8 ms·
What puzzles me about ancient humans is they were as smart as we are, so why did technology advance so slowly?
by WalterBright 5y ago
What puzzles me about ancient humans is they were as smart as we are, so why did technology advance so slowly?
- Mikeb85 5y agoThey spent more time surviving. Plus many 'discoveries' were likely accidents. Like, if you put even modern humans with knowledge of technology out in the wild how quickly do you think they'll be able to invent agriculture or work metals from minerals in rocks?
- aquaticsunset 5y agoI think about this more often than I probably should, and I've come to the same conclusion. We stand on mighty tall shoulders.
- WalterBright 5y ago> They spent more time surviving. Much of survival work is drudgery, where one can think about other things while working. For example, I do my best work while jogging. > Plus many 'discoveries' were likely accidents. Of course. But those accidents come from playing with things to see what happens, and being curious enough to notice when something unexpected happens. > Like, if you put even modern humans with knowledge of technology out in the wild how quickly do you think they'll be able to invent agriculture Agriculture isn't hard to invent. > or work metals from minerals in rocks? Most of this comes from playing with fire. A lot, though, depends on higher temperatures which require a bellows. The idea for a bellows would come from simply blowing on embers to turn them into flames. Once you've got a bellows, you'll notice that the fire gets much hotter, and they you might throw various things in that hot fire to see what happens. There are other things, like weaving, boats, sails, chimneys, etc., that make life easier and don't require metals. Very few modern people, even engineers, have the faintest idea how to get iron out of ore, or would even recognize ore.
- WalterBright 5y agoI enjoy watching that Alone TV series. I was intrigued that some of the contestants would just build an open fire inside their shelter. Those had a lot of problems with smoke inhalation, and would often burn down their shelter, causing them to exit the game. Putting a vent hole in the roof didn't help much. Some would build a fireplace on the side, those did better. One contestant built a fireplace on the side, and put a chimney on it made of stone and clay. No tools needed to build it. It worked as you'd expect - famously. Chimneys are very simple technology, but took a very long time to invent - not until medieval times.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> Agriculture isn't hard to invent Alright, go find a wild grass or vegetable and turn it into something resembling a modern staple crop or vegetable.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt doesn't have to be a modern crop or vegetable. What do you think the gatherers of a hunter-gatherer tribe were gathering?
- Mikeb85 5y agoWhy do you think the agricultural revolution was a big deal? Prior to that, humans spent way too much time hunting and gathering (prey ran away and wild edibles don't have many calories). The whole reason technological development accelerated is because people became sedentary.
- mc32 5y agoTotal population was much smaller, communities were smaller, communication was oral. I think all that results in restricted dissemination as well as technologies and techniques that died with the innovators in many instances.
- InitialLastName 5y agoAs I understand it, this is an open question, but one explanation has a few factors: a) In the absence of many external pressures, hunting and gathering is actually a reasonably low-effort and flexible lifestyle. From a moment-to-moment perspective, agriculture (and our "technological" world) mostly doesn't seem like an improvement. Long-term, the quality-of-life improvements come about in resiliency and stability, but those aren't visible to the people making the decision. b) The transition to agriculture (which triggered the technology explosion) took a long period of luck, including groups of people living in a floodplain for a long enough time to breed plants that were suitable for agriculture. Note that this was an extremely rare thing, in that it probably only happened ~4-5 times in human history and spread everywhere else.
