7 ms·
> I avoid personal debt like the plague. If that means living in a small house, and driving an old car, then so be it. Going into debt that you can pay off and
by astrange 5y ago
> I avoid personal debt like the plague. If that means living in a small house, and driving an old car, then so be it.
Going into debt that you can pay off and will make you a profit is good - because making a profit is literally the thing that gets you through bad times. (That's why having savings be 100% cash is riskier than investing - you are 100% guaranteed to not have it go up.) And recent years' zero-to-negative interest rates were the time to borrow.
But going into debt for a depreciating asset like a car is a bad idea, yes. A house is complicated, because land value likely means it's profitable, except that you can't sell it because you're living in it.
- davedx 5y agoYour advice might be okay for good times (investing, buying land, houses). But in hard economic times, the global economy will be doing badly and therefore most investments will too, even housing (see 2008). Going into debt that you then invest is doubly risky: you have debt, plus you have a risky investment. Saving cash is actually indeed the best way to prepare for hard times.
- szundi 5y agoExactly. OP was asking about hard times.
- dwg 5y agoI apologize for being blunt, but you have it backwards. A the adage goes: buy low sell high. In what people equate with "good economic times," prices are high, but in hard economic times everything is on sale! That said, firstly and foremost we should all make sure to have enough savings to ride out hard economic times—including personal ones. That is, enough to pay our monthly expenses for a year or so, in case we become unable to work or we do not want to take income from investments (because say, the market is down). How long you should be able to last is a mater of individual comfort level, but IMHO, no less than 6 months. Too much savings in the bank however—and this I believe relates back to the point being made by the original commenter—is actually not good. That money is losing value, and therefore so are you. You should invest it somehow, but that's not the only way. Another way is taking on debt, if that debt is the sort that generates a profit. We're not talking about car loans here (unless of course your a car dealer). Please forgive me if I misinterpreted your point, but I felt it important to make this clarification.
- jwalton 5y ago> but in hard economic times everything is on sale! In sufficiently hard economic times, everything is on sale because no one has any idea what will still be around tomorrow and what is going to drop to zero.
- dwg 5y agoPutting war and personal risk of injury or forced relocation aside, which go beyond hard economic times, anyone with a sufficiently long-term view will not fall trap to "not having any idea about what will still be around tomorrow and what is going to drop to zero."
- marcusverus 5y ago> A the adage goes: buy low sell high. Don't forget the other adage--Don't time the market. > That said, firstly and foremost we should all make sure to have enough savings to ride out hard economic times—including personal ones. That is, enough to pay our monthly expenses for a year Having a year of expenses is good practice in general. I'm not sure that qualifies one as ready for actual hard times at a societal level--not just a stint of unemployment, but global depression, accelerating price inflation, or even general European war and the rationing that could follow. > Too much savings in the bank however—and this I believe relates back to the point being made by the original commenter—is actually not good. That money is losing value, and therefore so are you. There are ways to save that protect you (somewhat) from inflation. Like short term bonds (ex: from treasurydirect.gov). > Another way is taking on debt, if that debt is the sort that generates a profit. We're not talking about car loans here (unless of course your a car dealer). Unless there is some full-proof investment scheme that you're aware of, this would essentially be gambling. If you take on debt and your profit-generating scheme fails (which is certainly possible in the "hard times" scenario that OP has envisioned), then you're worse off--you've got debt to service, on top of everything else.
- bratwurst3000 5y agoThere could be contracts that generate future value but oneself needs money atm to fullfill it. I know still gambling… but with little risk depending on the conditions
- hoseja 5y agoEnter hyperinflation.
- nivenkos 5y agoInflation will wipe out that cash though. Honestly, it's hard to give advice since it's so specific to the region and job market, etc. Like many US engineers can easily afford to buy a house outright with $200k+ salaries, that isn't possible as often in Europe or Asia for example. But basically do what you can to get fixed costs that you know you can afford and stability - i.e. a fixed rate mortgage, fixed rate utilities, and trade union membership and unemployment insurance, etc.
- nradov 5y agoThere are very few US engineers who can afford to buy a house outright. The ones making $200K+ salaries are mostly in HCOL areas where houses are very expensive. And the ones who can afford to buy outright are usually doing so based on equity gains, not salaries.
- jjav 5y ago> Like many US engineers can easily afford to buy a house outright with $200k+ salaries That's about 100K after taxes + medical (not included in taxes in the US) and other deductions. With houses in good markets far above $1M, nobody making $100K net is buying a house outright. Or even being able to buy a house at all.
