6 ms·
The succession drama at Scholastic
- jimbob45 5y agoSeems like it's not in anyone's interests for company shares to be heritable. How many companies have been burned to the ground because someone inherited them and had no idea how to run such a company? Is there any movement to force owners to liquidate their shares upon their death? I'm surely not the first one to think of something like this.
- jaredandrews 5y ago"Estate tax"
- ultrarunner 5y agoSeems like it'd be in the family's best interest, being one of the best ways to build generational wealth?
- tiahura 5y agoIf Bob's Muffler Shop is incorporated, why shouldn't it be heritable? In the US we generally don't confiscate companies from private individuals because we think we can run the company better. Additionally, shareholders would simply place the shares in a trust, or give the shares to their heirs before they die. So, no. There really isn't any movement to force sales of family business at death.
- georgeecollins 5y agoIf a thing is heritable indefinitely it is a title in the feudal sense. If my family could control Bob's Muffler Shop for ten generations aren't we sort of the Earls of Bob's Muffler Shop?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> If my family could control Bob's Muffler Shop for ten generations aren't we sort of the Earls of Bob's Muffler Shop? I dunno, are you the Earl of your great grandfather's pocket watch, or the Duke of the Heirloom Dresser?
- actually_a_dog 5y agoOwning Bob’s Muffler Shop doesn’t give you any of the privileges granted to feudal lords, though. That’s a terrible analogy.
- barry-cotter 5y agoPeople own their own property and they can decide what to do with it. That’s what property means. They can leave a company to whoever they want, just like they can leave Aunt Gertrude’s silverware. Companies are property and people can make extremely foolish decisions with them if they want because they are their property. I can buy an original Hiroshige print and use it to light a fire if I want. By the same token you can leave your billion dollar company to your feckless coke snorting, whore frequenting grandson if you want. That’s what owning something means.
- jedberg 5y agoSure but at some point when the company gets to be that big and employ that many people, there is a public interest to see it continue to exist. Also as a public company they have a fiduciary duty to the shareholders to keep it running well. There's some pretty good arguments to be made that when a major shareholder of a public company dies, their shares should be distributed by the board and not their will.
- barry-cotter 5y agoTaking (a part of) someone’s property is a tax. Deciding that you will do that to companies above a certain size is a tax on getting big, a discouragement to do so. Security of property rights is a pretty compelling public interest. Keeping a particular company going is not on remotely on the same order. The fiduciary duty is a red herring. If you want to destroy your own property you can. If you make poor decisions about your own property that’s on you. Public companies are actively traded. If you don’t like management sell the shares. There are an uncountable number of ways that management can mess up. Why mess with property rights for one particular small class of ways companies can be messed up? If there is an argument for taking someone’s property upon their death and give it to other people because they are co-owners of a company please make it.
- jedberg 5y agoYou talk about a red herring and then say this: > Deciding that you will do that to companies above a certain size is a tax on getting big, a discouragement to do so. That's the biggest lie of all. High taxes has never discouraged someone from starting or growing a company. No one ever says, "gee I have a great idea but I don't want to pay a lot of tax on my windfall earnings so I just won't bother". But if you're so worried about discouraging growth, then fine. Make it apply to the death of any shareholder -- upon death the board gets to say where the voting rights of the shares go. Let the owner will the value of the shares to whomever they want, but let the board decide where the voting power goes.
- hackernewds 5y agoanyone? are you sure?
- paxys 5y agoThe article goes on for pages and pages but I'm failing to see the drama. Owner of a large private publisher dies, and instead of passing the company to his sons he gives control to the chief of strategy who has been with the company for decades, and who he happened to date for some period of time. Like...okay? No one is contesting it. No one is rebelling. His sons are pissed, but of course they will be. She seems to be running the company exactly like how it was before, and how everyone expected (which makes sense considering none of the leadership has changed). The article is alright if you want some background on Scholastic and Dick Robinson, but there is really no deeper story here.
- be_nice 5y agoI, too, abstract away drama in my dismissive summary so I can claim there's no drama.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoI mean, there's drama, but it doesn't seem like particularly interesting drama from HN's point of view: more gossip than "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity".
- burnished 5y agoAs a filthy gossip I feel comfortable pronouncing that if everyone is acting basically sort of reasonable then it isn't drama.
- crackercrews 5y ago> instead of passing the company to his sons he gives control to the chief of strategy who has been with the company for decades There are two issues here: the wealth and the control of the company. I don't think it would have been terribly noteworthy if he'd split up his ownership. He could have given his ex-girlfriend voting shares and his sons shares with financial value. But that's not what happened. The whole bundle went to the ex-girlfriend, which is a bit of a strange occurrence.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spoonjim 5y agoThis isn’t “drama” — it’s two coddled sons of a wealthy man being “dramatic” that their father willed the company to the Chief Strategy Officer instead of them.