- ghaff 5y agoBut even the Roman Empire--looked at on a long enough timescale--basically didn't move the needle on societal advancement relative to what happened once the industrial revolution got going. https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.vox.com%2Ffuture-perfect%2F2018%2F11%2F8%2F18052076%2Fhuman-history-in-one-chart-industrial-revolution&psig=AOvVaw1e9LiAMXHPZaXl8a3oRriP&ust=1647391401703000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAsQjRxqFwoTCLDNiK3xxvYCFQAAAAAdAAAAABAD https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.vox.co...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deutschew 5y agoThe roman empire had steam powered contraceptions or prototypes too but lacked the machinery to produce them in large scale but more importantly their demographic were not very open to automation since they had human robots they could control aka slaves. Why build an elaborate steam powered textile factory when it costs nothing to use slaves to do it for you? Why do you need UFC on 4k television when you can watch gladiators duke it out live with no censorship? Why do you need porn when...okay I will stop here but you get my point. These mechanical constructions were always in the back of engineer's minds but nobody wanted it. If Romans invented the car, they would shun it for a horse. I believe it is the development of commerce, colonialism and laws that really made it impossible to rely on human labor alone. Like the Dutch East Company and British one, the difference really came from increased need to manage the looting, I'm sorry, "legalized taking". Wars also were increasingly more catastrophic and costly, an arms race if you will that really made them sit down and start engineering how to do real damage to one another.
- sfblah 5y agoHow do we know they were as smart as we are?
- WalterBright 5y agoThe American peoples split off from the Asian peoples 25,000 years ago, and are the same intelligence today. That would seem unlikely unless they were the same then as today.
- Madmallard 5y agoAsians are smarter though
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- missedthecue 5y agoNot enough to be considered a different species.
- Madmallard 5y agoI don't think that's relevant here. There is almost a 10 point variation between Japan's average IQ and United States. That's quite a lot. It seems quite plausible older humans could all be significantly below 100 average and have just not figured anything out.
- Alan_Dillman 5y agoThat would fly in the face of nature, where wild animals are almost universally more cognitively resourceful than domesticated versions. Its special pleading to say humans should be different.
- Madmallard 5y ago
- adolph 5y agoConsider the Antikythera mechanism, what must have existed to bring it into existence and what has transpired since. We now enjoy the fruits of a period of advancement. It isn't guaranteed to continue though. A turn of history may set humans will be back to square one, maybe even in a worse position than before. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism
- devnull3 5y agoAdvancement in science & tech needs curiosity, critical & independent thinking and most importantly ability to change mind when data says that you were wrong. These are precisely the things which religion (organised or otherwise) has suppressed for thousands of years. The most important factor in advancement of sciences came because of: separation of the state and religion. When this happened it still took few centuries where rational thinking was accepted in ruling class. From this point it was really the case of one idea leads to another.
- jcranmer 5y agoMy thesis is that it's a mixture of a few things: a) Underappreciation of what things require technological advancements. Imagine being a [1] first person to discover that you can turn certain grasses into dough that can be cooked into bread... and you can't turn other grasses into that dough. That kind of person could well have been the Lavoisier of their day. Yet today, that's the kind of skill passed down from parent to child as the most pedestrian thing ever. b) Bootstrapping effect. A lot of technology requires itself to be built, whether it's a compiler to compile your compiler, or a kiln to bake the bricks to make your kiln. In the inverse of this effect, until you build up enough infrastructure to use your technology to perpetuate itself, it might not be appreciated that it's worthwhile to do so--I'm reminded of the anecdote that Dijkstra once chastised a student for wasting precious computer time running an assembler program. c) Societal effects of smaller, nomadic societies. If you're small, you run a greater risk of knowledge simply dying out; information loss rates were probably much higher 20,000 years ago than today. Similarly, a nomadic society is probably less willing to invest in infrastructure (like, say, kilns) that isn't readily able to move with them, and this will retard certain technological development. It's just a thesis, though; I don't really have any hard evidence for anything, just thought experiments. [1] As I mentioned elsewhere, this is probably an example of something that was independently invented several times.
- tosser0001 5y agoIt’s a question that thinkers have wondered about for a long time. Argument IV against the eternity of the world: "Yes, Sir, The late Invention of Arts, and the Shortness of the History of the World, are invincible Arguments against its Eternity. If the World was from Eternity, you must needs make them an eternal Race of the most stupid Blockheads imaginable, without the least Drachm almost of Wit, or Contrivance, or indeed common Sense; and that none of these Qualification ever were known in the World, till within these two or three thousand Years last past." William Nichols, "A Conference with a Theist" (1696) https://archive.org/details/aconferencewith00nichgoog/page/44/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/aconferencewith00nichgoog/page/4...