- philipov 5y ago"Going into debt you then invest" is probably the exact wording used by pathological gamblers to justify betting their house at cards. In older times, that's how people gambled their way into slavery. "I'll borrow some money to buy the seeds I need to plant my crops" and then the harvest goes bad and you have neither food nor money to repay the debt. Suddenly the wealthy neighbor you borrowed from is taking your land to pay for it.
- dionidium 5y agoBuying a house gives you extreme leverage, though, and with extremely favorable tax treatment. You can put as little as $25k down on a $500k house and when the land underneath it increases in value you get to keep all the upside and pay no capital gains on up to $250k in profit ($500k if you're married). And you'll pay, what, a fixed rate of 3.5% for 30 years? If you find a bookie giving you terms like that, then you should take them.
- philipov 5y agoThis is a conversation about hard economic times, when the house could very well depreciate in value, and you'll be stuck with a mortgage worth much more than the house. Remember 2008? It was caused by people assuming like this that the value of houses always goes up.
- avgDev 5y agoInvesting, buying property is the best during "SALES" and those occur during hard economic times. 1. Build an emergency fund. I have enough to cover about 12 months of all my expenses. 2. Avoid life style creep when you start making more money. 3. Invest pre-tax, take full advantage of 401k and IRAs (make sure your expense ratio is low in your selected funds) 4. If you need a car be reasonable, take efficiency and repair costs into consideration 5. Learn how to do basic home/car maintenance 6. Learn how to cook The idea of emergency fund is that you are not forced to sell during hard times. It is extremely likely that total market will recover and go higher than before. Saving cash beyond emergency fund is like setting it on fire. Every year inflation is eating it away.
- jjav 5y ago> Saving cash is actually indeed the best way to prepare for hard times. Cash is the worst possible holding. Inflation will destroy it. If you feel higher inflation is coming, holding as much debt as possible is what you want. Of course, you do want to have enough cash on hand for short-term expenses, say like a year of living. Anything beyond that is very risky.
- AlgorithmicTime 5y agoIf you went into fixed interest rate debt before a period of inflation, you're likely to be fine.
- hervature 5y ago> But going into debt for a depreciating asset like a car is a bad idea, yes. This is just as stupid as: "But going into debt for a depreciating asset like a computer is a bad idea, yes." They are both investments in potential tools. For many, an investment in a car can ultimately be cheaper than most other modes of transportation. Just like how companies finance their data centers with debt. Of course, it does not mean any car. Hell, it does not even imply a new car. But the advice of using debt to finance a car is always a bad idea is just patently false.
- quxbar 5y agoNot to mention even crappy used cars appreciated over the past two years.
- sofixa 5y ago> For many, an investment in a car can ultimately be cheaper than most other modes of transportation. That's a joke, right? It's entirely dependent on one's location, and i think for more people here on HN the inverse would be true ( I'm assuming the majority of users here live in or around big cities, where tech was traditionally concentrated). In well developed big cities ( so excluding the many failures at urban design and planning in the US) public transit is at least decent, and i don't think there are any places around the world where owning a car is cheaper than paying for public transit ( with the caveat that depending on how you measure the time spent could alter that)
- CPLX 5y ago> i don't think there are any places around the world where owning a car is cheaper than paying for public transit ( with the caveat that depending on how you measure the time spent could alter that) That's the world's biggest caveat. Investment in a modest car that stops you from spending 3 hours each way commuting over 4 separate bus routes from exurban home to exurban job is about as high a return on money as you're ever going to see. Not to mention grocery shopping kids and whatever else. There are painfully few places in the U.S. where this isn't true. I prefer your model and I live in one of those places (Brooklyn) but let's be honest here about how the world actually works.
- pibechorro 5y agoDebt is leverage. When times are good you are great, when they are not and the repo man cometh, they are awful. The banks always win via bailout or not. Staying debt free is the only safe place, you have flexibility.
- tnel77 5y agoI feel like there’s a middle ground to be had here. You obviously don’t want to be over leveraged, but I don’t think a small amount of debt is inherently bad. I have a mortgage and some student debt, but they are a modest amount of my household income. You work to pay them off and save up an emergency fund, but the reality is that most Americans would never own a house without a mortgage. At a certain point, debt is essentially inevitable.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoThink of it like crossing an ocean. When the winds are good let out the sails to be propelled along, when the storms come take it the sales and ride out the weather. If you want to do it all under your own steam without a bit of help, well it's a long paddle across an ocean so you will be confined to travelling a short distance in your life.