and breach at speed under fire. The Russians are not exactly offering a tour de force in optimal support of their heavy armor. I will take their user error in favor of the good guys but don’t want to draw a broader lesson about the utility of the tank quite yet. 120mm cannon rounds are cheaper and more plentiful than guided missiles, which means a lot. That said, it’s getting harder and harder to understand a scenario in which tanks can be employed successfully against a motivated, competent defender with plentiful ATGM and loitering munition stocks.
- kitrose 5y agoWorks great while your infantry platoon has the missiles to pop one or two unsupported. If they are in force then you get rolled.
- sklargh 5y agoYeah a well employed heavy armor element, particularly supported by dismounted infantry and SHORAD is going to stomp an infantry element that has exhausted anti tank rocket/missile stocks. Not debating that for a second.
- lmilcin 5y ago> I don’t think the the utility of a tank is completely obviated. The whole point of tank, as the word suggests, is to be able to survive enemy fire. With proliferation of easy to carry weapons that can pierce any tank it is largely relegated to being heavy, costly and fragile mobile cannon that needs a lot of support to stay alive. There are much better devices that can fill those roles. You should no longer assume that you can ambush anything with your tanks -- with live overhead feed it is easy to spot any tanks encroaching on your position and place any antitank in the right spot. And then you have drones that you can basically point and shoot any tank from. I am pretty sure this is the last war where we see large number of tanks involved. Every country that is watching this is click spamming to buy as many drones as possible.
- 5y ago
- ruddct 5y agoReminds me of a trip to the DPRK side of the Korean DMZ a few years back. As you close in on the DMZ the roads get narrower, then narrower, then you start to see brutalist-looking concrete sidewalls, sculptures, & overhead signs all over the place. We all thought they were sculptures (there's a lot of brutalist concrete in the DPRK). Turns out they're tank traps! You can see a few pics at the top of this article[0], they're pretty neat. [0]https://99percentinvisible.org/article/hostile-terrain-tank-traps-fake-towns-secret-tunnels-korean-borderlands/ https://99percentinvisible.org/article/hostile-terrain-tank-... EDIT: Looks like South Korea may have these near the DMZ too!
- tyingq 5y agoPage from an old book showing some different types of tank traps: https://www.militaryimages.net/media/tank-traps.112392/full?d=1521519395 https://www.militaryimages.net/media/tank-traps.112392/full?...
- openasocket 5y agoI don't think tanks are going away anytime soon. Nothing else offers the same degree of mobility, armor, and firepower. Sure, a Javelin is cheaper than a tank, but a bullet is cheaper than a soldier and we don't talk about infantry being obsolete. People think of tanks as just lumbering around the battlefield shooting at targets, but they employ fire-and-maneuver tactics the same as infantry. So in combat a tank will be moving from cover to cover, with additional tanks providing suppressive fires from protected positions. Tanks don't move around on their own, they are always fighting as part of at least a platoon (a platoon is 3-4 tanks depending on the country) of other tanks, and almost always with infantry support. I think improvements in APS and maybe some new reactive armor will be enough to keep the balance between ATGM and tank more or less in the same place it was in the 1980s.
- jpmattia 5y agoI used to work on infrared imagers long ago in the late 80s, so I still sometimes notice obscure technical details about IR. Many modern anti-tank weapons were designed back in the 90s and then battle-tested over the next decades. So like aircraft and spacecraft, a lot of the electronics is quite antiquated by modern standards. For example: The Javelin shoulder-fired missile that we are currently reading about in Ukraine was put into service in the late 90s. It finds its way to the target using an infrared focal-plane array with a resolution of 64x64 [1]. Part of the reason that the resolution is so small: A room-temperature object will have peak E&M radiation around 8-12 microns, and mercury-cadmium-telluride imagers were optimal for that wavelength range in the 90s. However, processing of the materials was pretty difficult back then, so 64x64 was pretty much all you could manage while achieving a usable yield. Eventually the current generation will be replaced, and that will presumably include a serious upgrade to the IR resolution. It's hard to imagine that won't affect the usefulness of tanks in the coming decades. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FGM-148_Javelin#Focal_plane_array_(FPA) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FGM-148_Javelin#Focal_plane_ar...
- tyingq 5y agoIt does seem like high resolution would make a big difference. If you look at pictures of tanks that are pretty fully covered with reactive armor, there are still lots of gaps of varying sizes for things like hatches, view ports, exhaust, between reactive armor modules, and so on. So a high res focal plane could direct the weapon into one of many sweet spots.
- chipsa 5y agoI think the point of higher resolution isn't to necessarily hit the sweet spots, but rather to better improve countermeasure rejection.
- livueta 5y agoSorry if this is a dumb question: Reading your link, it sounds like the HgCdTe-based FPAs are primarily an electrochemical thing, akin to the microchannel plate approach of traditional analog image intensification. My impression of more modern IR-spectrum imaging (Teledyne/BAE/L3 stuff) was that it is basically a bolometer sensor behind vanadium/germanium-doped glass, then somehow hooked up to a cmos sensor. So, modern sensors are still partially based in an electrochemical process, just a different one that's more amenable to improvements in manufacturing process or something? I'm thinking of some of the new stuff that can deliver 1920x1080 60hz output - that'd definitely help with targeting.
- alksjdalkj 5y agoI feel like most commenters here didn't read the article - in many cases a single soldier /can't/ take out a modern tank because of their active protection systems.
- belter 5y agoYes, that is the premise of the article. And even a whole team with several missiles might not defeat some of these systems. It seems the Russians did not deploy their tanks with these. I wonder if that is what Russia requested from the Chinese. They seem to have a system whose capabilities are untested so far.
- bell-cot 5y agoProperly employed, tanks are a weapon of fast movement, maneuver, and rapid exploitation of breakthroughs. German commanders spent most of the Battle of France (1940) in a semi-panic over how many tanks they were losing. By the end, 1/3 of all the tanks the German Army started the battle with were total losses, and another 1/3 were "out of action, awaiting major repairs". Tank-for-tank, the French tanks very clearly out-performed the German tanks. But France was still conquered.