- bena 5y agoIntelligent, yes. Knowledgeable, no. Consider programming. Compare programming in the 1970s and 1980s to now. We're way more sophisticated now than we were then. Knowledge builds on knowledge and is logarithmic in growth. When I was born, we had 2400 baud modems. When I was graduating high school, getting a 56k baud modem was hot shit. Now, if I can't stream high definition video in real time on my phone, I think the connection is shitty. We had to invent agriculture. We had to invent bread. We had to invent construction. The wheel. Pulleys. Ladders. Boats. Vacuum tubes. Transistors. Netflix. Etc. But we can't invent Netflix before we invent transistors. We can't even think of certain things before certain things are invented. But as more things are invented and recorded, the less leg work we have to do. I don't need to invent bread. Bread is solved six ways from Sunday. We got all sorts of bread. We're so beyond bread, we've invented and solved ways to cook bread after it's been baked. Pre-historic man can't even imagine bread pudding because he doesn't know bread exists. Progress, at the very least, has a logarithmic component. It could be an arctangent. Where there's a long build up, a rapid rise, then a long tail.
- WalterBright 5y agoProgress happens because the intermediate inventions are useful. Nobody jumps from wooden wheels to steel ball bearings. But there are some exceptions. The invention of the airplane had intermediate steps, but they were fairly useless on their own. You can see this in the series of prototypes the Wrights made, and then combined them to build a useful airplane.
- xscott 5y ago> Compare programming in the 1970s and 1980s to now. We're way more sophisticated now than we were then. I think this is revisionist history at best. Your comments about baud rates and CPUs getting faster is true of course, but look at something like programming languages: I'd put ML from 1973 (later Standard ML, 1983) against Go or Rust, and I'd put something like Icon from 1977 against JavaScript or Python. If anything, I think we've regressed because ML and Icon could actually run on 70s era hardware, but Rust can barely compile its own compiler on 2020s era hardware, and Python wastes CPU and memory as though it was a design goal. Seriously, look at Standard ML, Icon, or even Scheme and SmallTalk from the 70s, and ask how Python and Go improved on those. ----- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ML_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ML_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_ML https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_ML https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icon_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icon_(programming_language)
- hbarka 5y agoHaving the luck of abundance of coal and abundance of metal-bearing earth allowed states to smelt metals to a scale that can defeat enemies and then the rise of arms races and industrial revolutions and science.
- postalrat 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Sentinel_Island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Sentinel_Island Go ask them.
- earleybird 5y agoThey don't seem that approachable. :-)
- jsnodlin 5y ago
- Steko 5y ago1. Technically they weren’t as smart. Fetal and child nutrition is hugely important for brain development. Modern language is far more complex. Intellectual stimulation for children is far mote advanced. 2. Slow by who’s definition? It seems like they were doing lots of useful things in a pretty harsh environment. Cleverness for cavemen was measured in surviving and outcompeting other smart humans, hominids and predators. Language and culture got more and more complex and yeah they developed a long list of physical technology. 3. Intelligence isn’t sufficient to produce a lot of technology. For example, domesticating wild grains may require you to be sedentary which itself has other requirements and is something you don’t get when your survival depends on following herds of megafauna around. More than the tech tree often you need some sort of pressure like running out of new places to live and/or running out of the megafauna you’ve always chased.
- JudgePenitent 5y agoBecause there were so few people. The inverse of your question is why did technology seemingly explode beginning around 10k years ago? And the answer to that is simple: the Milankovitch cycles had brought about a warming trend, bringing an abundance of resources. It is interesting to notice that sedentism and agriculture happened at the same time. The modern theory is that agriculture practice led to sedentism, but at the very least its unclear which came first because the earliest confirmed harvested (ie non wild growing) varieties of grains from the middle east come from approximately the same period as the beginning of this warming. However, once not only agriculturalism but pastoralism (and even beyond that nomadic pastoralism, and the domestication of the horse) had proven their usefulness to maintaining scaling sedent populations, the populations exploded and naturally, bored human beings with brains and full bellies sit around and think of different ways to do things. tl;dr: they were unlucky wrt technological innovation